What's new

Welcome Ramadhan: Read This First

LordJames

Post of the Week winner
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Runs
3,141
Post of the Week
2
Question: Which Islamic Year is this?

Answer: Islamic Calendar begins from when Prophet Muhammad ﷺ migrated from Makkah to Madina and that year is designated as Year 0 as there is no concept of Birthdays or Anniversaries etc in Islam. This year is 1447.

Question: How many Months in Islamic Calendar?

Answer: 12. The Calendar system and the name of the months has continued since before Islam and no changes have been made.

Question: Which month is Ramadhan? And what does it mean?

Answer: The month of "Ramadhan" existed before Islam and the Arab meaning is "To Burn", "To Scotch".

The Arabs also used it to convey "purification process through application of intense heat".

It is the 9th month of the Islamic Calendar.

Question: Why do some people call in "Ramzan"?

Answer: Arabic has 28 letters and the 22nd letter Ḍād (ﺽ) is the hardest to pronounce and takes practice so majority of Muslims pronounce it in their native (Urdu, Persian, Turkish) as "z" and say Ramzan OR Ramazan.

Even Ramadan is incorrect and it is a sound between D and Z and hard to articulate in English.



Question: What is done in Ramadhan?

Answer: The most common and well known act is fasting from true dawn (not sunrise) to sunset and lesser known is abstention from sexual acts.

Fasting means no eating or drinking anything.

After sunset and until true dawn (not sunrise) eating/drinking/sex is permitted.

Just like the name of the month, the act of fasting is also not exclusive to Islam and was prescribed before Islam to others.

[2:183] O believers! Fasting is prescribed for you—as it was for those before you, so perhaps you will become mindful ˹of Allah˺.

Question: How does Ramadhan start and how long is it?

Answer: The Islamic Calendar is Lunar in nature and the months begin by the sighting of the moon and end with the sighting of the moon (for the next Islamic month). The advantage of it being a Lunar calendar is that it rotates throughout the year and throughout seasons so over a person's lifetime Ramadhan will fall in Spring, Summer, Winter & Autumn and all of the normal months of the year.

Each Islamic month is either 29 or 30 days and as taught by Prophet Muhammad ﷺ Muslims around the world attempt to sight the moon on the 29th of every month, if the moon is sighted the next month begins the next day otherwise 30 days are completed and the next month begins thereafter.

Question: So the name and the act are both continued from previous eras?

Answer: Yes. Because Creator has always been the same and his message was sent to various messengers (Prophets) so there are many actions in Islam which are a continuation of the past.

[3:144] Muḥammad is no more than a messenger; other messengers have gone before him.



Question: Does everyone has to Fast in Ramadhan?

Answer: Every adult Muslim (man or woman) is required to fast with general exemptions being:​
  1. Patients​
  2. Those with insufficient strength to fast​
  3. Those who are travelling​
  4. Pregnant & Nursing Mothers​
  5. Menstruating and woman with Lochia (Postnatal Bleeding)​
These specific categories of people fast later when the condition which prevented them from fasting is lifted (e.g. no longer sick, no longer traveling etc).

[2:184] ˹Fast a˺ prescribed number of days. But whoever of you is ill or on a journey, then ˹let them fast˺ an equal number of days ˹after Ramaḍân˺. For those who can only fast with extreme difficulty, compensation can be made by feeding a needy person ˹for every day not fasted˺. But whoever volunteers to give more, it is better for them. And to fast is better for you, if only you knew.

Question: Who is a "Traveler" during Ramadhan?

Answer: There is a difference of opinion in Islamic Jurisprudence but I am going to give one of the opinions.​
  1. When a Person has traveled more than 88 KM (55 miles) from their primary residence​
  2. And intends to stay at that destination for less than 15 days​
Reference

Question: When does he becomes a "Traveler" and then ceases?

Answer: When he exits his city limits he becomes a "Traveler" and then ceases upon reentry. If he is flying and the Airport is outside his city limits then he is a "Traveler" and many airports are outside city limits.

Question: When is a "Traveler" exempt from Fasting?

