What's new

Who should Pakistan appoint as the new Test captain?

Who should Pakistan appoint as the new Test captain?


  • Total voters
    16

BouncerGuy

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Aug 29, 2023
Runs
33,891
With Salman Ali Agha recently appointed as Pakistan's T20I captain, the focus now shifts to the Test side. Shan Masood, who has been leading the team in the longest format, could be at risk of losing his spot due to inconsistent performances. If that happens, PCB will face a critical decision: Who should take over as Pakistan’s new Test captain?

Should they promote an experienced campaigner like Babar Azam to balance leadership across formats? Or is it time to back an emerging leader like Saud Shakeel or Mohammad Rizwan to steer the Test squad forward?

Who do YOU think should lead Pakistan in Test cricket moving forward?
 
The test team is going to get battered for a long time. Many of the better players in Pakistan will skip test cricket or be tested for certain matches.

It is becoming the captain of a sinking ship and my fear is that it will interfere with LOI progress.

It makes sense to have someone who is not going to play any ODI cricket and especially not T20 cricket. Let the test captain be in control of managing older domestic pros and FC only players to see what he can accomplish. Despite our love of Test cricket it's time for Pakistan to officially treat the format as of less importance than LOI and stop pretending that we are serious about it.

So continue with Shan or bring in a domestic pro like Salahudin ( if he is still playing) but don't burden Saud or Agha.

Rizwan is an option too provided he is happy not being considered for LOI.
 
Saud Shakeel, but it is likely to be Agha Salman because PCB has decided to make him our new Abu.

I really like him as a player, but I think he is being forced down our throats a little too much and is getting too much too soon.

Ideally, he should be the VC across formats or at best, the white ball captain.

Saud Shakeel Test captain, Shaheen white ball captain, Agha Salman all format VC. This is my recommendation.
 
Saud Shakeel, but it is likely to be Agha Salman because PCB has decided to make him our new Abu.

I really like him as a player, but I think he is being forced down our throats a little too much and is getting too much too soon.

Ideally, he should be the VC across formats or at best, the white ball captain.

Saud Shakeel Test captain, Shaheen white ball captain, Agha Salman all format VC. This is my recommendation.
Salman is probably oldest of them and has 3-4 years of international cricket only.
 
The test team is going to get battered for a long time. Many of the better players in Pakistan will skip test cricket or be tested for certain matches.

It is becoming the captain of a sinking ship and my fear is that it will interfere with LOI progress.

It makes sense to have someone who is not going to play any ODI cricket and especially not T20 cricket. Let the test captain be in control of managing older domestic pros and FC only players to see what he can accomplish. Despite our love of Test cricket it's time for Pakistan to officially treat the format as of less importance than LOI and stop pretending that we are serious about it.

So continue with Shan or bring in a domestic pro like Salahudin ( if he is still playing) but don't burden Saud or Agha.

Rizwan is an option too provided he is happy not being considered for LOI.
pak should play longer series against weaker teams, until they start beating them consistently they should only play rare and short series agains the better teams. getting whitewashed again and again serves no developmental purpose.
 
1) Shabzada Farhan
2) Saim Ayub
3) Azan Awais
4) Kamran Ghulam
5) Saud Shakeel
6) Salman Ali Agha
7) Muhammad Rizwan

^^ This should be Pakistan's test batting lineup.
 
Personally I'd go with Saud Shakeel. He's proven himself to be an excellent Test batsmen and played quite a few match winning knocks already. No need to put extra pressure on Agha as an all-format captain either. Let his focus remain on white ball.

Too often a player/captain will have dip in one format and start getting criticized and put under pressure for all of them. No need to do that when you avoid it and have a perfectly legitimate candidate in Saud who is often used to captaining in FC as well.
 
What's worrying is that Pakistan isnt playing test cricket.

Theirs over 60 days remaining until Pakistan plays its series vs wi on 31st July.

They can easily schedule a 3 match test series in the mean time.

Heck why not schedule a test series vs WI and provide them a warm up for Australia lol.
 
Agha all format captain, only player who was good both in australia and home conditions. And he will only improve. Match winner, can bat with tail.
 
