Plight of Hindus in Bangladesh after coup

You either don't know Nuremberg law or you playing ignorant. Nuremberg law was applied to people of Germany. CAA was for religious minorities of surrounding neighbour's of India. India can choose whom they allow in their lands. There are other types of persecutions but this bill was only about religious persecution on minorities.
Even then CAA did not DENY anyone else. Others would have the normal path, but religious minority refugees were getting a speed track. I mean CAA hardly did anything for the refugees because they were so few in number, but imagine the hatred that they did such a big protest for something so irrelevant.
 
Even then CAA did not DENY anyone else. Others would have the normal path, but religious minority refugees were getting a speed track. I mean CAA hardly did anything for the refugees because they were so few in number, but imagine the hatred that they did such a big protest for something so irrelevant.
Exactly. Don't want minorities even to escape from religious persecution and lead a decent life.
 
I am getting some reports of vandalizing again, specifically from.Chattogram where business shops of Hindu owners have been burnt. The next few days are very important.
 
I don't think that will happen in BD.

Remember that this overthrowing of Hasina was really possible due to young students. Students have many different political positions.

It is likely BD may opt in for a center-right party (either BNP or a new party).
Iranian Shah was also overthrown by socialists. But we all know who seized the power.

For the good of BD and India, I hope a democratically elected government comes to power.
 
I am getting some reports of vandalizing again, specifically from.Chattogram where business shops of Hindu owners have been burnt. The next few days are very important.
Soft targets for Islamists. Loot and burn down the shops.
 
It got backlash because it was discriminatory. It was based on ridiculous premise that persecution is possible only on religious grounds and then went to exclude Burma from its list of neighbouring countries where muslims are murdered.
Just ridiculous.
It was nothing but imitation of Nuremberg law that was enacted by Hitler's party
Im not a modi or BJP fan but he did right things. There are more than 50 countries who were formed just based on islamic religion.

There is not a single country who were form based on Hindu ,sikh etc

CAA is helpful for minorities around the india.
 
Im not a modi or BJP fan but he did right things. There are more than 50 countries who were formed just based on islamic religion.

There is not a single country who were form based on Hindu ,sikh etc

CAA is helpful for minorities around the india.
People who have normalized discrimination against their very citizens will be questioning you, and you will be defending yourself. The perks of being neutral and unbiased which hindus have strange obsession for.
 
I am getting some reports of vandalizing again, specifically from.Chattogram where business shops of Hindu owners have been burnt. The next few days are very important.
This is only prove that it is not a revolution but goons are behind the students .
 
Isolated incidents, and mostly fake news. Don't blow it out of proportion.
Look man, I don't have any interest in you and sweep shot's arguments. I am just posting which reports I am getting. I have big expectations from Bangladeshi students, that's why I think it's important to report things truthfully.
 
Look man, I don't have any interest in you and sweep shot's arguments. I am just posting which reports I am getting. I have big expectations from Bangladeshi students, that's why I think it's important to report things truthfully.
Rabindranath Tagore also had big expectations from Bengalis, and he wanted hindu and muslim bengalis to tie rakhis to each other as show of brotherhood.

Guess what. Bengalis gave a tight slap to Tagore. He lost. Suhrawardy won.

Not going to change anything. You have already lost a place you could call home. Now trying to scavenge for glory on the coat tails of bengali muslims, some of whom are attacking their citizens of another faith. There was never any bengali brotherhood. Bamponthis will never get it.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Bro are you into business profession or non business because because you might be undermining the negotiating power of Bharat here which is despite of all these issues rock solid very strong.

The neighbours need us way more than we need them. Whatever you mentioned applies to them as much if not more than it applies to us.

Maldives which has been cuddling up with China has come back to you for financial aid and security.

Sri Lanka also learnt a lot of bitter lessons.

People tend to overreact to the Chinese influence, if anything they’re betting big on some hopeless nations from where ROI is going to be extremely difficult.

