[VIDEO] Mehdi Hasan Miraz's controversial run-out of Salman Ali Agha: Fair or not?

[Major]

You put salman agha in mehidi place and mehidi in salman agha place and you will knew who is third class?

Unsportsman like yes, but no need to insult a nation for it.

Thy followed rules.

Forget agha. India has done something similar with Misbah during a test series in 2008 against Pakistan. He was inside, ball was coming, jumps up in the crease, gets runned out. India keeps the appeal.

Fair decision. Now should i go around call the indians as third class?

 

[Varun]

Bangladesh are not made for sport.

Even after doing this they will lose.

 

[sithb]

Forget agha. India has done something similar with Misbah during a test series in 2008 against Pakistan. He was inside, ball was coming, jumps up in the crease, gets runned out. India keeps the appeal.

A more apt example would be inzamam getting run out when defending the ball outside of the crease.

Here the player is actively impeded. No player was impeding either misbah or inzy

 

[charlie007]

Just watched the replay on YouTube. That’s a total brain fade from Salman. Miraz was clearly looking for fielding the ball and Salman played the fielder there! Miraz did nothing wrong.

I have always maintained that every player should always remember the laws of the game. The spirit of the game should never be in contravention of the laws of the game. It is just as wrong to criticize Mankading as it is to criticize such run outs. There’s a reason why there are laws, follow them. You would have seen many times when batters get out of their crease to talk or tap their bat at a spot, they either indicate to the umpire or the opposition player before venturing out of their crease to indicate they are venturing out (while not attempting a run), here is a ball in play and you casually walk out and hand the ball to the fielder?? Coaches must teach all players to know and stick to the laws. If you want to show sportsmanship, tie the batter’s shoelaces or ask them if they’re ok after being felled by the bouncer. Such incidents always infuriate me for their carelessness toward rules.

 

[sithb]

Mankading is a legitimate form of dismissal as the non striking batsmen is actively attempting to steal an advantage for a quick single etc.

 

[Bhaijaan]

Delulu is ur only solulu. That's bdesh is way ahead of ur economy healthcare education . U name it they r ahead of u

Bruh Bangladesh economy is literally being a Darzi to the world. We are exporting sophisticated fighter jets to 7 countries now. We ain’t the same mylulu!

 

[Major]

A more apt example would be inzamam getting run out when defending the ball outside of the crease.

Here the player is actively impeded. No player was impeding either misbah or inzy

Yes, inzi did it twice.

Here the difference is its Bangladesh.

We pakistanis are racists and dont respect Bangladeshis and Afghanis.

We kiss up to players, and when we see others not having it, playing the game and following the rules, we become racists and end up throwing insults to a nation and call their people third class.

Why? Cause rules were followed, and our begging bowl for sportsmanship wasnt answered.

Had this been Australia, or South Africa, or Nz or England, no one would had complained.

Reminds me of Azhar Alis run out against Australia. Or was it shafiq

 

[Hikaru]

I hope that this doesn't sow seeds of disharmony between the fans of two brotherly nations.

 

[sithb]

Yes, inzi did it twice.

Here the difference is its Bangladesh.

We pakistanis are racists and dont respect Bangladeshis and Afghanis.

We kiss up to players, and when we see others not having it, playing the game and following the rules, we become racists and end up throwing insults to a nation and call their people third class.

Why? Cause rules were followed, and our begging bowl for sportsmanship wasnt answered.

Had this been Australia, or South Africa, or Nz or England, no one would had complained.

Reminds me of Azhar Alis run out against Australia. Or was it shafiq

It's extreme naivete. Indian players are well aware of the antics that Bangla cricketers get to doing. They don't allow them the chance. Srilanka learnt the lesson the hard way.

This is nothing against the country , this is against the cricketers.

And it's cute how a lot of Indians and Pakistanis do sense a common brotherhood when it comes to bashing the bangladeshis

 

[RedwoodOriginal]

Grow up mate.

There is one thing to have an opinion, but to go and bash their cricket history or insult posters that disagree with you shows how immature you are.

Ur or my two eyes dont matter. Third umpires does, and he made the correct decision

You should be the last person on this forum telling someone to "grow up". I've seen some of the stuff you say here and how you interact with certain people, so please spare me the sanctimonious preaching.

Also, I will comment on this dismissal or insult a country's lack of cricketing history as much as I want. Its called having an opinion. And if you have a problem with that then you're more than welcome to buzz off.

 

[charlie007]

I don't think he really had a choice in that. Out is out at the end of the day, however unsportsmanlike it is. But it just looks like something a 12 year old would pull in street cricket.

