What's new

US immigration agent fatally shoots woman in Minneapolis

BouncerGuy

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Aug 29, 2023
Runs
42,218
US immigration agent fatally shoots woman in Minneapolis

A US immigration agent has shot dead a 37-year-old woman in the city of Minneapolis, sparking protests overnight.

Federal officials said the woman, Renee Nicole Good, had tried to run over immigration agents with her car but the city mayor said the agent who shot her had acted recklessly.

Videos of the incident show ICE agents approaching a car which is in the middle of the street. As it attempts to drive off, one of them points his gun at the driver and at least two shots are heard. The FBI is investigating.

Hundreds of ICE agents have been deployed to Minneapolis, in the state of Minnesota, as part of the White House's crackdown on illegal immigration.

Videos posted to social media by onlookers appear to show the moment of the shooting, which occurred around 10:25 local time on Wednesday morning.

From various vantage points, a maroon SUV can be seen blocking a residential street in Minneapolis.

A crowd of people, who appear to be protesting, are lining the pavement.

Law enforcement vehicles appear nearby. ICE agents (Immigration and Customs Enforcement) pull up to the vehicle parked in the street, emerge from the truck and tell the woman behind the wheel to get out of the SUV. One of the agents tugs at the driver's side door handle.

Another agent is positioned near the front of the vehicle.

It's not clear exactly how close the agent is standing or whether he was struck by the vehicle based on the videos reviewed immediately by the BBC.

That agent opens fire as the maroon SUV attempts to drive off.

The vehicle can be seen losing control and crashing into a car parked nearby along the street.

In a post on Truth Social, Trump said an ICE officer was "viciously" run over. "It is hard to believe he is alive, but is now recovering in the hospital," he wrote.

The Republican president also blamed the "Radical Left" for "threatening, assaulting, and targeting our Law Enforcement Officers and ICE Agents on a daily basis".

Minneapolis police chief Brian O'Hara said the driver was in her vehicle and was blocking the roadway on Portland Avenue. She was then approached on foot by a federal law enforcement officer, "and she began to drive off".

US Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said the woman was "stalking and impeding" officers throughout the day and tried to "weaponise her vehicle" in an attempt to run over the officer in an act of "domestic terrorism".

The federal agent fired "defensive shots" and was himself injured, Noem said, before he was treated and discharged from a local hospital.

The Minneapolis City Council, however, said in a statement that Good was simply "caring for her neighbours" when she was shot and killed.

The same agent was also hit by a car in the line of duty in June, Noem said.

She added that ICE operations in the city would continue, and the FBI would investigate Wednesday's incident.

Emily Heller told CNN she was at home when she saw the ICE agents arguing with protesters outside. She said she heard agents shouting at a woman driving an SUV, then one agent tried to open her car door, and the driver went into reverse and began pulling away.

"An ICE agent stepped in front of her vehicle and said, 'Stop!' and then - I mean, she was already moving - and then, point blank, shot her through her windshield in the face," Heller told the US network.

Minnesota State Governor Tim Walz also pushed back on federal accounts of the incident.

"Don't believe this propaganda machine," Walz wrote in response to a Department of Homeland Security post about the shooting.

"The state will ensure there is a full, fair, and expeditious investigation to ensure accountability and justice."

Top Democrats, including former Vice-President Kamala Harris and House minority leader Hakeem Jeffries, also released statements. Harris called the Trump administration's version of events "gaslighting".

Protests and marches took place in several parts of the city as some outraged Minneapolis residents condemned the shooting and called for ICE to leave.

The scene of the shooting is about one mile from where George Floyd was murdered in 2020 by a city police officer, sparking worldwide anti-racism protests.

Protests were being organised in other US cities, including New Orleans, Miami, Seattle and New York City.

Minneapolis Public Schools announced that classes were cancelled for the rest of the week, "due to safety concerns". It comes after federal agents reportedly made arrests outside a high school on Wednesday.

Why is ICE in Minneapolis?

The Trump administration deployed an additional 2,000 federal agents to the Minneapolis area in recent weeks in response to allegations of welfare fraud in the state.

The mayor said in the Wednesday press conference that ICE was not making the city safer. "They're ripping families apart, they're sowing chaos in our streets," he said.

The deployment, which began on Sunday, is one of the largest concentrations of Department of Homeland Security personnel in a US city in recent years.

It follows an immigration enforcement campaign launched by ICE late last year to target individuals in Minneapolis who were issued deportation orders, including members of the city's Somali community.

That community has been criticised frequently by Trump, who has called them "garbage".

"I don't want them in our country. I'll be honest with you," the president has said. "Their country's no good for a reason. Their country stinks."

Trump later doubled-down on his remarks after a YouTube video by a conservative online content creator accused daycare centres run by Somali immigrants of mass fraud.

In response, Trump has withheld federal childcare funds from the state of Minnesota.

The Trump administration has sent ICE agents to other cities across the US, where they have made thousands of arrests as part of what the administration says is a crackdown on crime and immigrants who illegally entered the country.

 
Last edited:
How sad. Trump has taken the country backwards.

Is there any news regarding who this woman was?
 
Man this anti Somali rhetoric seems so artificial too. Isn't it a bit of a coincidence that they start bashing Somalis from Somalia just as Somaliland gets recognised by the Israelis and pushing for wider recognition?
 
Merge with this bro

 
Is Trump claiming the ICE agent is in hospital? Is this some other ICE agent we didn’t see or is it the same one that moved out of the way in the video as she was trying to get away and got shot? I didn’t see any ICE agent get run over.
 