Fact is that no matter how much they bark, none of these countries can practically afford to turn Bharat into an enemy.
Not sure if you're arguing with yourself or me because I'm the one who's arguing against giving up on relationships with neighbouring countries just because we've suffered a couple of setbacks. Things change fast in politics and diplomacy and enemies today become the best of friends tomorrow.

India still has plenty of influence and incentive on relations with neighbouring countries.

It's still a tough neighbourhood though.
 
Not sure if you're arguing with yourself or me because I'm the one who's arguing against giving up on relationships with neighbouring countries just because we've suffered a couple of setbacks. Things change fast in politics and diplomacy and enemies today become the best of friends tomorrow.

India still has plenty of influence and incentive on relations with neighbouring countries.

It's still a tough neighbourhood though.


It sounded like you feel Bharat is dependent on these small and poor neighbours and that we need them so desperately.

Its not.
They need us and will always. Red is way more than we need them.
We hold the cards and if we go rogue we can make it real bad for them.
 
Look man, I don't have any interest in you and sweep shot's arguments. I am just posting which reports I am getting. I have big expectations from Bangladeshi students, that's why I think it's important to report things truthfully.

What expectation? I don't know if you have read history.

But on the very streets of Kolkata muslim bengalis murdered 1000s of Hindus so that they could get East Pakistan.
 
Not sure if you're arguing with yourself or me because I'm the one who's arguing against giving up on relationships with neighbouring countries just because we've suffered a couple of setbacks. Things change fast in politics and diplomacy and enemies today become the best of friends tomorrow.

India still has plenty of influence and incentive on relations with neighbouring countries.

It's still a tough neighbourhood though.

You can talk to Lanka or Nepal. Myanmar Msldives Bhutan or even China. The relationship with them will be of mutual benefit.

There is no use talking to Pakistan or BD. Shut the border.

BD border has to be treated on par with pakistan.
 
What expectation? I don't know if you have read history.

But on the very streets of Kolkata muslim bengalis murdered 1000s of Hindus so that they could get East Pakistan.
Bro, I guess you are referring to Direct Action Day, right?
 
Or else us Assamese and you Benglais will have to bear the brunt. Both of our communities have already suffered enough till date.
be prepared for a mass influx of refugees! We are not Egypt or Jordan or Saudis letting innocents facing genocide stay trapped for political reasons! Tough times ahead.
 
I just want to know, have the following people condemned these attacks on Hindus -

Arfa Khanum Sherwani
Dhruv Rathee
Swara Bhaskar
Rana Ayyub
Zoo Bear
Sayema
Rajdeep Sardesai
Akash Banerjee
Ravish 'Darr ka mahol' Kumar
Last but not the least - that clown prince Rahul Ghandy


Looks like everyone is maintaining pedestrian distance as if Hindu lives don't matter.

It was good to see however that Arnab Goswami obliterated the liberals in his debate last night. Absolutely humiliated them and exposed their double standards.
 
I just want to know, have the following people condemned these attacks on Hindus -

Arfa Khanum Sherwani
Dhruv Rathee
Swara Bhaskar
Rana Ayyub
Zoo Bear
Sayema
Rajdeep Sardesai
Akash Banerjee
Ravish 'Darr ka mahol' Kumar
Last but not the least - that clown prince Rahul Ghandy

Has Modi, Amit Shah and Yogi bear condemned ?
 
What expectation? I don't know if you have read history.

But on the very streets of Kolkata muslim bengalis murdered 1000s of Hindus so that they could get East Pakistan.
Every thing Is not black and white. There are counter revolutionary forces attacking minorities true, but it is also true students are trying their best to guard the minorities. Some temples were saved even by madrasa students. Even after the 1992 riots or the 1983 Sikh riots the hindus in West Bengal did their best to protect the minorities. The Bangladeshi students are trying to do the same. It's true that their opponent is strong, but don't lose hope. As Swami Vivekananda said "manusher upor Biswas harano pap."
 