Answer: When true dawn (not sunrise) arrives and he has exited the city limits. Even if he leaves hours early to catch a flight or train etc deliberately and on purpose. For example, his flight isn't until 11:20 but he left his house at 03:20 to the Airport and decides to wait in the lounge etc.

Question: Can a "Traveler" fast?

Answer: Yes, many Muslims fast on flights, buses, trains etc.



Question: How do Muslims prepare for fasting all day (no water, no food) during Ramadhan?

Answer: Before true dawn (not sunrise) Muslims wake up a little early at night and take a meal which is called Suhoor (or Sehri). It is highly recommended religious practise and not just for nutricious reasons, so even if you are not hungry you still eat (or drink a little) because it is a virtous act to eat at this time.

Reference

Then a person makes "Intention" for fasting.

Question: What and how is "Intention" for fasting made?
Answer: "Intention" for fasting is not a verbal declartion and not in a specific language, the person just makes an intention in the heart that they will be fasting.​
  1. They can think it at the begnning of Ramadhan that I will fast the whole month, OR
  2. Make Intention daily when they are eating at Suhoor (or Sehri)​
Its just a "thought" process, although a person can express their thought verbally if they want to.

Question: What if someone doesn't wake up for Suhoor (or Sehri) meal?

Answer: Suhoor (or Sehri) is not an obligation but fasting is an obligation so you still fast if you didn't wake up or didn't eat.

Question: Is there a specific meal or food iteam when opening the fast at sunset?

Answer: It is recommended and virtous to open (or break the fast) with Dates or Water and then eat whatever.

Reference

Question: What happens to good deeds during Ramadhan?

Answer: In Islam, acts are roughly divided into two categories:​
  1. Mandatory (like 5 times prayers)​
  2. Optional (like smiling, helping people etc)​
During Ramadhan, the rewards are multipled many folds.

Question: Are there any special days/night during Ramadhan?

Answer: The whole of Ramadhan is blessed and full of virtues but there is a special night which in which worship is equal to worhsipping a thousand months and it is within the last 5 odd night of Ramadhan so it could be from:​
  1. 21st Night​
  2. 23rd Night​
  3. 25th Night​
  4. 27th Night​
  5. 29th Night​
In English, it is generally referred to as "Night of Power" or "Night of Glory" etc.

[97:1] Indeed, ˹it is˺ We ˹Who˺ sent this ˹Quran˺ down on the Night of Glory.
[97:2] And what will make you realize what the Night of Glory is?
[97:3] The Night of Glory is better than a thousand months.
[97:4] That night the angels and the ˹holy˺ spirit descend, by the permission of their Lord, for every ˹decreed˺ matter.
[97:5] It is all peace until the break of dawn.

Question: How come you don't know which specific night this is?

Answer: The exact night is delibertaly not revealed so Muslims can exert themselves in worship during the last 5 odd night.

Question: Is the concept of Day/Night the same in Islam as in the 24 hour clock?

Answer: No! In Islam:​
  1. The next date begins at sunset so night comes first​
  2. Day follows the night.​


Question: Besides fasting, what else is done during Ramadhan?

Answer: Beside fasting, special congreagtional prayers called Taraweeh are held at the Mosques at night. It is either 8, 20 or 36 extra units of prayers depening on the difference of opinion.

Question: So how do you pray if it is 8, 20 or 26 units of extra prayers during Ramadhan?

Answer: The extra units are differed but is agreed upon to start with the Imam (the one leading the prayer) and end the prayers with him, no matter how many he is leading.

In practise, most Muslims pray in their local neighbourhood Mosque.

Reference

Question: Besides fasting and Taraweeh, what else is done during Ramadhan?

Answer: A special charity is due on every Muslim which is called Sadaqtul-Fit'r and it must be paid when Ramadhan begins and before praying at Eid.

Question: How much is Sadaqtul-Fit'r or Fitrana during Ramadhan?

Answer: There is a difference of opinion in Islamic Jurisprudence but I am going to give one of the opinions. It is Cash equaivalient of any of the following, depending on the person's financial standing:
StandardWeight
Wheat (Grain or Flour)3.85 Lbs OR 62 Oz OR 1.75 KG
Barley (Grain or Flour)7.72 Lbs OR 124 Oz OR 3.5 KG
Raisins7.72 Lbs OR 124 Oz OR 3.5 KG
Dates7.72 Lbs OR 124 Oz OR 3.5 KG

Reference

Question: How do Muslims know the amount of Sadaqtul-Fit'r or Fitrana during Ramadhan?

