iHammad
Senior T20I Player
- Joined
- Sep 2, 2009
- Runs
- 18,060
Simple question, what do you guys think?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Noora hi jeetien gaye..
PTI is not strong enough in Punjab to form a government in center, and as we have seen in the 2013 elections and PML-N victory, you only need to win in Punjab even if you have next to nothing in other provinces.
So unfair
Even when IK was in Khi for NA 248 election he said sth like 'I dont need to win in Karachi to be PM,' That was sad to hear.
Yes it's unfair for the people of other provinces i know but it's a bitter truthlook at PMLN how many NA seats they got from Sindh or KPK? but still they got two third majority. 148 out of 272 NA seats are from Punjab so that means even if we combine NA seats of Sindh,KPK,Fata,Isb and Baluchistan still they are only 124 that is 24 less than Punjab seats. So any party that want to come in power will have to focus more on Punjab otherwise there will be coalition governments and coalition government in Pakistan are only for mafaad perasti everyone want a fair share.
That's why PMLN will never let Punjab divide into more provinces like Seraiki, Bahawalpur and Potohar.
Yes it's unfair for the people of other provinces i know but it's a bitter truthlook at PMLN how many NA seats they got from Sindh or KPK? but still they got two third majority. 148 out of 272 NA seats are from Punjab so that means even if we combine NA seats of Sindh,KPK,Fata,Isb and Baluchistan still they are only 124 that is 24 less than Punjab seats. So any party that want to come in power will have to focus more on Punjab otherwise there will be coalition governments and coalition government in Pakistan are only for mafaad perasti everyone want a fair share.
That's why PMLN will never let Punjab divide into more provinces like Seraiki, Bahawalpur and Potohar.
we need 2-3 provinces in Punjab, 2 in Sindh and 2 even in Balochistan if nationalists agree to it
I wish we can go back to presidential form of goverment in Pakistan so that the nation can chose a leader instead of these clowns selecting a leader for awaam. This system is not working.
Musharraf with his collation parties will win.
REMEMBER YOU READ IT HERE FIRST.
Musharraf with his collation parties will win.
REMEMBER YOU READ IT HERE FIRST.
or maybe there needs to be a rule that the party which forms the federal government needs to have atleast 10% of seats in each province. Failing that they need to get into a coalition to reach that representation figure. Or some way for more provincial representation. PML-N won a grand total of 1 seat in Sindh in 2013 I think and that too was due to the personalitu
sth like US system?
Awaam selects the Prez every four years. Awaam selects 1/3rd of the upper and lower houses for parliament (HOR, Senate) every 2 years. Both keep checks and balances on each other.
It can be tinkered to suit us better but to have parliament seats up for election every 2 years would mean that there is no khuli choot for 5 years.. You can totally destory the country in 5 years and go about your merry way and no one can do anything because if they do jamhooriat khatray mai hai
Yes but the issue is for all this to happen we need legislation and this goes against PMLN interest so i don't see it happening at least till PMLN is in goverment. That one seat was i think Hakeem Baloch?
Musharraf will win in Chitral thats it.
Yup. In Steel mills area where YK used to live as a kid. It was always a PPP stronghold before that but in this election PPP notables in area did not like the candidate selected so deserted him and backed this guy. So it was pure luck lol
I wish we can go back to presidential form of goverment in Pakistan so that the nation can chose a leader instead of these clowns selecting a leader for awaam. This system is not working.
So another 8 years of Nawaz Sharif as PM? 3 until 2018 and 5 more after that?
Simple question, what do you guys think?
Pmln wont get a clear majority like 2013 the rest will remain the same. As long as elections are fair who wins is not that important as we as nation have lost trust on the election system as we never had a real democracy for very long before interference from the army or others.It would be pretty much the same as the GE 2013 except that the PPP would lose a few seats to the PTI in Punjab.Apart from this, no major changes.
Sent from my Lenovo A6000 using Tapatalk
These goons use democracy to loot people.This is not democracy.Pmln wont get a clear majority like 2013 the rest will remain the same. As long as elections are fair who wins is not that important as we as nation have lost trust on the election system as we never had a real democracy for very long before interference from the army or others.
Iftikhar might have been a PMLN jiyala but it has woken up the judiciary to get independent from our rulers. This with better election system would improve it over time.
