Rate these South African players out of 10

[Ted123]

Jacques kallis
Shaun Pollock
Graeme Smith
AB de Villiers
Hashim Amla
Gary Kirsten

 

[Cuts_and_cuts_hard]

Kallis
Pollock
Amla
Smith
Kirsten
AB de Villiers

 

[giri26]

Jacques kallis - 9
Shaun Pollock - 9
Graeme Smith - 8
AB de Villiers - 7
Hashim Amla - 7
Gary Kirsten - 7

 

[Bilal7]

Kallis: 10 - Doesn't get much better than Kallis.
Amla: 9 - ATG.
Pollock: 8.5 - ATG.
Smith: 8.5 - Great batsmen, legendary captain.
de Villiers: 8 - Great.
Kirsten: 7 - A good player.

 

[Ab Fan]

Combining all formats,

Kallis
Pollock
de Villiers
Amla
Smith
Kirsten

In tests:

Kallis - 9.25
Pollock -8.75
Smith -8.5
Amla - 8.25 /8.5
de Villiers -7.5
Kirsten - 7.5

 

[Hasan123]

Kallis 9.5
Pollock 9
ABD 8.5
Amla 8
Smith 9
Kirsten 7.5

 

[Majestic]

Jacques kallis - 9
Shaun Pollock - 9
Graeme Smith - 8.5
AB de Villiers -8.5
Hashim Amla -8
Gary Kirsten -7.5

 

[jagatk]

Jacques kallis - 9
Shaun Pollock - 8
Graeme Smith - 7
AB de Villiers -9
Hashim Amla -6.5
Gary Kirsten -7.5

 

[BreadPakoda]

Jacques kallis - 8.5
Shaun Pollock - 8.5
Graeme Smith - 8.5
AB de Villiers - 8
Hashim Amla - 6.5
Gary Kirsten -7.5

 

[Ab Fan]

Jacques kallis
Shaun Pollock
Graeme Smith
AB de Villiers
Hashim Amla
Gary Kirsten

The first four are ATGs, rest South African greats.

 

[Ab Fan]

Combining all formats,

Kallis
Pollock
de Villiers
Amla
Smith
Kirsten

In tests:

Kallis - 9.25
Pollock -8.75
Smith -8.5
<B>Amla - 8.25 /8.5
de Villiers -7.5</B>
Kirsten - 7.5

Over the last three months:-

Amla slips to 8/8.25.
AB is a 8 now.

Others remain same.