So let's list the for and against.
For
- Was captain when we won a mickey mouse tournament
Against
- Threw his toys out of the pram and cried about being a "dummy captain" even though he was just a taking charge for a couple of weeks while Inzi was suspended.
- Resigned, only to come back when the PCB chairman was replaced.
- Younis Khan, despite being vice captain and groomed for the captaincy for years, refused the captaincy after Inzi's retirement because fans were upset after the World Cup exit and he couldn't handle the pressure. Shoaib Malik ended up getting the job at a stage of his career where he wasn't prepared for the job and the results were predictably disastrous for both the team and Malik's career.
- He finally accepted the captaincy in 2009. To the surprise of nobody, he
couldn't make it to the end of the year before resigning again because someone hurt his feelings. Led to Yousuf being appointed as captain, we all know how that turned out.
- Let's not forget that time he turned off his mobile phone and went AWOL on a fishing trip when the PCB was trying to get in touch with him about going on tour down under just because he was sulking.
That's just the stuff I can remember off the top of my head. Yeah, that's exactly who we need to be leading the team. A guy who is too emotional and spits his dummy out the moment things don't go entirely his own way or he faces criticism.
Let him concentrate on batting, he's bloody good at that. Leave the captaincy to someone else, anyone else, because Younis is bloody useless at that.