Is Trump claiming the ICE agent is in hospital? Is this some other ICE agent we didn’t see or is it the same one that moved out of the way in the video as she was trying to get away and got shot? I didn’t see any ICE agent get run over.

He wasnt even hurt in any way. The dead lady was steering away from him. It seems they were looking for an excuse to execute someone in public.
 
The US is basically apartheid South Africa on steroids with more land/population and a much bigger economy/military.
 
The US is basically apartheid South Africa on steroids with more land/population and a much bigger economy/military.
I think this is a bit much. Obviously you cannot compare apartheid South Africa with any other state today except Israel.

The internal political noise in the US is amplified by the RWingers immensely and its not an accurate portrayal of reality. It is definitely getting worse under Trump compared to how things were under say Obama or before. But it cant be compared with apartheid.

There is overall hope that after three or so years and his term, things will start normalizing.
 
I think this is a bit much. Obviously you cannot compare apartheid South Africa with any other state today except Israel.

The internal political noise in the US is amplified by the RWingers immensely and its not an accurate portrayal of reality. It is definitely getting worse under Trump compared to how things were under say Obama or before. But it cant be compared with apartheid.

There is overall hope that after three or so years and his term, things will start normalizing.

There are rumours if the democrats take the mid terms, Trump will be impeached and ICE disbanded?
 
I think this is a bit much. Obviously you cannot compare apartheid South Africa with any other state today except Israel.

The internal political noise in the US is amplified by the RWingers immensely and its not an accurate portrayal of reality. It is definitely getting worse under Trump compared to how things were under say Obama or before. But it cant be compared with apartheid.

There is overall hope that after three or so years and his term, things will start normalizing.
Maybe not now though there is still racism and minority bashing but you only have to go back a few decades and you had Jim Crow with segregation, lynching, denying voting rights, etc. I don’t see how the US was any different to Apartheid South Africa.
 
Maybe not now though there is still racism and minority bashing but you only have to go back a few decades and you had Jim Crow with segregation, lynching, denying voting rights, etc. I don’t see how the US was any different to Apartheid South Africa.
If you mean by a few decades as in the 60s, sure. even apartheid south africa WAS apartheid SA till the 80s and is not so anymore, so let us not use word salad to try and make a foolish point.
 
There are rumours if the democrats take the mid terms, Trump will be impeached and ICE disbanded?
He has been impeached twice, the bigger question is the result of the impeachment and not so much he is subjected to impeachment. Unfortunately, a sitting president is endowed with a lot of immunity and the system is geared towards massive protections so it is an almost impossible task to make a meaningful impact as in penalties or outright dismissal.

The best outcome sane Americans are hoping for is that the current extremist movement of Trump will come to a head and self immolate given its incendiary nature and people will truly see it for what it is and reject it at the next polls.
 
He has been impeached twice, the bigger question is the result of the impeachment and not so much he is subjected to impeachment. Unfortunately, a sitting president is endowed with a lot of immunity and the system is geared towards massive protections so it is an almost impossible task to make a meaningful impact as in penalties or outright dismissal.

The best outcome sane Americans are hoping for is that the current extremist movement of Trump will come to a head and self immolate given its incendiary nature and people will truly see it for what it is and reject it at the next polls.
He was only impeached in the House (I think it's called the accusation process). It's never been completed through both houses and they'll never manage it. It needs a two-thirds majority in the Senate to convict a sitting President and the Dems can't even manage a majority.
 

'They are rewriting history': Simon Marks reacts to the ICE shooting​





good views by simon marks
 
He has been impeached twice, the bigger question is the result of the impeachment and not so much he is subjected to impeachment. Unfortunately, a sitting president is endowed with a lot of immunity and the system is geared towards massive protections so it is an almost impossible task to make a meaningful impact as in penalties or outright dismissal.

The best outcome sane Americans are hoping for is that the current extremist movement of Trump will come to a head and self immolate given its incendiary nature and people will truly see it for what it is and reject it at the next polls.
Third term? Supposedly impossible. But somehow his team already checking the loopholes.
 
He was only impeached in the House (I think it's called the accusation process). It's never been completed through both houses and they'll never manage it. It needs a two-thirds majority in the Senate to convict a sitting President and the Dems can't even manage a majority.
Correct, and even so the sitting president is granted a lot of immunity. Unless you are involved in a massive scandal like watergate, a President is almost guaranteed bulletproof protections no matter what.

Clinton got away with getting BJs in the Oval Office, haha.
 
Correct, and even so the sitting president is granted a lot of immunity. Unless you are involved in a massive scandal like watergate, a President is almost guaranteed bulletproof protections no matter what.

Clinton got away with getting BJs in the Oval Office, haha.
Come on that wasn’t a crime. That was a consensual executive order, not a criminal offense. :)
 

USA is a mess.

This was clear cold blooded murder of a woman.

Has anyone ever met an ICE agent? It seems like some far right outfit parading as immigration enforcement.
They are ex IDF by the sounds of it… they’re fighting for their existence going of the squeals their fan girls on here
 
Minnesota officials say FBI blocked their access to ICE shooting probe

Minnesota officials say the FBI has blocked their access to an investigation into the fatal shooting of a woman by a US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent.

People have taken to the streets of Minneapolis to protest the killing of 37-year-old Renee Nicole Good, who died on Wednesday after being shot in her car.

Minnesota Governor Tim Walz has accused the Trump administration of blocking state officials from involvement in the case, but the US vice-president said the investigation is a federal issue.

Officials have offered differing accounts of the incident, with the Trump administration claiming the ICE agent was acting in self defence, while local officials say the woman posed no danger.

Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem has claimed the ICE agent shot Good multiple times because she was trying to run over the officer in her car.

The US Federal Bureau of Investigation said it would investigate the incident.

Minnesota's Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (BCA) said the FBI had initially agreed to a joint investigation with state officials but then reversed course and denied the state access to materials and evidence.

Without the ability to access all the necessary case materials and evidence, the BCA has "reluctantly withdrawn" from the investigation, the BCA's superintendent Drew Evans said in a statement.

Speaking at a news conference on Thursday, Walz said he was worried the federal government would not be able to carry out an unbiased investigation.

"It feels now that Minnesota has been taken out of the investigation," Walz said. "It feels very, very difficult that we will get a fair outcome."

Vice President JD Vance told reporters on Thursday that the investigation into the shooting was a federal issue, arguing it would go against precedent for a local official to be involved in prosecuting the case.

Videos of the incident show ICE agents approaching a car which is in the middle of the street, and tell the woman behind the wheel to get out of the SUV. One of the agents tugs at the driver's side door handle.

As the vehicle attempts to drive off, one of the agents points their gun at the driver and several shots are heard.

The car then continues to drive away from the officer and crashes into the side of the street.

At the scene of the crash on Thursday, blood from the shooting could still be seen in the snow. People set up a vigil at the site to honour Good, lining the bank with candles and roses.

Hundreds of demonstrators showed up throughout the day, shouting insults at ICE and offering their neighbours coffee on the cold winter day.

Susie Hawyard, a minister, said she went to the scene of the shooting as soon as she heard the news to verify "with my own eyes" what happened.

"I was horrified," she said. "I saw the car, I saw Renee's car, I saw Renee's blood."

Protesters also gathered at a federal building in Minneapolis early Thursday morning, where they were met with armed officers. The protests remained largely peaceful there, as residents expressed their anger over the killing of Good.

"They cannot get away with killing someone. There has to be consequences for actions," said Gavin, one of dozens of people outside the federal building.

Those who knew Good said she was a poet and guitarist who had just moved to the city of Minneapolis.

Her mother, Donna Ganger, told the Minnesota Star Tribune that her daughter was "probably terrified" during the confrontation with officers that saw her fatally shot.

"She was extremely compassionate," Ganger told the daily newspaper. "She's taken care of people all her life. She was loving, forgiving and affectionate. She was an amazing human being."

Even those who did not know Good said they were touched by her death.

"Renee was everything that was good about our community," said Nimco Ahmad, a Somali immigrant who grew up just blocks from the incident.

Ahmad said she and others were gathered to help ensure justice would be secured for Good.

The exclusion of state authorities from the probe into Good's killing is likely to undermine public trust, said Edward Maguire, a criminology professor at Arizona State University.

"From a criminological perspective, jurisdictional claims in cases like this are often less about legal requirements and more about political efforts to control the investigation and shape its outcome," he said.

But the state could still file criminal charges later against the federal officer who killed Good, said Bryna Godar, a staff attorney with the State Democracy Research Initiative at the University of Wisconsin Law School.

BBC
 
Just looked up who this "terrorist" was. She was a 37 year old poet, doesn't exactly seem the terrorist type.
 
Verily, to Him we belong, to Him we return.

A sad and dangerous state of affairs orchestrated by evil.

I think many here and in other places don't realize that Trump is an asset for some powerful intelligence agencies, including the one from the country that this forum belongs to. Trump is being used just as others have been used before him in his position or in other leadership and important posts around the world.

Unfortunately, the game at the top is very cruel, and it always comes at the cost of selling your soul to the devil or the highest bidder. These bidders are also the ones who bring you to power, keep you in power, and remove you from power.

It's just how things are and have been for almost all nations worldwide for a long time.

To have power, one needs money, and big money is only parted with when intelligence, even though evil, dictates the terms. It's no charity work.

Trump has had some very powerful organizations and rich people supporting him and dictating to him.

Always follow the money trail. If someone is powerful but doesn't have money, then see who their backers are. They will definitely have money.

And once you achieve the throne, you have to get with the program, which Trump is doing right now. If you don't, then just ask JFK or ask IK what happens.
 
Video emerges of Minneapolis shooting filmed by ICE agent who opened fire

A video filmed by the US immigration agent who fatally shot a woman in Minneapolis on Wednesday has emerged, showing the moments before gunfire rang out.

The 47-second footage, obtained by Minnesota-based outlet Alpha News, shows Renee Nicole Good sitting behind the wheel of her car and speaking to the officer.

US Vice-President JD Vance shared the clip on social media, commenting that the agent had acted in self-defence. Local officials have insisted the woman posed no danger.

Good's wife has paid tribute to the 37-year-old, saying the pair were trying to support their neighbours when she was shot. Her death has sparked protests across the US.


 
Video emerges of Minneapolis shooting filmed by ICE agent who opened fire

A video filmed by the US immigration agent who fatally shot a woman in Minneapolis on Wednesday has emerged, showing the moments before gunfire rang out.

The 47-second footage, obtained by Minnesota-based outlet Alpha News, shows Renee Nicole Good sitting behind the wheel of her car and speaking to the officer.

US Vice-President JD Vance shared the clip on social media, commenting that the agent had acted in self-defence. Local officials have insisted the woman posed no danger.

Good's wife has paid tribute to the 37-year-old, saying the pair were trying to support their neighbours when she was shot. Her death has sparked protests across the US.



Once Trump is gone from the office, they should be sued heavily. The shooting officer should be jailed for murder (just like George Floyd's shooter was jailed).
 