Answer: Two ways:​
  1. It is generally advertised within the country and by local Mosques, e.g. in Pakistan it is 300 PKR (for 2026)​
    1. In the West and many countries the amount is set a little higher than the actual amount due but the standar and formula is given in the table.​
  2. Select the "standard" and look at the price and calculate e.g. look at the price of "Flour" in your local store and calculate​


Question: What happens if a Muslim is unable to fast and unable to make the obligatory fasts after Ramadhan?

Answer: There is a difference of opinion in Islamic Jurisprudence but I am going to give one of the opinions. Those who are unable to fast (and make up) pay 1 Sadqatul-Fitr' for each missed e.g. lets say that Sadaqaqtul-Fit'r amount is around $2 USD so someone who missed 30 fasts will pay $60 USD

Question: How does Ramadhan end?

Answer: On the 29th night (after sunset), attempt is made to sight the new moon (Crescent) and if it is sighted then Ramadhan ends and next (10th Islamic month) of Shab'aan begins.

If the new moon (Crescent) is not sighted then an extra (30th fast) is done.

Remember the answer to a previous question that in Islam, the date changes at sunset and night comes before the day.

Question: Can you use Astronomical Calculations and science for Ramadhan start/end?

Answer: Yes, science is heavilty used to make Calendars, book vacation, time offs etc but the actual event is marked by sighting of the Moon.

Muslims have a pretty good idea when Ramadhan will start because Astronomical calculations are fairly accurate.


Question: What is the greatest misunderstanding about Ramadhan?

Answer: Most Non-Muslims and many Muslims think that it is only about abstention from eating/drinking and sex only from true dawn (not sunrise) to sunset but it is also about avoidance of argments and acting foolishly etc.

Arguments, engaging in (useless) debates and atcing foolishly do not break the fast but severly dent its blessings and lessen the rewards.


Reference
 
Question: What breaks a fast?

Answer: Sexual Intercourse breaks the fast, Ejaculation breaks the fast and...

Technically, anything which goes down the throat either via the mouth (food or drink) or nasal passage (cigarette smoke) invalidates and breaks the fast.

So brushing the teeth (with toothpaste) as usual does not invalidate the fast as long as neither the water nor the toothpaste goes down the throat.

An Insulin Injection does not invalidate the fast.

A blood test does not invalidate the fast.

Any other medical procedure in which material does not go down the throat does not invalidate the fast.


Dentist.png

Question: Is it just a matter of something going down the throat?

Answer: NO! The "Intent matters" so if a person can:​
  1. Make a mistake OR while being extra careful accidentally something can go down the throat OR
  2. A person can deliberate, thoughtfully and on purpose and without an excuse:​
    1. Smoke a Cigarette​
    2. Eat or Drink​
    3. Have Sex​
    4. Masturbate and Ejaculate​
Question: What is an excuse?

Answer: A person can faint, develop weakness or have an accident or medical emergency due to which food or water will need to be given or taken.

Question: What happens if a mistake is made or fast is broken due to a mistake?

Answer: Make up the broken fast after Ramadhan.

Question: What happens if the blood pressure drops or blood sugar drops or any other weakness or dizziness occurs?

Answer: Break the fast, get medical help and then make up the broken fast after Ramadhan. It is an obligation to save life!

Question: Does taking Insulin break the fast and does a Diabetic person needs to fast?

Answer: Taking Insulin does not affect the fast and it depends on the person and the severity of their diabetes and Doctor's advice.

Question: Does taking Inhaler break the fast and does an Asthmatic person needs to fast?

Answer: It depends on the person and the severity of their Asthma and Doctor's advice but in terms of Inhaler or other treatments while fasting:​
  1. Taking Oxygen does not break the fast​
  2. Taking (any other Gas) does not break the Fast​
    1. A group of scholars say that it breaks the fast but it is a valid excuse so need to make up just for the broken fast​
    2. A group scholar say that it does not break the fast.​
In case 3, a person should consult the scholars of their choice.

