What's new

Why Misbah ul-Haq is Pakistan’s greatest Test captain

#GreenRoars

T20I Star
Joined
Feb 8, 2015
Runs
32,520
There have been three great captains of Pakistan. The first was A.H. Kardar, the country’s first Test captain. Born in Lahore, and talent-spotted by the senior Nawab of Pataudi, Kardar played for India before Partition. He led Pakistan to victory over India in its second-ever Test match in Lucknow in 1952, and even more famously over England at the Oval Test in August 1954. Uniquely, Kardar won at least one Test match in Pakistan’s inaugural series against each other country.

Pakistan’s next great captain was Imran Khan, the all-rounder who inspired his country to a famous World Cup victory in 1992, and now has honourable aspirations to become Pakistan’s prime minister.

The third is Misbah-ul-Haq, and he has a claim to be the greatest. On statistics alone his claim is indisputable: 20 wins in 42 Tests as captain. Imran had 14 wins in 48 Tests, Kardar six in 23.

But most importantly, Misbah became captain in the wake of two disasters. The first was the terrorist attack on the Sri Lankan team bus at Lahore in 2009. This incident immediately condemned Pakistan to international isolation. No Test side has visited Pakistan since. Pakistan’s international players have been condemned to a perpetual shuttle between foreign hotel rooms, cut off from extended family and community networks which count for so much in Pakistan. So-called ‘home’ matches are played in the UAE, in echoing deserted stadiums.

The second calamity took place the following year when the Pakistan team toured England. Three of its players, including the captain, Salman Butt, and its brilliant young opening bowler, Mohammad Amir, were entrapped by the News of the World. The team was disgraced and the three players involved were later sent to jail.

At that dark hour, there was reason to doubt the survival of Pakistan cricket. That was when Misbah took over. He was not an obvious choice as captain. He had a mixed Test record, and was not even selected for the 2010 Tour, nor the one before in 2006. He was already 36 — ancient for a modern player.

Yet he proved an inspired choice. He had exactly the right qualities to lead his team at its moment of supreme crisis. He has not only anchored the batting time and time again but given his team a mental and moral example.

In both tasks he has been magnificently supported by his lieutenant Younus Khan, now Pakistan’s highest-scoring Test batsman, although the two men are very different on and off the pitch. Younus is voluble and extrovert and always seems on the move; Misbah is calm and cerebral, measured in speech and motion. They do share an intense patriotism and devotion to their families.

Misbah-ul-Haq was raised in Mianwali, in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (formerly North West Frontier province). He is related to Imran Khan’s father and a member of the same Niazi clan. Both his parents were educators and made him give academic work priority over cricket. He gained an MBA at the University of Management and Technology in Lahore, a qualification which makes him one of the best-educated cricketers in the modern era. His studies of leadership skills and human resource management delayed his entry to the first-class game until he was 24, but have been of lasting value to him as captain.

He is one of those rare cricketers whose Test performance has been massively enhanced by the duties of captaincy. Before 2010, Misbah had scored 1,008 runs in 33 Tests at an average of 33.60. Since becoming Captain, he has scored a further 3,344 runs in 42 Tests, at an average of 56.68.

‘Responsibility,’ Misbah told us, ‘has always given me a lot of confidence to face the music and perform.’

As a Test captain, Misbah has the priceless gift of looking as though he always has a plan on the field. In fact, he usually does. He has gained victories with an inexperienced attack since the loss of his former matchwinner, the spinner Saeed Ajmal, with a suspect action. When he led Pakistan to a 2 - 0 victory over England last winter in the UAE, none of his bowlers had taken 100 Test wickets.

Misbah is now 42. Assuming he captains in the fourth Test at the Oval he will be the oldest Test captain since the mighty Warwick Armstrong of Australia in 1921. He is barely half Armstrong’s 22 stone in weight: he and Younus (aged 38) are reputedly the fittest players in the Pakistan party.

Like his predecessors, Misbah has had clashes with selectors, adminstrators, media and fellow players. His undemonstrative style has sometimes made him undervalued in his own country. However, he commands a personal authority to match Khan, Steve Waugh for Australia or even Sir Frank Worrell in the West Indies.

Again with Younus’s help he should get the best from an exciting Pakistan line-up. Misbah’s most difficult task is to guide Mohammad Amir, still only in his rehabilitation, back into Test cricket. If he succeeds, Amir and his partner, Wahab Riaz, could become one of the best left-arm opening attacks in cricket history.

The other bowling priority will be the legspinner Yasir Shah, returning after a three-month drugs ban, who on his day is a magician to match his predecessors Abdul Qadir and Mushtaq Ahmed. Pakistan’s batting is sketchy. However, Misbah will hope that the strokemakers Mohammad Hafeez, Shan Masood, Azhar Ali, Asad Shafiq and the bouncy wicketkeeper Sarfraz Ahmed can take the strain from himself and Younus.

