What's new

[VIDEO] Jos Buttler to Vernon Philander "you fu***** kn**head"

AAli98

First Class Star
Joined
Jun 15, 2017
Runs
3,338
Jos Buttler clashed with Vernon Philander on the final day of the Cape Town Test, with England’s wicketkeeper calling the South African veteran a ‘f***ing knobhead’.

Buttler reacted badly after Philander stood his ground and blocked the path of the ball which was thrown in by an England fielder. When Philander came to the crease, South Africa were 237-6, with England desperately searching for wickets to win the Test and level the four-match series at 1-1.

During the evening session, Buttler could be heard telling Philander: ‘F***ing move. F***ing knobhead. Get past that f***ing gut.’

The pair continued to exchange words for the rest of the over, with South Africa’s Dwaine Pretorius intervening at the change of ends.

Read more: https://metro.co.uk/2020/01/07/jos-...h-africa-v-england-test-12017467/?ito=cbshare





<div style="width: 100%; height: 0px; position: relative; padding-bottom: 56.250%;"><iframe src="https://streamable.com/s/8zn12/zrzkxe" frameborder="0" width="100%" height="100%" allowfullscreen style="width: 100%; height: 100%; position: absolute;"></iframe></div>
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Embarrasing, a guy with 1 century in 39 test matches tries to sledge one of the greatest test bowlers of this decade. Needs to shut up and carry on doing his job.
 
Embarrasing, a guy with 1 century in 39 test matches tries to sledge one of the greatest test bowlers of this decade. Needs to shut up and carry on doing his job.

This is called "jazba" - am sure this is considered a sign of manliness.
 
To be honest he should be fined by the ICC - but will it happen?
 
That was totally uncalled for. There was absolutely no need for that. Always thought Butler is one of the most calm and humble guys in the English team, guess I was wrong.
 
That was totally uncalled for. There was absolutely no need for that. Always thought Butler is one of the most calm and humble guys in the English team, guess I was wrong.

I'm surprised too. Butler always came across as a gentlemen.

Could also be a planned thing to unsettle the SA batters.
 
Big talk from somebody who doesn't even merit a place in the starting XI. Surprised given Buttler is a generally reserved and quiet guy.
 
Very surprising- I didn’t think that he was capable of something like this.
 
Philander had every right to stand his ground. I could think of a few players who would have wrapped their bat around Buttler's head.
 
Seriously, wth is wrong with Buttler??

This was so uncalled for. Philander has some serious patience for not giving him a talking to like he deserved.
 
His batting is getting to his head.
He needs to be dropped from the English side to get his head in order!
 
Pathetic. You can say all sorts of things to disturb a batsman's concentration, but no need to add profanity. Tim Paine is always talking behind the stumps. Don't hear him doing this kind of thing.
 
It's always amusing how the below par test cricketers are always the loudest on the field.

Almost feel like they need to do that to make themselves belong.
 
No wonder vernon was staring him down.

Feel sorry for poor vern, does not deserve to be abused like that. He is a better test cricketer than butler will ever be.

Once foakes comes back, butler will be back in the colored jerseys with bairstow for the rest of his career and barely get a test match

England's success last year has made butler arrogant, it seems.
 
It's always amusing how the below par test cricketers are always the loudest on the field.

Almost feel like they need to do that to make themselves belong.

He will be replaced by ben foakes sooner or later, and then barely get a test again in his career.

he knows philander is a better test cricketer then he will ever be
 
I like this. This is the stuff I want to hear behind the stump mic not that stupid Australian crap come on garry come on garry. Aussies are so soft learn something from poms
 
I'm surprised too. Butler always came across as a gentlemen.

Could also be a planned thing to unsettle the SA batters.

He’s far from a gentlemen lmao he abuses every player that comes to bat he got into a ugly spat with Bengalis few years ago too. He ain’t no gentlemen and neither he should be as well
 
Pathetic from Butler. Good on Philander in letting it pass and not create too much about it.

Clearly England were trying everything in their bag to get a win there.
 
