What if it was India instead of Iran?

[Rafale Nidhal Fan]

Iran allowed two indian tankers to pass through the strait even after India stood silent and let US take out Iran navy crew who had come to India for a joint navy exercise.

Lets switch the roles for a bit.

Had India done the same and shown mercy to Iran if Iran had let Pakistan down Indian navy boat??

We all should be honest here, it's a big no.

I have seen so many posters bring religion in things that are not even linked to religion but what Iran did is a great example of humanity.
I for one cannot even thing something like this from an extremist bjp led indian government. And of course one should also add, they will ask their masters 3 times before taking any steps.

 

[The Bald Eagle]

Iran allowed two indian tankers to pass through the strait even after India stood silent and let US take out Iran navy crew who had come to India for a joint navy exercise.

Lets switch the roles for a bit.

Had India done the same and shown mercy to Iran if Iran had let Pakistan down Indian navy boat??

We all should be honest here, it's a big no.

I have seen so many posters bring religion in things that are not even linked to religion but what Iran did is a great example of humanity.
I for one cannot even thing something like this from an extremist bjp led indian government. And of course one should also add, they will ask their masters 3 times before taking any steps.

They don't even have the gall to stand before a bigger enemy. And it's not an ad lib comment but their history. They can't take one any big power on their own.

 

[Devadwal]

Hahaha Pakistan ki itni himmat ni hai ki indian Navy ko kuch kare. end of thread..

 

[Local.Dada]

Iran allowed two indian tankers to pass through the strait even after India stood silent and let US take out Iran navy crew who had come to India for a joint navy exercise.

so Iran has pride to take on USA and not back down but you believe Pak media that India backstabbed Iran and the whole world knows about it but Iran still favors India?

Your first thought should be did this did really happen lol instead of over complicating for yourself .

India is partners with both Iran and Israel. We are not bound by any religious sentiments like Pak for which Israel is a big no-no. You understand that, everything will fall in place.

 

[sweep_shot]

Indians probably would have cried about it for 50 years.

Bhakts are sore losers. Petty people.

 

[Rafale Nidhal Fan]

so Iran has pride to take on USA and not back down but you believe Pak media that India backstabbed Iran and the whole world knows about it but Iran still favors India?

Your first thought should be did this did really happen lol instead of over complicating for yourself .

India is partners with both Iran and Israel. We are not bound by any religious sentiments like Pak for which Israel is a big no-no. You understand that, everything will fall in place.

Al Jazeera, BBC aren't Pakistan media

And thread is about "What If"

India isn't a partner of Iran when its laying down for Israel.

The idea of this thread came from how india media were crying like little kids over the peace talks held by Pakistan to the point US Consulate members had to call them out for this childish behavior.

 

[Sachin fan]

Al Jazeera, BBC aren't Pakistan media

And thread is about "What If"

India isn't a partner of Iran when its laying down for Israel.

The idea of this thread came from how india media were crying like little kids over the peace talks held by Pakistan to the point US Consulate members had to call them out for this childish behavior.

So wait, another country chose not to mess with india and you are somehow painting it as India's weakness?

Lmao, the mental gymnastics of you guys.

Any country will be proud to be in a position where others are not messing with them but they can mess back.

 

[Bhaijaan]

It appears that India is following the Chinese script word to word at being a silent background player. They are not seeking to be in the limelight and beign looked at as a heroic nation but one that has deep industrial and people to people relations with all important nations.

 

[Local.Dada]

Al Jazeera, BBC aren't Pakistan media

And thread is about "What If"

India isn't a partner of Iran when its laying down for Israel.

The idea of this thread came from how india media were crying like little kids over the peace talks held by Pakistan to the point US Consulate members had to call them out for this childish behavior.

What did they say? India attacked and backstabbed Iran? I don’t think so but Ok.

They also said (they have no choice because it’s a fact) that Iran has been allowing Indian ships safely with 0 issues.