Misbah and his team will enjoy far more support from British Asian cricket lovers than in their ‘home’ Tests in the UAE. This great man is coming to the end of his career and deserves a farewell to match Don Bradman’s at the Oval 1948. His achievement has been epic. Like Bradman, he has been far more than a simple cricketer. For his six years at the helm of the national team, Misbah has helped to bind Pakistan together as a nation.

http://www.spectator.co.uk/2016/07/why-misbah-ul-haq-is-pakistans-greatest-test-captain/
 
Peter Oborne really seems to have developed a soft spot for Pakistan. Nice article.
 
If cricket was played on Microsoft Excel and statsguru then yes. However reality is that he isn't.

In his entire captaincy stint he's had to tour away outside of Asia exactly once where we got whooped 3-0.

Imran had to contend with much fiercer away tours which including setting the platform for infamous series victories in England, a feat for any Asian team. Not to mention going head to head and matching toe to toe with the then #1 West Indies in their own den and walking out with respectable team results especially compared to the other teams.

Misbah basically had the flat as a pancake UAE pitches served to him, and just had to let the spinners lose. Doesn't take much tactical thinking or planning to win it in the UAE if you're a subcontinental team.

In terms of integrity and bringing stability to the team he might rank with Imran. But tactically and strategically Imran and Wasim were both superior to him. Wasim is an underrated Pak captain as well.

Had the latter left behind the shady activities, could've led us to some famous victories.
 
Last edited:
Haters gonn' hate. :misbah

In reality, Imran Khan still has a bit of edge, but Misbah will definitely reach him OR go above IF he's able to win this Test series in England.

Definitely one of the most genius, tactically brilliant Test leaders produced by Pakistan.

Best cricketing brain in the country currently.
 
Well atleast statistically, Misbah has a better record than not only Imran, but every other Asian captain too.

But again, it's statistically.
 
If cricket was played on Microsoft Excel and statsguru then yes. However reality is that he isn't.

In his entire captaincy stint he's had to tour away outside of Asia exactly once where we got whooped 3-0.

Imran had to contend with much fiercer away tours which including setting the platform for infamous series victories in England, a feat for any Asian team. Not to mention going head to head and matching toe to toe with the then #1 West Indies in their own den and walking out with respectable team results especially compared to the other teams.

Misbah basically had the flat as a pancake UAE pitches served to him, and just had to let the spinners lose. Doesn't take much tactical thinking or planning to win it in the UAE if you're a subcontinental team.

In terms of integrity and bringing stability to the team he might rank with Imran. But tactically and strategically Imran and Wasim were both superior to him. Wasim is an underrated Pak captain as well.

Had the latter left behind the shady activities, could've led us to some famous victories.

Slight correction Sul - Misbah had another tour outside Asia to ZIM, which indeed his team avoided a white wash - it ended 1-1.
 
Imran Khan is the greatest captain from the subcontinent, not just from Pakistan. However, I have my highest regards for Misbah.
 
I would still say Imran is better but if Misbah can win the England series than he could seriously challenge Imran as the greatest Pakistani test captain
 
imran had a team of winners misbah have a team of losers
Lool. Imran believed in his players esp the new ones and fought against selectors who would not pick players he wanted. Misbah never backed any promising young players. He used all the tactics,resources,strategies other captain left. He had the luxury of playing on phattas of UAE where our ftbs glored and our spin attack who was quite exceptional did its job.
 
Mushtaq Mohammad was also a great captain.Imran outshines all though.One of the greatest captains of all.
 
Misbah-ul-Haq is the best test captain of Pakistan
Because he captained Pakistan Test Team when there were allegations of match fixing on Pakistan team and he brought Pakistan cricket team on a winning track
Thus Misbah is the best:misbah
 
Misbah-ul-Haq is the best test captain of Pakistan
Because he captained Pakistan Test Team when there were allegations of match fixing on Pakistan team and he brought Pakistan cricket team on a winning track
Thus Misbah is the best:misbah

Lol @ allegations. Only spot fixing controversy it was, not that as if our team was in a state of war.
 
Great article and couldn't agree more. He's so underrated among Pakistan fans. Admittedly he's had most of his success in the UAE but the dominant force we have become there is largely down to his leadership.

I would love nothing more than for him to win in England and Australia - I think he deserves it.
 
Kudos always to Misbah, took over at a difficult moment. He may, may have eeked out no.1 ranking in tests for Pakistan has Amir and Asif not been banned...
 
Imran Khan

Mushtaq Muhammad

A.H. Kardar

Misbah-ul-Haq

In that order. Until Misbah beats Australia in Australia, England in England, South Africa in South Africa and India in India.
 