He’s far from a gentlemen lmao he abuses every player that comes to bat he got into a ugly spat with Bengalis few years ago too. He ain’t no gentlemen and neither he should be as well

Im a England fan but there's no space for extreme verbal abuse which can lead to physical altercation, then whose to blamevthen?
 
Philander should have smashed his bat in buttlers face.
 
He shouldn’t have said what he said but it was in the heat of a very tense moment in the game. I am sure both Buttler and Philander are mature enough to let it be water under the bridge.

It is also inevitable that some people would play the typical victim card and jump to the conclusion that Butler will not be banned because he is white. At least wait for ICC’s decision and what they say. At least he did not mock Philander for his color like a “certain WK captain” did in South Africa last year.
 
WOW never heard this side of Buttler. But I guess he's had to do this since he's in bad form.
 
Im a England fan but there's no space for extreme verbal abuse which can lead to physical altercation, then whose to blamevthen?

Bruh cricket is way too soft of a sport a fight in cricket is called sledging so wack. Test cricket is boring as well this was entertaining atleast I wish philander had said something back or even swung his bat across butlers face than stokes would jump in as well. That would be hell of a fight plus free good wwe entertainment for the crowd
 
This happens daily at the county/ minor county/ premier league and most decent standard of cricket in England. They are pretty rough with language and expect it back as well.
 
Bruh cricket is way too soft of a sport a fight in cricket is called sledging so wack. Test cricket is boring as well this was entertaining atleast I wish philander had said something back or even swung his bat across butlers face than stokes would jump in as well. That would be hell of a fight plus free good wwe entertainment for the crowd

Lol are you serious, these guys are role models for kids growing up in to cricket, then they can asume to verbal at club and school levels
 
I have no issue with the words used....only with the fact that it was picked up on the stump mics
 
csnt wait for buttler to come to india.

phaintas waiting for englsnd.
anyway buttler sounds like a girl. lol been should have reacted. Too soft. buttler should try this with someone like rabada.
 
Philander had every right to stand his ground. I could think of a few players who would have wrapped their bat around Buttler's head.

Philander had the right to stand his ground but then swore at the fielder for chucking the ball in his general vicinity (followed up by this from Buttler).
 
Nothing new about swearing in tense test match situations. I expect it got sorted out over beers after the match. If Buttler has broken the Code of Conduct he will get a fine.
 
Lol are you serious, these guys are role models for kids growing up in to cricket, then they can asume to verbal at club and school levels

Hell yeah I’m serious. And whats this role mode thing I’m perplexed when people say that. Kids look upto singers and actors are they good role models. Hell no they have sec on screen use the f word in every sentence do drugs on screen and in real life too. So what is a good role model a cricket player? Is kohli a good role model he’s the best cricket player in the world and people and kids look upto him the most but he has another quality as well cussing people’s mothers and sisters. So when you say they are role models no they are not infact there really is no such thing you can be motivated be by someone but at the end of the day kids will do what they wanna do. Plus I’m pretty sure every kid in the UK knows the f word by the age of 3 it’s used in every household and western culture it’s such a normal thing to say the f word.
 
Hell yeah I’m serious. And whats this role mode thing I’m perplexed when people say that. Kids look upto singers and actors are they good role models. Hell no they have sec on screen use the f word in every sentence do drugs on screen and in real life too. So what is a good role model a cricket player? Is kohli a good role model he’s the best cricket player in the world and people and kids look upto him the most but he has another quality as well cussing people’s mothers and sisters. So when you say they are role models no they are not infact there really is no such thing you can be motivated be by someone but at the end of the day kids will do what they wanna do. Plus I’m pretty sure every kid in the UK knows the f word by the age of 3 it’s used in every household and western culture it’s such a normal thing to say the f word.

I do agree in society speaking French is nothing new, but this is elite professional sport, these guys are professionals which has added attachments so you can't behave like that, I'm sure buttler will be regretting this, bet you had this been anywhere down the street or club then it would have led to a full brawl, but philander full credit to him behaved in a professional manner, maybe buttlers taking his frustration out that he ain't good enough for test cricket
 
Nothing new about swearing in tense test match situations. I expect it got sorted out over beers after the match. If Buttler has broken the Code of Conduct he will get a fine.

