What's new

Who is the best captain in the 2019 World Cup?

Who is the best captain in the 2019 World Cup?


  • Total voters
    110

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
218,054
Ten teams will compete in the much-anticipated ICC Men's Cricket World Cup 2019 in England and Wales, starting on 30 May, and each will depend a lot on their captains.

Out of the 10, three captains – Eoin Morgan, Jason Holder and Mashrafe Mortaza – have led their side in the previous edition, while the other seven are set to make their World Cup captaincy debuts. We take a look at their past records in charge in ODIs, and how they can influence their respective sides.


Afghanistan – Gulbadin Naib

Not only will Gulbadin Naib be making his World Cup debut as captain, but he is also set to lead in an international game for the first time. Naib was recently named the new Afghanistan ODI captain, taking over from Asghar Afghan, as the Afghanistan Cricket Board adopted a split captaincy system, featuring a different leader for each of the three formats. With no past leadership experience, how Naib fares in his new role remains to be seen. His credentials as a player: 807 runs in 52 ODIs to go alongside 40 wickets.


Australia – Aaron Finch

Under Aaron Finch, Australia have won last eight ODIs – three against India and five against Pakistan
In October 2018, Aaron Finch was named Australia's ODI captain. He has since led the side in 18 ODIs and won 10 of them, for a win percentage of almost 56. Barring one against South Africa, all those wins have come this year. Finch struggled with the bat for a good chunk of his captaincy period, before regaining form in the series against Pakistan in March, when he scored two centuries and as many fifties.


Bangladesh – Mashrafe Mortaza

One of the most experienced members of the side, Mashrafe Mortaza will be leading Bangladesh for the second time at the World Cup. Under his leadership in the 2015 edition, the team finished fourth in Group A, above England, Afghanistan and Scotland, before losing in the quarter-final to India. That had been Bangladesh's first entry into the knockouts of a World Cup, and it arrived via a nervy, famous 15-run win over England. Mortaza has been a successful captain for Bangladesh, winning 40 of the 73 games he has led in.


England – Eoin Morgan

Eoin Morgan has been at the helm, overseeing England's remarkable transformation into a formidable one-day outfit, since their heartbreaking exit in the group stage at the 2015 edition. Under Morgan's leadership, England have ascended to the top of the pile and are currently No.1 in the MRF Tyres ICC Men's ODI Team Rankings. They head into this year's tournament as one of the favourites, and are eyeing their maiden World Cup crown, at home. Morgan is captaining what is arguably the strongest England team to ever compete in a World Cup. Since that 2015 exit, Morgan has led England to 50 wins in 76 ODIs.


India – Virat Kohli

As is the case with Morgan, Virat Kohli carries extra baggage as captain of one of the favourites to win the tournament. Kohli's leadership has developed with time, and he arrives at the tournament with a staggering win percentage of 73.88 in ODIs. Out of the 68 games India have played under Kohli, they have won 49. Kohli has past experience of leading at a world event, having captained India during their run to the final of the ICC Champions Trophy 2017, which they lost to Pakistan at Lord's. He is now set to lead in his maiden World Cup, and will be one of the most-watched players.


New Zealand – Kane Williamson

The current New Zealand skipper was part of the team that finished as runners-up in 2015, after making the final for the first time. While Williamson grew under the then captain Brendon McCullum, he brings a vastly different approach to the captaincy himself. Calm and composed, Williamson brings laser-sharp focus and unquestionable intent, both to his batting and to his captaincy. Williamson will be the lynchpin of the New Zealand line-up, as its most successful batsman. Concurrently, he has also enjoyed success as a leader, boasting a win percentage of 53.96.


Pakistan – Sarfaraz Ahmed

The captain during their run to the ICC Champions Trophy title in 2017, Sarfaraz Ahmed will look to lead Pakistan to the World Cup trophy at the same site of their Champions Trophy triumph. He certainly possesses the track record to make it happen, having won 21 out of the 35 ODIs he has captained in, for a win percentage of 61.76. Sarfaraz will play several important roles for Pakistan during the World Cup, as captain, as a middle-order batsman, and as a wicket-keeper.


