Should PCT prioritize a specialist spinner over the "versatility" of Shadab Khan

[gazza619]

Pakistan will win more games with a proper, specialist spinner than with a part‑time one — unless Shadab is genuinely contributing with ball and bat.

Right now, Shadab Khan is not doing that, while Usman Tariq is capable of what a frontline spinner is supposed to do.

Is the Team management keen for Pakistan to win?

 

[sweep_shot]

Shadab is not needed.

Pakistan already have Abrar, Saim, and M Nawaz. There are Sufiyan and Usman Tariq on the bench also.

 

[DeadlyVenom]

Sheddy should play but need to understand his role. If he is a batting all rounder then he plays and we can drop Babar and bring in someone else.

As a bowling all rounder then yeah it's tough to slot him in. Especially if he is slotted in after Nawaz.

 

[jnaveen1980]

Given the amount of collapses Pakistan suffered last year they will play Shadab.

 

[Devadwal]

I think Pakistan don't need Salam Mirza to play , they are going to play in Lankan conditions so can play Faheem as an second Pacer Along with Shaheen.

I'm this case they can play a pure spinner usman Tariq so batting depth remains same.

 

[GoUgandaCranes]

Personally I like him but he's probably the most halwa spinner in international circuit.

Tariq, Faisal Akram, & Sufyan offer more with the ball without any doubt. The batting for Shadab just hasn't proceeded to the next level and he's not better than Hassan Nawaz. He's there for the balance but being below average in both just doesn't add anything to the team.

Then the team is also trying to fit in Babar, Fakhar, Agha, & Usman and when we consider all of that, that cannot happen.

 

[jnaveen1980]

I think Pakistan don't need Salam Mirza to play , they are going to play in Lankan conditions so can play Faheem as an second Pacer Along with Shaheen.

I'm this case they can play a pure spinner usman Tariq so batting depth remains same.

what if the pitch suddenly plays like a road lol

 

[RedwoodOriginal]

I know he didn't fire today but Shadab's batting is definitely a plus. He might even have the highest batting strike-rate in the team. Bowling is definitely a plus for the opposition but I guess they are hoping that he can be more effective as a part of the spin-attack where the bowling is more centred around Abrar, Nawaz and Saim.

 

[hur rizvi]

He is still bowling filth

At the moment he shouldn’t bowl unless some other spinner is having a howler

 

[hur rizvi]

Pakistan at least need to drop one of babar/fakhar though practically both shouldn’t play

Usman khan is terrible too

Too many weak spots in this T20 team

 

[DRsohail]

He is not needed.

 

[Concerned]

Shadab is the son in-law of an X cricketer. That's his place secured until retirement regardless of performance

 

[Rana]

He is not needed.

He is more useful than Zimbu

 

[Slim]

Hundred percent. We should play Usman Tariq and Abrar both. Its a no brainer. Shadab never merited his place, he was parachuted into the squad by Hesson who is day by day getting exposed as a fraud.

 

[DeadlyVenom]

Hundred percent. We should play Usman Tariq and Abrar both. Its a no brainer. Shadab never merited his place, he was parachuted into the squad by Hesson who is day by day getting exposed as a fraud.

I think his hands are tied by Aqib..

But I don't think the selection of Shadab is as bad as people are saying.

He is a handy T20 cricketer for these conditions.

If Babar is dropped for another batter the team looks better.

 

[RidiculousMan]

Hundred percent. We should play Usman Tariq and Abrar both. Its a no brainer. Shadab never merited his place, he was parachuted into the squad by Hesson who is day by day getting exposed as a fraud.

I hope in the big matches in WT20. Hesson actually plays both Abrar and Tariq. Provided conditions continue to assist the spinners.

Not playing Tariq here much could be strategy. As he has a mystery about him with his bowling and pause in it. He'll trouble lots of batters who'll be playing him the very first time.

 

[RidiculousMan]

I think his hands are tied by Aqib..

But I don't think the selection of Shadab is as bad as people are saying.

He is a handy T20 cricketer for these conditions.

If Babar is dropped for another batter the team looks better.

This XI is much better.

