There is no slot for Umar Amin in future T20I squads, Aamer Yamin should replace him

[Hermoine Green]

From what i ave seen in the past and now, Umar Amin seems to be aproven failure for me. And also he is a wastage down the order, not good with ball either.

Would be better if he is replaced by Aamer Yamin, the position is best for him and he is not a blind slogger. Can play a long aggressive innings and also good with the ball ( but has potential to become better with the ball too)

(I hope no one want Harris Sohail in T20I squad)

Ur thoughts?

 

[BlueDoritos]

Yamin should play T20Is ahead of Amin, Hafeez, Harris, Nawaz etc.

 

[Eagle_Eye]

Yamin should play T20Is ahead of Amin, Hafeez, Harris, Nawaz etc.

As a batter, he is rubbish with the ball.

 

[BlueDoritos]

As a batter, he is rubbish with the ball.

Batting should be his priority, he's capable of scoring at high strike rates. Should play at number 6 in LOIs.

It seems the team management is treating him as a bowling all-rounder right now.

 

[srh]

From what i ave seen in the past and now, Umar Amin seems to be aproven failure for me. And also he is a wastage down the order, not good with ball either.

Would be better if he is replaced by Aamer Yamin, the position is best for him and he is not a blind slogger. Can play a long aggressive innings and also good with the ball ( but has potential to become better with the ball too)

(I hope no one want Harris Sohail in T20I squad)

Ur thoughts?

why not Sharjeel Khan replace Umar Amin in future T20Is?

 

[SM1989]

Umar Amin is a future star provided he is invested in properly.

Aamer Yamin is a bottler when the going gets tough. E.g. His failure against Pollard in PSL where he couldn't defend 10 runs off 2 balls and his failure to see Pakistan over the line in the final ODI against New Zealand earlier on.

 

[Pete Rose]

Umar Amin is a future star provided he is invested in properly.

Aamer Yamin is a bottler when the going gets tough. E.g. His failure against Pollard in PSL where he couldn't defend 10 runs off 2 balls and his failure to see Pakistan over the line in the final ODI against New Zealand earlier on.

what is a future star and how does one become without doing anything in the current. I have company appraisal coming up and I want to pitch this line to my boss.

 

[Abdullah719]

Umar Amin is a future star provided he is invested in properly.

Aamer Yamin is a bottler when the going gets tough.

Perhaps you meant if the other way around?...

 

[msb314]

Perhaps you meant if the other way around?...

Haha that’s what I thought too!

 

[SARJ_BD]

Umar Amin just played two t20s. Scored 45 in one and flopped the other.
It will be harsh and impatient to remove him.

 

[AAli98]

Amins & yamins wouldn’t get into the Afghanistan team. Amins footwork is horrendous his backlift is like Lara’s thats where the similarities end.

Let Sharjeel back in, wev let 1 crook back in 2 won’t matter aswell...

 

[Hedz]

Amins & yamins wouldn’t get into the Afghanistan team. Amins footwork is horrendous his backlift is like Lara’s thats where the similarities end.

Let Sharjeel back in, wev let 1 crook back in 2 won’t matter aswell...

That’s the worse attitude to go by
We have better players who are waiting to come through
Why go back to people who saw the consequences of their actions through amir, Butt and Asif
Yet still chose to engage in fixing

 

[Hasan123]

Amin seems to be more of a ODI player than a T20 player. Should play him in that format.

 

[Rayyman]

Agree that Amin has no future, but it shouldn't be Yamin who replaces him.

Fakhar
Shehzad/U. Akmal
Babar
Haris
Sarfraz*+
Imad
Faheem
Hasan
Shadab
----------------
That should be the batting lineup. With Farhan as backup opener and Talat as backup middle-order.

 

[Deewana Mastana]

why not Sharjeel Khan replace Umar Amin in future T20Is?

People still expecting a player to walk in the team in 5 years time at the ripe age of 34-35.

 

[ask_analyse_act]

Umar Amin just played two t20s. Scored 45 in one and flopped the other.
It will be harsh and impatient to remove him.

This is how he was treated ever since he started his career. I don’t know how ppl judge the players potential with continued chopping and changing. He always plays with that fear of getting dropped which sarfraz said he himself had that experience.

 

[ammar_merry]

People still expecting a player to walk in the team in 5 years time at the ripe age of 34-35.

sharjeel ban will finish in mid 2019

 

[Deewana Mastana]

sharjeel ban will finish in mid 2019

Oh yes 2.5 banned and 2.5 suspended wasn't it?

Will depend on then if he will make it back as he will be in his 30's anyway.

 

[SM1989]

Perhaps you meant if the other way around?...

Honestly the way Yamin is hyped up on this group makes you think he is the next coming of Abdul Razzaq.

 

[Markhor]

Yamin looks a powder puff bowler. If you want to play him as a specialist bat, then I'd rather we actually play a specialist bat or someone like a Hussain Talat who's a stronger batting AR.

Amin has failed to live up to the PP hype whenever he's got a chance to play international cricket. We need another powerhitting opener not an accumulator.

 

[ShahidDar08]

Be patient with Umar Amin, he is fine batsman and will score consistently. He is needed at 5-6 position.

 

[ShahidDar08]

Yamin should play T20Is ahead of Amin, Hafeez, Harris, Nawaz etc.

Umar Amin can bowl better than Aamer Yamin. So what is the point of dropping a complete batsman for a bits and pieces player like Yamin.

 

[indianpanacea]

Wr are choosing people for wrong formats..umar amin should be in test squad ad he has a good technique
My test team shsll be and oneday be
Azhar ali. Fakhar
Sami Aslam. Shahzad
Umar Amin. Babar
Asad shafiq. Sarfaraz
Usman salahuddin. Harris sohail
Babar azam. Hafiz/malik
Sarfaraz. Shahdab
Yasir shah. Faheem
Amir. Hassan ali
Mohd.nawaz. amir/afridi
Sohal khan/whb riaz. Sohailkhan/junaid
$T-20team should be
Fakhar
Sahibzada farhan
Sohaib maqsood
Umar akmal
M.saad
Hussain talat
Nawaz
Amir yamin
Imad wasim
Rumaan Raees
Junaid khan

 

[jonestony]

Yamin should play T20Is ahead of Amin, Hafeez, Harris, Nawaz etc.

he is good as a batsman only. his bowling is very bad.

 

[mastersaan10]

Yamin, hammad, mohsin are the type of players who should give up bowling. They do not realize how good of a batsman they are and can become. We have good enough all-rounders in imad, shadab, Fahim and plus enough bowlers to choose from. They should give up bowling and just practice batting. They will easily make it bc we don't have quality batsman in loi.

 

[Ummii]

He managed to score 107 runs in 8 matches and some people thinks that he is gonna be a future star.