There is no “what if” here. You seem to be finding it hard to grasp that it is very much possible in diplomacy to be friends with both sides that are fighting- Iran and Israel in this case .

Only thing here is some Indian public sentiment is with Iran. Some love Israel. Most don’t like USA (it’s just a subcontinent thing. Every wants to migrate to USA but everyone also thinks it’s a big bad wolf). That doesn’t always reflect Indian govt diplomatic policy. So next time I would suggest not to get triggered by random social media posts, study the facts and form a full fledged opinion.

 

[Rafale Nidhal Fan]

What did they say? India attacked and backstabbed Iran? I don’t think so but Ok.

They also said (they have no choice because it’s a fact) that Iran has been allowing Indian ships safely with 0 issues.

There is no “what if” here. You seem to be finding it hard to grasp that it is very much possible in diplomacy to be friends with both sides that are fighting- Iran and Israel in this case .

Only thing here is some Indian public sentiment is with Iran. Some love Israel. Most don’t like USA (it’s just a subcontinent thing. Every wants to migrate to USA but everyone also thinks it’s a big bad wolf). That doesn’t always reflect Indian govt diplomatic policy. So next time I would suggest not to get triggered by random social media posts, study the facts and form a full fledged opinion.

are you stupid? or did you graduate from the same institutes indian media do.

read the OP again if you have problem reading english, DM me

 

[Local.Dada]

are you stupid? or did you graduate from the same institutes indian media do.

read the OP again if you have problem reading english, DM me

Don’t need to reach a bunch of gas (no pun intended) twice.

You are saying Iran let ships containing gas through for India despite India backstabbing Iran: your premise itself is wrong.

That makes your “what if” null and void.

Maybe your mastery of English language isn’t helping you to read and comprehend diplomacy and world events.

 

[Rafale Nidhal Fan]

Don’t need to reach a bunch of gas (no pun intended) twice.

You are saying Iran let ships containing gas through for India despite India backstabbing Iran: your premise itself is wrong.

That makes your “what if” null and void.

Maybe your mastery of English language isn’t helping you to read and comprehend diplomacy and world events.

india let US attack iran ship on their waters so yeah they did backstab iran like the little cowards they are. US can come and urinate in indian mouths and your government won't do anything and accept it.

 

[Local.Dada]

india let US attack iran ship on their waters so yeah they did backstab iran like the little cowards they are. US can come and urinate in indian mouths and your government won't do anything and accept it.

How come India has had the least minimal impact then? Not a single ship has been blocked. Sure delays and inconvenience happens in such a sensitive time. India didn’t let anything like that happen. It’s a chooran sold to you and clearly seems to be working well . Iran clearly knows it and understands. There ends the matter. Why are you so blind to see that?

 

[Cpt. Rishwat]

What did they say? India attacked and backstabbed Iran? I don’t think so but Ok.

They also said (they have no choice because it’s a fact) that Iran has been allowing Indian ships safely with 0 issues.

There is no “what if” here. You seem to be finding it hard to grasp that it is very much possible in diplomacy to be friends with both sides that are fighting- Iran and Israel in this case .

Only thing here is some Indian public sentiment is with Iran. Some love Israel. Most don’t like USA (it’s just a subcontinent thing. Every wants to migrate to USA but everyone also thinks it’s a big bad wolf). That doesn’t always reflect Indian govt diplomatic policy. So next time I would suggest not to get triggered by random social media posts, study the facts and form a full fledged opinion.

I don't see much Indian sentiment with Iran on these boards. Modi dancing for phaadarland didn't exactly give off those vibes either.

 

[Local.Dada]

I don't see much Indian sentiment with Iran on these boards. Modi dancing for phaadarland didn't exactly give off those vibes either.

I don’t think so, You barely venture out of PP and I have never seen you given an opinion that looks well researched or a thought that looks like it is fully formed.