Dozens arrested and one police officer injured in Minneapolis protests

At least 29 people have been arrested in Minneapolis during protests over the death of a woman who was shot by a US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent.

One police officer was also injured after a "chunk of ice was thrown at them", city officials said, during demonstrations which saw 1,000 people take to the streets of the city on Friday night.

Protests against immigration enforcement have been held across the US after 37-year-old Renee Nicole Good was shot in her car on Wednesday.

The Trump administration said the agent who fired the shots acted in self-defence. Local officials have insisted the woman posed no danger.

Minneapolis Police declared an unlawful assembly on Friday night as protesters gathered outside the Canopy Hotel in the city, where some ICE agents were believed to be staying.

The Minneapolis police department said in a statement that "some individuals forced entry into the hotel through an alley entrance".

Videos posted online showed protesters flashing bright lights into the area, blowing whistles and banging on drums.

Police said there were "well over 1,000" demonstrators in the area and some threw ice, snow and rocks at officers, police vehicles and other vehicles, but no serious injuries were reported.

One law enforcement officer suffered minor injuries but did not need any medical attention, according to the BBC's US partner CBS News.

Officials said another hotel in the city was also targeted and had window and graffiti damage.

At a news conference on Saturday, Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey applauded the majority of protesters who he said have been peaceful, but noted that individuals who cause damage to property or put others in harm's way would be arrested.

The 29 people arrested on Friday night were later released, Minneapolis Police Chief Brian O'Hara said.

O'Hara said that by 01:00 local time (07:00 GMT), the crowd had been dispersed, and his officers deployed a "disciplined and restrained response".

Many Minnesotans have been frustrated by the presence of ICE in the state and O'Hara said his department was getting dozens of phone calls every day about the federal agency's operations.

On Saturday, three congresswomen from Minnesota also attempted to tour an ICE facility in Minneapolis. The women said they were initially allowed to enter, but were then told they had to leave.

Democratic Congresswomen Ilhan Omar, Kelly Morrison and Angie Craig said ICE and the Department of Homeland Security were obstructing members of Congress from fulfilling their duty to oversee operations there.

"They do not care that they are violating federal law," Craig said.

"The public deserves to know what is taking place in ICE facilities," Omar posted on X.

Further protests are planned in Minneapolis this weekend, as well as in Texas, Florida, Washington DC and elsewhere in the US, according to Indivisible, an organisation that formed to resist the Trump administration.

Good was shot and killed in her car on Wednesday.

Videos of the incident show ICE agents approaching a car which is in the middle of the street, and telling the woman behind the wheel to get out of the SUV. One of the agents tugs at the driver's side door handle.

As the vehicle attempts to drive off, one of the agents at the front of the car points their gun at the driver and several shots are heard.

The car then continues to drive away from the officer and crashes into the side of the street.

Good's wife told local media the pair had gone to the scene of immigration enforcement activity to support neighbours.

The officer who fired on Good is Jonathan Ross, a veteran ICE agent who was previously injured in the line of duty when he was struck by a car.

Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem has claimed the ICE agent shot Good multiple times because she was trying to run over the officer in her car.

But Democratic Minneapolis Mayor Frey called that version of events a false narrative, saying it was clear to him she was trying to leave the scene, not attack an agent.

The FBI is investigating the incident.

On Friday, Minnesota officials said they would open an inquiry into the shooting after saying they had been frozen out of the federal investigation.

The announcement came a day after the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension said the FBI had initially pledged a joint investigation, then reversed course. The US vice-president said the investigation was a federal issue.

BBC
 
ICE agent shoots Minneapolis man in the leg

An Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officer has shot a man in the leg in the US city of Minneapolis, where an ICE agent shot dead a woman last week.

In a statement, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) said federal officers initially pursued the man in a car chase because he was illegally in the US from Venezuela.

The City of Minneapolis confirmed a man was shot and taken to hospital for non-life threatening injuries. An ICE officer was also taken to hospital to be treated for injuries, the DHS said.

Minneapolis city officials said on X: "We understand there is anger. We ask the public to remain calm."

"The City of Minneapolis again demands that ICE leave the city and state immediately," they added.

The man got out of his car and an altercation took place between him and an ICE official, the DHS said. It added that during the incident two other people emerged from a nearby apartment building and allegedly "attacked" the officer.

"Fearing for his life and safety as he was being ambushed by three individuals, the officer fired defensive shots," the DHS statement said, adding "both attackers are in custody".

The BBC could not immediately independently verify details in the statements. Minneapolis Police chief Brian O'Hara said the FBI is investigating the incident.

In response to the latest ICE shooting, Minneapolis mayor Jacob Frey accused federal officers of "creating chaos" across the state.

Protesters gathered at the scene of the shooting soon after the news first emerged, condemning ICE raids in Minneapolis, the largest city in the state of Minnesota.

Around 3,000 ICE officers have been deployed to Minnesota over recent weeks.

Demonstrations also took place there last week after 37-year-old Renee Nicole Good was shot dead by an ICE agent.

Federal officials accused Good of trying to run over immigration agents with her car, but Frey said the agent who shot her had acted recklessly.

Videos of the incident show ICE agents approaching a car, which is in the middle of the street. As it attempts to drive off, one of them points his gun at the driver and at least two shots are heard.

The FBI is investigating the incident.

In a statement on X responding to reports of ICE shooting the man in the leg, US Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche said: "Minnesota insurrection is a direct result of a FAILED governor and a TERRIBLE mayor encouraging violence against law enforcement. It's disgusting."