South Africa – Faf du Plessis

Easily the most successful captain on this list, Faf du Plessis has enjoyed terrific success as leader: out of the 30 ODIs in which he has captained, South Africa have lost only five, translating to a brilliant win percentage of 83.33. Since the start of 2018, South Africa have lost only one bilateral series, and have won five. A stylish middle-order batsman, du Plessis averages 46.54 in ODIs, making him a vital top-order asset. However, he is also flexible enough to be used in the lower middle-order.


Sri Lanka – Dimuth Karunaratne

Sri Lanka will be without the services of some of their more regular and experienced players, including Niroshan Dickwella, Dinesh Chandimal, Upul Tharanga and Akila Dananjaya. Dimuth Karunaratne, who last played an ODI in March 2015, at the previous World Cup, was named captain for this year's tournament. He recently led his side to a historic 2-0 sweep of South Africa earlier this year - Sri Lanka's maiden Test series win in the country – but is yet to make his captaincy debut in ODIs. Karunaratne has some way to go as a batsman – he's got the technique and knows how to score runs, but has only 190 runs from 17 games, at an average of under 16.


West Indies – Jason Holder

West Indies won the first two editions of the World Cup, in 1975 and 1979, and their current captain takes inspiration from the man who led them to those triumphs: Clive Lloyd. Holder recently opened up about his relationship with the West Indies legend and is keen on repeating history this year at Lord's, the venue of the side's last World Cup win. The 27-year-old all-rounder is going to be the youngest captain at this year's tournament, and with a good mix of experience and youth in his side, is focused on repeating history. Although West Indies haven't won a bilateral ODI series since 2014, they recently drew a five-match series against tournament hosts England at home, and will take the confidence from that going into the tournament.

https://www.icc-cricket.com/news/1197696/featured
 
Kane Williamson in my view will prove to be the best - whether his side can help him or not, I am not sure.
 
Jason Holder has evolved himself as a wonderful leader - one of the best in his generation as a leader.

He has ignited another fire in the West Indies camp.
 
1. Mashrafe Mortaza
2.Kane Williamson
3.Jason Holder
4.Sarfraz Ahmed
5.Virat Kohli
6.Aaron finch
7.Eoin Morgan
8.Faf du plesis
9.Dimuth Karuratne
10.Gulbadin Naib
 
Top 3 captains who can outperform other in terms of playing abilities, game awareness and tactics.

1. Eoin Morgan
2. Kane williamson
3. Jason Holder
 
Jason Holder has suddenly become popular here after just one good home series, wasnt talked about much before the Eng series.

I think he has definitely become a better leader than few years ago when he was given captaincy, shows patience is the key to develop players as well as captains especially when selected young. Though I wont say he has become a top leader after just one good series as a captain and a team.

How he goes as captain in the WC and in the next season will be something to look forward to.
 
Morgan, Kohli, Williamson, Faf and Holder are the standouts.
 
Williamson
Morgan
Mortaza

Have consistently shown their leadership quality over last 3,4 years in ODI cricket.
 
Jason Holder has suddenly become popular here after just one good home series, wasnt talked about much before the Eng series.

I think he has definitely become a better leader than few years ago when he was given captaincy, shows patience is the key to develop players as well as captains especially when selected young. Though I wont say he has become a top leader after just one good series as a captain and a team.

How he goes as captain in the WC and in the next season will be something to look forward to.

Not just one home series. He was decent in India too. He gets extra marks for managing WI.
 
Not just one home series. He was decent in India too. He gets extra marks for managing WI.

I agree he is the best WI has gotten after a long time and I also rate him pretty highly due to the very same point you have made regarding managing WI. However, just surprised that he is now suddenly in the top 3 captains of the WC which is in 50 overs format in which WI recently lost a series to BD and he wasnt very good in that series as captain.

Yes has definitely improved and recent Eng series is a proof but I still believe that he needs to show some consistency in ODI cricket atleast to be rated in top 3.

Richard Pybus went under the radar in that Eng series where he was really good as acting head coach of WI and is one of the best cricket brains around. He is also serving as director of cricket for WI for sometime now and we definitely see development. Would have liked him till WC but then he had to go and resume his normal role.
 