Having said that, India is a democracy, there is 1. A strong enough opposition to BJP 2. India Have a few million Shias and a lot more Muslims sympathetic towards Iran 3. Not every Hindu is automatically pro- Israel 4. Not every Hindu automatically votes for BJP. 5. The demographics are way too diverse and complex than just classifying everyone to BJP- Non- BJP/ Hindu- Muslim.

All those pointers are not some complicated scientific study, just common sense but then again…… will leave it there.

 

[Cpt. Rishwat]

I don’t think so, You barely venture out of PP and I have never seen you given an opinion that looks well researched or a thought that looks like it is fully formed.

Having said that, India is a democracy, there is 1. A strong enough opposition to BJP 2. India Have a few million Shias and a lot more Muslims sympathetic towards Iran 3. Not every Hindu is automatically pro- Israel 4. Not every Hindu automatically votes for BJP. 5. The demographics are way too diverse and complex than just classifying everyone to BJP- Non- BJP/ Hindu- Muslim.

All those pointers are not some complicated scientific study, just common sense but then again…… will leave it there.

I specifically said these boards. Maybe read properly before going off into what then becomes meaningless waffle.

 

[Local.Dada]

I specifically said these boards. Maybe read properly before going off into what then becomes meaningless waffle.

“These boards” reflect an entire diplomatic manifesto of a country or the uniform sentiments of 1.4b people , what are you even trying to say lmao.

 

[Cpt. Rishwat]

“These boards” reflect an entire diplomatic manifesto of a country or the uniform sentiments of 1.4b people , what are you even trying to say lmao.

I don't live in India so my interaction with Indians is mostly these boards. Is that simple enough for you?

 

[Local.Dada]

I don't live in India so my interaction with Indians is mostly these boards. Is that simple enough for you?

but you seem to spend enough time on the corners of the internet to scrounge for random Indian news or super enthusiastic to discuss India all the time. So by default I would have expected at least some level of growth but I guess it is what it is

 

[Cpt. Rishwat]

but you seem to spend enough time on the corners of the internet to scrounge for random Indian news or super enthusiastic to discuss India all the time. So by default I would have expected at least some level of growth but I guess it is what it is

The Indian public voted in a hindutva party on the back of the slaughter of a Muslim community in Gujarat. I would say the Indian posters here are a fair reflection of that, or at least the Hindu vote base.

 

[Local.Dada]

The Indian public voted in a hindutva party on the back of the slaughter of a Muslim community in Gujarat. I would say the Indian posters here are a fair reflection of that, or at least the Hindu vote base.

Wrong again, Gujarat riots happened in 2002, Modi got elected in 2014. There were 2 election cycles in between where BJP lost and lost badly. Even today a lot of significant states in India have a non- BJP govt. even in the last 12 yrs since BJP govt, they lost in some states and won in some states based on their performance. It’s like dejavu as all these have been explained to you multiple times by various people . However your intent as I said is to ragebait or copy paste something that looks offensive and will get a raise out of people. Dont think you actually comprehend or listen/read answers to your own questions. Maybe in Bradford you vote randomly as a block without thinking though for a Muslim candidate and being Pak origin maybe you don’t understand how democracy works, fair game but don’t pass of rhetoric as some factual argument

 

[The Bald Eagle]

Guys, please stick to the thread topic

 

[emranabbas]

Point everyone keeps missing is india is buying Iranian oil since the war started the reason indian tankers are passing through its not because Iranians loves india. If india stops buying Iranian oil no indian tankers will pass through

Iran needs indian money so they can fight the war with israel every country should buy Iranian oil if possible to support iran against israel and usa.