Shortly before news of the latest shooting emerged, Minnesota Governor Tim Walz urging Trump to end the "occupation" of ICE officers in the state in a video on social media.

"Angry is not a strong enough word," Walz said during his address.

 
Around 1,500 soldiers on standby for deployment to Minneapolis, reports say

Soldiers are on standby for possible deployment to Minneapolis, a US defence official has told CBS News, the BBC's US partner.

The official said the 1,500 soldiers, currently in Alaska, are an option for the US president if he decided to use active duty military personnel, as anti-Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) demonstrations continued in the city on Saturday.

No decision has yet been made on whether to deploy the soldiers from Alaska, the official said.

Minnesota officials have urged protesters to stay orderly and peaceful during demonstrations after an ICE agent shot dead US citizen Renee Good earlier this month.

The soldiers are part of the 11th Airborne Division in Fort Wainwright, the official added.

It comes as a US federal judge issued an order limiting the crowd control tactics that can used by ICE agents towards "peaceful and unobstructive" protesters in Minneapolis.

Judge Katherine Menendez earlier ruled that federal agents cannot arrest or pepper spray peaceful demonstrations, including those monitoring or observing ICE agents.

The state's National Guard has been mobilised and placed on alert by Governor Tim Walz, and other law enforcement officers were deployed to Minneapolis ahead of the anti-ICE demonstrations.

Recent protests in the city were sparked by widespread action by ICE in the city, and follow Good's death on 7 January.

City leaders said Good was there as a legal observer of ICE activity.

But the Trump administration has called her a "domestic terrorist".

Good's death sparked protests across the country, with many people holding signs that read "Justice for Renee".

BBC
 
US officials probing Minnesota ICE protest that disrupted church service

The US justice department has said it is investigating protesters who disrupted a Sunday service at a Minnesota church because they believe a pastor there works for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).

Video showed protesters inside the church chanting "ICE out" and "Justice for Renee Good", the woman killed by an ICE agent in Minneapolis earlier this month.

Justice department officials accuse the protesters of "desecrating a house of worship", and say they will investigate them for civil rights violations.

Anti-ICE protests continue in the state against President Donald Trump's immigration crackdown, and the Pentagon reportedly placed 1,500 soldiers on standby for possible deployment.

On Sunday, US Attorney General Pam Bondi vowed to exercise the "full force of federal law" against the demonstrators who interrupted the service at the Cities Church in St Paul, which neighbors Minneapolis.

Later on Monday, Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon said on X that the justice department "will pursue federal charges in this case".

Protesters say that one of the church's eight pastors, David Easterwood, is a local ICE official.

Easterwood was not leading the service on Sunday.

A person by the same name is identified in ACLU court filings as the acting director of the ICE St Paul field office, according to reporting by the Associated Press and the Minnesota Star Tribune newspaper.

The AP also reported he appeared alongside Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary Kristi Noem in Minneapolis at a news conference last October.

The BBC has contacted the church for comment.

In a statement, DHS said it does not confirm or deny the identities of its agents as "publicizing their identities puts their lives and the lives of their families at serious risk".

Monique Cullars-Doty, a co-founder of Black Lives Matter Minnesota and one of the protest organisers, told CBS News, the BBC's US partner, that "we can't sit back idly and watch people go and be led astray".

Elsewhere in the city, protests with occasional clashes have persisted at the Whipple building in Minneapolis where federal agents are headquartered.

A DHS spokesperson said on Monday that at least 3,000 people have been arrested in Minneapolis since the deployments.

On Friday, a US federal judge issued an order limiting the crowd control tactics that can be used by ICE agents toward peaceful protesters in Minneapolis.

Thousands of ICE agents are in Minnesota as part of a surge by the Trump administration after his election pledge for the biggest deportation operation of undocumented migrants in history.

On Sunday, CBS News reported that 1,500 active-duty soldiers have been placed on standby for possible deployment to Minneapolis, after President Trump said he may invoke the Insurrection Act to respond to protests.

The 19th-Century law allows the president to use active-duty military personnel to perform law-enforcement duties inside the US.

It was last invoked in 1992 when massive riots broke out in Los Angeles over the acquittal of four white police officers in the beating of Rodney King, a black man.

Separately, the US justice department said on Friday it had opened investigations into Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey and Minnesota Governor Tim Walz, both Democrats, for allegedly impeding federal immigration operations.

Both Frey and Walz have spoken out strongly against ICE deployments to their city and state.

Anti-ICE protests have intensified there since the death of Good, a 37-year-old mother of three and a US citizen, who was shot and killed by an ICE agent while in her vehicle in Minneapolis on 7 January.

City officials said she was killed while legally observing ICE activities. The Trump administration, however, labeled her a "domestic terrorist" and said the agent who shot her acted in self-defence.

Meanwhile, an undocumented immigrant has died in custody at an ICE detention centre in Texas, the third such death in 44 days, US media report.

Victor Manuel Diaz, a 36-year-old from Nicaragua, was detained by ICE agents earlier this month in Minneapolis.

"He died of a presumed suicide; however, the official cause of his death remains under investigation," ICE said in a statement.

Earlier this month, a 55-year-old Cuban immigrant, Lunas Campos died at the same facility in Texas.

Tricia McLaughlin, assistant secretary for the Department of Homeland Security, told the Washington Post that Lunas Campos died after attempting to take his own life.

BBC
 
The implementation of this has been catastrophic, how can you kill your own citizens?

Even if one believes trump had good intentions the implementation has been shocking.

I hope better sense prevails and they put a stop to this nonsense.
 