I agree he is the best WI has gotten after a long time and I also rate him pretty highly due to the very same point you have made regarding managing WI. However, just surprised that he is now suddenly in the top 3 captains of the WC which is in 50 overs format in which WI recently lost a series to BD and he wasnt very good in that series as captain.

Yes has definitely improved and recent Eng series is a proof but I still believe that he needs to show some consistency in ODI cricket atleast to be rated in top 3.

Richard Pybus went under the radar in that Eng series where he was really good as acting head coach of WI and is one of the best cricket brains around. He is also serving as director of cricket for WI for sometime now and we definitely see development. Would have liked him till WC but then he had to go and resume his normal role.

Apologies, Jason Holder wasnt the captain in the BD series rather Rovman Powell, Holder was out with an injury but I would still wait and see his leadership over the WC and coming season to rate him as a top ODI captain.
 
Last edited:
Kane Williamson is the best captain in world cricket currently.

Here is my order of how I rate all these captains:

1) Kane Williamson
2) Eoin Morgan
3) Sarfraz Ahmed
4) Jason Holder
5) Faf Du Plessis
6) Aaron Finch
7) Virat Kohli
8) Mashrafe Mortaza
9) Dimuth Karunaratne
10) Gulbadin Naib
 
The one who trumped over all in the last world event despite captaining a comparitevely poor team full of newbies.
 
Williamson has some nice tactics at times but I just don't think the NZ squad is good enough to win the WC
 
Really Kohli the captain who lost home series to weak Aius team despite being 2 -0 ahead.

And Sarfaraz is the captain who lost 9 consecutive ODIs against higher ranked teams last year. Kohli is a very good captain and his record speaks for itself.

He is not a tactical genius like Dhoni, but he inspires the team with his individual brilliance and his aggression gets the best out of his bowlers.
 
And Sarfaraz is the captain who lost 9 consecutive ODIs against higher ranked teams last year. Kohli is a very good captain and his record speaks for itself.
.

Not to mention the tactical blunders over the years; bowling Fakhar + Shadab to Pandya when we could have bowled them out for less than a 100, not going for the kill when Bangladesh was 12-3.
 
Rohit Sharma will make the best captain across all teams. His bowling changes and field placements are unmatched and create a lot of pressure on opposition. Refer Asia cup
 
Best captains on field
Sarfraz Ahmed
Faf Du Plesis
Kane Williamson

Best Leaders
Jason Holder
Mashrafe Murtaza
Virat Kohli
 
MSD will be India's default captain in the world cup

Dhoni will set fields and guide spinners. Seamers and batters and will do their own things. Kaptaan will make a lot noise on field. And facial expressions.
 
Williamson is a better test captain. Bax was a better captain in ODIs. Holder is the best followed by Morgan/Mashrafe.
 
Dhoni will set fields and guide spinners. Seamers and batters and will do their own things. Kaptaan will make a lot noise on field. And facial expressions.

And then will go and field at long off during the final overs :))
 
Aaron Finch, Kane Williamson and Jason Holder are the top 3 captains going into this world cup.

If i had to pick one right now, it would be Finch.
 
Williamson, Morgan, and Faf.

Kohli is not even the best captain in his own team. Dhoni and Sharma are far better captains.

Sarfraz does not make the team on merit, he should not be on this list.
 
D5Af77NWkAIASfg.png:large


So which one of these is capable of leading their team to win the World Cup?|
 
It has to be Sarfraz Ahmed for me, he gets the nod purely on his fitness and diet alone
 
Ten teams will compete in the much-anticipated ICC Men's Cricket World Cup 2019 in England and Wales, starting on 30 May, and each will depend a lot on their captains.

Out of the 10, three captains – Eoin Morgan, Jason Holder and Mashrafe Mortaza – have led their side in the previous edition, while the other seven are set to make their World Cup captaincy debuts. We take a look at their past records in charge in ODIs, and how they can influence their respective sides.