India turns to Iran for oil and gas after 7-year hiatus, signaling limits to U.S. tilt

India has resumed oil and gas imports from Iran after seven years, in a bid to rebalance its ties with Tehran and secure supplies through the Strait of Hormuz.

www.cnbc.com

 

[Cpt. Rishwat]

Wrong again, Gujarat riots happened in 2002, Modi got elected in 2014. There were 2 election cycles in between where BJP lost and lost badly. Even today a lot of significant states in India have a non- BJP govt. even in the last 12 yrs since BJP govt, they lost in some states and won in some states based on their performance. It’s like dejavu as all these have been explained to you multiple times by various people . However your intent as I said is to ragebait or copy paste something that looks offensive and will get a raise out of people. Dont think you actually comprehend or listen/read answers to your own questions. Maybe in Bradford you vote randomly as a block without thinking though for a Muslim candidate and being Pak origin maybe you don’t understand how democracy works, fair game but don’t pass of rhetoric as some factual argument

It's hardly worth responding to you in all honesty, I try to ignore your petty jibes about Bradford, or scouring internet for anti-India stuff because it's not relevant to what I am discussing. Otherwise I would also respond with 100 word essays focusing on the rage and fury evident in your posts.

Point is, for all the different religions and politics in your different states, a hindutva diehard continues to get elected in India and his ministers often fuel the ethnic strife in India with their remarks.

 

[straighttalk]

Iran allowed two indian tankers to pass through the strait even after India stood silent and let US take out Iran navy crew who had come to India for a joint navy exercise.

Lets switch the roles for a bit.

Had India done the same and shown mercy to Iran if Iran had let Pakistan down Indian navy boat??

We all should be honest here, it's a big no.

I have seen so many posters bring religion in things that are not even linked to religion but what Iran did is a great example of humanity.
I for one cannot even thing something like this from an extremist bjp led indian government. And of course one should also add, they will ask their masters 3 times before taking any steps.

That's because you lie and make false assertions in this short post

Lie no 1 is India allowed us to sink the boat. It happened outside India's water. India didn't provide any intelligence ... It was a bad precedent but not India's fault.

Second India provided shelter to the second Iranian ship.

Lastly a Pakistani talking. About masters after being. The slave of USA and China is bit rich... We just don't know whether you guys are more hypocrites or beggars

 

[Local.Dada]

It's hardly worth responding to you in all honesty, I try to ignore your petty jibes about Bradford, or scouring internet for anti-India stuff because it's not relevant to what I am discussing. Otherwise I would also respond with 100 word essays focusing on the rage and fury evident in your posts.

Point is, for all the different religions and politics in your different states, a hindutva diehard continues to get elected in India and his ministers often fuel the ethnic strife in India with their remarks.

Feel free to. Better than repeating the same nonsense. you should blurt all your emotions at once and get it over with , so we can address the root cause of the issue.

Well as far as your sensitive feelings, maybe stay away from gaslighting in every other post if you are that touchy.

 

[Cpt. Rishwat]

Feel free to. Better than repeating the same nonsense. you should blurt all your emotions at once and get it over with , so we can address the root cause of the issue.

Well as far as your sensitive feelings, maybe stay away from gaslighting in every other post if you are that touchy.

Root cause of what issue? Do you even recall what this topic was about?

 

[Local.Dada]

Root cause of what issue? Do you even recall what this topic was about?

My views on the topic have already been addressed above.

 

[Cpt. Rishwat]

My views on the topic have already been addressed above.

I think they got derailed because you got angry that I questioned Indian sentiment with Iran/israel.

 

[Local.Dada]

I think they got derailed because you got angry that I questioned Indian sentiment with Iran/israel.

That is correct and your reference point to that was posts on Pak passion .

 

[Cpt. Rishwat]

That is correct and your reference point to that was posts on Pak passion .

And your hindutva govt.

 

[Local.Dada]

And your hindutva govt.

Which seems to have great relationship with Iran and Middle East. So that ends the matter.

 

[Cpt. Rishwat]

Which seems to have great relationship with Iran and Middle East. So that ends the matter.

Just goes to show, even the most supposedly hardline Islamic countries are quite adept at dealing with international politics.

 

[RizwanT20Champ]

If it was Ind instead of Iran we would have seen @Rajdeep and @Devadwal doing bhangra because they would have willingly given up everything given their docile personalities.