Kudos always to Misbah, took over at a difficult moment. He may, may have eeked out no.1 ranking in tests for Pakistan has Amir and Asif not been banned...

He wouldn't have been Captain though.Salman Butt wouldn't have been banned either
 
Misbah-ul-Haq ticks a lot of boxes.


1) Educated 2) Dignified 3)No False Bravado or insecurities 4)Honest 5)Consistent performer 6)Not politically inclined 7) Non-controversial 8) Well-Respected

On that alone Misbah is probably the best thing to happen to Pak cricket in a long time leave alone categorizing him as a batsmen or captain
 
Misbah-ul-Haq ticks a lot of boxes.


1) Educated 2) Dignified 3)No False Bravado or insecurities 4)Honest 5)Consistent performer 6)Not politically inclined 7) Non-controversial 8) Well-Respected

On that alone Misbah is probably the best thing to happen to Pak cricket in a long time leave alone categorizing him as a batsmen or captain
Really?playing for own stats and avgs does untick some boxes?
 
Imran Khan cant even get as many wins as Misbah, so obviously Misbah is the greatest.
 
Those who think misbah is the greatest captain clearly are on the misbah kool aid. The guy led the team twice outside of Asia. Lost to SA 3-0 and even has the 'honor' of losing a test to an associate nation zimbabwe. If misbah is being called as our best test captain than we surely are in the worst timeline of pakistan cricket.
 
Imran Khan cant even get as many wins as Misbah, so obviously Misbah is the greatest.

Rubbish.

Imran played an era where which was dominated by draws whereas Misbah in the present era has played in one where home teams dominate and win matches. Misbah has rarely been tested away home and whenever he has, he has been awful - Whitewashed in SA and couldn't even in Zimbabwe.

Hasn't even been tested in England and Australia, so please take off your misbah tinted specs and get to grips with reality.
 
Rubbish.

Imran played an era where which was dominated by draws whereas Misbah in the present era has played in one where home teams dominate and win matches. Misbah has rarely been tested away home and whenever he has, he has been awful - Whitewashed in SA and couldn't even in Zimbabwe.

Hasn't even been tested in England and Australia, so please take off your misbah tinted specs and get to grips with reality.

UAE is not home. Its a neutral venue
 
UAE is not home. Its a neutral venue

That's the only gain of 3/9 events - Misbah's team won about 12 Tests in UAE - in PAK, 10 of those would have been drawn with PAK dominating, 1 win by PAK & 1 win by a visitor from back door (due to one of few days when they'll get PAK off guard).
 
Slight correction Sul - Misbah had another tour outside Asia to ZIM, which indeed his team avoided a white wash - it ended 1-1.

sir ji please enlighten these kids with your great knowledge about IK leading Pakistan to a successful Windies tour.
 
Blah blah. Same old accusations against Misbah.

if it's accusations then you should accept that Misbah was limited in skills? otherwise there is no logical explanations to Misbah's 80 ball 40-50 runs coming to bat in the late order. Look at Mathews. He leads even worse side,bats at same spot but his numbers are always impressive,almost run a ball and always provides a good finish. 230s was the usual scores under Misbah which were really really worse. He failed as a captain in ODIs and failed as a batsman for me. I do not care about his 40s when it were never effective enough to win us a game. We always relied on Umar Akmal,Afridi,Hafeez's heroics for win.
 
There are probably only some 3-4 people out in PP (including me, MMHS and a few others) who hasn't jumped on the Misbah the test captain bandwagon.

Don't get me wrong.

He is a great guy, a very respectable captain and I really really like him.

But unfortunately, his captaincy gets over-rated to the skies when he is yet to tour overseas more. Comparison with Immy is seriously a joke. Then when he fails, the same media will lay onto him.

Performing in Asia shouldn't be looked down. He has been damn good. But then LOTS of captains have performed in Asia. Its their approach (not the results per se) when they are faced with tough situations that would indicate what kind of a captain they are.

Tactically...team selection wise...Misbah leaves a LOT to be desired.

I am not sold on Misbah the test captain.

He is what Pakistan needed in 2010.

But is he the best Pakistan has had?

Not really.
 
Last edited:
sir ji please enlighten these kids with your great knowledge about IK leading Pakistan to a successful Windies tour.

Wastage of time - IK loses out hands down as all that glitter is gold these days, number doesn't lie. Misbah has won more Tests.
 
There are probably only some 3-4 people out in PP (including me, MMHS and a few others) who hasn't jumped on the Misbah the test captain bandwagon.

Don't get me wrong.

He is a great guy, a very respectable captain and I really really like him.

But unfortunately, his captaincy gets over-rated to the skies when he is yet to tour overseas more. Comparison with Immy is seriously a joke. Then when he fails, the same media will lay onto him.