Nobody has ever said ignore the rules and follow the so called spirit. In fact, this is a huge issue when that spirit conflicts with the laws of the game. As a fielder when a very tired batter is stumbling on a run with cramps taking that single and you can easily run him out, will you choose not to because you should feel sympathy for the tired batter? It’s the human spirit there, right?
You’ll find countless such examples. It’s best everyone is told, advised, instructed to FIRST follow the law and rules, and do the spirit deeds when they don’t conflict with the laws.

 

[Major]

You should be the last person on this forum telling someone to "grow up". I've seen some of the stuff you say here and how you interact with certain people, so please spare me the sanctimonious preaching.

Also, I will comment on this dismissal or insult a country's lack of cricketing history as much as I want. Its called having an opinion. And if you have a problem with that then you're more than welcome to buzz off.

Like i said grow up.

Showing your paindu pana and racism....

No wonder @Rana treats u like crap here

 

[Bhaag Viru Bhaag]

Waiting for Anil chaudry to give his pov on this. Guy gives very good insights on contemporary umpiring decisions

Speaking of Anil Chaudhary, have you watched his new song?

 

[JaDed]

I hope that this doesn't sow seeds of disharmony between the fans of two brotherly nations.

Its a domestic cup.. east vs west always have issues

 

[Major]

Nobody has ever said ignore the rules and follow the so called spirit. In fact, this is a huge issue when that spirit conflicts with the laws of the game. As a fielder when a very tired batter is stumbling on a run with cramps taking that single and you can easily run him out, will you choose not to because you should feel sympathy for the tired batter? It’s the human spirit there, right?
You’ll find countless such examples. It’s best everyone is told, advised, instructed to FIRST follow the law and rules, and do the spirit deeds when they don’t conflict with the laws.

The rules and spirit is conditional for many of us. We see the opposition and its country.

If its a SENA country, we would just accept what happens. But if its a country that we look down upon, than we would not only cry about sportsmanship, we would throw racists insults.

I watch NHL, and alot of these thekaydar of sportsmanship would go crazy if they ever watch that sport

 

[Major]

Speaking of Anil Chaudhary, have you watched his new song?

Abeyy. I will pretend i never saw that. Chaudry saab has immense respect in my heart.

 

[Rafale Nidhal Fan]

poor stuff from bangladesh. the bowler blocked Agha's way also and it should've been considered dead ball.

Such stuff always comes back to bite bangladesh

 

[sithb]

The rules and spirit is conditional for many of us. We see the opposition and its country.

If its a SENA country, we would just accept what happens. But if its a country that we look down upon, than we would not only cry about sportsmanship, we would throw racists insults.

I watch NHL, and alot of these thekaydar of sportsmanship would go crazy if they ever watch that sport

I'd wager to say that Agha would be more angry with himself and not at the opposition when he looks back at the dismissal.

 

[Romali_rotti]

Nangin kitty cat on purpose got in Salman's way to prevent him from getting back to the crease.

P.S. Salman looks like an Azhar Mahmood twin

 

[Major]

I'd wager to say that Agha would be more angry with himself and not at the opposition when he looks back at the dismissal.

He threw a hissyfit. And it seemed like he wanted a lifeline from the bangladeshis. Good from the bangladesh side not to give any lifelines.

 

[sithb]

Nangin kitty cat on purpose got in Salman's way to prevent him from getting back to the crease.

P.S. Salman looks like an Azhar Mahmood twin

This looks bad the more times I'm seeing it.

Brainfade from Agha surely but this needs to be addressed by the ICC

 

[Romali_rotti]

This looks bad the more times I'm seeing it.

Brainfade from Agha surely but this needs to be addressed by the ICC

I don't know about the exact rules that apply here, but, shouldn't there be a provision that states if a player obstructs a batsman's path then the benefit of the doubt goes to the bat ?.

 

[charlie007]

This spirit vs laws is a VERY slippery slope. Batters don’t walk after edging to second slip, fielders claim bump balls, bowlers appeal on anything and everything knowing the batter is not out, bowlers block the batter’s path for running, captains often don’t recall a batter knowing he’s not out. If the spirit is more important than the laws, follow it every time and not just selectively.

 

[sithb]

Agha's first instinct should be the preservation of his wicket. That was the major blunder.

Make your way back to the crease not attempting to gather the ball .

But it's unsporting behaviour from the Bangladeshi cricketer. The more I see it , the worse it looks

 

[Nikhil_cric]

It really did look like Mehidy was obstructing Agha. But very dozy by Agha too. Should have looked to get back in the crease first.

 

[Romali_rotti]

Can't wait till our boys play these Bangaldeshi dopes next time, give em a trashing of their lifetime....