Afghanistan – Gulbadin Naib

Not only will Gulbadin Naib be making his World Cup debut as captain, but he is also set to lead in an international game for the first time. Naib was recently named the new Afghanistan ODI captain, taking over from Asghar Afghan, as the Afghanistan Cricket Board adopted a split captaincy system, featuring a different leader for each of the three formats. With no past leadership experience, how Naib fares in his new role remains to be seen. His credentials as a player: 807 runs in 52 ODIs to go alongside 40 wickets.


Australia – Aaron Finch

Under Aaron Finch, Australia have won last eight ODIs – three against India and five against Pakistan
In October 2018, Aaron Finch was named Australia's ODI captain. He has since led the side in 18 ODIs and won 10 of them, for a win percentage of almost 56. Barring one against South Africa, all those wins have come this year. Finch struggled with the bat for a good chunk of his captaincy period, before regaining form in the series against Pakistan in March, when he scored two centuries and as many fifties.


Bangladesh – Mashrafe Mortaza

One of the most experienced members of the side, Mashrafe Mortaza will be leading Bangladesh for the second time at the World Cup. Under his leadership in the 2015 edition, the team finished fourth in Group A, above England, Afghanistan and Scotland, before losing in the quarter-final to India. That had been Bangladesh's first entry into the knockouts of a World Cup, and it arrived via a nervy, famous 15-run win over England. Mortaza has been a successful captain for Bangladesh, winning 40 of the 73 games he has led in.


England – Eoin Morgan

Eoin Morgan has been at the helm, overseeing England's remarkable transformation into a formidable one-day outfit, since their heartbreaking exit in the group stage at the 2015 edition. Under Morgan's leadership, England have ascended to the top of the pile and are currently No.1 in the MRF Tyres ICC Men's ODI Team Rankings. They head into this year's tournament as one of the favourites, and are eyeing their maiden World Cup crown, at home. Morgan is captaining what is arguably the strongest England team to ever compete in a World Cup. Since that 2015 exit, Morgan has led England to 50 wins in 76 ODIs.


India – Virat Kohli

As is the case with Morgan, Virat Kohli carries extra baggage as captain of one of the favourites to win the tournament. Kohli's leadership has developed with time, and he arrives at the tournament with a staggering win percentage of 73.88 in ODIs. Out of the 68 games India have played under Kohli, they have won 49. Kohli has past experience of leading at a world event, having captained India during their run to the final of the ICC Champions Trophy 2017, which they lost to Pakistan at Lord's. He is now set to lead in his maiden World Cup, and will be one of the most-watched players.


New Zealand – Kane Williamson

The current New Zealand skipper was part of the team that finished as runners-up in 2015, after making the final for the first time. While Williamson grew under the then captain Brendon McCullum, he brings a vastly different approach to the captaincy himself. Calm and composed, Williamson brings laser-sharp focus and unquestionable intent, both to his batting and to his captaincy. Williamson will be the lynchpin of the New Zealand line-up, as its most successful batsman. Concurrently, he has also enjoyed success as a leader, boasting a win percentage of 53.96.


Pakistan – Sarfaraz Ahmed

The captain during their run to the ICC Champions Trophy title in 2017, Sarfaraz Ahmed will look to lead Pakistan to the World Cup trophy at the same site of their Champions Trophy triumph. He certainly possesses the track record to make it happen, having won 21 out of the 35 ODIs he has captained in, for a win percentage of 61.76. Sarfaraz will play several important roles for Pakistan during the World Cup, as captain, as a middle-order batsman, and as a wicket-keeper.


South Africa – Faf du Plessis

Easily the most successful captain on this list, Faf du Plessis has enjoyed terrific success as leader: out of the 30 ODIs in which he has captained, South Africa have lost only five, translating to a brilliant win percentage of 83.33. Since the start of 2018, South Africa have lost only one bilateral series, and have won five. A stylish middle-order batsman, du Plessis averages 46.54 in ODIs, making him a vital top-order asset. However, he is also flexible enough to be used in the lower middle-order.