ICE detains five-year-old and father in Minnesota, lawyer says

US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers detained a five-year-old boy on Tuesday during an immigration enforcement operation, Minnesota school officials and the family's lawyer have said.

Pre-schooler Liam Ramos was with his father - named by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) as Adrian Alexander Conejo Arias - when Conejo Arias was approached by agents on his driveway.

In a statement posted on X, the DHS said "ICE did NOT target a child", but was conducting an operation against his father, an "illegal alien" who "abandoned" his son when approached.

Zena Stenvik, the Columbia Heights Public Schools superintendent, asked: "Why detain a five-year-old?

"You can't tell me that this child is going to be classified as a violent criminal."

In a post on X, ICE denied the child had been detained.

"A criminal illegal alien ABANDONED his child as he fled from ICE officers, and our officers ensured the child was kept SAFE in the bitter cold," the agency said.

"ICE made multiple attempts to get the family inside the house to take custody of the child.

"They refused to accept custody of the child. The father told officers he wanted the child to remain with him."

DHS did not immediately respond to the BBC's request for comment.

Photos provided to the BBC by the school district show a boy, identified as Liam Ramos, wearing a bunny-shaped winter hat, standing outside as an officer holds on to his backpack.

The Columbia Heights Public Schools authority described these as bystander photos. The district did not identify the individuals who took the pictures, referring to them as "known and confirmed community members".

Marc Prokosch, a lawyer representing the family, told a press conference on Thursday that Liam and his father were being held at a detention centre in San Antonio, Texas, and attorneys were trying to contact them.

Prokosch said the boy and his father had come to the US in 2024 from Ecuador to seek asylum.

"This family was not eluding ICE in any way," he said. "They were following all the established protocols."

School officials said an agent asked the child to knock on the door of the home to see if anyone else was there.

The boy had just arrived home from pre-school at the time, Stenvik told the press conference.

She said another adult living in the home asked to take the young boy inside, but was refused.

School board member Mary Granlund said she was on the scene and told immigration officials she could take Liam Ramos, but they still detained him.

US Vice-President JD Vance, who visited Minnesota on Thursday amid ongoing protests against immigration enforcement, told reporters ICE had no choice because "the father ran".

"What are they supposed to do?" he said of ICE agents. "Are they supposed to let a five-year-old child freeze to death?

"Are they not supposed to arrest an illegal alien in the United States of America?"

He added: "If the argument is that you can't arrest people who have violated laws because they have children. . . that doesn't make any sense."

Stenvik said that ICE had recently detained a total of four students in her school district, including a 10-year-old, and two 17-year-olds.

"The onslaught of ICE activity in our community is inducing trauma," Stenvik told reporters.

The DHS maintains it is arresting the "worst of the worst criminal illegal aliens" in an effort to restore public safety in Minnesota.

At a DHS press conference on Tuesday, Gregory Bovino of the US Border Patrol said: "Our operations are lawful, are targeted, and are focused on individuals who pose a serious threat to this community."

The immigration enforcement initiative, dubbed Operation Metro Surge, has sparked outcry from residents in Minneapolis, St Paul and other cities in the state.

On 7 January, a federal officer fatally shot a woman named Renee Good in Minneapolis, sparking protests and condemnation from local and state officials.

The Trump administration alleged the 37-year-old was using her vehicle as a weapon and the officer acted in self-defence.

Also on Thursday, seven Democrats in the US House of Representatives voted with Republicans to narrowly pass $1.2tn (£900bn) in funding for government agencies, including ICE.

The measure - which would allocate $64.4bn to DHS, including $10bn for ICE - was approved 220-207. It must still pass the Senate.

Democrats who voted in favour said they did so to fund the Transportation Security Administration and Federal Emergency Management Agency, both under DHS.

BBC
 
Hundreds of Minnesota businesses close to protest ICE presence

Hundreds of businesses in Minnesota shut their doors on Friday and thousands of protesters turned out in the frigid cold as part of an economic protest against the immigration crackdown in the state.

The widespread rallies come after organisers encouraged residents to skip work or school and refrain from shopping in a show of opposition to US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).

The ICE operation ordered by Trump administration in the state have been going on for more than six weeks.

The administration has characterised it as a public safety operation aimed at deporting criminals illegally in the country. Critics warn migrants with no criminal record and US citizens are being detained too.

On Friday, about 100 clergy members were arrested at the Minneapolis airport while holding a protest calling on US airlines to refuse to transport detainees arrested by ICE.

A spokesman for the airports commission told the Minnesota Reformer that the arrests took place after the "permitted activity went beyond agreed upon terms" and was to done to protect the public safety and airport access.

Thousands of federal officers have been deployed to Minnesota as part of "Operation Metro Surge".

The killing of 37-year-old Minneapolis woman Renee Good earlier this month flared tensions across the state and brought condemnation from local officials.

"We want ICE out of Minnesota, and we want ICE out of every state, with their extreme overreach," said Bishop Dwayne Royster, whose organisation Faith in Action is supporting local partners in Minneapolis during the strike. "We want Congress to stand up and provide oversight to ICE."

Friday's marches are thought to be the largest display of opposition to date to the current immigration policy in the state, as thousands of people walked downtown through temperatures of -10F (-23C).

As they made their way to the city's NBA arena to hold an anti-ICE rally, taking place on the home court of the Minnesota Timberwolves, protesters chanted and played music.

On Friday morning, Minneapolis resident Corey Lamb closed his business, Harriet Grove Botanicals, in solidarity and headed to a protest. He objected to the presence of ICE agents in his city, and was outraged by Good's death in early January.

