What's new

"Salman Butt is still good enough to play for Pakistan" : Yasir Arafat

Saj

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Jun 1, 2001
Runs
96,138
In his latest blog for PakPassion.net, Pakistan all-rounder Yasir Arafat writes about some of the much talked about players in the ongoing National One-day cup tournament including Salman Butt and Mohammad Asif, looks at a couple of players who have impressed him in this season’s domestic circuit, and assesses the quality of the cricket in the National One-day cup.


yasir_arafat_cms_2.jpg


Sadaf Hussain

Sadaf is a much improved and totally different bowler these days. He’s picked up a yard of pace and is bowling consistently over 80 mph, around 83 or 84 mph. He’s a tall man and gains extra bounce from even the placid surfaces of Karachi which can trouble most batsmen. He bowled really well against my team Rawalpindi where he took five wickets but he has also been consistent throughout the National One-Day cup taking wickets in every match he has played in. I’m surprised that he’s not been picked for at least the Pakistan A team as I think he deserves that opportunity due to his performances and consistency in domestic cricket. If the criteria to be selected for the Pakistan team is to perform in domestic cricket then Sadaf definitely deserves a chance. In the past people have questioned his lack of pace but this season he looks stronger and definitely a quicker bowler than in previous years. He's performed well for the last three or four years and the Pakistani selectors should give him a chance. I think if he can work a bit on his fielding and batting, then he can definitely go on and play for Pakistan.


Fakhar Zaman

To me he looks like a compact batsman who has all the attributes to do well in domestic cricket and then go on and play international cricket. However I think it would be too soon to throw him into international cricket. Pick him for Pakistan A tours and see how he performs and let him mature in domestic cricket first and score heavily there. Watching him bat, he seems to have all the shots and he has a good head on his shoulders and looks like a player who has patience and can build an innings well. He’s definitely one to keep an eye on and I think if he continues to improve he could go on and play for Pakistan.


Mohammad Asif

I played against Mohammad Asif and Salman Butt recently and both of them impressed me particularly given they have not played any first-class cricket for five years. Watching Asif, nothing much has changed, he still swung and seamed the new ball around and put the ball in the right areas consistently which has always been his strength. His pace is around the same, but he’s obviously never been a bowler who was very quick and never relied on speed to confuse opponents. He will obviously be a little rusty due to lack of cricket but I think he’ll be back to his best after a full season in domestic cricket. When you’ve not played cricket for five years, particularly a bowler it doesn’t matter how good you are or experienced you are, it will take some time for you to reach the standard you once were. Give Asif a few more months and he will undoubtedly be back to his best.


Salman Butt

I was very impressed with Salman’s batting. He scored around 30 against Rawalpindi but he was batting fluently. It seemed like despite having only played a few domestic matches so far he was in good shape. He looked fit, was moving his feet nicely and timing the ball well. It didn't look to me like here was a player who had been away from cricket for five years. I think if he continues his good form it’s only a matter of time before the selectors pick him for Pakistan again. Technically he looked good, his form has been impressive and his fitness levels look very good. However he’s another who will benefit from a full season in domestic cricket and we may see him in even better form in the second season. He's still good enough to play for Pakistan.


Two to watch

I’ve been very impressed with Zain Abbas of KRL. He looks a very promising batsman and has a fine array of shots. His defence looked solid and his attacking stroke play was excellent. He scored a century against us and really impressed me. He's a batsman who has scored runs in four-day cricket and looks a quality cricketer to me. I think the Pakistani selectors should keep an eye on this batsman as I believe he is definitely one for the future.

Also Altaf Ahmed the Habib Bank medium fast bowler impressed me. He's good with the new ball and also bowls some excellent yorkers with the old ball at a good pace.


Rawalpindi

Our batting has really struggled so far this season not only in the fifty-over format but also in the four-day format. We've simply not been good enough and we need to have a long hard look at the cricket we have played, especially in the batting department and look to improve in future.