Has Modi, Amit Shah and Yogi bear condemned ?

Modi, Amit Shah and Yogi don't give statements, make YouTube videos and post on X daily. They have better work to do i.e running the country. It is funny you are comparing Modi and Shah with these fake liberals.

How about your charcoal king who called Sanatana Dharma as Dengue? Has he condemned these attacks yet?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Modi, Amit Shah and Yogi don't give statements, make YouTube videos and post on X daily. They have better work to do i.e running the country. It is funny you are comparing Modi and Shah with these fake liberals.

How about your charcoal king who called Sanatana Dharma as Dengue? Has he condemned these attacks yet?

I don't think so.

I'd expect hindutva warriors like Modi, Amit and Yogi bear to say something, but looks like they don't even care.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Close how ? There is no magic fence across the entire Indo-Bangla border.

Most of the border is fenced.

There needs to be shoot on sight just like Pakistan border.
Every thing Is not black and white. There are counter revolutionary forces attacking minorities true, but it is also true students are trying their best to guard the minorities. Some temples were saved even by madrasa students. Even after the 1992 riots or the 1983 Sikh riots the hindus in West Bengal did their best to protect the minorities. The Bangladeshi students are trying to do the same. It's true that their opponent is strong, but don't lose hope. As Swami Vivekananda said "manusher upor Biswas harano pap."

There is no saving minorities. Bangladeshi media is reporting widespread violence against them.

There will be a Mullah military alliance in BD.

And why are you comparing what happened in India to what happens in BD?
 
I don't think so.

I'd expect hindutva warriors like Modi, Amit and Yogi bear to say something, but looks like they don't even care.

First take the name of a Hindu Mathadheesh properly. He is a respected religious figure and head of the Nath Sect.

Seems even these little etiquettes are not known to you.

And you preach others.
 
You want to shoot dead people who are fleeing for their lives ? Wow.

There country. There problem. India isn't a refugee dump.

I don't want to have to leave my country one day and be a refugee somewhere.
 
Most of the border is fenced.

There needs to be shoot on sight just like Pakistan border.


There is no saving minorities. Bangladeshi media is reporting widespread violence against them.

There will be a Mullah military alliance in BD.

And why are you comparing what happened in India to what happens in BD?
It's true that there is violence. It's also true that students are trying their best to stop it. Why just report one side? In this revolution the students were the central force. Look at how many of them kept awake at night guarding the minorities without rejoicing in their success.
 
Most of the border is fenced.

There needs to be shoot on sight just like Pakistan border.


There is no saving minorities. Bangladeshi media is reporting widespread violence against them.

There will be a Mullah military alliance in BD.

And why are you comparing what happened in India to what happens in BD?
The students have rejected military rule. They want professor Younus to be the head of the interim government. You know how much the mullahs hate Professor Younus right ?
 
It's true that there is violence. It's also true that students are trying their best to stop it. Why just report one side? In this revolution the students were the central force. Look at how many of them kept awake at night guarding the minorities without rejoicing in their success.

Guarding from whom? Jews? Christians? Sikhs? Who?
 
I don't think so.

I'd expect hindutva warriors like Modi, Amit and Yogi bear to say something, but looks like they don't even care.

He is your 3 times Prime Minister...deal with it. :cool:
 
I don't think so.

I'd expect hindutva warriors like Modi, Amit and Yogi bear to say something, but looks like they don't even care.
Its an international crisis, needs a delicate and diplomatic touch. If Mamta Bannerjee can understand this complexity and is not making a mess, it should be understood by everyone!
 
Most of the border is fenced.

There needs to be shoot on sight just like Pakistan border.


There is no saving minorities. Bangladeshi media is reporting widespread violence against them.

There will be a Mullah military alliance in BD.

And why are you comparing what happened in India to what happens in BD?
Naive students think they can prop up Mohd. Yunus as the leader.
They will soon get a reality check, when ultra hardliners take control :p
 
Why around hundreds peoples were killed even after shekh hasina flew to india.