 

[sithb]

I don't know about the exact rules that apply here, but, shouldn't there be a provision that states if a player obstructs a batsman's path then the benefit of the doubt goes to the bat ?.

The brainfade of Agha wanting to gather the ball played a likely part here.

 

[Nikhil_cric]

Unsportsman like yes, but no need to insult a nation for it.

Thy followed rules.

Forget agha. India has done something similar with Misbah during a test series in 2008 against Pakistan. He was inside, ball was coming, jumps up in the crease, gets runned out. India keeps the appeal.

Fair decision. Now should i go around call the indians as third class?

India never ran Misbah out like this.

 

[Savak]

Salman Ali Agha needs to realize he cannot be in chewing gum mode all the time.

 

[sithb]

Agha would have a case against being run out if he tried to barge in to the cricketer and then fell down in the process.

He was obstructed, assumed wrongly that the ball would be declared dead when he was outside the crease.

 

[charlie007]

I don't know about the exact rules that apply here, but, shouldn't there be a provision that states if a player obstructs a batsman's path then the benefit of the doubt goes to the bat ?.

Miraz is not obstructing Agha. He’s there to field the ball, not to block Agha - the ball is literally under Agha. He’s under no obligation to go around Agha to get to the ball, in fact it’s Agha who should have gotten into the crease right away instead of fielding the ball for Miraz.

 

[jnaveen1980]

Watching the video what Agha did is also funny lol. He is standing his ground like he is inside the crease. There is a potential chance of richochetting on to stumps. You should immediately try to drag yourself back in.

If you do research Rizwan is the root cause of this problem

 

[sithb]

India never ran Misbah out like this.

India's run outs of misbah were legal.

 

[RedwoodOriginal]

Like i said grow up.

Showing your paindu pana and racism....

No wonder @Rana treats u like crap here

Yes I'm a paindu and a racist for insulting the Bangladesh cricket team. Because the Bangladesh cricket team = all Bangladeshis.

Whatever you say terrorist sympathizer.

Why don't you go and kiss the many pictures of terrorists you like to put on here instead of barking incessantly because you're mad at my opinion lol

 

[sithb]

Miraz is not obstructing Agha. He’s there to field the ball, not to block Agha - the ball is literally under Agha. He’s under no obligation to go around Agha to get to the ball, in fact it’s Agha who should have gotten into the crease right away instead of fielding the ball for Miraz.

He blocks Agha first. Gets him off his return stride. And then further obstructs him by attempting to gather the ball.

Agha should have been more assertive rather than trying to be the nice guy

 

[nish_mate]

Fair decision. Now should i go around call the indians as third class?

Misbah or no Misbah, ain't gonna stop you from calling us all sorts of names under the blue skies....

But this threads about Miraz, don't drag us in please

 

[Romali_rotti]

Miraz is not obstructing Agha.

Yeah well.

And

Tooth fairies exist also....

 

[Major]

India never ran Misbah out like this.

2008 series test. He jumped in the air, someone threw the ball, and he got run out. Lol. There is a youtube video aswell.

 

[sachin-10dulkar]

Pak POV to BD right now!!

 

[Banda298]

Bruh Bangladesh economy is literally being a Darzi to the world. We are exporting sophisticated fighter jets to 7 countries now. We ain’t the same mylulu!

Lol ..exporting or doing import export from new best friend ? What about the countless loan trips by pm etc ... Bdesh isn't running around the world for just a billion

 

[nish_mate]

Cricket gone downhill ever since BD gifted full time membership

It just ain't cricket, what Miraz did sillier than Botham sending his MIL

 

[Nikhil_cric]

2008 series test. He jumped in the air, someone threw the ball, and he got run out. Lol. There is a youtube video aswell.

That's not the same as another player obstructing him though is it?

That was just Misbah losing his head and doing something silly.

 

[sithb]

If its a SENA country, we would just accept what happens. But if its a country that we look down upon, than we would not only cry about sportsmanship, we would throw racists insults.

I don't think SENA and most other countries (including India) would do this blatant level of idiocy that the bangla cricketers have time and time exhibited.

 

[charlie007]

Yeah well.

And

Tooth fairies exist also....

Bro! Don’t go cute on me. Think a bit deeper than just mocking me. Obstruction would be if the ball were elsewhere and he blocked a running Agha. Miraz got into the line of the ball to field as soon as the striker hit it while Agha was advancing for the run and stopped after the ball came to him. Miraz was totally justified to be there and get to the ball. The onus was on Agha to get into his crease, even if he had to go around Miraz (like running batters typically do), not act as a fielder.