Performing in Asia shouldn't be looked down. He has been damn good. But then LOTS of captains have performed in Asia. Its their approach (not the results per se) when they are faced with tough situations that would indicate what kind of a captain they are.

Tactically...team selection wise...Misbah leaves a LOT to be desired.

I am not sold on Misbah the test captain.

He is what Pakistan needed in 2010.

But is he the best Pakistan has had?

Not really.

True words, which were never spoken before.

Some people here don't know what was IK, and how he built a team on his own. People are over-rating Misbah because may be the think that he lifted a team who was under controversies, spot fixing scandal e.t.c e.t.c.

Imran Khan had to lead a team that was severely troubled by in-fighting and had in it some players who even refused to speak to each other. In in 1983, he quit cricket for two years due to some injury. And with his exit team once agai crumbled, internal revolts woken up. Khan returned as skipper in 1986.

Imran arrived as a captain with an aggressive plan to turn Pakistan into an attacking side. And then he lifted his team upto no.1 Team in ICC ranking, not only ranking, his team was praised by the whole world.

Pakistan team conditions when Khan took the charge was more worst than the time when Misbah took the charge.

I am not taking away Misbah's achievements, but he is no way near Imran Khan.

And you are asking about 2010 and captaincy options, Misbah was not even in the squad when he was asked to lead. Misbah had made his Test debut in 2002 but was soon dropped. He was recalled to the side five years later in 2007.

In 2010, he was again dropped and was most likely to have remained in obscurity but thanks to spot fixing.

Cricket board requested him to lead the side for the 2011 series against South Africa. It was a one-series-deal, a series played in the UAE.

Board wasn't able to trust those players who were in the squad, as there were some reports of internal fights, so Board went for Misbah.
 
There are probably only some 3-4 people out in PP (including me, MMHS and a few others) who hasn't jumped on the Misbah the test captain bandwagon.

You couldnt be more than wrong than that. There is a majority who does not believes that Misbah is a good captain. Look at this thread for instance. Nothing to feel special about; everyone knows that a captain who loses a test to an associate nation and gets blanked in the only away tour is far from being the best captain of nation with a big legacy in test cricket.
 
if it's accusations then you should accept that Misbah was limited in skills? otherwise there is no logical explanations to Misbah's 80 ball 40-50 runs coming to bat in the late order. Look at Mathews. He leads even worse side,bats at same spot but his numbers are always impressive,almost run a ball and always provides a good finish. 230s was the usual scores under Misbah which were really really worse. He failed as a captain in ODIs and failed as a batsman for me. I do not care about his 40s when it were never effective enough to win us a game. We always relied on Umar Akmal,Afridi,Hafeez's heroics for win.

Let's keep this thread about Tests please?

On topic, don't really agree with the author(s).
 
Imran Khan cant even get as many wins as Misbah, so obviously Misbah is the greatest.

Imran also can't get as many losses as Misbah, so obviously Misbah is the worst. See how stupid your argument sounds?
 
Misbah's contribution to PAK cricket is almost unparalleled - higher than Imran & probably almost at per with Kardar.

He hold the fort at a time when PAK cricket was at it's lowest - fixing, isolation, insights, politics for power/captaincy. PAK had the least controversial 4 years under Misbah - compared to the dark days of 90s & the dog house of 70s, 2000s. A PAK team, in the news paper for wrong reason for 4 weeks was miracle - he kept his house in order for 4 years & still going strong.

Tactically, he is poor - but he is winning lots of Test matches on favourable conditions because of his command & stability of the team. This might be negative in long term as PAK Test team is officially 35 years old, ODI team under him in WC as also almost 35 - he kept his team intact & strong with a known bunch of players for a particular condition. For example, he does know that PAK's top 3 'll be exposed outside Asia (UAE) - but he won't change order or selection over his pal - Azhar/MoHa. Neither he'll drop 40+ years old Babar. Had he been in charge of ODI, Babar Azam would have debuted in 2019, rest never in their life as by the time they reach 35, other players would emerge. BUT, he is indeed winning matches when the chips are in his favour.

This is where the telling difference with Kardar, Imran & Misbah (apart from playing capacity & tactical nuances) - those two carried the legacy of PAK cricket in establishing as a super power (or a dominant new comer) - Misbah consumed the resources for a quick gain. I would rate him for the persona he is in difficult time than anything else - under others, PAK cricket team would have been a laughing stalk on & off the field in every format.
 
You couldnt be more than wrong than that. There is a majority who does not believes that Misbah is a good captain. Look at this thread for instance. Nothing to feel special about; everyone knows that a captain who loses a test to an associate nation and gets blanked in the only away tour is far from being the best captain of nation with a big legacy in test cricket.