Sri Lanka – Dimuth Karunaratne

Sri Lanka will be without the services of some of their more regular and experienced players, including Niroshan Dickwella, Dinesh Chandimal, Upul Tharanga and Akila Dananjaya. Dimuth Karunaratne, who last played an ODI in March 2015, at the previous World Cup, was named captain for this year's tournament. He recently led his side to a historic 2-0 sweep of South Africa earlier this year - Sri Lanka's maiden Test series win in the country – but is yet to make his captaincy debut in ODIs. Karunaratne has some way to go as a batsman – he's got the technique and knows how to score runs, but has only 190 runs from 17 games, at an average of under 16.


West Indies – Jason Holder

West Indies won the first two editions of the World Cup, in 1975 and 1979, and their current captain takes inspiration from the man who led them to those triumphs: Clive Lloyd. Holder recently opened up about his relationship with the West Indies legend and is keen on repeating history this year at Lord's, the venue of the side's last World Cup win. The 27-year-old all-rounder is going to be the youngest captain at this year's tournament, and with a good mix of experience and youth in his side, is focused on repeating history. Although West Indies haven't won a bilateral ODI series since 2014, they recently drew a five-match series against tournament hosts England at home, and will take the confidence from that going into the tournament.

https://www.icc-cricket.com/news/1197696/featured

Captain fantastic, he puts the C in Captain this man has this special aura about him as a true leader, the old west indian flame of greatness burns within him. The Caribbean couldn't be more proud.
 
Could've been a bit more neutral here.

No, he is right.

As, I have explained many times - out of the 10 WC teams, (12 actually, you can add ZIM & IRL as well) - EVERY team has a Captain who makes the playing XI on his (or her, if we consider the Ladie's team as well) playing skills - PAK is the only team, whose Captain is their for leadership & on-field Captaincy (which is executed through mouth, by the tools like tongue, vocal cord, lips ....) - Sarfraz has to be the best. And, he is quite selfless as well - often sends bowlers before him to showcase their batting skills.

Though, I am not actually sure what is the criteria of "Best Leader" - if it's about leading from the front with his own game, then Mash over Kohli (& subsequently Williamson, Root/Morgan, FaF, Finch/Smith ...) is quite flattering indeed.
 
On a serious note, Probably the best captain (not player) has to be Mortaza.
-Mortaza is definitely responsible for their turnaround from a superminnow team who even lost to Canada to a decent team, able to push the best to the corner on their day. Great motivator.

Another very good tactician/captain behind the scene in disguise for us has to be DHONI :vk2

But ... the BEST OF THE BEST has to be Safraz LOL. I mean he got 5 votes already, that too without being the best keeper/batsmen.
 
Kane Williamson is the best captain in world cricket currently.

Here is my order of how I rate all these captains:

1) Kane Williamson
2) Eoin Morgan
3) Sarfraz Ahmed
4) Jason Holder
5) Faf Du Plessis
6) Aaron Finch
7) Virat Kohli
8) Mashrafe Mortaza
9) Dimuth Karunaratne
10) Gulbadin Naib

Just wondering why Sarfraz is so high up there?

You do know that we're on a losing streak under him in ODIs and Tests.

Haven't won against any half-decent team since 2 years?

His captaincy has also been mediocre, even if we ignore that he cannot bat.
 
Eoin Morgan is the best captain followed by Williamson. No doubt England have a great team, but Morgan is a calm presence who gets the best out of these players.
 
Eoin Morgan is the best captain followed by Williamson. No doubt England have a great team, but Morgan is a calm presence who gets the best out of these players.

Morgan played a part in selecting these players. He also made the decision to stick with a core group of players for the next 4 years after 2015 WC. Brilliant LO captain.
 
Just wondering why Sarfraz is so high up there?

You do know that we're on a losing streak under him in ODIs and Tests.

Haven't won against any half-decent team since 2 years?

His captaincy has also been mediocre, even if we ignore that he cannot bat.

We are on a 2 match losing streak in ODIs under him, if you meant series then there is some point but even then last time he captained a full series, we drew with New Zealand.

He led the worst team in Champions Trophy to the title victory, by playing with lot of passion and bringing the best out of our team. He always takes a weak Quetta team to the end and won this time around, and it took 3 years for us to lose a T20I series which was also a one off match.