He also saw the immigration raids as an economic threat to his business, and others in his community.

"We have a lot of friends that we rely on, we have a lot of businesses that we rely on, in order to make our business work," Lamb told the BBC.

"When those individuals are struggling because they're afraid of being detained or disappeared, it has an effect not only morally but economically on what's going on here, and also in the greater Midwest."

Lamb's business was joined by hundreds of others, from restaurants and tattoo parlours to toy stores.

Kim Bartmann is the owner of six restaurants in Minneapolis, including four that remain open in the winter but that she shut on Friday.

While she supports the cause, she said the decision to participate had been a tricky one, given the costs.

"Everyone is in solidarity, but everyone needs to buy groceries and pay their rents," she said, noting that staff at one of her locations had initially asked to stay open, before deciding the risk of backlash over not participating would be too great.

"Economically, it is a severe blow to my business," she said.

She said sales at her restaurants, which include Barbette and Gigi's Café, have already dropped more than 30% over the past three weeks as a result of the ICE operation, which has prompted her to limit her opening hours as customers and staff stay home.

"We have a lot of employees who are US citizens or have paperwork to work in the US who are still terrified to leave their homes," she said.

ICE's presence has outraged many of Minnesota's residents, who have protested against their operations and other federal officers operating in their city.

This week, school officials in the suburb of Columbia Heights announced that four of their students had been detained by ICE, ranging from ages five to 17.

A two-year-old child was also detained on Thursday, while driving home from a grocery store with her undocumented father in south Minneapolis, according to CBS, the BBC's US partner.

In a speech on Thursday, Vice-President JD Vance called for local Minnesota law enforcement to coordinate with federal officers to carry out immigration enforcement.

Minnesota, and some of its cities, have so-called "sanctuary" policies, which limit the ways that local government and law enforcement cooperates with ICE. The Trump administration has criticised these policies as a threat to public safety.

Meanwhile, a Minneapolis FBI agent resigned this week over concerns about the bureau's handling of the investigation into Good's shooting, CBS News, the BBC's US partner, reported. The New York Times was first to report the resignation.

Tracee Mergen left "in part due to the pressure on her to reclassify/discontinue the investigation" over Good's death, CBS News reported, citing sources.

The BBC has contacted the FBI for comment.

Earlier this month, US media reported that at least six prosecutors in the Minneapolis US Attorney's office resigned over the administration's handling of the federal investigation.

BBC
 
Hundreds of Minnesota businesses close to protest ICE presence

Hundreds of businesses in Minnesota shut their doors on Friday and thousands of protesters turned out in the frigid cold as part of an economic protest against the immigration crackdown in the state.

The widespread rallies come after organisers encouraged residents to skip work or school and refrain from shopping in a show of opposition to US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).

The ICE operation ordered by Trump administration in the state have been going on for more than six weeks.

The administration has characterised it as a public safety operation aimed at deporting criminals illegally in the country. Critics warn migrants with no criminal record and US citizens are being detained too.

On Friday, about 100 clergy members were arrested at the Minneapolis airport while holding a protest calling on US airlines to refuse to transport detainees arrested by ICE.

A spokesman for the airports commission told the Minnesota Reformer that the arrests took place after the "permitted activity went beyond agreed upon terms" and was to done to protect the public safety and airport access.

Thousands of federal officers have been deployed to Minnesota as part of "Operation Metro Surge".

The killing of 37-year-old Minneapolis woman Renee Good earlier this month flared tensions across the state and brought condemnation from local officials.

"We want ICE out of Minnesota, and we want ICE out of every state, with their extreme overreach," said Bishop Dwayne Royster, whose organisation Faith in Action is supporting local partners in Minneapolis during the strike. "We want Congress to stand up and provide oversight to ICE."

Friday's marches are thought to be the largest display of opposition to date to the current immigration policy in the state, as thousands of people walked downtown through temperatures of -10F (-23C).

As they made their way to the city's NBA arena to hold an anti-ICE rally, taking place on the home court of the Minnesota Timberwolves, protesters chanted and played music.

On Friday morning, Minneapolis resident Corey Lamb closed his business, Harriet Grove Botanicals, in solidarity and headed to a protest. He objected to the presence of ICE agents in his city, and was outraged by Good's death in early January.

He also saw the immigration raids as an economic threat to his business, and others in his community.

"We have a lot of friends that we rely on, we have a lot of businesses that we rely on, in order to make our business work," Lamb told the BBC.

"When those individuals are struggling because they're afraid of being detained or disappeared, it has an effect not only morally but economically on what's going on here, and also in the greater Midwest."

Lamb's business was joined by hundreds of others, from restaurants and tattoo parlours to toy stores.

Kim Bartmann is the owner of six restaurants in Minneapolis, including four that remain open in the winter but that she shut on Friday.

While she supports the cause, she said the decision to participate had been a tricky one, given the costs.

"Everyone is in solidarity, but everyone needs to buy groceries and pay their rents," she said, noting that staff at one of her locations had initially asked to stay open, before deciding the risk of backlash over not participating would be too great.

"Economically, it is a severe blow to my business," she said.

She said sales at her restaurants, which include Barbette and Gigi's Café, have already dropped more than 30% over the past three weeks as a result of the ICE operation, which has prompted her to limit her opening hours as customers and staff stay home.

"We have a lot of employees who are US citizens or have paperwork to work in the US who are still terrified to leave their homes," she said.

ICE's presence has outraged many of Minnesota's residents, who have protested against their operations and other federal officers operating in their city.

This week, school officials in the suburb of Columbia Heights announced that four of their students had been detained by ICE, ranging from ages five to 17.