 

[NishanKonar]

I don't think SENA and most other countries (including India) would do this blatant level of idiocy that the bangla cricketers have time and time exhibited.

Actually they do. Check how John Bairstow got run out at Lords in the 2023 Ashes

 

[RidiculousMan]

Not Out!

Umpires made a big mistake.

When the ball was pushed back Salman's first instinct was the get back at the crease but Miraz came in his way. Hence Salman stopped.

 

[charlie007]

Yes I'm a paindu and a racist for insulting the Bangladesh cricket team. Because the Bangladesh cricket team = all Bangladeshis.

Whatever you say terrorist sympathizer.

Why don't you go and kiss the many pictures of terrorists you like to put on here instead of barking incessantly because you're mad at my opinion lol

Calm down bro, you’re better than this and a good poster. Never seen you so agitated.

 

[RedwoodOriginal]

Terrorist sympathizer? So burhan wani is a terrorist?

Millions of people have bin laden as a dp. That doesnt mean they sympathize with him, its a joke.

Anyways, you act like a feminine men around here. Someone who gets crazy when others disagree with him.

On the contrary, Major Bin Laden. I'm not the one who quote replied you and then got mad because your refused to change your opinion. That was all you.

Also, I don't need a terrorist sympathizing incel who probably didn't talk to a girl till he was married to tell me how effeminate I am lol.

 

[Smbhayi]

Just coming to pp to see this actually.. school boy error by Agha there.. Absolute fair to run out him..

 

[nish_mate]

Bro! Don’t go cute on me. Think a bit deeper than just mocking me. Obstruction would be if the ball were elsewhere and he blocked a running Agha. Miraz got into the line of the ball to field as soon as the striker hit it while Agha was advancing for the run and stopped after the ball came to him. Miraz was totally justified to be there and get to the ball. The onus was on Agha to get into his crease, even if he had to go around Miraz (like running batters typically do), not act as a fielder.

Should have shoulder barged Mehidy and got back in crease.
never gets in batsmens way in his follow through after he learnt his lesson

 

[Major]

On the contrary, Major Bin Laden. I'm not the one who quote replied you and then got mad because your refused to change your opinion. That was all you.

Also, I don't need a terrorist sympathizing incel who probably didn't talk to a girl till he was married to tell me how effeminate I am lol.

Typical feminine men... going crazy over disagreement..

 

[sithb]

Not Out!

Umpires made a big mistake.

When the ball was pushed back Salman's first instinct was the get back at the crease but Miraz came in his way. Hence Salman stopped.

Shouldn't have gone for the ball

 

[RedwoodOriginal]

Typical feminine men... going crazy over disagreement..

Typical misogynist terrorist-sympathizing incel...

 

[RedwoodOriginal]

Calm down bro, you’re better than this and a good poster. Never seen you so agitated.

OP dug his own grave by refusing to leave well enough alone

 

[Major]

I don't think SENA and most other countries (including India) would do this blatant level of idiocy that the bangla cricketers have time and time exhibited.

Well it depends how many games Ashwin has played against us. I cant believe he retired without pulling any of his moves against us.

Infact during the usman tariq issue, he was the one to suggest for the batters to pull out.

But Bangalis did nothing wrong here nor with Matthews.

Rules were followed

 

[nish_mate]

Typical misogynist terrorist-sympathizing incel, acting like a typical misogynist terrorist-sympathizing incel

Shant gadadhari Bheem Shant

Hate to see two Pakistanis falling out over a Bangladeshi please. Before brotherly nation comes apna mulk and apne log.

 

[Major]

Typical misogynist terrorist-sympathizing incel...

Ok feminine male.

 

[batandballbattle]

The main thing is lack of game awareness from Agha, sure it's a little cheap from Miraz but it's a contest at the end of the day

 

[sithb]

Well it depends how many games Ashwin has played against us. I cant believe he retired without pulling any of his moves against us.

Infact during the usman tariq issue, he was the one to suggest for the batters to pull out.

But Bangalis did nothing wrong here nor with Matthews.

Rules were followed

Usman holds back his delivery way longer and when he's well into his delivery stride

 

[Smbhayi]

View attachment 162806

He was stopping the ball, and Agha should've tried to be back in the crease..

 

[Mainul]

The audio suggests crowd supported Miraz's actions rather than condemning it, yet here we have Sweepy et al saying BD supporters are open minded

If you understand Bengali then go to Tsports you tube highlights of this out and see the 2.1k comments by Bangladeshis . Everyone is criticizing Miraz. In stadium the crowd erupts in every action. You shouldn't judge that .