It's my list and not a ICC one, otherwise it would have been in order of rankings of the teams as they would be winning more than the team below them, under their captain.

Just wondering why did you only see Sarfraz up there?

I placed Jason Holder on 4th just below him, whose team didn't play CT, got to WC through qualifiers and hardly wins a series, yet he looks like a good leader who has the potential to take WI forward in coming years.

I placed Virat Kohli very low, even though India is one of the best teams, but still he dosen't look like a good captain tactically and maybe India can play even better under Dhoni or Rohit Sharma.
 
Morgan and Holder. Both get the best out of their players and often peform as skippers too.

Sarfraz and Kohli, too emotional and tactically average.

The rest are ok but nothing special.
 
Kohli is a great batsmen no doubt but as captain is not better than Sarfraz. I personally find them both average in tactics and behaviour.

Morgan and Holder for me, both play hard but fair. You dont see them acting like idiots in front of the watching world every match they play.

Holder for me is the best right now and an inspiring leader, it wouldn't shock me if WI's sneaked into the last 4 they have the batting! But in this tournament, great bowling will be instrumental
 
Holder for me is the best right now and an inspiring leader, it wouldn't shock me if WI's sneaked into the last 4 they have the batting! But in this tournament, great bowling will be instrumental

What I love about the Windies is they show no fear. Even down in the dumps they won 2 T20 cups and recently played brilliantly to beat England in the test series.

If Holder was English or Indian, he would have article after article written about him . I have a lot of friends from the Caribbean , hoping to go with them to see a couple of Windies matches this world cup.A few are much older and remember the times of the great Windies team so they are not used to seeing Windies lose but their banta is is brilliant. If the Windies can get into the Semis, they will be tough to beat for anyone.
 
Sarfraz is just poor at everything.

Kohli is no tactical genius either, but at least he inspires by his performances team India.

CT 17' was Sarfraz's high point but I have a feeling Kohli will eclipse Sarfraz by winning a World Cup, here or 04 years from now.

Sarfraz legacy will be CT' 17 for many years to come unless somehow magically Pakistan wins the World Cup.
(I can wager my house on it not happening).

Addendum

I think if Kohli wins the World Cup, it will be remembered for decades but CT' 17 will be forgotten soon as the tournament is defunct.
 
Last edited:
Dont get personal with each other - stick to topic
 
A lot depends on the teams themselves, a captain will always look good with a good squad working for him, so far Eoin Morgan looking good
 
Eoin Morgan For me - This is England's world cup to lose.

Jason Holder is very impressive as well.
 
There are three parameters that we can use to define good captaincy.

1. Leading the team from the front by his batting or bowling or in the field.

2. Having tactical shrewdness in terms of bowling changes and field settings.

3. Inspiring his troops to give more than their best through his words or actions.

So by applying the above criteria, these are the rankings according to me.

1. Faf du Plessis
2. Kane Williamson
3. Mashrafe Mortaza
4. Virat Kohli
5. Jason Holder
6. Eoin Morgan
7. Sarfraz Ahmed
8. Aron Finch
9. Dimuth Karunaratne
10. Gulbadin Naib
 
1: Morgan
2: Kane
3: Kohli
4: Sarfraz
5: Holder
6: Faf
7: Naib
8: Mortaza ( gets -10 for picking overrated Sabbir )
 
It has to be Kane Williamson and he is rightly leading the votes.
 
It's between Morgan or Williamson for me. But gotta support green team all the way through! :sarf2
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-partner="tweetdeck"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Top 4 in the table - captains who lead from the front & take full responsibility:<br><br>Kane Williamson 225 runs at an average of 225<br>Aaron Finch 343 runs at an average of 68.60<br>Eoin Morgan 249 runs at an average of 62.25<br>Virat Kohli 177 runs at an average of 59.00<a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/CWC19?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#CWC19</a></p>— Saj Sadiq (@Saj_PakPassion) <a href="https://twitter.com/Saj_PakPassion/status/1141422209153548288?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">June 19, 2019</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
Kane Williamson is the best captain in world cricket currently.