Agha doesnt want to be the focus of attention as far as i ve observed meanwhile its quite opposite for saud. Agha ll be good ig if he doesnt take the pressure of all format captaincy.
Ideally we should groom shaheen and saim for captaincy.
 
1) Shabzada Farhan
2) Saim Ayub
3) Azan Awais
4) Kamran Ghulam
5) Saud Shakeel
6) Salman Ali Agha
7) Muhammad Rizwan

^^ This should be Pakistan's test batting lineup.
Receipe for disaster in sena conditions.
Farhan,Azan,Kg Saud,salman will be sitting ducks on bouncy tracks.
 
Agha doesnt want to be the focus of attention as far as i ve observed meanwhile its quite opposite for saud. Agha ll be good ig if he doesnt take the pressure of all format captaincy.
Ideally we should groom shaheen and saim for captaincy.
Na bro Shaheens career is over for now.
 
Stop chopping and changing captains for no reason... Shan won the test series recently against England and Westindies even if its spin track..

Agha better be white ball captain and focus on it , shouldnt rush him to test captaincy for now or until 2027 CWC ... Can still make Saud Shakeel as the next test captain if needed..
 
Saud Shakeel, but it is likely to be Agha Salman because PCB has decided to make him our new Abu.

I really like him as a player, but I think he is being forced down our throats a little too much and is getting too much too soon.

Ideally, he should be the VC across formats or at best, the white ball captain.

Saud Shakeel Test captain, Shaheen white ball captain, Agha Salman all format VC. This is my recommendation.
Saud has grown as player and will grow again if made Captain. It wasn't long ago that Salman was accused of being a Parchi because of his friendship with Babar. I would like to see Babar open with Saim, Salman at 4 and Saud as Captain and bat at 5.
 
I think it will most probably be Salman and I think it is fair enough. I think Agha is a smart captain. Maybe not to hype him too much and expect some 100% results but yeah, he is an upgrade over Shan for sure.
 
In Pakistan, You should not choose a test specialist as your test captain. It might work for Australia, England and maybe India but that will never work for Pakistan. Pakistan plays very few test matches, which in result will neither improve that player’s own game nor his captaincy. You need an all format man and Agha is your man right now.
 
Bakhri reporting PCB have elected Saud Shaqeel as the Test captain


Agha to lead ODI and T20
 
We enter the era

Of Saud’s class

Because there ain’t no class

Like Saud Class!
 
Saud shouldn't be the captain,Agha should be all format captain.
I think it’s a correct decision

Agha should focus solely on white ball cricket. There are seriously different requirements and challenges in all 3 formats. It’s far too much for one player to deal with the pressures of all of them. Eventually the negativity you incur from one format’s poor performances will follow you through into the others as a leader

Saud or Agha both are fine to lead the Test side. I don’t even mind Shan too much either but I guess his time is up.

Rizwan would have been OK too but he clearly took the path of making T20 cricket his prestige format, although he had no business playing this format in the first place!
 
I think it’s a correct decision

Agha should focus solely on white ball cricket. There are seriously different requirements and challenges in all 3 formats. It’s far too much for one player to deal with the pressures of all of them. Eventually the negativity you incur from one format’s poor performances will follow you through into the others as a leader

Saud or Agha both are fine to lead the Test side. I don’t even mind Shan too much either but I guess his time is up.

Rizwan would have been OK too but he clearly took the path of making T20 cricket his prestige format, although he had no business playing this format in the first place!
Does Saud merit a place in the team in SENA conditions??
 
Does Saud merit a place in the team in SENA conditions??
You can’t hide him for those conditions. He will have to battle hard and come strong for Pakistan

There are flat decks in SENA as well. Nobody clearly Merits a spot in the team on extremely tough conditions abroad.

We do not have any player in Pakistan who is on Mohammad Yousuf’s batting level.
 
Make Rizwan the test captain

He should be captaining both odi and tests team
 
The only thing that I disagree with my PP brothers on and still do is Shan Masood.