There's difference to swearing and a full blown personnal verbal attack, I hope buttler gets banned
 
csnt wait for buttler to come to india.

phaintas waiting for englsnd.
anyway buttler sounds like a girl. lol been should have reacted. Too soft. buttler should try this with someone like rabada.

Lol he won't, he will be discarded in to limited over slog fest like Roy and bairstow , he ain't good enough for tests
 
LOL at Buttler abusing a great like Philander.

Philander was perfect. Didn't respond, didn't react, stood his ground. No need to give any answer to that. Hopefully the ICC will do their job as this clearly is a bit beyond sledging.
 
He shouldn’t have said what he said but it was in the heat of a very tense moment in the game. I am sure both Buttler and Philander are mature enough to let it be water under the bridge.

It is also inevitable that some people would play the typical victim card and jump to the conclusion that Butler will not be banned because he is white. At least wait for ICC’s decision and what they say. At least he did not mock Philander for his color like a “certain WK captain” did in South Africa last year.

Lol ur being an apologist... and then u bring up something that has nothing to do with this.

I dont agree with both. But butler is an avg player test player at best and is clearly agitated with his below avg performance recently.

Doesnt excuse the way he behaved. Coudlve poked fun at his belly in a different manner. &#55357;&#56834;
 
Not sure why so many PPers bringing in Butler's test cricket credentials in the discussion. For the record, he averages 33 coming at no: 6/7, which is a damn good average and I can't think of one country in world cricket, baring SA, which won't have Butler as their test wicketkeeper, if given a chance.
 
This did not look like banter to my eyes. Butler looked pretty ****** off and furious for whatever reason. Credit to Philander for keeping his calm.
 
https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2...manner-of-celebration-after-losing-his-wicket

When he was given a send-off by Bangladesh in 2016 he wasn't having it and almost got into a fight with Mahmudullah and everyone slated Bangladesh for giving a send-off to one of the nicest guys in international cricket.

World cricket needs to stop treating English players as the paragons of virtue and gentlemanliness. Those days are long gone. They are as ill-mannered and foul-mouthed as they come.
 
He has been exposed as a classless idiot masquerading as a gentleman of the game. The ball clearly bounced awkwardly and Philander could not get out of the way. There was no need to abuse him. Furthermore, Philander is one of the best players of his generation who is playing his last series while Buttler is a Test flop. No sense of respect for a fellow professional.
 
Anyone know what Stokes was saying?

Stokes said "that's fair enough, he's got a point"

Buttler had said "then ******* move" in reply to Philander saying something along the lines of "watch where you're ******* throwing/what you're ******* doing".
 
Not sure why so many PPers bringing in Butler's test cricket credentials in the discussion. For the record, he averages 33 coming at no: 6/7, which is a damn good average and I can't think of one country in world cricket, baring SA, which won't have Butler as their test wicketkeeper, if given a chance.

Foakes is better alternative
 
LOL at Buttler abusing a great like Philander.

Philander was perfect. Didn't respond, didn't react, stood his ground. No need to give any answer to that. Hopefully the ICC will do their job as this clearly is a bit beyond sledging.

Philander blatantly says something in response based on the phrasing of Buttlers reply. We just don't know what it was.
 
Much ado about nothing, it all worked in Philander's favor.

He could have responded and it could have got ugly.
He could have walked away and diffused the situation.
He just stared at Buttler and unsettled him.
 
