In terms of weakest to strongest(LOL strongest not saying much)
1) Abrar (having a test specialist mystery spinner who can't take wickets and is expensive is criminal, spinners are the pride of test cricket, taking crucial wickets in intervals and bowling the longest spells.)
2) Shaheen Afridi (This dude is completly farigh now, your ace bowler being a trundler is a no no for test)
3) Naseem shah( I'll be fair to Naseem, he should have gotten 4 wickets instead of 2 as his catches were dropped, but he's gained weight, can't bowl line and length and is rubbish)
4) Babar Azam (Can I ask what's the point anymore? He's ironically been the worst batter in the entire squad so far, Everyone else albeit kedicore have scored 50's here and their)
5) Abdullah Shafique (I'd have put him lower but his century changed my mind, Regardless still got bowled for a duck, and overall is rubbish)
6) Saim Ayub (This man scored 2 half centuries when conditons were difficult in the first Test against Bangladesh thanks to rain, So for me that 50 he made is > Abdullah's 100 on a phatta, but he's overall been a failure as well, also he took 2 wickets deapite not even being a bowler)
7) Shan Masood (Atrocious and rubbish captain, his 151 has forced me to put him here sadly, but he's a crap batsmen and his fraud narrative of playing positive is irritating the life out of me)
8) Muhammad Rizwan (Tbf to rizzu he did alright in Bangladesh series, but omg he's so rubbish ahainat any bowler who's half decent and he's so rubbish as a keeper behind the stumps, catch it catch it. Mazzaq chal raha hai kya? Pure bottler)
9) Saud Shakeel (Again tbf, he only scores soft runs in the first innings and he can bowl, but he's always rubbish in the 2nd innings and overall rubbish as a whole)
10) Aamer Jamal (To be fair conditons were tough and Shan made horrible field selections, He bowled okay for a bowling allrounder, can't expect much and he batted well too in 2nd innings going not put. His fielding is also great. Ik he's medicore but you can't fault him for being interested and being the only bowler who tried his best and only batter who tried)
11) Agha (He and jamal are the only gems so far. Yes it's a phatta but these 2 are the only cricketers who give me the feeling of hard work and effort. Not Shan Masood)