Based on past threads also.

Maybe I was wrong with the numbers but not the general idea.
 
Let's keep this thread about Tests please?

On topic, don't really agree with the author(s).

let's talk about tests.
Misbah averages in the low 20s in Sri Lanka,SA,Aus and he is yet to be tested in England this year.
Misbah has 60% runs scored in UAE.
Out of 9 hundreds he has 8 of them in subcontinent and out of them 6 were on UAE's phattas.
 
Even Samaraweera who was known ftb has better stats away home than Misbah. In fact if I'm not wrong he had a very good SA tour.
 
He wouldn't have been Captain though.Salman Butt wouldn't have been banned either

Misbah would've taken over as captain at some point. Salman Butt pre-fixing was appalling as captain. Batted first at Edgbaston when the conditions were a seamer's paradise and then let England come back from 102-7 to score 446 in the deciding Test at Lord's. His form didn't merit a place in the team either.
 
Misbah's contribution to PAK cricket is almost unparalleled - higher than Imran & probably almost at per with Kardar.

He hold the fort at a time when PAK cricket was at it's lowest - fixing, isolation, insights, politics for power/captaincy. PAK had the least controversial 4 years under Misbah - compared to the dark days of 90s & the dog house of 70s, 2000s. A PAK team, in the news paper for wrong reason for 4 weeks was miracle - he kept his house in order for 4 years & still going strong.

Tactically, he is poor - but he is winning lots of Test matches on favourable conditions because of his command & stability of the team. This might be negative in long term as PAK Test team is officially 35 years old, ODI team under him in WC as also almost 35 - he kept his team intact & strong with a known bunch of players for a particular condition. For example, he does know that PAK's top 3 'll be exposed outside Asia (UAE) - but he won't change order or selection over his pal - Azhar/MoHa. Neither he'll drop 40+ years old Babar. Had he been in charge of ODI, Babar Azam would have debuted in 2019, rest never in their life as by the time they reach 35, other players would emerge. BUT, he is indeed winning matches when the chips are in his favour.

This is where the telling difference with Kardar, Imran & Misbah (apart from playing capacity & tactical nuances) - those two carried the legacy of PAK cricket in establishing as a super power (or a dominant new comer) - Misbah consumed the resources for a quick gain. I would rate him for the persona he is in difficult time than anything else - under others, PAK cricket team would have been a laughing stalk on & off the field in every format.

lovely post and well expressed.

I am afraid Misbah will never get the adulation that is reserved for more high-profile colleagues and I am pretty sure he doesnt crave it either.

EVERY person I know who has met him is impressed by him and this article is a mere reflection of that sentiment
 
There have been three great captains of Pakistan. The first was A.H. Kardar, the country’s first Test captain. Born in Lahore, and talent-spotted by the senior Nawab of Pataudi, Kardar played for India before Partition. He led Pakistan to victory over India in its second-ever Test match in Lucknow in 1952, and even more famously over England at the Oval Test in August 1954. Uniquely, Kardar won at least one Test match in Pakistan’s inaugural series against each other country.

Pakistan’s next great captain was Imran Khan, the all-rounder who inspired his country to a famous World Cup victory in 1992, and now has honourable aspirations to become Pakistan’s prime minister.

The third is Misbah-ul-Haq, and he has a claim to be the greatest. On statistics alone his claim is indisputable: 20 wins in 42 Tests as captain. Imran had 14 wins in 48 Tests, Kardar six in 23.

But most importantly, Misbah became captain in the wake of two disasters. The first was the terrorist attack on the Sri Lankan team bus at Lahore in 2009. This incident immediately condemned Pakistan to international isolation. No Test side has visited Pakistan since. Pakistan’s international players have been condemned to a perpetual shuttle between foreign hotel rooms, cut off from extended family and community networks which count for so much in Pakistan. So-called ‘home’ matches are played in the UAE, in echoing deserted stadiums.

The second calamity took place the following year when the Pakistan team toured England. Three of its players, including the captain, Salman Butt, and its brilliant young opening bowler, Mohammad Amir, were entrapped by the News of the World. The team was disgraced and the three players involved were later sent to jail.

At that dark hour, there was reason to doubt the survival of Pakistan cricket. That was when Misbah took over. He was not an obvious choice as captain. He had a mixed Test record, and was not even selected for the 2010 Tour, nor the one before in 2006. He was already 36 — ancient for a modern player.

Yet he proved an inspired choice. He had exactly the right qualities to lead his team at its moment of supreme crisis. He has not only anchored the batting time and time again but given his team a mental and moral example.