Sent from my SM-G925I
This is a democracy as they are looting becuase we the people that bring them to power vote for them. You saw what happened with ppp the most corrupt party ever they were decimated in the next election. PMLN would have been as bad or worse than PPP. If they hadn't realize that they will loose their seats in the next election if they don't show some improvement over the previous government.These goons use democracy to loot people.This is not democracy.
Sent from my Lenovo A6000 using Tapatalk
Yes, we brought them to power.However, Pakistan's political system is such that corrupt people keep coming back albeit with the help of the public. The PPP and PML-N, despite their horrendous performance during the 1990s, were voted back into the government.This happens in no other country.This is a democracy as they are looting becuase we the people that bring them to power vote for them. You saw what happened with ppp the most corrupt party ever they were decimated in the next election. PMLN would have been as bad or worse than PPP. If they hadn't realize that they will loose their seats in the next election if they don't show some improvement over the previous government.
PMLN showed some improvement over PPP so will probably stay in government for another election. But PPP was so bad that even little improvement seems magnified. But the election after that people will ask for more.
With each election people will start asking for more from its elected representatives. This will result in the improvement in the systems of our country.
Intervention by military or others stops the systems from improving and we start back from zero.
Sent from my SM-G925I
Both didn't complete their terms in the 90s so were able to come in power with a clean slate.Yes, we brought them to power.However, Pakistan's political system is such that corrupt people keep coming back albeit with the help of the public. The PPP and PML-N, despite their horrendous performance during the 1990s, were voted back into the government.This happens in no other country.
In any other country, these two parties along with the MQM would have been banned long time ago.
Additionally, education is necessary for democracy to work.
I agree with you that we bring these thugs to power but to say this is democracy would be - unfair.
Sent from my Lenovo A6000 using Tapatalk
Both didn't complete their terms in the 90s so were able to come in power with a clean slate.
But after last election PMLN had to devolve power to the provinces. And now they are being forced to implement local governments something they both don't want. If we can have a few more election cycles the systems will keep improving with every election. But it will take decades can't happen over night.
Sent from my SM-G925I
In KP there is more hate towards Nawaz Sharif so he will not get more seats there. ANP?
TBH the Hazara area of KP (Abbotabad, Mansehra, Haripur etc) always remained pro PMLN even when PMLN agreed to change NWFP name in PPP govt there were huge protests in Hazara against PMLN but still they voted for PMLN in next elections and recent local body election as well. Now with the motorway for Hazara Nawaz is again gaining more popularity so unless PTI do something really special i don't see PMLN getting out of Hazara anytime soon.
Well I was talking about complete picture. Its obvious some parties are quite famous in certain parts of province
Politics change everyday, If this same question was asked in 2005 about the 2008 elections, almost everyone would have said Musharraf will sweep them and no one in there mind would have thought Zadari would replace him.
Will be voting for PML-N this time, after voting for PTI in 2013.
I wish we can go back to presidential form of goverment in Pakistan so that the nation can chose a leader instead of these clowns selecting a leader for awaam. This system is not working.
Presidential system is still useless. It would be NS, IK running for presidentship. Same story. No common man can bear the finances of a presidency campaign.
I was listening to local lahore traders today thandi aahen bher bher ke musharraf ke suhaane dor ko yaad ker rahe thai or mian khandan ko kos rahe thai. But i know jab vote dene ka waqt ayega phr isi khaandan ko daal ker ayenge because we are blind and we expect different result after doing same mistake.
Mush was a dictator i was against him and used to criticize him 24/7 but Zardari govt or is govt ke haalat dekh ker to Mush ka dor suhana lagta he or democracy se nafrat hoti ja rae he. Aysee democracy ka kia faayda jo awaam ko kuch na de sake or bas leader ke bank balance increase kere.
More people will appear on the scene if they can attract the public with their thinking because in that form of goverment you directly pick your leader instead of electing candidates and than they selecting a leader which is mostly their part leader.
Lol mush ka durr kesay suhana tha? That guy didnt do jack and thats why we are bearing the fruits in the form of loadshedding, drone strikes and terrorism. Any form of democracy is better than dictatorship.
Ask any common Pakistani things were much much better if you compare it with current and last goverment you are hearing this from someone who spent year criticizing Mush the dictator. Mush did blunders no doubt about that and he was a dictator but current fake form democracy is giving nothing to a common man but yes ameer to ameer ter ho raha he or ghareeb to ghareeb ter. I love democracy but the form you see in Pakistan is actually a civil dictatorship, no value of parliament and goverment being run like a familybusiness or senate ki to baat he na kero that's mostly for rich persons and chaheetes of these parties get senate seats.
