What is the Meaning of Ahl-e-Bait?

[TalentSpotterPk]

1. Javed Ahmad Ghamdi sahib

2. Mufti Mohammad Ashraf Qadri sahib

3. " AhleBait by Maulana Tariq Jameel " sahib (Youtube)




[MENTION=139075]Hadi Rizvi[/MENTION] please watch these videos all having different POV of who is to be Counted as Ahl e Bait. You were claiming that the whole Islamic World has Consensus over this that only Fatima RA, Hassan RA, Hussain RA & Ali RA are Ahl e Bait.




Once you watch these and many other videos with difference of opinion tham you kindly educate me that does Allah have different paramaters to count Ahl e Bait wrt different Prophets or His boundaries and principles are uniform for all his Prophets ?




Note: Don't tell me that Ghamdi, TJ or Ashraf Qadri sahibeen haven't yet read 33:33 of the Holy Quran.

 

[Justcrazy]

Ahle bait basically means people of the house.

Even salman Farsi RA was called ahle bait.

There are levels in ahle bait. The highest is those five who were under the cloak of the prophet , they were the ones taken to Mubahila by the prophet as well.

Wives are also ahle bait , but not to the same level as those under the cloak.

 

[TalentSpotterPk]

Ahle bait basically means people of the house.

Even salman Farsi RA was called ahle bait.

There are levels in ahle bait. The highest is those five who were under the cloak of the prophet , they were the ones taken to Mubahila by the prophet as well.

Wives are also ahle bait , but not to the same level as those under the cloak.

Thank You for this. Alhamdoulillah.


I haven't started about Ahl e Bait of other Prophets from.Quran.


Hazrat Salman as a devout follower was named Ahl e Bait for a message to be umderstood that there are Spiritual Ahl e Bait too. It's not just blood.


And No. I don't agree with Cloak. All Wives are amongst Ahl e Bait so are all the kids.


And who are Ahl e Bait ? There is no universal consensus on this in even the 3 scholars I referred. There are many Difference of Opinions amongst all.


Panjtan is a Shia Muslim concept. It cannot be substantiated from Holy Quran..


If there are any narrations they are as Good as Ayesha RA narrations of being 6 or 9 at time of marriage which can be proven wrong from same Saha e Satta other narrations.

 

[Justcrazy]

Thank You for this. Alhamdoulillah.


I haven't started about Ahl e Bait of other Prophets from.Quran.


Hazrat Salman as a devout follower was named Ahl e Bait for a message to be umderstood that there are Spiritual Ahl e Bait too. It's not just blood.


And No. I don't agree with Cloak. All Wives are amongst Ahl e Bait so are all the kids.


And who are Ahl e Bait ? There is no universal consensus on this in even the 3 scholars I referred. There are many Difference of Opinions amongst all.


Panjtan is a Shia Muslim concept. It cannot be substantiated from Holy Quran..


If there are any narrations they are as Good as Ayesha RA narrations of being 6 or 9 at time of marriage which can be proven wrong from same Saha e Satta other narrations.

What do you mean by I do not agree with cloak hadeeth ? Prophet himself explains one verse with his action , no matter what scholar says , interpretation of prophet will be taken. It is from Muslim.

Also look at the ayat e Mubahila , what are the words there .

 

[TalentSpotterPk]

What do you mean by I do not agree with cloak hadeeth ? Prophet himself explains one verse with his action , no matter what scholar says , interpretation of prophet will be taken. It is from Muslim.

Also look at the ayat e Mubahila , what are the words there .

If you believe in Allah being Consistent in his principles, ordains, definitions for Prophets not differenciating amingst them and not having Bias than first come to Holy Quran and discuss Ahl e Bait of other Prophets.

In Islam superiority is only limited to Righteousness, Virtues and Deeds. Blood only commands Respect due to Love & Honour.


Allah does not differenciate amongst his Creatures.


Any Hadith which does not fall in Line with Quranic injunctions cannot be preferred over Quran. Since Quran duscusses only Ahl e Bait so domain remains there strictly.


Hazur Pbuh did not say these things infront of our face so critical analysis of these narrations is needed.


Because of these Billion disagreements there was a Need for Hakam o Adal to teach Divine interpretations. This is why Allah revealed (7:35)

 

[Justcrazy]

If you believe in Allah being Consistent in his principles, ordains, definitions for Prophets not differenciating amingst them and not having Bias than first come to Holy Quran and discuss Ahl e Bait of other Prophets.

In Islam superiority is only limited to Righteousness, Virtues and Deeds. Blood only commands Respect due to Love & Honour.


Allah does not differenciate amongst his Creatures.


Any Hadith which does not fall in Line with Quranic injunctions cannot be preferred over Quran. Since Quran duscusses only Ahl e Bait so domain remains there strictly.


Hazur Pbuh did not say these things infront of our face so critical analysis of these narrations is needed.


Because of these Billion disagreements there was a Need for Hakam o Adal to teach Divine interpretations. This is why Allah revealed (7:35)

The Quran was also transmitted to us from the same people who transmitted Hadeeths.

Moreover the superiority of ahle bait , that is Ali RA , fatima RA , hassan RA and Hussain RA is not because of there blood , but because of deeds also.

have you read the ayat of Mubahila ? It was revealed to Muhammad SAW , he knew what it meant and he took the people that fit the ayat.