What's new

Research shows that half of cricket umpires face verbal abuse in the UK! Thankless job?

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,862
More than half of cricket umpires say they have been a victim of verbal abuse, according to a new research seen by the BBC.

The University of Portsmouth gathered data from hundreds of umpires about the abuse they receive.
Around 50% said abuse, such as swearing and aggressive confrontations, had increased in recent times.

Cricket chiefs said umpires were vital to the game and the findings were "disappointing but not surprising".

Spitting and swearing

One umpire, who wanted to remain anonymous, has been officiating in Derbyshire for six years.
He told 5 live Investigates that he regularly encounters problems.

"I've had a person spit at me… how would you feel if someone spat at you? I think it's the most deplorable and disgusting thing you could ever think of.

"I've been sworn at… that's a regular thing, every match."

A total of 763 umpires in England responded to the survey. The vast majority were officiating at a recreational level.

Half said that they received abuse every couple of games or a couple of times a season.

In 2015, five matches in the recreational game in the UK had to be abandoned following outbreaks of violence.

'Concerning'

Just over 40% said that abuse was making them question whether or not to continue umpiring.
Dr Tom Webb, senior lecturer in sports management at the University of Portsmouth and one of academics behind the research, said: "What we are noticing is there is an underlying trend here and particularly in cricket, given the spirit of cricket, there is an issue and something that needs to be addressed."

In addition, nearly 3% said they had been a victim of physical abuse as an umpire.

"We didn't expect to see any umpires in cricket saying they had been physically abused. So that is concerning," added Dr Webb.

Abuse of umpires is not the only concern affecting the sport.

Violence

In 2015, five recreational matches in the UK had to be abandoned because of violence.

Chris Brownhill from Kingswinford was taking part in a Sunday friendly earlier this year when fighting broke out.

"All hell broke loose," he said. "One of our lads said a comment he shouldn't have then the batsman peeled off his pads and came charging towards our fielder.

"I managed to restrain him for a little bit before people were descending into a brawl."
Meanwhile, a cricketer in Sheffield was banned from playing the sport for 12 years after he assaulted another player during a match in July.

The game's law-makers, the MCC, have been trialling new on-field sanctions in an attempt to improve behaviour.

They range from penalty runs to giving umpires the power to dismiss players.
MCC head of laws Fraser Stewart said a final decision had yet to be made on whether they would be enshrined in law: "It's something we trialled this year and we're just getting the feedback which initially seems quite positive."

Nick Cousins, head of the England and Wales Cricket Board Association of Cricket Officials (ACO), said: "The game cannot afford to lose these people.

"If we are being told that large numbers of them are considering giving up the game because of increasing amounts of player abuse, then the one thing we can't do is nothing.

"We'll continue to work hard to improve player behaviour to ensure that players and umpires have a good experience when they take part in the game."

http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-37865718
 
Wonder how bad things are in Pakistan and India?
 
Umpires should walk off if they are abused and shouldnt come back until the offending players are removed from the field.
 
Umpires should walk off if they are abused and shouldnt come back until the offending players are removed from the field.

Umpires are the ones that uphold the rules on the field, if they walk off, there will be no one to mandate the match.
 
Exactly, players will learn pretty quickly.

Nope - if there's no punishment and instead umpires have to be whimsical for the game to be progressed then than makes the playing environment unfair and unjust. There should be stronger rules in place to eradicate umpire abuse, although it doesn't happen very often at the top of the game.
 
This article only focuses on the specifics of a bigger story but I'd like to say that when an Umpire stops being an Umpire then that abuse which comes is only natural, now when I say when an Umpire stops being an Umpire I'm not entirely referring to incompetency alone, these angels provoke the behaviour which they receive; every action has an equal and opposite reaction, always remember that.
 
Wonder how bad things are in Pakistan and India?

In Pakistan my guess would be that its a whole different scenario.

The umpire being an elder is probable respected due to our culture ethics.
 
So [MENTION=46929]shaz619[/MENTION] has played in half of all UK club games. What a playa :yk
 
This article only focuses on the specifics of a bigger story but I'd like to say that when an Umpire stops being an Umpire then that abuse which comes is only natural, now when I say when an Umpire stops being an Umpire I'm not entirely referring to incompetency alone, these angels provoke the behaviour which they receive; every action has an equal and opposite reaction, always remember that.

I kind of agree with this view.

Umpiring should be like customer service, you need to be a punching bag.
Anything an umpire says could turn against him, so its best if he stays stubborn and doesn't need to offer any explanation.

In our club circuit, where the umpire is chosen from the batting side, if an argument arise, the umpire only responds to the captain, no one else.
 
its not a thankless job because they get paid

every empire / referee in every sport faces abuse
 
Back
Top