1. Saim
2. Farhan
3. Salman
4. Hasan
5. Nafay (wk)
6. Shadab
7. Nawaz
8. Faheem
9. Shaheen
10. Abrar
11. Tariq / Mirza

 

[DRsohail]

He is more useful than Zimbu

Babar is super star, he will stay, you can keep whining.

 

[Slim]

I think his hands are tied by Aqib..

But I don't think the selection of Shadab is as bad as people are saying.

He is a handy T20 cricketer for these conditions.

If Babar is dropped for another batter the team looks better.

I dont think Aqib has anything to do with Shadab’s selection.

Shadab’s selection has IU connection. Hesson made him VC as soon as he joined the team.

One of Babar Fakhar needs to be dropped for Hassan Nawaz.

 

[TeymurBlake]

I would actually bring in Faheem for Shadab. Maybe take out Fakhar Zaman for Usman Tariq.

Pakistan definitely have a bowling attack which can consistently take 10 wickets.

 

[Devadwal]

I think his hands are tied by Aqib..

But I don't think the selection of Shadab is as bad as people are saying.

He is a handy T20 cricketer for these conditions.

If Babar is dropped for another batter the team looks better.

Most spinners gain control over the ball with time, but Shadab is the opposite; his control accuracy is diminishing. He bowls at least three boundaries per over (long-hip, full-toss).

What is his father in-law doing as he was Great limited over spinner.

 

[Flat_Track_Bully]

Why do they keep bringing him back. He neither a good batter or bowler at international level.

 

[Katwalindian]

Most spinners gain control over the ball with time, but Shadab is the opposite; his control accuracy is diminishing. He bowls at least three boundaries per over (long-hip, full-toss).

What is his father in-law doing as he was Great limited over spinner.

He was good from 2018 to 2022

 

[Slim]

Why do they keep bringing him back. He neither a good batter or bowler at international level.

The damads of Pakistan cricket.

 

[Raja Ishtiaq]

Shadab needs to go.

We can't afford any passengers in this team

 

[Raja Ishtiaq]

Babar is super star, he will stay, you can keep whining.

There is a saying that applies to him. Bandar kya jaane adhrak ka suaad

 

[shamaan]

Him and Fahim should are fighting for that 1 position.

 

[shamaan]

If Saim wasnt in the xi and wasnt bowling any overs then yes play a specialist spinner however Saim is bowling really well so I rather go with batter who can bowl.

 

[pakistani pride]

He is still bowling filth

At the moment he shouldn’t bowl unless some other spinner is having a howler

Then what is his point in the team?

 

[gazza619]

If Saim wasnt in the xi and wasnt bowling any overs then yes play a specialist spinner however Saim is bowling really well so I rather go with batter who can bowl.

Though Saim has pulled above his weight as a bowler, I am still not comfortable in him opening the bowling on a regular basis. We need proper bowlers

 

[hur rizvi]

Faheem at present seems a better option than shadab

His bowling utility is zero

 

[BouncerGuy]

Shadab can be rested for Faheem and we can try Usman Tariq also...

 

[DeadlyVenom]

I dont think Aqib has anything to do with Shadab’s selection.

Shadab’s selection has IU connection. Hesson made him VC as soon as he joined the team.

One of Babar Fakhar needs to be dropped for Hassan Nawaz.

YOu are right, Shadab is Hesson. Its a good selection. I know many are against him but he is an X Factor plyer and needs opportunities post his injury recovery to see if he is capable of bowling to his best.

It makes sense that Hesson would bring his franchise captain back.

Babar, Fakhar, removal of Hassan Nawaz, Abbas Afridi etc I feel is Aqibs hand.

 

[BouncerGuy]

NO PERSONAL REMARKS PLEASE

 

[Josh]

Shadab will be Pakistan's captain if they do.badly at this coming world cup

 

[Hyder]

Shadab is not the problem

4 5 6 of babar fakhar usman is the problem

I d like usman tariq to play

Shadab
Nawaz
Usman
Saim
Abrar

5 spinners
With faheem and shaheen should be enough.
If pitch seems pace friendly then we can draft in salman