Question: Does dental treatment, root canal break the fast?

Answer: No, as long as the water or (medicine or treatment) does not go down the throat, it does not invalidate the fast.

Question: Do eye/ear drops break the fast?

Answer: No.

Question: Does Injection or IV treatment break the fast?

Answer: No.

Question: Does kissing break the fast?

Answer: No.

Question: Does eating/drinking "forgetfully" break the fast?

Answer: No. This is a fairly common scenario and a person can forgetfully eat or drink while fasting and it does not break the fast.

Question: What happens if a fast is broken on purpose and deliberately?

Answer: A person who deliberately, thoughtfully and on purpose and without an excuse breaks a fast will need to fast for 60 continuous days and then also make the fast which was broken.

 
Question: What breaks a fast?

Answer: Sexual Intercourse breaks the fast, Ejaculation breaks the fast and...

Technically, anything which goes down the throat either via the mouth (food or drink) or nasal passage (cigarette smoke) invalidates and breaks the fast.

So brushing the teeth (with toothpaste) as usual does not invalidate the fast as long as neither the water nor the toothpaste goes down the throat.

An Insulin Injection does not invalidate the fast.

A blood test does not invalidate the fast.

Any other medical procedure in which material does not go down the throat does not invalidate the fast.


View attachment 161622

Question: Is it just a matter of something going down the throat?

Answer: NO! The "Intent matters" so if a person can:​
  1. Make a mistake OR while being extra careful accidentally something can go down the throat OR
  2. A person can deliberate, thoughtfully and on purpose and without an excuse:​
    1. Smoke a Cigarette​
    2. Eat or Drink​
    3. Have Sex​
    4. Masturbate and Ejaculate​
Question: What is an excuse?

Answer: A person can faint, develop weakness or have an accident or medical emergency due to which food or water will need to be given or taken.

Question: What happens if a mistake is made or fast is broken due to a mistake?

Answer: Make up the broken fast after Ramadhan.

Question: What happens if the blood pressure drops or blood sugar drops or any other weakness or dizziness occurs?

Answer: Break the fast, get medical help and then make up the broken fast after Ramadhan. It is an obligation to save life!

Question: Does taking Insulin break the fast and does a Diabetic person needs to fast?

Answer: Taking Insulin does not affect the fast and it depends on the person and the severity of their diabetes and Doctor's advice.

Question: Does taking Inhaler break the fast and does an Asthmatic person needs to fast?

Answer: It depends on the person and the severity of their Asthma and Doctor's advice but in terms of Inhaler or other treatments while fasting:​
  1. Taking Oxygen does not break the fast​
  2. Taking (any other Gas) does not break the Fast​
    1. A group of scholars say that it breaks the fast but it is a valid excuse so need to make up just for the broken fast​
    2. A group scholar say that it does not break the fast.​
In case 3, a person should consult the scholars of their choice.

Question: Does dental treatment, root canal break the fast?

Answer: No, as long as the water or (medicine or treatment) does not go down the throat, it does not invalidate the fast.

Question: Do eye/ear drops break the fast?

Answer: No.

Question: Does Injection or IV treatment break the fast?

Answer: No.

Question: Does kissing break the fast?

Answer: No.

Question: Does eating/drinking "forgetfully" break the fast?

Answer: No. This is a fairly common scenario and a person can forgetfully eat or drink while fasting and it does not break the fast.

Question: What happens if a fast is broken on purpose and deliberately?

Answer: A person who deliberately, thoughtfully and on purpose and without an excuse breaks a fast will need to fast for 60 continuous days and then also make the fast which was broken.

Typo/Text messed up, correction....

Question: Does taking Inhaler break the fast and does an Asthmatic person needs to fast?

Answer: It depends on the person and the severity of their Asthma and Doctor's advice but in terms of Inhaler or other treatments while fasting:
  1. Taking Oxygen does not break the fast
  2. Taking (any other Gas) does not break the Fast
  3. Taking an Inhaler (Gas + Medication) has a difference of opinion:
    1. A group of scholars say that it breaks the fast but it is a valid excuse so need to make up just for the broken fast
    2. A group scholar say that it does not break the fast.
In case 3, a person should consult the scholars of their choice.
 