Here is my order of how I rate all these captains:

1) Kane Williamson
2) Eoin Morgan
3) Sarfraz Ahmed
4) Jason Holder
5) Faf Du Plessis
6) Aaron Finch
7) Virat Kohli
8) Mashrafe Mortaza
9) Dimuth Karunaratne
10) Gulbadin Naib


Ahahahahaha Sarfraz better than Kohli and Faf. Even Finch is a better captain than your hero.
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-partner="tweetdeck"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Top 4 in the table - captains who lead from the front & take full responsibility:<br><br>Kane Williamson 225 runs at an average of 225<br>Aaron Finch 343 runs at an average of 68.60<br>Eoin Morgan 249 runs at an average of 62.25<br>Virat Kohli 177 runs at an average of 59.00<a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/CWC19?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#CWC19</a></p>— Saj Sadiq (@Saj_PakPassion) <a href="https://twitter.com/Saj_PakPassion/status/1141422209153548288?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">June 19, 2019</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Sarfraz fans told us performances doesn't matter as long as the team is winning.

The 4 teams who will make the semis the captains are standout performers.
 
Was a little dissapointed with Holder in the last game but the whole team didn't seem in good shape for some reason.

Morgan has done brilliant so far but Kane Williamson is way ahead of everyone. Every single player respects him, plays for him and admires him. He also shows a very mature attitude off and on the pitch, something the likes of Sarfraz and Kohli could learn from.

It will be a great sight if Williamson lifts the world cup, a gentleman playing a gentlemans game with inteligence and passion.
 
Morgan and Kane are not only good leaders but also great on-field captains
 
Ahahahahaha Sarfraz better than Kohli and Faf. Even Finch is a better captain than your hero.

First of all, he is not my hero and rather our nation's captain. Secondly, how many trophies have Kohli, Faf and Finch have won combined all together with better players under them? That's right Zero.

Everyone can have their own opinion and I respect that, there is no genuine measuring device to tell us who is better in reality.
 
First of all, he is not my hero and rather our nation's captain. Secondly, how many trophies have Kohli, Faf and Finch have won combined all together with better players under them? That's right Zero.

Everyone can have their own opinion and I respect that, there is no genuine measuring device to tell us who is better in reality.

Those 3 haven't won trophies but Sarfraz didn't win the CT single handily and it wasnt because of his captaincy we won the CT anyway.

If winning a ICC tournament is a judge of captain, than Malinga is one of the great captain for winning the World T20 final in 2014.
 
Those 3 haven't won trophies but Sarfraz didn't win the CT single handily and it wasnt because of his captaincy we won the CT anyway.

If winning a ICC tournament is a judge of captain, than Malinga is one of the great captain for winning the World T20 final in 2014.

Ofcourse Sarfraz didn't won it singlehandedly and I never said that, but captaincy sure plays a part in winning even if you have the the world's best players under you.

As for second point, captaining in ODI tournament victory is far more significant and difficult than in a T20I one, so better leave that alone. Also, Lasith Malinga wasn't even the Captain actually. It was Dinesh Chandimal for first few matches, with Malinga a part time one as a makeshift for him.
 
Ofcourse Sarfraz didn't won it singlehandedly and I never said that, but captaincy sure plays a part in winning even if you have the the world's best players under you.

As for second point, captaining in ODI tournament victory is far more significant and difficult than in a T20I one, so better leave that alone. Also, Lasith Malinga wasn't even the Captain actually. It was Dinesh Chandimal for first few matches, with Malinga a part time one as a makeshift for him.


I didn't see anything special in his captaincy. Also we have seen over the last 2 years that his captaincy is not one of the best in the world. You can't judge someone off 4 or 5 games.

I was aware he was not the captain for all the games . But he was the captain for the final. You are saying Sarfraz is a good captain because he won a tournament, so Chandimal and Malinga must be good captains for that World T20 win then.
 
I didn't see anything special in his captaincy. Also we have seen over the last 2 years that his captaincy is not one of the best in the world. You can't judge someone off 4 or 5 games.

I was aware he was not the captain for all the games . But he was the captain for the final. You are saying Sarfraz is a good captain because he won a tournament, so Chandimal and Malinga must be good captains for that World T20 win then.