In both tasks he has been magnificently supported by his lieutenant Younus Khan, now Pakistan’s highest-scoring Test batsman, although the two men are very different on and off the pitch. Younus is voluble and extrovert and always seems on the move; Misbah is calm and cerebral, measured in speech and motion. They do share an intense patriotism and devotion to their families.

Misbah-ul-Haq was raised in Mianwali, in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (formerly North West Frontier province). He is related to Imran Khan’s father and a member of the same Niazi clan. Both his parents were educators and made him give academic work priority over cricket. He gained an MBA at the University of Management and Technology in Lahore, a qualification which makes him one of the best-educated cricketers in the modern era. His studies of leadership skills and human resource management delayed his entry to the first-class game until he was 24, but have been of lasting value to him as captain.

He is one of those rare cricketers whose Test performance has been massively enhanced by the duties of captaincy. Before 2010, Misbah had scored 1,008 runs in 33 Tests at an average of 33.60. Since becoming Captain, he has scored a further 3,344 runs in 42 Tests, at an average of 56.68.

‘Responsibility,’ Misbah told us, ‘has always given me a lot of confidence to face the music and perform.’

As a Test captain, Misbah has the priceless gift of looking as though he always has a plan on the field. In fact, he usually does. He has gained victories with an inexperienced attack since the loss of his former matchwinner, the spinner Saeed Ajmal, with a suspect action. When he led Pakistan to a 2 - 0 victory over England last winter in the UAE, none of his bowlers had taken 100 Test wickets.

Misbah is now 42. Assuming he captains in the fourth Test at the Oval he will be the oldest Test captain since the mighty Warwick Armstrong of Australia in 1921. He is barely half Armstrong’s 22 stone in weight: he and Younus (aged 38) are reputedly the fittest players in the Pakistan party.

Like his predecessors, Misbah has had clashes with selectors, adminstrators, media and fellow players. His undemonstrative style has sometimes made him undervalued in his own country. However, he commands a personal authority to match Khan, Steve Waugh for Australia or even Sir Frank Worrell in the West Indies.

Again with Younus’s help he should get the best from an exciting Pakistan line-up. Misbah’s most difficult task is to guide Mohammad Amir, still only in his rehabilitation, back into Test cricket. If he succeeds, Amir and his partner, Wahab Riaz, could become one of the best left-arm opening attacks in cricket history.

The other bowling priority will be the legspinner Yasir Shah, returning after a three-month drugs ban, who on his day is a magician to match his predecessors Abdul Qadir and Mushtaq Ahmed. Pakistan’s batting is sketchy. However, Misbah will hope that the strokemakers Mohammad Hafeez, Shan Masood, Azhar Ali, Asad Shafiq and the bouncy wicketkeeper Sarfraz Ahmed can take the strain from himself and Younus.

Misbah and his team will enjoy far more support from British Asian cricket lovers than in their ‘home’ Tests in the UAE. This great man is coming to the end of his career and deserves a farewell to match Don Bradman’s at the Oval 1948. His achievement has been epic. Like Bradman, he has been far more than a simple cricketer. For his six years at the helm of the national team, Misbah has helped to bind Pakistan together as a nation.

http://www.spectator.co.uk/2016/07/why-misbah-ul-haq-is-pakistans-greatest-test-captain/

Beautiful write up - thanks for sharing.
Bhai - do u know who the author is?
Sums how the English see Pakistan - a dichotomy really - some seen as a pariah team from a pariah nation while others see us as volatile mercurial exciting
 
What is your definition of unselfish innings 12(4) kind of knocks?

to be really honest with you Misbah wouldn't have made the team if it wasn't for spot fixing. As a player he was done and dusted in 2009. His limitations as a batsmen were completely exposed and that's why he was dropped. Spot fixing helped him make comeback into test team by leading it which in turn made a way for his ODI comeback. And his limitations were exposed again by Indian team and then again he was dropped. But Afridi-Ijazz butt fiasco led to Afridi's resign which again turned to be another life from God for Misbah ul haq's already dead career. But his another comeback didn't change any thing. In fact things got worse. He developed big ego not only as a player but as a captain as well. He would back players who on merit shouldn't be in the ODI squad at all(players averaging low 20's you know what I mean here) and he would not trust newcomers with good potential(Harris,Amin,Baber Azam,Hammad) and back players were the need of today's cricket(Umar Akmal .etc).

Misbah's captaincy had a lot of fear in it. He always feared to lose. He never wanted to experiment or take chances. He would never give chances to newbies even if results of the series were already decided. He was/is scared of loses because he knew his stay in the team only depended on his captaincy because at this age like Afridi he would find difficult to be picked if his captaincy was taken from him. That's why we saw him showing so much faith in old guns like Younis Khan and his pals like Azhar Ali,Shafiq even in ODIs.

his strike bowlers used to be Gul,Cheema,Junaid,Sohail Tanveer for many years until they got injured/dropped by selectors then Misbah had to try different combinations. He didn't pick Wahab for many years under his captaincy.
 