 

[nish_mate]

Who was the genius comparing the Misbah run-out with the pathetic incident from this match ?

Apples and pears comparison

 

[nish_mate]

If you understand Bengali then go to Tsports you tube highlights of this out and see the 2.1k comments by Bangladeshis . Everyone is criticizing Miraz. In stadium the crowd erupts in every action. You shouldn't judge that .

You can sugar coat it as much as you want, the audio shows crowd in stadia approved it.

 

[sithb]

If you understand Bengali then go to Tsports you tube highlights of this out and see the 2.1k comments by Bangladeshis . Everyone is criticizing Miraz. In stadium the crowd erupts in every action. You shouldn't judge that .

Had this discussion with a Bangladeshi friend and he was embarassed at this dismissal as well.

 

[Mainul]

I think it was a complete foolish action by both .

Agha should not have done this .

Miraz should not have done this .

Both did idiotic act

 

[Mainul]

You can sugar coat it as much as you want, the audio shows crowd in stadia approved it.

You are in the class of Salman Ali agha and Miraz too who will also get the adjective of '' I" by me

 

[charlie007]

OP dug his own grave by refusing to leave well enough alone

I can see he got personal first - good on you to stand up for yourself, but withdraw from that conversation quickly because it won’t go anywhere and just irritate you. I use this tactic often with some folks around here.

 

[Mainul]

Had this discussion with a Bangladeshi friend and he was embarassed at this dismissal as well.

Almost every Bangladeshi with a cricketing sense won't support this act by Miraz.

 

[nish_mate]

You are in the class of Salman Ali agha and Miraz too who will also get the adjective of '' I" by me

Go on mate, hardly gonna lose sleep over it, but bask in the warmth of highlightingthe hypocrisy of BD fans who 24/7 lament about spirit of cricket and gentleman's game whilst being oblivious to cheap antics of their national team

 

[RidiculousMan]

lol Rizwan was hugging Litton who was abusing Salman.. What is this guy @Rana

Jadu ki Jhapi resolves everything

 

[sithb]

Almost every Bangladeshi with a cricketing sense won't support this act by Miraz.

The point does remain that there have been various acts by Bangladeshi cricketers that lead people (not me) to attribute that to Bangladesh as such.

I do think Bangladesh cricket needs to set their priorities in order. The cricketers they choose to represent their country firstly.

 

[nish_mate]

Almost every Bangladeshi with a cricketing sense won't support this act by Miraz.

Except for those in the stadia and their reactions are verifiable...remainder are fictionary..

 

[charlie007]

Cricket as a sport has a big issue - the spirit of the game (which by the way of it remains undefined and open to opinion and subjective interpretations) should never be in conflict with the documented laws of the game. It often is and so often opens up needless incidents and discussions. Only if there were just the laws to be followed!! Alas!

 

[Romali_rotti]

Who was the genius comparing the Misbah run-out with the pathetic incident from this match ?

Ramiz Raja: He will have to fly out of the crease now.

 

[Banda298]

Should have shoulder barged Mehidy and got back in crease.
never gets in batsmens way in his follow through after he learnt his lesson

U need to be a proper man to do that. It's not even aggression. It's actually called saving ur ass which this stockholmed captain or ex cap doesn't know.

See his body language in the video.. almost as if he's sleeping or thinking it's a dead ball now ... Followed by misplaced aggresion later.

Had he shown 1/5,th of that so called meat eating aggression initially he'd be safe.

And then there was a legend called Dhoni who smashed mustafizur into the ground when he tried to do the same with him despite verbal and physical hand pointing warning by Rohit sharma.

Meat eating ≠ On field mental clarity and aggression

 

[RedwoodOriginal]

Ramiz Raja: He will have to fly out of the crease now.

Somebody should make a compilation of Ramiz commentary anti-quips. It would be comedy gold.

 

[Bhaijaan]

11K views · 488 reactions | Out of context Cricket II on Reels

www.facebook.com

Agha threw insults. A pakistani way of giving someone lannat...

They deserved it.
Don’t you try to defend them here right now. We are with Kaptaan here, standing in solidarity and guarding the spirit of cricket.

 

[Bhaag Viru Bhaag]

I made this. @Major @The Bald Eagle @RidiculousMan

 

[Romali_rotti]

Somebody should make a compilation of Ramiz commentary anti-quips. It would be comedy gold.

Ramiz is my favourite commie.

'Oh that is a magnificent blow'

'he will have to fly out of the crease now'

 

[Bhaijaan]

Those who are saying the spirit of cricket is nonsense, kindly don’t tell us about your upbringing here. This is a forum of civilised men. Me who can cut your head off with a sword but with honour.