Their goal was achieved still they killed people's.
 
Now Islamic extremists needs to gaurdian from another Islamic extremists. Intresting :kp
The students are not Islamic extremists. They want professor Younus to head the interim government who is hated by Islamists.
 
It's true that there is violence. It's also true that students are trying their best to stop it. Why just report one side? In this revolution the students were the central force. Look at how many of them kept awake at night guarding the minorities without rejoicing in their success.
If hindus are attacked and some muslims are trying to protect them, then protect them from whom? It is not two side. It is one side only.

Two side would be when hindus are also attacking muslims, and then you can blame others for not reporting the other side.
 
I don't think so.

I'd expect hindutva warriors like Modi, Amit and Yogi bear to say something, but looks like they don't even care.

Address your Prime Minister with due respect.

It’s PM Modi
Preferably PM Modi ji, in case you follow the western casual approach PM Modi would be fine.
 
The students have rejected military rule. They want professor Younus to be the head of the interim government. You know how much the mullahs hate Professor Younus right ?

😂

Military will rule whether directly or by proxy.
 
Once again, in the aftermath many houses of even the Muslim students are getting attacked. Many awami Muslim leaders have been killed. It's a chaotic situation right now. Don't jump to any conclusion so early.
 
Keep your faith in the Bangladeshi students. Remember Jamat and BNP have tried to overthrow Hasina many times, with it ending in failure. It was the students who succeeded. Now our hope should be that they stop the Islamic extremists too. They are the brightest part of a nation. Place your hopes on them, pray if you are a theist.
 
The students are not Islamic extremists. They want professor Younus to head the interim government who is hated by Islamists.
Students are not the reason behind Hasina ousted.

This is coup behind the students and its done by army .

 
The students are not Islamic extremists. They want professor Younus to head the interim government who is hated by Islamists.
Only naive people ignorant of ground reality think that Mohd. Younus will be allowed to lead in anyway.
Wait for the reality to kick in. Students are good at revolting but in the aftermath. It is very easy to destroy a system (good or bad),putting a fair system in place, that's an highly improbable task in the hands of students.
Proof: Entire history of mankind!
 
Follow the Factbook page of some of the student leaders. They are not even using Islamic language like the minorities are the Amanat of Muslims, and so it's the duty of the Muslims to protect them. Instead They are saying minorities took part equally in 1971 and 2024, they are equal citizens of the country and their contributions are equally valuable. Their safety is their right as an equal citizen and not as a minority. Keep your faith on these students who have so clear understanding of the political language of human agency. Yes there is chances that extremists will hijack the scenarios. But keep faith.
 
Keep your faith in the Bangladeshi students. Remember Jamat and BNP have tried to overthrow Hasina many times, with it ending in failure. It was the students who succeeded. Now our hope should be that they stop the Islamic extremists too. They are the brightest part of a nation. Place your hopes on them, pray if you are a theist.

Bharat has helped Bangladesh gain independence and has historically supported Bangladesh but look at what we are getting in return. Islamists are bashing us and are singing brotherly songs with Pakistanis who considered you second class citizens , killed your people, massacred them. What is your bond with them if not for religion. Bangladesh has turned rogue and their people are bashing Bharat, attacking Hindus on the streets, vandalising Hindu temples.
 
Follow the Factbook page of some of the student leaders. They are not even using Islamic language like the minorities are the Amanat of Muslims, and so it's the duty of the Muslims to protect them. Instead They are saying minorities took part equally in 1971 and 2024, they are equal citizens of the country and their contributions are equally valuable. Their safety is their right as an equal citizen and not as a minority. Keep your faith on these students who have so clear understanding of the political language of human agency. Yes there is chances that extremists will hijack the scenarios. But keep faith.
Bhai, These students will be pushed aside and a radical wing to preserve the "new revolution" will take control. That's the standard operating procedure of all leaderless revolts especially by students.
Right now, they are cheering Mohd. Yonus and when he starts speaking against extremism or anything they don't like he will be shunted on the side.
Give one example, where students revolts have led to peaceful democracies, we can list tens of such revolts leading to further dictatorships.
 