Don't wish to sound like Mamoon, but Shan just didnt really make sense to me. English and communication skills is one thing but he never really gave me the vibes of turning things around.

He was a poor captain in PSL and as a test captain he frequently let sides recover from collapsed positions.

I feel like Shan due to being an improvement captaincy wise over babar was viewed in a positive light but he isnt a good test batsmen either.

It honestly should have been agha from the start. He's basically Shan in terms of communication skills but is also a good batsmen.

However I dont blame Shan for the losses as Pakistan was never beating Aus at home, and was never beating any side on those home road pitches.
 
“PAKISTAN CRICKET

There are reports now, rising, not quite yet deafening, but steady that Salman Ali Agha is to be handed the keys to Pakistan cricket across formats. Captain in all three.

The tone of this speculation carries certainty, as if it’s already been written in the margins somewhere in Gaddafi Stadium’s corridors. And perhaps it has.
It is not a leap of faith entirely.

Salman brings with him not just a cricketing intellect, the kind that thinks on its feet and evolves with the flow of a match but also a presence. A quiet assertion. The kind of presence that doesn’t shout leadership but carries it in the way it stands still while others shift around it. That is no small thing in Pakistan cricket, where captains are not chosen but survived.

Yet, let’s not rush to romanticise. Salman, for all his qualities, was never shaped in the kiln of T20 cricket. He was not meant for its chaos. But cricket has a way of making its own demands, and players, especially in Pakistan find ways to answer.

Salman has adapted, grown, morphed into something more multidimensional. It’s credit to his hunger. His captaincy, though, will find truer tests ahead in conditions not just foreign, but hostile; against teams not just stronger, but ruthless.

In Tests, Shan Masood’s brief tenure felt like a misstep waiting to be corrected. His captaincy record abysmal, his personal form not entirely lost, in fact, he sits second on the Test averages this year.

But there’s a sense that the project lacked clarity. Shan never quite looked like he believed the job was his. Salman, by contrast, feels like the succession plan the board didn’t know it had.

But what of the ODIs? What of Mohammad Rizwan? Here is a man who has not just held the line, but, in a sense, dignified it. As captain, as batsman, he has been more than serviceable.

There’s a quiet intelligence to his batting, a resilience that belies his limitations. Why unseat him? What crime has he committed? That he doesn’t fit the future the selectors now dream of?

Perhaps this is the cost of Pakistan’s pivot, a belated and an unnecessary dependent on someone who complies, & exterminate who ask questions.


Babar and Rizwan, so central for so long, now find themselves cast aside in T20s, relics of a style that once worked but no longer flies. The world has moved on. Pakistan is trying to catch up. Fair enough. Justified.

But why overload Salman? Why risk fraying him by spreading him thin? Let him shape the red-ball team, the format where real leaders are sculpted — and take charge of the new T20 vision.

But in ODIs, surely, a more thoughtful debate is warranted. One format too many can blur even the clearest minds.
Salman may well be the future. But futures need not be forced all at once. Let him grow into it, rather than be thrown into it.”

Who do you think wrote this drivel?
 
“PAKISTAN CRICKET

There are reports now, rising, not quite yet deafening, but steady that Salman Ali Agha is to be handed the keys to Pakistan cricket across formats. Captain in all three.

The tone of this speculation carries certainty, as if it’s already been written in the margins somewhere in Gaddafi Stadium’s corridors. And perhaps it has.
It is not a leap of faith entirely.

Salman brings with him not just a cricketing intellect, the kind that thinks on its feet and evolves with the flow of a match but also a presence. A quiet assertion. The kind of presence that doesn’t shout leadership but carries it in the way it stands still while others shift around it. That is no small thing in Pakistan cricket, where captains are not chosen but survived.

Yet, let’s not rush to romanticise. Salman, for all his qualities, was never shaped in the kiln of T20 cricket. He was not meant for its chaos. But cricket has a way of making its own demands, and players, especially in Pakistan find ways to answer.

Salman has adapted, grown, morphed into something more multidimensional. It’s credit to his hunger. His captaincy, though, will find truer tests ahead in conditions not just foreign, but hostile; against teams not just stronger, but ruthless.