National One-Day Cup

The tournament has been split between two venues, Karachi and Rawalpindi. In Karachi where we have been playing the wickets have largely been batting-friendly and in Rawalpindi the scores have been much lower than in Karachi, as the pitches have been seamer-friendly. Conditions in Karachi are a lot drier and the weather has been hot and humid so the batsmen have flourished. I guess it's a good opportunity for the bowlers to learn when they are playing in Karachi and likewise it's a good test for the batsmen who are playing in the half of the competition which is based in Rawalpindi.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Good blog.I am encouraged by his observation of Sadaf Hussain.What else does the bloke need to do?Get 20 wickets in a four day match?
 
We lack good coaches and selectors

This is hampering the development of players

Also we need to question the analyst in Pakistan team The one who is meant to analyse each player from his own team and the opposition and then comeback with a gameplan , no wonder our batsmen and bowlers are clueless.

I really think we need a foreign head coach and batting coach.

A foreign game analyst

Luden as fielding coach

Shoaib akhter as bowling coach
Keep mushtaq as spin coach

At u19 and Nca likes of azhar Mahmood , yasir Arafat and wasim akram as bowling coaches

Muhammad yusuf to work with youngsters on batting at nca and u19s


And saqlain as spin coach u19s

I'd make Amir sohail the selector who alongside mentioned coaches at nca u19s shall select the players from domestic cricket one criteria will be too go to the first class matches and see the matches properly and then scout the players that impress them not rely on cricinfo stats , pp hype and media pressure


The reason I mentioned Amir sohail because he is a good judge of technique

He's the one who vouched for rahat Ali

And rahat Ali has all the ingredients to be a good bowler height pace and natural swing , plus his recommendation and selection came on the back of strong pentangular tournament where he was leading wicket taker .
 
Really excellent blog with insights not normally available to the fan base, really well done to pp.

Yasir is a really honest and genuinely lovely human being, so for me his observations I'm sure are very honest. Agree with the posters above that his comments on sadaf Hussein are extremely encouraging, at least to the fan base. I suspect the idiots in charge of selection though will not have spent as much time as the average fan in scanning available talent, so it would absolutely be no surprise at all to see him languish at the top of the domestic league tables like fawad alam.
 
a proper insight into domestic cricket affairs, good stuff from Yasir Arafat and PP.
 
Altaf Ahmed Khan is not medium pace. Yasir was impressed by his pace yet he wrote him as medium pace.

I have seen him bowl in 2 matches. He is right arm fast who had no control. Good to know that now he bowls with control. Unfortunately he cannot be in reckoning with so less wickets than others.


The way Fakhar and Asif Zakir were going in national one day cup I had no doubt that they would have been top run getters in national one day cup ahead of kamran and Salman.

Salman's strike rate is very poor. He cannot replace Shehzad with this strike rate, if he does pakistan will remain in trouble. Ahmed Shehzad should be replaced by an opener who has a career list A strike rate of 90+ ideally 95+
 
Now now, this will hurt some posters who say Sadaf bowls at 125 on the basis of a few deliveries they saw 3,4 years back.
 
Interesting comments on Butt and Asif [MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION]

Great Read, also a shame that arafat has not been given a lengthy run in our T20 team.
 
One thing I like when I speak to Yasir Arafat is that his opinions are without bias or favouritism.

He doesn't care whether a player is from Karachi, Lahore or wherever else he will give an honest opinion.

Opinions on Sadaf are interesting.
 
Encouraging remarks regarding Sadaf. If he is 83-84 mph and can move the ball around, he is worth a try
 
Now now, this will hurt some posters who say Sadaf bowls at 125 on the basis of a few deliveries they saw 3,4 years back.
That has never been my worry.

You already have a tail even worse than Zimbabwe and Bangladesh. If Sadaf or anyone else sneaks in as the fourth bowler they need to be able to bat.

Yet this interview makes clear that he has improved his strength - bowling - but that his weaknesses in bowling and fielding persist.

It just seems so unprofessional.
 
That has never been my worry.

You already have a tail even worse than Zimbabwe and Bangladesh. If Sadaf or anyone else sneaks in as the fourth bowler they need to be able to bat.

Yet this interview makes clear that he has improved his strength - bowling - but that his weaknesses in bowling and fielding persist.