As mentioned in my post before this, captaining in a 50 over tournament victory is far more significant and difficult than in a T20I, hence Sarfraz can't be compared to Chandimal/Malinga in that achievement.

Also, I agree Sarfraz dosen't look like a great captain, but he is up there because there is hardly any inspirational or tactically
equipped standout captain nowadays barring Kane Williamson. Other captains just look good because their team have better players in them and they win more. Nothing special in most of the captains today except for like I said before Kane Williamson. All others aren't much different to each other.
 
Last edited:
As mentioned in my post before this, captaining in a 50 over tournament victory is far more significant and difficult than in a T20I, hence Sarfraz can't be compared to Chandimal/Malinga in that achievement.

Also, I agree Sarfraz dosen't look like a great captain, but he is up there because there is hardly any inspirational or tactically
equipped standout captain nowadays barring Kane Williamson. Other captains just look good because their team have better players in them and they win more. Nothing special in most of the captains today except for like I said before Kane Williamson. All others aren't much different to each other.


It's an achievement for the team more than it ssd for Sarfraz but if you think Sarfraz was the main reason for that , you can believe that theory.

Well obviously you need good players to win consistently. You can't really do much without quality players bu Sarfraz cannot inspire, has poor man management, awful tactics , and doesn't set a good example.

Kane Williamson is a very good captain. But Kohli, Moragn ,Mashrafee, and Moragn are also good captain.

Captaincy is more than just tactics and moving the field around.
 
It's an achievement for the team more than it ssd for Sarfraz but if you think Sarfraz was the main reason for that , you can believe that theory.

Well obviously you need good players to win consistently. You can't really do much without quality players bu Sarfraz cannot inspire, has poor man management, awful tactics , and doesn't set a good example.

Kane Williamson is a very good captain. But Kohli, Moragn ,Mashrafee, and Moragn are also good captain.

Captaincy is more than just tactics and moving the field around.

I never said it was a sole achievement of Sarfraz, it was rather a comparison between him and Chandimal/Malinga for the importance of their position and success with respect to different tournaments.

Like I said, it's not just Sarfraz, there are only few inspirational captains nowadays. Players just lift themselves up and their team with quality performances.

I know captain is more than just being tactically standout, you should have a character, a impressive personality, cool and calm nature under pressure, dominant nature and your own performances. I don't see many captains today filling that bill. You can have your own opinion, just like anyone.
 
With the resources he has Aaron Finch has impressed the most with Kohli being more astute than Morgan and Williamson played a true captains knock

Moral of the story is that teams whose captains are performing have been consistent
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-partner="tweetdeck"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Top 4 in the table - captains who lead from the front & take full responsibility:<br><br>Kane Williamson 225 runs at an average of 225<br>Aaron Finch 343 runs at an average of 68.60<br>Eoin Morgan 249 runs at an average of 62.25<br>Virat Kohli 177 runs at an average of 59.00<a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/CWC19?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#CWC19</a></p>— Saj Sadiq (@Saj_PakPassion) <a href="https://twitter.com/Saj_PakPassion/status/1141422209153548288?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">June 19, 2019</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Each of these guys is equally deserving of the award of best captain.
 
Sarfaraz captaincy has improved as the tournament has gone on - but too little, too late?
 
Rank the captain's on the basis of worldcup 2019

So the worldcup is done and dusted. My order after seeing all the team performance especially captaincy of each team
1)Kane Williamson
2)Eion Morgan
3)Aaron Finch
4)Virat kohli
5)Sarfraz ahmed
6)Faf duplessi
7)Masrafe Mortaza
8Jason holder
9)Dimuth Karunaratne
10)Gulbadin Naib

I enjoyed kane captaincy more than anyone's. He was simply outstanding with the tactics
 
Last edited:
What i liked about Kane is he learnt from his mistakes.

He didn't repeat what happened in the Aus game again, it's why we beat India. He didn't take the foot off the gas and rotated the bowlers brilliantly. Hopefully he can muster something up again for 2023.

This felt like our 92, but in the end instead of Kane lifting the WC, he got kicked in the balls...
 
Back
Top