Wow People need to toughen up... competitive sport thats what we want to see in test cricket... Personal remarks
 
Wow People need to toughen up... competitive sport thats what we want to see in test cricket... Personal remarks

Cricket is end of the day just a game, ok just imagine in a normal street some one said that to you then I presume youd allow it?
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-partner="tweetdeck"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">LOTS having a go at <a href="https://twitter.com/josbuttler?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@josbuttler</a> here! <br>LEAVE HIM ALONE! <br><br>This is Test Cricket and believe me, this is nothing compared to lots that goes on, on the field. <br>Series is alive big time! <br><br>END OF! <a href="https://t.co/vSh4zDL1AY">pic.twitter.com/vSh4zDL1AY</a></p>— Kevin Pietersen&#55358;&#56719; (@KP24) <a href="https://twitter.com/KP24/status/1214788530322444288?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">January 8, 2020</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
Does anybody know if Buttler was penalized for this

2 differing opinions:


https://www.thesouthafrican.com/spo...ction-for-verbal-abuse-directed-at-philander/

England wicketkeeper Jos Buttler has yet to be charged by match officials for his verbal abuse of Vernon Philander on day five of the second Test against South Africa.

The International Cricket Council have five days to level charges against Buttler, though such charges would normally be filed after the umpires make their report to the match referee.

It seems likely that Buttler will escape sanction after he was heard calling Vernon Philander a “fat ***ing kn**head” after an inaudible exchange between the South African allrounder and the wicketkeeper.

The match referee and the ICC power structures generally only act on reports from on-field and TV umpires, although there have been cases where infringements have been brought to their attention by television broadcasts such as the infamous sandpaper ball-tampering incident involving Cameron Bancroft.

In 2017 Kagiso Rabada missed the second Test on the tour of England after picking up a demerit for his send-off of Ben Stokes in the first Test of that series. Rabada was heard through the stump mics as he shouted “**** off” at the batsman after claiming his wicket. Rabada’s suspension was not solely based on that action as he had already picked up three demerits before the incident.

Buttler does not currently have any demerits on his record with the points he earned in a 2016 clash with a Bangladesh having falling away. The standard sanction for an audible obscenity would be a single demerit plus a fine. He will not miss any action even if he is given the maximum punishment.

The ICC has strict rules in place that prevent supporters from verbally abusing players, with any reports of player abuse taken seriously and fans guilty of such action being removed from the ground, fined and given a ban from attending matches.

===

Jos Buttler is set to be fined for his foul-mouthed outburst at South Africa’s Vernon Philander after it was picked up by the stump microphone and broadcast live on television.

The England wicketkeeper took exception to Philander apparently blocking his view in catching the ball as the visitors chased down victory on the second Test at Newlands.

As Philander stood waiting for the next delivery in his crease, Buttler berated him from behind the wicket and appeared to call the South African pace bowler a “f****** k***head”.

The International Cricket Council is set to take action against the 29-year-old as a result, with his punishment expected to include at least a fine of his match fee and a demerit point for a level one breach of the ICC’s Code of Conduct.

The incident came with England still needing three wickets to clinch victory in Cape Town with time running out on the fifth and final day, with tensions boiling over as the ball was returned to Buttler from the field.

The foul language was heard on the live broadcast coverage beamed around the world, which triggered an immediate apology from Sky Sports commentator and former England captain Michael Atherton. It was not the first time in the final innings that players on both sides were told to ease off the level of sledging being deployed as James Anderson and Faf du Plessis clashed earlier in the day when the England bowler appeared to get in the way of the South African captain.

The ICC deems sledging to be unsportsmanlike but it largely goes under the radar, with the governing body only stepping in in extreme cases.

The incident was played down by England captain Joe Root, who believes the high-running emotions as the game neared a climax led to the verbal clash.

“I don’t think it was anything serious,” Root said. “It was just two guys playing hard Test cricket.

“Emotions were running quite high and I don’t think anyone overstepped the mark. You want a bit of spice on the TV anyway, don’t you?”

Former England batsman Kevin Pietersen also offered his thoughts on sledging, with the Sky Sports pundit claiming that umpire Kumar Dharmasena was wrong to give Anderson, Du Plessis and Stuart Broad a ticking off for their clash during the opening session.

https://www.independent.co.uk/sport...land-second-test-fine-match-fee-a9274896.html
 
Last edited:
not sure wats the big mess? much worse has been said n done on the field.... philander is big boy enough to know and take all this and will give it back to butler.... him or some1 in the SA team...

