What's new

PoTW : MMHS

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,924
As always its down to the wise words of one of our most respected posters to put some sense into the whole debate on whether PCB got it right to schedule a Test in 'Pindi in December.

Congratulations [MENTION=79064]MMHS[/MENTION]


http://www.pakpassion.net/ppforum/s...i-Lanka-in-Rawalpindi&p=10584054#post10584054


You can’t - I can explain the reason scientifically, but I guess we’ll have to wait till PCB tries that in future for a proof.

This rain has has just allowed an excuse to PCB for saving their face, otherwise you could have seen the mockery of gamesmanship here. This is the 3rd millennium- no one gives a damn middle finger about sportsmanship. In a Test where you know that max you can get 330-350 overs and absolutely no space to extend play - whichever side is slightly behind will adopt unfair tactics to waste time. I can recall one Test in early 1990s vs WIN (Lahore) - they were in strong position at start of 4th innings, so they bowled abound 23 overs in 90+ minutes.... next day Imran & Masud Anwar (?) put a resistance and at one point it got a bit too close - WIN bowled 19 overs in almost two hours until umpires offered light - that’s in 90s, now you’ll see players faking injury to bring ambulances and some how take the game to 4:20pm.....

Look, I sound oxymoron because I can see few things. Being a Bangladeshi, living in Toronto, two months back when I came to know that SRL will travel to PAK and play two Tests there - my first post was : why Rawalpindi in December? This is science, you don’t need to be a genius to figure it out if you know the game. Few years back, I saw another stupendous stupidity from PCB - they brought Tea earlier, so that “... jayada se jayada cricket achhi roshni ke wakt may khela jaye ....”. Such an idiotic plan, when you need 6 hours + 30 minutes day light and, you have maximum 5 hours available.

There are only two solutions here - first one is to develop at least three-four southern venues - Karachi (2), Hyderabad (Don’t know why Niaz stadium didn’t host Cricket these days, Javed’s 280* was scored there), and one at Gwadar may be. Then, you can start Test matches at 9 am even in December and extend play till 4:30pm for full 90 overs. Northern venues can be compensated with games in their better day light time - August-Sep, Mar-May (I know about heat in PAK, which is another Bull Sh!t excuse - they are playing at Perth right now at 48C ground temperature).

Second one is to reschedule domestic Callander - white ball cricket doesn’t need day light, PSL can be arranged between Nov-Dec and that’s actually better for PCB - the more distant PSL is from IPL, the better. This will open the best period of cricket in PAK - Feb - May. They can arrange few LO domestic tournaments between Sep- Oct, then the grand show between Nov-Dec, a week’s break and by mid January start the FC season for 4/5 month’s uninterrupted cricket. And, this’ll help PAK players participating in domestic FC more as well - other all important mega events like BPL, BBL, Qatar League, UAE League, Afghan Leagues ... still haven’t invaded that small window between Feb- May, from the fear of IPL; but it’s not touching PAK players as they are not welcomed to IPL.

There is a 3rd solution as well, and I dare to say which has brought PAK cricket to this minnow level after 7 decades of glory (though I am sure [MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION] won’t agree with me here) - make wickets such that 300 overs are enough for a direct result in four innings game. Unfortunately, that’s where the problem started - those wickets make Awais Zia more valuable than Babar Azam (a blind slogged 65 is match winner there, instead of trying to build an innings over 6 hours - when you’ll hardly survive more than two hours) ....and Kashif Bhatti or Sadaf Khan more potent than Mo Asif (you can check their domestic stats). I suggests, better don’t go to that route.

I sincerely hope Wasim Khan is reading my disgusted rant, written at 3:30 am.
 
Well deserved. Pretty much all his posts are POTW worthy. By country mile the best poster on PP.
 
He is the Sachan of this forum. Always scoring 100s by giving his 100 percent in every posts he writes.
 
If [MENTION=79064]MMHS[/MENTION] can give three brilliant solutions. The why Waseem Khan can't come up with some potent solution who is being paid heavily.
 
Congratulations [MENTION=79064]MMHS[/MENTION] . By far the best poster on PP.
 
One of my favourite posters on this forum.

10th POTW for him - richly deserved
 
Bravo, well deserved. PCB and their poor planning and ideas continue to baffle.
 
PSL in Nov-Dec is a bad idea cause the southern hemisphere teams play their home season so all the good players would be busy on tours or domestic tournaments in the southern hemisphere.
 
Lol Not even player from Southern hemisphere comes for Psl So it doesnt affect us anyway

All We Get is first-class england cricketers and few dozens mercenaries.
 
Well deserved as always. However, would like to respond to a few of the points here and to MMHS's response to my post on the topic in another thread that is now locked.

Agree completely that there was a great probability of this game being washed off or being a draw due to weather and PCB would have known that. I also fully endorse your point about long term planning regarding the development of alternative venues. However, as of now, in the absence of valid alternatives, Pindi was the only viable option unless both tests were held in Karachi. That would have been much better in terms of results and having a meaningful series but as you pointed out yourself this was an emotional occasion and playing both matches in the same venue would have drawn a lot of criticism from the fans and media in other parts of the country (even if they wouldn't have actually come to the ground to watch it).

I don't think Hyderabad or Gwadar will solve the problem as it is pretty much the same as having all the matches in Karachi. You have to have a part of every series somewhere in Punjab (and hopefully in KPK as well). So the best solution would be your second recommendation where the schedule is rejigged and the test season is shifted either to Sept-Oct (pretty hot in some parts of the country) or mid-february onwards. However, given the tightrope act that is international scheduling and how difficult it already is to get teams to Pakistan I don't know how viable that will be.
 
Congrats MMHS. Seriously, I will ask for his autograph if I ever get to meet him.
 
Back
Top