Abu Hurairah narrated that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: “​
  1. May the man before whom I am mentioned - and he does not send Salat upon me - be humiliated.
  2. And may a man upon whom Ramadan enters and then passes, before he is forgiven, be humiliated.
  3. And may a man whose parents reached old age in his presence, and they were not a cause for his entrance to Paradise, be humiliated.”​
Jami` at-Tirmidhi 3545

images
 
Question: How do Muslims know when to open their fast?

Answer: A brief answer has already been given that it is at sunset. In Islamic terminology it is also the time for "Maghrib Prayers".

There is no need or requirement to sit and observe the "actual sunset" but sunset in Islamic Jurisprudence is defined as follows:

When the disc of the sun has disappeared, at that point the fasting person may break his fast, and the time when offering supererogatory prayers is disallowed has come to an end. The deep red afterglow that may remain on the horizon does not affect any rulings at all.

In the US, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) has defined the sunset times provided and graphically it can be presented as follows

NOAA-1.pngWhen the Islamic understanding is superimposed on the sunset times provided, we find that the "physical sunset" and refraction of light (in the atmosphere) have already been taken into Account and resulting explanation can be depicted as follows:

NOAA-2.png
Therefore, requirements of Islamic Jurisprudence are satisfied with obtaining the sunset times from a reliable source such as NOAA for your respective location.
NOAA-3.png





 
Typo/Text messed up, correction....

Question: Does taking Inhaler break the fast and does an Asthmatic person needs to fast?

Answer: It depends on the person and the severity of their Asthma and Doctor's advice but in terms of Inhaler or other treatments while fasting:
  1. Taking Oxygen does not break the fast
  2. Taking (any other Gas) does not break the Fast
    1. A group of scholars say that it breaks the fast but it is a valid excuse so need to make up just for the broken fast
    2. A group scholar say that it does not break the fast.
In case 3, a person should consult the scholars of their choice.
Had Always thought inhaler breaks the fast.
Another thing, if you put too many drops in your ear, they do tend to get absorbed and go down the throat, even less amount is required for nasal drops.
So I am not sure if ear drops is totally valid or not.
 
Had Always thought inhaler breaks the fast.
Another thing, if you put too many drops in your ear, they do tend to get absorbed and go down the throat, even less amount is required for nasal drops.
So I am not sure if ear drops is totally valid or not.
Ear buds are haram
 
Had Always thought inhaler breaks the fast.
Another thing, if you put too many drops in your ear, they do tend to get absorbed and go down the throat, even less amount is required for nasal drops.
So I am not sure if ear drops is totally valid or not.
Ear drops are totally valid, the classical opinion was based on incomplete knowledge of Anatomy, please see note 2
 
Ear drops are totally valid, the classical opinion was based on incomplete knowledge of Anatomy, please see note 2
No, I am talking from a medical point of view since I am professional in that field. Ear drops if given in a high dose tends to get absorbed into the pharynx. So this is what surprises me.
 
No, I am talking from a medical point of view since I am professional in that field. Ear drops if given in a high dose tends to get absorbed into the pharynx. So this is what surprises me.
Ear drops in a non-performed ear drum can pass into the throat? Can you please give me some studies on this as I would like to read up on it, because most professionals say the opposite (page 18)

 
Discussion with an ENT Surgeon:

Just spoke to him.

No, I am talking from a medical point of view since I am professional in that field. Ear drops if given in a high dose tends to get absorbed into the pharynx. So this is what surprises me.
  1. In a non-perforated ear drum, there is no chance of ear drops going anywhere.​
  2. In a perforated ear drum, even if you put a lot of drops they hardly reach the nasopharynx and even if they did it is anatomically above the throat . There is a greater chance of water reaching the nasopharnyx during Wudhu (when water is taken into the nose) because it is closer and in higher quantity.​
Not a Scholar but as an ENT Surgeon, the probability of a fast breaking from ear drops is almost nil.