A two-year-old child was also detained on Thursday, while driving home from a grocery store with her undocumented father in south Minneapolis, according to CBS, the BBC's US partner.

In a speech on Thursday, Vice-President JD Vance called for local Minnesota law enforcement to coordinate with federal officers to carry out immigration enforcement.

Minnesota, and some of its cities, have so-called "sanctuary" policies, which limit the ways that local government and law enforcement cooperates with ICE. The Trump administration has criticised these policies as a threat to public safety.

Meanwhile, a Minneapolis FBI agent resigned this week over concerns about the bureau's handling of the investigation into Good's shooting, CBS News, the BBC's US partner, reported. The New York Times was first to report the resignation.

Tracee Mergen left "in part due to the pressure on her to reclassify/discontinue the investigation" over Good's death, CBS News reported, citing sources.

The BBC has contacted the FBI for comment.

Earlier this month, US media reported that at least six prosecutors in the Minneapolis US Attorney's office resigned over the administration's handling of the federal investigation.

BBC
I've just seen the video, absolutely disgusting, they beat him up for around 20 seconds, then shoot him (around 5 bullets i heard) dead.
 
Immigration chief at centre of Trump's crackdown set to leave Minneapolis

A top US immigration official is expected to leave the US city of Minneapolis in what may mark a shift in the White House's tone after the fatal shooting of a second US citizen by federal officers over the weekend.

As Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bovino and some immigration agents depart, "border tsar" Tom Homan will begin leading on-the-ground efforts in the Minnesota city after the shooting of Alex Pretti on Saturday escalated tensions.

The decision by President Donald Trump may indicate the administration's interest in walking back more aggressive federal action in his nationwide immigration crackdown.

Despite the announcement, online tracking shows immigration raids have continued.

Bovino was the face of the operation when Pretti - an observer seen filming agents - became involved in a confrontation that ended in him being shot numerous times.

The border control commander inflamed the situation in the aftermath, claiming that Pretti intended to "massacre" federal agents.

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) said the agents fired in self-defence after Pretti, who they say had a handgun, resisted their attempts to disarm him on Saturday.

Eyewitnesses, local officials and the victim's family have challenged that account, pointing out Pretti had a phone in his hand, not a weapon. His parents, meanwhile, have accused the administration of spreading "sickening lies" about what happened.

Bovino has been key to the Trump administration's hardline approach to immigration enforcement in several cities, active on social media and regularly filming raids and posting promotional videos showing his agents' action.

Homan, who will report directly to the president, advocates for Trump's aggressive immigration enforcement. But he also has experience in the role - Homan worked with immigration and deportations during Barack Obama's Democrat administration.

On Monday tension and frustration over the presence of federal officials remained high in Minneapolis.

"A lot of people aren't able to work right now, they aren't able to leave their house, they're afraid," said George Cordero, a resident of St Paul, Minneapolis', sister city.

Pretti was the second Minneapolis resident shot and killed by federal immigration officials since their arrival in the state. Renee Nicole Good was killed by an Immigration and Customs Border Enforcement (ICE) agent on 7 January.

Some media reports suggested Bovino had been let go from his role, but Homeland Security spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin denied that, saying the border patrol chief was "a key part of the president's team and a great American".

Much of the anger in the city and from politicians on both sides of the aisle was directed at Bovino and border patrol agents sent to Minneapolis along with ICE agents at Trump's directive. In total, there are more than 3,000 immigration agents in the city.

Micayla Pretti, Alex Pretti's younger sister, released a statement on Monday, the Associated Press reported, calling her brother "my hero".

"When does this end? How many more innocent lives must be lost before we say enough?" her statement said.

Carol Engelheart, a retired nurse from Minneapolis, said events in the city had left her shaken.

"We need to care about this country, we need to care that we have a Constitution left, and if the people organise and the people stand up, we can do this," she said.

White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt said on Monday that it is the president's "hope and wish and demand for the resistance and chaos" in Minneapolis to end.

Also on Monday, Trump spoke with both Minnesota Governor Tim Walz and Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey - Democratic leaders who have resisted the immigration efforts and demanded agents be removed from the state. Trump has criticised both in recent weeks.

Both Trump and the local leaders characterised the talks as positive - a sign that both sides were seeking a way to end their standoff over Trump's deportation drive.

Trump said he and Walz are "on a similar wavelength" and said his target is "any and all criminals that they have in their possession".

"The president agreed to look into reducing the number of federal agents in Minnesota and to talk to DHS about ensuring the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension is able to conduct an independent investigation, as would ordinarily be the case," Walz said after the call.

Ensuring an independent investigation into Pretti's death has been a central focus for Walz. In its immediate aftermath, local authorities obtained a judicial warrant to gain access to the crime scene to preserve evidence.

In the aftermath of Good's shooting, local and state authorities said they were being kept out of the investigation by federal immigration officials.

Frey meanwhile said he hoped to meet Homan on Tuesday to discuss next steps.

Republican senator and Trump ally Lindsey Graham called Trump's decision to send Homan to Minneapolis "a very smart move".

Another Republican senator, John Curtis from Utah, called for a "transparent, independent investigation" into Pretti's shooting.

"Those responsible - no matter their title - must be held accountable," he said.

Memorials for Pretti - a 37-year-old ICU nurse - and demonstrations against ICE action continued on Monday night, including one that saw about a hundred people gather outside the hotel Bovino was believed to be staying in and demanding that he leave the city.

More vigils and demonstrations are planned for the coming days.

BBC
 
Back
Top