It just seems so unprofessional.
Sadaf would not be replacing Wahab in the lineup. Also, Amir is likely to be the part of the team next time we play tests. Sadaf will come in for Rahat/Imran, who are both duds with the bat anyways.
In ODIs too, Amir and Wahab will be there. Also Zafar is now likely to play. So we can afford a number 11 who can't bat. Also this reason is why YOU don't want him to play. Selectors haven't been keeping him out for this reason. We've had Rahat, Irfan, Talha, Imran, Irfan, Junaid play for us. We have had Rahat come in at no. 9 for us. So while you might consider batting the reason for why he shouldn't play, selectos don't have that reason.
 
Pakistani cricketers who have spent more time in England or have more exposure to international clubs generally comment positively about fellow cricketers, and hardly undermine them unneccessarily. I'm talking about Yasir, Azhar, Mushi and some others. Unlike cricketers who didn't have much international cultural exposure like MoYo and Razzaq always find ways to criticize others.

Yasir might not be a great cricketer but with his vast experience, could be a great coach of any T20 team, in future.
 
Sadaf Hussain, Fakhar Zaman and Nauman Anwar treated like a step son by the selectors.............................
 
Yeah with the kind of inconsistent openers with us,Butt literally deserves a chance in place of either shehzad or azhar.
More importantly there should be a left hand,right hand opening pair and Butt could fill in the gap.
 
Interesting comments on Butt and Asif [MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION]

Great Read, also a shame that arafat has not been given a lengthy run in our T20 team.

you want to reconsider accepting Butt back now ? I think we need him more than our egos despise him
 
Seeing Pakistani batsmen in PSL, He deserves to play for Pakistan on merit
 
Initially I thought Butt wouldn't make an international comenback, but given recent performances by our openers, I wouldnt be suprised if Butt is recalled in future.
 
Initially I thought Butt wouldn't make an international comenback, but given recent performances by our openers, I wouldnt be suprised if Butt is recalled in future.

Agree and saying this for many days , we don't have replacement for Fast Bowler and Opening Batsmen in Domestic circuit
 
Yasir Arafat comeback

We are looking for a genuine fast bowling allrounder, I was thinking Yasir Arafat is only 33 years old and he was a good bowler and could also bat a bit why don't we play him? Not as we have Wasims and Razzaqs already waiting.
 
We are looking for a genuine fast bowling allrounder, I was thinking Yasir Arafat is only 33 years old and he was a good bowler and could also bat a bit why don't we play him? Not as we have Wasims and Razzaqs already waiting.

He bats like a tailender.
 
He would have nicked first ball into the slips on a pitch like yesterday
 
I remember him scoring on such pitches. Scoring against McGrath, Warne and co in such conditions. Then scoring tons over two-paced wickets.

On bouncy pitches yes he scored but on seaming tracks he was a sitting duck.
 
Time to select Salman Butt in LOIs

If Amir can play then he should play as well.

He is clearly the best opener we have right now.:lara
 
Amir, Asif and Butt were three good players back then.

One can safely say that just like Amir, Butt and Asif will also show that he is better than the other dross.

Butt was not world class, but he wipes the floor with Manzoor and Sharjeel any day of the week.

It is painful to say this, but Shehzad and Butt combo seems to be our best bet at the moment.

Painful because one of them is mediocre and the other decent at best who hasn't played for 6 years.

Sums up Pakistan cricket.
 
Amir, Asif and Butt were three good players back then.

One can safely say that just like Amir, Butt and Asif will also show that he is better than the other dross.

Butt was not world class, but he wipes the floor with Manzoor and Sharjeel any day of the week.

It is painful to say this, but Shehzad and Butt combo seems to be our best bet at the moment.

Painful because one of them is mediocre and the other decent at best who hasn't played for 6 years.

Sums up Pakistan cricket.

I dont want shehzad in the team , oh man!!! Where are the other options though? I cant believe i am saying it but Maybe sami aslam should be selected again? Dont think much of him but he wasn't given chances. One ODI and he scored 45 at 90 sr. I have forgotten who else is there.
 