This is me, trying to understand what he (ENT surgeon) is saying...

eustachian-tube.jpg


image-of-the-nasopharynx.jpg


This is pretty much what Dr Rafaqat Rashid has also written on Page 18 that ear drops do not break the fast.

Ear buds are haram
I meant during a fast not completely
Although most nurses don’t recommend you use them
In the shafi madhab it would break your fast and also in classical hanafi texts


In an ENT scenario, an ear bud is an ear plug and not sure what is the connection with fasting? Please explain and can you post a picture of what you are referring to? And I will ask him? I would like to understand this myself.

Do you mean in the classical Hanafi text, ear drops did break the fast? If that's what you mean then agreed.
 
Discussion with an ENT Surgeon:

Just spoke to him.


  1. In a non-perforated ear drum, there is no chance of ear drops going anywhere.​
  2. In a perforated ear drum, even if you put a lot of drops they hardly reach the nasopharynx and even if they did it is anatomically above the throat . There is a greater chance of water reaching the nasopharnyx during Wudhu (when water is taken into the nose) because it is closer and in higher quantity.​
Not a Scholar but as an ENT Surgeon, the probability of a fast breaking from ear drops is almost nil.

This is me, trying to understand what he (ENT surgeon) is saying...

eustachian-tube.jpg


image-of-the-nasopharynx.jpg


This is pretty much what Dr Rafaqat Rashid has also written on Page 18 that ear drops do not break the fast.





In an ENT scenario, an ear bud is an ear plug and not sure what is the connection with fasting? Please explain and can you post a picture of what you are referring to? And I will ask him? I would like to understand this myself.

Do you mean in the classical Hanafi text, ear drops did break the fast? If that's what you mean then agreed.
Like I said I am not an Islamic expert. But as a physician, like I said, in conditions, adding too much drops does lead to its absorption into the nasopharynx. But like I said, I do not know whether that would break the fast or not. No religious expert, just trying to learn more.
 
Ear drops in a non-performed ear drum can pass into the throat? Can you please give me some studies on this as I would like to read up on it, because most professionals say the opposite (page 18)

Nasopharynx technically which is above the throat. It usually happens with perforated ear drum, but eustachian tube in the middle ear drains into nasopharynx. Patients with complicated otitis media may have tympanostomy tubes in place in their ear or wick procedure (tube) inserted in their ear that takes the antibiotics into the middle ear.
Bro I never said non perforated ear drum.
Ear drops aren't an OTC stuff that people routinely do, obviously only people with external, middle or inner ear infections (generally speaking) use ear meds.
 
Nasopharynx technically which is above the throat. It usually happens with perforated ear drum, but eustachian tube in the middle ear drains into nasopharynx. Patients with complicated otitis media may have tympanostomy tubes in place in their ear or wick procedure (tube) inserted in their ear that takes the antibiotics into the middle ear.
Bro I never said non perforated ear drum.
Ear drops aren't an OTC stuff that people routinely do, obviously only people with external, middle or inner ear infections (generally speaking) use ear meds.
That's exactly why I am interested in your opinion, appreciate the time and the explanation :)

What is your opinion on page 18 which the Doctor is explaining? and that's pretty much what I got from the ENT Surgeon even on a perforated ear drum.
 
That's exactly why I am interested in your opinion, appreciate the time and the explanation :)

What is your opinion on page 18 which the Doctor is explaining? and that's pretty much what I got from the ENT Surgeon even on a perforated ear drum.
Yes I agree with that. I did not know about the rulings regarding invalidation of fast. I used to hear that even performing wuzu you should try not to swallow any drop of water or the fast could be invalidated.
 
Yes I agree with that. I did not know about the rulings regarding invalidation of fast. I used to hear that even performing wuzu you should try not to swallow any drop of water or the fast could be invalidated.​
It seems that the scholars are distinguishing between two different scenarios. In the case of gargling or performing wuḍūʾ, there is a direct and immediate pathway for water to enter the throat, which makes the possibility of ingestion more apparent and foreseeable.

By contrast, with ear drops, any potential reaching of the throat would only occur in highly unusual circumstances such as a significant perforation of the eardrum and even then, the possibility of the liquid reaching the throat (as opposed to merely the nasopharynx) would be remote.