Here is the thing. You cant attract people by just thinking. You need to run a campaign and that requires finances. Practically impossible. Sorry man. But just like a two legged horse in usa whose election process is another sham; the same would happen in pakistan.
Ameer getting ameer and ghareeb getting ghareeb would always be the case no matter what. Thats capitalism for you, sir.
Now regarding mush and democratic governments. At least these pmln etc have fear of votes and thats why we see things like cpec, metro, electricity project. Musharaff came to power like pakistan auski baap ki jaager hai. The whole premise of him becoming president was illegal and in a way hijacking the public of pakistan. That guy didnt do jack. He had 9 years. If someone else had that much time they would have done way better.
In 3 years anything could happen.
Initial work on CPEC was started in Mush era. ok metro fine to show case in election campaign but where are the basic facilities? Why not spend on a common man life? education, health, clean water, creating jobs etc? Because you can't show case them in next elections? I am hungry i need food i need clean water but no you are happy to give me metro first instead of basic things that human need.
This is easy. I can bet my house and all my family money that PMLN will win. The reason I have been to Pakistan(Lahore) 5 times in the last 3 years . People make fun of Imran Khan in Lahore. Whoever supports Imran Khan, people make fun of them. I have not seen 1 businessman supportting Imran Khan. People who are earning good money do not vote PTI.
Two men Personally I know who are moved her in Denmark from Pakistan(Islamabad by getting married)1 earning money via IT and 1 by business in Pakistan. These guys are educated and somehow will never ever vote for PTI.
Sadly Imran Khan will keep fighting and die fighting. I think Imran Khan is born in a wrong born in a wrong era and place.
What did mushraff do to give you these basic necessities, uncle?
Awam needs to get out of this slave mentality. Army ka kaam borders par hai. Not in government offices. Thats pretty clear on my part.
PTI needs to organize itself and work at constituency level. I don't see any reason why it can't surpass N league.
If there are elections today, it will be a tie between N league and PTI. Farmers are really angry.
The thing is electables join the party which they think has a potential to add to their personal vote bank.
In a single constituency there is mostly close competition between couple of candidates. Both have their personal vote bank and need few thousands party votes to make it a victory.
And in rural areas people also tend to vote on the basis that which party which is expected to form government because then they will be able to get favors from the winning candidate.
In last general elections ticket distribution was criminal from PTI. Many electables, who were denied pti ticket, could have won on pti's platform.
There is also no clear policy from pti that whether they aim to win solely on the basis of popularity or only electables. There has to be a subtle mixture of both these elements which was rightly adopted in the previous elections but poorly followed. Yes, electables should be allowed in the party but after some introspection and analysis. But in urban areas you need a worker type candidate who could knock at doors and galvanize people around him.
This is easy. I can bet my house and all my family money that PMLN will win. The reason I have been to Pakistan(Lahore) 5 times in the last 3 years . People make fun of Imran Khan in Lahore. Whoever supports Imran Khan, people make fun of them. I have not seen 1 businessman supportting Imran Khan. People who are earning good money do not vote PTI.
Two men Personally I know who are moved her in Denmark from Pakistan(Islamabad by getting married)1 earning money via IT and 1 by business in Pakistan. These guys are educated and somehow will never ever vote for PTI.
Sadly Imran Khan will keep fighting and die fighting. I think Imran Khan is born in a wrong born in a wrong era and place.
Why?? You still believe that Nooras are better than PTI?
Look I know PTI is no where near perfect, but really, they are better than Nawaz and his goons.
Really hope PTI wins the next one. Can't do much worse than PML-N or PPP.
Imran Khan has the mentality of a 10 year old. He is not mentally fit enough to lead the country - it will be absolute shambles.
U-turns are costly at that level. Very costly.
I think you can come up with better arguments at least, there is not a single politician who is not known for U turns on issues and that is consistent all around the world not just Pakistan. You approach, policy, point of view changes with time. Imran Khan sits live on tv giving point of view on every single issue almost EVERY DAY (internal or external). Then there are protests, dharnas etc. Compare that to Nawaz and Zardari who give probably 1 or 2 interviews a year and that too with handful of PARCHIS. Now that's what you call a 10 year old mentality leaders who can't talk about a single issue without help from others.