Butt's case is not simple, he was never as talented as Amir was and older too. Let him perform in domestic cricket first, exceptionally, then decide,
 
I dont want shehzad in the team , oh man!!! Where are the other options though? I cant believe i am saying it but Maybe sami aslam should be selected again? Dont think much of him but he wasn't given chances. One ODI and he scored 45 at 90 sr. I have forgotten who else is there.

Sami Aslam could not score more than 20 runs in 4 innings on the flattest of Bangladeshi wickets where the likes of Hafeez and Tamim scored double hundreds.

These days, he also fails against any half-decent attack in A/warmup matches. Safe to say that the 45 he scored was a one-off performance.

Would rather put faith in Butt than him. At the least the former has some international pedigree, and would have had close to 20 ODI tons by now.
 
Yes, we should bring back Asif and Butt. It is quite apparent how pathetic our team is without them and at least those 2 have performed in the past and I would bet on them to perform much better than the garbage that we have now. Hell I would bet even Miandad at this age could bat better than Manzoor.
 
Salman Butt has scored 76 vs one of the best pace bowling lineup of Qea in a daynight match.

1. Shehzad Azam Rana

2. Hasan Ali

3. Mohammad Irfan (21)


He only averages 30 in Test Cricket in a sample set of 62 test innings.


I checked his Fc average and it was 40.66. It was abit surprising.

I subtracted his Test Numbers and found out that Salman's Fc batting Average is 47.1. This Fc average is the best in Pakistan wrt Openers with more than 2000 Fc runs.


I am not his Fan as an Individual or as a player but if he scores in next 5 Fc matches than I think he will give tough time to 4,5 openers who are eyeing 3rd opener position in Pakistan Test Squad for the tour of NZ & Australia.

[MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION]
 
Salman Butt has scored 76 vs one of the best pace bowling lineup of Qea in a daynight match.

1. Shehzad Azam Rana

2. Hasan Ali

3. Mohammad Irfan (21)


He only averages 30 in Test Cricket in a sample set of 62 test innings.


I checked his Fc average and it was 40.66. It was abit surprising.

I subtracted his Test Numbers and found out that Salman's Fc batting Average is 47.1. This Fc average is the best in Pakistan wrt Openers with more than 2000 Fc runs.


I am not his Fan as an Individual or as a player but if he scores in next 5 Fc matches than I think he will give tough time to 4,5 openers who are eyeing 3rd opener position in Pakistan Test Squad for the tour of NZ & Australia.


[MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION]
I reluctantly agree.

I will never lose my anger towards him, but currently there is zero back-up for if Azhar or Sami break a hand. Butt has to be the spare opener.
 
Yes would field better than Azhar & Shehzad and would Bat with 40 plus Ave & SR of 80 plus.


Attrocious Captaincy has brightened his comeback chances.

Imad's poor fitness and inconsistent batting performances mean He won't be given captaincy. Rightly So.

Umar Amin is well spoken, intelligent and quite fit lately but too too soft character to be handed over captaincy.

Hafeez might get dropped as he is 37, not as good bowler as he was before ban and plays at Poor SR.


Malik might decline Captaincy offer again.


No other Choice if Sarfraz does not improve.


Salman Butt did not have cricketing abilities like Imran but He was well spoken, intelligent, shrewd, tactical genious. He made a terrible call for few thousand pounds at his peak cricketing years. He was improving as a batsman too and would have been still playing averaging 47 in Test Cricket Yes UAE man and 45 with 80-83 SR in Odi Cricket thanks to UAE. But corruption destroyed him when he had his peak years infront of him.


PCB invested in him for 12 years atleast when he made that horrible choice. Still if Sarfraz doesn't improve as Captain, Sethi doesn't become Pcb head, Inzamam stays at CS, Malik declines captaincy offer than Salman Butt will be back as Opener and Pakistan Captain. (All If's should work) Salman did Spot fixing but remember in Past there were 4 Match fixers who Captained Pakistan. 2 of them did Spot fixing at ICL aswell. So Salman is a lesser Sinner/Criminal.


Let me dissapoint you all with one last thing. 32 years old Salman Butt, Shoaib Malik (35), Amad Butt (22) & Kamran Ghulam (21) are the fittest Cricketers in Pakistan. Yeah 32 years old Salman Butt.
 
Back
Top