Follow the Factbook page of some of the student leaders. They are not even using Islamic language like the minorities are the Amanat of Muslims, and so it's the duty of the Muslims to protect them. Instead They are saying minorities took part equally in 1971 and 2024, they are equal citizens of the country and their contributions are equally valuable. Their safety is their right as an equal citizen and not as a minority. Keep your faith on these students who have so clear understanding of the political language of human agency. Yes there is chances that extremists will hijack the scenarios. But keep faith.


Extremists have already hijacked the whole thing.

Explain why the Islamists were seen vandalising Mujeeb ur Rehman’s statue ? What kind of symbolic display was that if not to tell the world Islamists have taken over Bangladesh and they don’t give a damn about 1971 or whatever Bharat did over the years to help them. They would rather go slave themselves to a Pakistan once again. This is the message we are seeing. Pakistanis are calling your wi called freedom fighters traitors and want to celebrate this victory.
 
Extremists have already hijacked the whole thing.

Explain why the Islamists were seen vandalising Mujeeb ur Rehman’s statue ? What kind of symbolic display was that if not to tell the world Islamists have taken over Bangladesh and they don’t give a damn about 1971 or whatever Bharat did over the years to help them. They would rather go slave themselves to a Pakistan once again. This is the message we are seeing. Pakistanis are calling your wi called freedom fighters traitors and want to celebrate this victory.
I am an Indian.
 
I am an Indian.
Extremists have already hijacked the whole thing.

Explain why the Islamists were seen vandalising Mujeeb ur Rehman’s statue ? What kind of symbolic display was that if not to tell the world Islamists have taken over Bangladesh and they don’t give a damn about 1971 or whatever Bharat did over the years to help them. They would rather go slave themselves to a Pakistan once again. This is the message we are seeing. Pakistanis are calling your wi called freedom fighters traitors and want to celebrate this victory.
Also you don't know Mujib's whole history. He played a great role in 1971. But once he got power he turned a dictator very quickly. The brightest communist leaders including Siraj Shikdar was killed by him. But I am friends with many of the Bangladeshi students, nowhere are they rejoicing for Pakistan.
 
In summary, India has no friends left in the region.

Cursed by geography, now cursed by politics.
 
Maybe the safest solution would be to allow the hindus of BD to follow their leader Sheikh Hasina to India if they feel threatened at home. I believe India has a policy of accepting Hindu migrants favourably.
 
I am an Indian.
You remind me an an egyptian colleague I had. The day after Egptian Revolution, I saw him smiling for the first time and he said in the thousand year history of Egypt, they never had a people's govt. After things went south, he would pass by me in the hallway without saying anything. It is difficult to change the DNA of some countries. Bangladesh is not going to change.

Personally, I wish them a proper islamic country, so that they can fully embrace their identity.
 
While Pakistan is blessed by geography and politics.
Thread isn't about Pakistan.

When will you Indians learn? Why not address the criticism towards India instead of deflecting to Pakistan?

India is now Asia's first, and only, Billy no mates country.
 
Thread isn't about Pakistan.

When will you Indians learn? Why not address the criticism towards India instead of deflecting to Pakistan?

India is now Asia's first, and only, Billy no mates country.
So you concede that Pakistan is cursed by geography and cursed by politics, that is why you have no response.

Btw, thread is not about India either.
 
So you concede that Pakistan is cursed by geography and cursed by politics, that is why you have no response.

Btw, thread is not about India either.
Keep deflecting.

India has money but no friends. That's how pathetic India's status is. Pakistan has no money and no friends. Hardly a shocker. I though money bought friends and respect? LOL

Modi's India is finished, India has no friends, Hinduism will remain decentralised, and Modi is hated more by his own country folk than anyone else in the world, and it is clear why.
 
Back
Top