Problem with many English and Aussie players is that they cannot take it back.. similar to kholi (as said by Rabada i think) .... they are happy to bark about but cannot take the bite when the other side does it ...

as long as it stays same both ways, its fine... its a tense fiery game ... cannot b played in sweet attitude all the time
 
Buttler was playing his role perfectly, rile us the batsmen so that they lose focus. He unleashed a verbal barrage on every SA batsman, England were desperate. His irritating behaviour must have had a role to play behind the lose shots played by many of the SA top order.

The game was close and even Philander & Rabada were capable of seeing off another 10 overs for a draw. England like any other competitive test team will do anything for a wicket, and if that means the keeper having a go at opposition batsmen, so be it.

The only reason BD, Paksitani and Indian keepers dont do it is because their english vocabulary is limited. Given a choice between a disciplinary fine and a Test match victory, we all know what everyone's choice would be.
 
This is why on field mics need to be limited. Things are said in the heat of the moment. Players get heated. Let the players go out there and play without fear of things like this getting out and media/fans hounding them about it. There is literally nothing about this video that is bad. A heated exchange happened. They moved on. We should too.

On a personal note, I find this to be quite hilarious.
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-partner="tweetdeck"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">LOTS having a go at <a href="https://twitter.com/josbuttler?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@josbuttler</a> here! <br>LEAVE HIM ALONE! <br><br>This is Test Cricket and believe me, this is nothing compared to lots that goes on, on the field. <br>Series is alive big time! <br><br>END OF! <a href="https://t.co/vSh4zDL1AY">pic.twitter.com/vSh4zDL1AY</a></p>— Kevin Pietersen�� (@KP24) <a href="https://twitter.com/KP24/status/1214788530322444288?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">January 8, 2020</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Oh for goodness sakes, KP is right, this is just handbags.
 
He should be fined at most. Banning him for this would be utterly ridiculous. This is absolutely nothing and these things happen regularly but are not picked up the stump mic.
 
Stupid thing to say. Buttler should concentrate on the game and not unnecessary sledging in close contests like this.
 
That should be a fine, especially under the current regulations. The likes of Rabada have been fined for a lot less.

Having said that, "get over your gut" hahahaha
 
They're big boys. This is fairly mild compared to some of the other stuff which the mics don't pick up.
 
Not a big deal, happens in heat of the moment, as long as its not a racial slur.
 
England wicketkeeper Jos Buttler has been fined 15 per cent of his match fee for breaching Level 1 of the ICC Code of Conduct during the fifth day of the second Test against South Africa in Cape Town.

Buttler was found to have breached Article 2.3 of the ICC Code of Conduct for Players and Player Support Personnel, which relates to “Use of an audible obscenity during an International Match” following an incident with South Africa all-rounder Vernon Philander.

In addition to this, one demerit point has been added to the disciplinary record of Buttler, for whom it was the first offence during a 24-month period.

The incident occurred during South Africa’s second innings on Tuesday, when Buttler was heard using obscene language with Philander at the crease.

Buttler admitted the offence and accepted the sanction proposed by Andy Pycroft of the Emirates Elite Panel of ICC Match Referees and, as such, there was no need for a formal hearing.

On-field umpires Kumar Dharmasena and Paul Reiffel, third umpire Chris Gaffaney and reserve umpire Allahudien Palekar leveled the charges.

Level 1 breaches carry a minimum penalty of an official reprimand, a maximum penalty of 50 per cent of a player’s match fee, and one or two demerit points.

Notes:

*When a player reaches four or more demerit points within a 24-month period, they are converted into suspension points and a player is banned

**Two suspension points equate to a ban from one Test or two ODIs or two T20Is, whatever comes first for the player

***Demerit Points to remain on a Player or Player Support Personnel’s disciplinary record for a period of twenty-four (24) months from their imposition following which they will be expunged

https://www.icc-cricket.com/media-releases/1564892
 
Lol he averages just 32 in test cricket. And I was told by some IPL fans that Jos Buttler had improved his test game after playing in IPL. What happened now? :inti
 
Back
Top