Rank and rate these South African cricketers out of 10 in Tests

[Ted123]

Shaun Pollock
Graeme Smith
Hashim Amla
AB de Villiers
Vernon Philander
Morne Morkel

 

[Ab Fan]

Tests:

Shaun Pollock - 9
Graeme Smith- 8.5
Hashim Amla- 8.5
AB de Villiers- 8
Vernon Philander-7.5
Morne Morkel- 7

Overall(all formats combined):

Shaun Pollock= ABD > Amla > others

 

[Madplayer]

Shaun Pollock 8
Graeme Smith 9
Hashim Amla 8
AB de Villiers 7
Vernon Philander 7.5
Morne Morkel 6

 

[hafeezrocks]

Overall AB 10/10

Don't care about the rest.

 

[Joseph Gomes]

Overall AB 10/10

Don't care about the rest.

Nope, AB is nowhere near 10/10. He underachieved in tests.

 

[Hasan123]

Pollock 8
Smith 9
Amla 8.5
ABD 7.5
Philander 7
Morkel 6

 

[Ted123]

Shaun Pollock 8
Graeme Smith 9
Hashim Amla 8
AB de Villiers 7.5
Vernon Philander 7.5
Morne Morkel 6

Isn't Shaun Pollock a bit too low?

 

[Last Monetarist]

Shaun Pollock 8/10
Graeme Smith 8/10
Hashim Amla 8/10
AB de Villiers 7/10
Vernon Philander 7/10
Morne Morkel 6/10

 

[Madplayer]

Isn't Shaun Pollock a bit too low?

No he is perfectly okay at 8 i think. He was a very very good bowler but if you give him a 9 , what would you give guys like Allan donald or dale steyn who are superior to him?

Gareme smith seriously deserves a 9 because of his monumental contribution to SA cricket. Allan donald will be a 9 for me. Dale steyn would be a 9.5.

 

[Ab Fan]

No he is perfectly okay at 8 i think. He was a very very good bowler but if you give him a 9 , what would you give guys like Allan donald or dale steyn who are superior to him?

Gareme smith seriously deserves a 9 because of his monumental contribution to SA cricket. Allan donald will be a 9 for me. Dale steyn would be a 9.5.

Pollock was an ATG bowler.

 

[Madplayer]

Pollock was an ATG bowler.

Yes he is. No doubt about that but some ATGs are better than other ATGs. You think he as good as Donald and Steyn? I, for one, dont think so.

 

[Princejain191]

Graeme Smith - 9.5
Hashim Amla - 9
AB de Villiers - 8
Vernon Philander - 9
Morne Morkel - 7

 

[introvert]

Pollock 8.5
Smith 8.5
Amla 8.5
Ab 8
Philander 8
Morkel 7.5

 

[Ab Fan]

Yes he is. No doubt about that but some ATGs are better than other ATGs. You think he as good as Donald and Steyn? I, for one, dont think so.

They are better ofcourse.

 

[Bilal7]

1) Pollock: 9
2) Amla: 9
3) Smith: 8
4) ABD: 7.5
5) Philander: 7.5
6) Morkel: 6

 

[New Yorker]

No he is perfectly okay at 8 i think. He was a very very good bowler but if you give him a 9 , what would you give guys like Allan donald or dale steyn who are superior to him?

Gareme smith seriously deserves a 9 because of his monumental contribution to SA cricket. Allan donald will be a 9 for me. Dale steyn would be a 9.5.

This is not The Highlander. There can be more than one.

I have no problem giving Steyn a 10. He is not just ATG but goes head to head with McGrath and Marshall for best ever. Mad SR.

 

[thelandofthebravepeople]

Shaun Pollock 9.5/10
Graeme Smith 9/10
Hashim Amla 9/10
AB de Villiers 9,5/10
Vernon Philander 8.8/10
Morne Morkel 8/10

 

[khurram39]

Shaun Pollock
Graeme Smith
Hashim Amla
AB de Villiers
Vernon Philander
Morne Morkel

They are all best players and one can easily have these players in his team. If you have more bowling options then you think on last two otherwise they are pretty well and deserve high numbers.

 

[Madplayer]

This is not The Highlander. There can be more than one.

I have no problem giving Steyn a 10. He is not just ATG but goes head to head with McGrath and Marshall for best ever. Mad SR.

Just curious here, if you give Steyn a 10, What will you give Bradman?

 

[New Yorker]

Just curious here, if you give Steyn a 10, What will you give Bradman?

Why 11 of course #SpinalTapForever