In Tests, Shan Masood’s brief tenure felt like a misstep waiting to be corrected. His captaincy record abysmal, his personal form not entirely lost, in fact, he sits second on the Test averages this year.

But there’s a sense that the project lacked clarity. Shan never quite looked like he believed the job was his. Salman, by contrast, feels like the succession plan the board didn’t know it had.

But what of the ODIs? What of Mohammad Rizwan? Here is a man who has not just held the line, but, in a sense, dignified it. As captain, as batsman, he has been more than serviceable.

There’s a quiet intelligence to his batting, a resilience that belies his limitations. Why unseat him? What crime has he committed? That he doesn’t fit the future the selectors now dream of?

Perhaps this is the cost of Pakistan’s pivot, a belated and an unnecessary dependent on someone who complies, & exterminate who ask questions.


Babar and Rizwan, so central for so long, now find themselves cast aside in T20s, relics of a style that once worked but no longer flies. The world has moved on. Pakistan is trying to catch up. Fair enough. Justified.

But why overload Salman? Why risk fraying him by spreading him thin? Let him shape the red-ball team, the format where real leaders are sculpted — and take charge of the new T20 vision.

But in ODIs, surely, a more thoughtful debate is warranted. One format too many can blur even the clearest minds.
Salman may well be the future. But futures need not be forced all at once. Let him grow into it, rather than be thrown into it.”

Who do you think wrote this drivel?
I was gonna say well written but that's not really you bro, so im surprised you're making this argument.

Until I read the last line 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
 
I was gonna say well written but that's not really you bro, so im surprised you're making this argument.

Until I read the last line 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
So when Rizwan was awarded captaincy by the PCB…it was because he came across as a man of his own principles according to his fans. This is what was unique about him even though his methods as a player were ridiculous. But when he was removed, it’s the price he paid for asking too many questions?? I don’t get it. Why are so many excuses made to justify this clown?
 
The only thing that I disagree with my PP brothers on and still do is Shan Masood.

Don't wish to sound like Mamoon, but Shan just didnt really make sense to me. English and communication skills is one thing but he never really gave me the vibes of turning things around.

He was a poor captain in PSL and as a test captain he frequently let sides recover from collapsed positions.

I feel like Shan due to being an improvement captaincy wise over babar was viewed in a positive light but he isnt a good test batsmen either.

It honestly should have been agha from the start. He's basically Shan in terms of communication skills but is also a good batsmen.

However I dont blame Shan for the losses as Pakistan was never beating Aus at home, and was never beating any side on those home road pitches.
Bro one that thing is for sure pak thank god has decided to move away from those boring road pitches which ramiz made aqib has made it clear spin is the way to win vs sena teams and pak should do this every time yes they will loose tests along the way but thats the best way to play wtc final spin will always trouble sena teams as we have seen how sajid and noman made england look clueless.
 
Bro one that thing is for sure pak thank god has decided to move away from those boring road pitches which ramiz made aqib has made it clear spin is the way to win vs sena teams and pak should do this every time yes they will loose tests along the way but thats the best way to play wtc final spin will always trouble sena teams as we have seen how sajid and noman made england look clueless.
Pakistan will lose all of its games on these doctored pitches if they are forced to bat 2nd
 
Cant be worse than Shan.
Might as well just go with salman. Why??

because Pakistan is not playing that many games already so there is no need to go for different captains atm... Salman started well and he is looking like a good option atm. Better than saud even.
 
Might as well just go with salman. Why??

because Pakistan is not playing that many games already so there is no need to go for different captains atm... Salman started well and he is looking like a good option atm. Better than saud even.
Depends on what and how the mindset and brain of Agha is. Hesson made a great decision by sacking Taylor and giving Baz the captaincy which changed NZ cricket. If Agha seems to be head and shoulders above everyone else, then he should get the job. We as fans, don't really know about the mind of cricketers. We only get glimpses inside their head with their interviews, tactics and social media stuff. The guys other than Hesson in charge are all clowns in PCB who probably don't even know how to conduct a proper interview and assess leadership.
 
Back
Top