Additionally, intention appears to play a role. When someone uses ear drops, they are not intending to ingest anything. If, due to an anatomical abnormality, a trace amount were to reach the throat, it would be unintended and incidental rather than deliberate. This distinction between direct intake and an unintended, highly unlikely occurrence may be what underlies the scholars’ differentiation.

50+ years ago probably, the unanimous position was that this would break the fast. Pakistani Hanafi Scholars are pretty much united on this opinion while Indian scholars differ and still rely on classical opinion.

Scholars from Pakistan (specifically Karachi) do a lot of contemporary research and have consultants from different fields so rulings get revised and this doesn't go against anything specific to Qur'aan and Sunnah so Ijtehad can be done.

Always a pleasure learning from you.

 

The Medical Fiqh of Fasting: Applied Fiqh for Medical Care​



Can Type 1 Diabetics Fast in Ramadan?​



Fasting During Pregnancy and Breastfeeding​



When Is Fasting Haram? Islamic Rulings on Medical Conditions​



@BunnyRabbit
 
Discussion with an ENT Surgeon:

Just spoke to him.


  1. In a non-perforated ear drum, there is no chance of ear drops going anywhere.​
  2. In a perforated ear drum, even if you put a lot of drops they hardly reach the nasopharynx and even if they did it is anatomically above the throat . There is a greater chance of water reaching the nasopharnyx during Wudhu (when water is taken into the nose) because it is closer and in higher quantity.​
Not a Scholar but as an ENT Surgeon, the probability of a fast breaking from ear drops is almost nil.

This is me, trying to understand what he (ENT surgeon) is saying...

eustachian-tube.jpg


image-of-the-nasopharynx.jpg


This is pretty much what Dr Rafaqat Rashid has also written on Page 18 that ear drops do not break the fast.





In an ENT scenario, an ear bud is an ear plug and not sure what is the connection with fasting? Please explain and can you post a picture of what you are referring to? And I will ask him? I would like to understand this myself.

Do you mean in the classical Hanafi text, ear drops did break the fast? If that's what you mean then agreed.
Yes , the contemporary hanafi opinion has changed on this exactly as you mentioned due to major consensus ,ijtihad/ijma etc
 
Yes , the contemporary hanafi opinion has changed on this exactly as you mentioned due to major consensus ,ijtihad/ijma etc
Not on Buds but on Ear drops.

I am not sure what you mean by Ear Buds that they break fast
 
Apology and Forgiveness

During the month of Ramadhan, I would like to apologize and seek forgiveness from @Hitman @Champ_Pal @Major @RizwanT20Champ @rpant_gabba @Bhaag Viru Bhaag @uppercut @RexRex and/or anyone else whom I may have inadvertently insulted based on color, creed, nationality, religion or anything else.

It is never been intention to insult anyone and always my intention to have a dialogue and it is not possible to do so politely sometimes.

The failure is all mine and I seek your forgiveness.

 
Apology and Forgiveness

During the month of Ramadhan, I would like to apologize and seek forgiveness from @Hitman @Champ_Pal @Major @RizwanT20Champ @rpant_gabba @Bhaag Viru Bhaag @uppercut @RexRex and/or anyone else whom I may have inadvertently insulted based on color, creed, nationality, religion or anything else.

It is never been intention to insult anyone and always my intention to have a dialogue and it is not possible to do so politely sometimes.

The failure is all mine and I seek your forgiveness.

Bro, Nothing in our interactions warrants a apology from you.

Cheers. Hope you have a wonderful Ramadhan experience this year.
 
Apology and Forgiveness

During the month of Ramadhan, I would like to apologize and seek forgiveness from @Hitman @Champ_Pal @Major @RizwanT20Champ @rpant_gabba @Bhaag Viru Bhaag @uppercut @RexRex and/or anyone else whom I may have inadvertently insulted based on color, creed, nationality, religion or anything else.

It is never been intention to insult anyone and always my intention to have a dialogue and it is not possible to do so politely sometimes.

The failure is all mine and I seek your forgiveness.

Brother, full respect for you. No bad intentions especially in the holy month. I seek forgiveness if I inadvertently hurt you as well.
 
Back
Top