^^just to add..Misbah was never proactive on the field. Always had preset of plans that he would try to implement no matter what the actual requirements were. He never had any out of the box thinking. You guys can give him all credit for keeping Pakistan controversy free and being successful home but Misbah cannot compete with other captains of Pakistan likes of Imran Khan,Kardar,Mushtaq Mohammad and Wasim. They were both more successful overall and tactically way better than Misbah.
 
The writers of this article have recently published a fantastic book called White on Green. I've only read the first few chapters and am already hooked. A fantastic read.
 
Also comparing and considering the squads, *talented* players both captains had, domestic structure and corruption / sifarish system both captains played under, imo Misbah-ul-Haq has done better.

P.s. Batting and bowling conditions should be considered also.

But most of us haven't seen IK in 80s, except few. Therefore we can't really compare each other.
 
You can blame many things but you cannot blame sifarish. Misbah used the sifarish culture to his full advantage during his tenure. I would just give 4 examples:

1) Ifthikar's mind boggling selection in the squad.
2) Asad Shafiq's continous selection in the ODI squad during his early phase.
3) Azhar's selection as captain.
4) First rehman and now Zulfiqar Babar's continuous selection in the team irrespective of performance.
 
Haters gonn' hate. :misbah

In reality, Imran Khan still has a bit of edge, but Misbah will definitely reach him OR go above IF he's able to win this Test series in England.

Definitely one of the most genius, tactically brilliant Test leaders produced by Pakistan.

Best cricketing brain in the country currently.

Slight correction Sul - Misbah had another tour outside Asia to ZIM, which indeed his team avoided a white wash - it ended 1-1.
Yes I guess it was the ghost of Misbah who led us to a test series win in New Zealamd
On our last tour there
 
If cricket was played on Microsoft Excel and statsguru then yes. However reality is that he isn't.

In his entire captaincy stint he's had to tour away outside of Asia exactly once where we got whooped 3-0.

Imran had to contend with much fiercer away tours which including setting the platform for infamous series victories in England, a feat for any Asian team. Not to mention going head to head and matching toe to toe with the then #1 West Indies in their own den and walking out with respectable team results especially compared to the other teams.

Misbah basically had the flat as a pancake UAE pitches served to him, and just had to let the spinners lose. Doesn't take much tactical thinking or planning to win it in the UAE if you're a subcontinental team.

In terms of integrity and bringing stability to the team he might rank with Imran. But tactically and strategically Imran and Wasim were both superior to him. Wasim is an underrated Pak captain as well.

Had the latter left behind the shady activities, could've led us to some famous victories.
Its mind boggling how people conveniently ignore the series win in NZ lol.

And if winning in home was so easy why didnt our previous captains do that with such regularity?
 
Beautiful write up - thanks for sharing.
Bhai - do u know who the author is?
Sums how the English see Pakistan - a dichotomy really - some seen as a pariah team from a pariah nation while others see us as volatile mercurial exciting

Richard Heller and Peter Oborne.
 
There are probably only some 3-4 people out in PP (including me, MMHS and a few others) who hasn't jumped on the Misbah the test captain bandwagon.

Don't get me wrong.

He is a great guy, a very respectable captain and I really really like him.

But unfortunately, his captaincy gets over-rated to the skies when he is yet to tour overseas more. Comparison with Immy is seriously a joke. Then when he fails, the same media will lay onto him.

Performing in Asia shouldn't be looked down. He has been damn good. But then LOTS of captains have performed in Asia. Its their approach (not the results per se) when they are faced with tough situations that would indicate what kind of a captain they are.

Tactically...team selection wise...Misbah leaves a LOT to be desired.

I am not sold on Misbah the test captain.

He is what Pakistan needed in 2010.

But is he the best Pakistan has had?

Not really.

I think comparing the # of wins is a futile exercise.

Imran sat out quite a few of the 'padding up stats' series' because he just didnt want to minnow bash. For eg. he didnt play against NZ (esp once Hadlee retired ) and generally avoided SL too because he deemed it as a waste of time playing at an inferior level. Javed Miandad captained in his absence mostly and the fact that he has same number of wins as Imran (most being when he was standing in for Imran), means that if IK really wanted he would have def more than the 14 wins. All his wins are against Eng, Aus, WI, Aus and SL (farewell series). He sat out on wins over NZ home and away, Eng at home in 87 and SL in 1985.

So the number of wins comparison will never be a fair metric in this case.

