What's new

The 27th Amendment: Dictatorship Codified

Are the main items in 27th Amendment, the final nail in the coffin of Pakistan’s democracy?


  • Total voters
    10
Interesting take!

I understand that Pakistan’s situation is unique where no PM was able to complete their full term. But it also signified that, judiciary is balancing parliament which infact is a good thing. What was actually lagging was the unchecked power of the establishment / army. I understand your point you wanted to empower PM but you are weakening the judiciary in such a way that establishment further is unchecked.

The concept if immunity for COAS is farcical. This only means that, he knows he will be involved in politics and he doesn't want politicians to come back at him.

This move removes accountability on so many levels.
The decisions by some previous judges have made it evident that their powers must be restricted otherwise they will never allow parliament to run properly. In india supreme court can only take action when there is any changes done in basic structure of their constitution.

But pakistan me aaway ka aawaa hi bigraa hua hai

Even an office boy in government offices are more powerful than CEOs of private companies.
 
This is not the gotcha you think it is. I agree there is forces influence in politics and we are not a true democracy in that sense but that is how we have been since 14 Aug 1947. It s however getting better. What I dont agree is that elections were rigged just because IK lost.

There are no saints in politics. It is the hypocrisy of PTI supporters which gets me. Head in the sand when IK and QB were ruling roost eh?
Its not a gotcha( that happened with your stupidity on the governor of Punjab), it points your own contradictions and stupidity. You cant on the one hand claim there is no evidence and then at the same time claim its been going on since 1947. Yes,we know its been going on since 1947 and today we have another Martial Law with the criminal Munir at its help. PK cannot move forward when losers dont even understand their own contradictory posts.
 
Its not a gotcha( that happened with your stupidity on the governor of Punjab), it points your own contradictions and stupidity. You cant on the one hand claim there is no evidence and then at the same time claim its been going on since 1947. Yes,we know its been going on since 1947 and today we have another Martial Law with the criminal Munir at its help. PK cannot move forward when losers dont even understand their own contradictory posts.
You are a sellout using Hindvata logic and calling our biggest patriot a criminal. No point arguing with you. No wonder Emranabbas did not bother with you after owning you ad nauseam.
 
You are a sellout using Hindvata logic and calling our biggest patriot a criminal. No point arguing with you. No wonder Emranabbas did not bother with you after owning you ad nauseam.
This is just embarrassing. You have admitted he broke his oath to Allah and then you call him a patriot. Surely the Modi cow farms have better trolls.🤣🤣🤣
 
You are a sellout using Hindvata logic and calling our biggest patriot a criminal. No point arguing with you. No wonder Emranabbas did not bother with you after owning you ad nauseam.

What is a hybrid regime Khwaja talks about? Is that legal and doesnt it go against the oath they take. Don't tell me Khwaja is also against you guys
 
army chiefs in Pak throughout history have been imprisoning prime ministers, leaders, going over elected governments and judiciary. Am I too far off saying that? What is this amendment going to achieve? Is there something that wasn’t already there lol? What am I missing? Simplified explanation for a noob please 🙏
 
army chiefs in Pak throughout history have been imprisoning prime ministers, leaders, going over elected governments and judiciary. Am I too far off saying that? What is this amendment going to achieve? Is there something that wasn’t already there lol? What am I missing? Simplified explanation for a noob please 🙏
Mushraff could still have a case against him for what he did.. don’t think it can be done anymore.. anyone can correct me..
 
Mushraff could still have a case against him for what he did.. don’t think it can be done anymore.. anyone can correct me..
When someone really with a vendetta against Asim Munir (ex Imran) comes back, this amendment will also go in the dustbin I feel. That’s what I am not understanding why so much hulla.
 
When someone really with a vendetta against Asim Munir (ex Imran) comes back, this amendment will also go in the dustbin I feel. That’s what I am not understanding why so much hulla.
You expect Imran to come back? FM is even younger to IK.. also bringing down an amendment is literally next to impossible, Pak Army needed complete set of clowns/opportunists to even let this pass.
 
So Amin uddin stooge becomes the Head of CC , with his retirement just a fortnight to finish, but with this 27 amen he gets 3 more yrs.
 
So Amin uddin stooge becomes the Head of CC , with his retirement just a fortnight to finish, but with this 27 amen he gets 3 more yrs.
This isnt a SC or a Constitutional court, its a court of crooks who have videos of them doing some dirty things and have been blackmailed.
 

What is a hybrid regime Khwaja talks about? Is that legal and doesnt it go against the oath they take. Don't tell me Khwaja is also against you guys
Are you dense? Every one and their dog knows that the forces have an influence. This is how it has been since our inception. They have more of a role than in some other countries and in an ideal world that should be the case for us. Now is not that time though with IK looting and destroying the country during his tenure and Ind+Afg and all internal proxies baying for us.

Khwaja also made it clear that he has ultimate authority on defense matters as defense minister.
 
Are you dense? Every one and their dog knows that the forces have an influence. This is how it has been since our inception. They have more of a role than in some other countries and in an ideal world that should be the case for us. Now is not that time though with IK looting and destroying the country during his tenure and Ind+Afg and all internal proxies baying for us.

Khwaja also made it clear that he has ultimate authority on defense matters as defense minister.
But you wanted evidence. On the one hand, you are saying they break their oath and hold PK hostage and are good to break up the country but you still want evidence. Are you totally stupid or just an idiot.
 
But you wanted evidence. On the one hand, you are saying they break their oath and hold PK hostage and are good to break up the country but you still want evidence. Are you totally stupid or just an idiot.
I never said they broke their oath and hold us hostage. Show proof or leave the forum. Your 2 pound teaching job is not fit to shine the boots of FM or MN. Remember that.
 
I never said they broke their oath and hold us hostage. Show proof or leave the forum. Your 2 pound teaching job is not fit to shine the boots of FM or MN. Remember that.
Are you totally stupid, you just said they have been interfering since 1947. Do you suffer from memory loss or does Modi cow Urine damage your little brain.
 
Are you totally stupid, you just said they have been interfering since 1947. Do you suffer from memory loss or does Modi cow Urine damage your little brain.
You seem to be the one sending your women to drink it along with some Afg urine. I can talk smack too. Behave or I will expose you for the 2 pound spit polish that you are. Don't misquote me Bewala.
 
You seem to be the one sending your women to drink it along with some Afg urine. I can talk smack too. Behave or I will expose you for the 2 pound spit polish that you are. Don't misquote me Bewala.
You are troll. You cant even decide of breaking the oath is breaking the oath.🤣🥰🫢🤣🤣 Munafuq
 
Back
Top