However one must not discount Misbah too. To say that anyone would have won these series' in UAE is not true because our prior captains exactly failed to do that and def with this much domination. Misbah has a well laid out plan which he ensures is followed to the hilt and that deserves credit.
 
btw quite a few factual errors in the original article but generally great read
 
Also comparing and considering the squads, *talented* players both captains had, domestic structure and corruption / sifarish system both captains played under, imo Misbah-ul-Haq has done better.

P.s. Batting and bowling conditions should be considered also.

But most of us haven't seen IK in 80s, except few. Therefore we can't really compare each other.

Except Immy fought for, and hand picked the *talented* players you're referring to, whereas Misbah was a yes man and never had the courage to stand up to the board or management and made do with what he was given. Misbah also never had an eye for talent and preferred experience over exuberance of youth which had been the trademark of Pakistani cricketers. That's why you'll see him opting for Zulfiqar babar and others over players who are young but have potential. Mind you, the domestic structure and corruption you're referring to was present in Immy's era as well, so Idk where you're getting that from.

Add to this, Misbah's played most of his cricket on UAE phattas where it really isn't hard to win and has an atrocious record overseas. Also drew against the "mighty" Zimbos. Compare this to Immy's wins IN England and IN India, and his battles against the greatest team of the 80s, the WIs, Immy is comfortably ahead of Misbah.

People like to bring up that Misbah has the most wins as captain, but conveniently leave out that he's also got the most losses as well. Does that make him the worst captain, then? Of course not.

Don't let your personal hate against Immy the person and/or the politician cloud your judgement over Immy the cricketer.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Except Immy fought for, and hand picked the *talented* players you're referring to, whereas Misbah was a yes man and never had the courage to stand up to the board or management and made do with what he was given. Misbah also never had an eye for talent and preferred experience over exuberance of youth which had been the trademark of Pakistani cricketers. That's why you'll see him opting for Zulfiqar babar and others over players who are young but have potential. Mind you, the domestic structure and corruption/******** system you're referring to was present in Immy's era as well, so Idk where you're getting that from.

Add to this, Misbah's played most of his cricket on UAE phattas where it really isn't hard to win and has an atrocious record overseas. Also drew against the "mighty" Zimbos. Compare this to Immy's wins IN England and IN India, and his battles against the greatest team of the 80s, the WIs, Immy is comfortably ahead of Misbah.

People like to bring up that Misbah has the most wins as captain, but conveniently leave out that he's also got the most losses as well. Does that make him the worst captain, then? Of course not.

Don't let your personal hate against Immy the person and/or the politician cloud your judgement over Immy the cricketer.

As MMHS said Misbah always looked for short term solutions because it would suite him very well to prolong not only his career as well as his captaincy. He used resources like picking Asad,Azhar,YK into ODI squad when he could have go for youngsters and rebuild Pakistan team putting ODI failures aside once for all. He had all the time in the world but he choose not to because Misbah wouldn't have wanted to lose..with young new inexperienced players you always have a chance to lose but it's the long term solution but Misbah recycled same ttfs under his tenure to save his captaincy. The results are being seen right now and I'm really afraid we might see the same in tests. Do not see any replacement ready for Misbah,YK and no solid openers.
 
That's the only gain of 3/9 events - Misbah's team won about 12 Tests in UAE - in PAK, 10 of those would have been drawn with PAK dominating, 1 win by PAK & 1 win by a visitor from back door (due to one of few days when they'll get PAK off guard).

so is it our fault we have been successful in UAE?

THe fact that we get results from a UAE wicket should be appreciated. The fact that we know how to play spin better than everyone should be appreciated. The fact that we know how to take 20 wickets on a UAE wicket should be appreciated. The fact that we are able to chase down High scores in less time should be appreciated.

People talk here as if those wins were walk to the parks, but i have seen all those test games under which Misbah was captain. Every test win we achieved was fought for
 
so is it our fault we have been successful in UAE?

THe fact that we get results from a UAE wicket should be appreciated. The fact that we know how to play spin better than everyone should be appreciated. The fact that we know how to take 20 wickets on a UAE wicket should be appreciated. The fact that we are able to chase down High scores in less time should be appreciated.

People talk here as if those wins were walk to the parks, but i have seen all those test games under which Misbah was captain. Every test win we achieved was fought for
The fact that even an associate team like Zimbabwe makes same team dance to their tunes once they step outside UAE should be...?
 
Well someone who managed to captain Pakistan for 6 long years obviously must have had some leadership qualities to successfully do so. I would actually compare him to Stephen Flemming. He played the Stephen Flemming role for Pakistan Cricket at a crucial time. At the same time there were no other leadership alternatives, Younis Khan is too volatile and should never ever be given any sort of leadership role ever again. Azhar Ali is just a horrible captain so what are the alternatives? Sarfaraz has just come about now and hopefully the PCB will back him to take over in all formats of the game once Misbah retires.

My only complaint against Misbah is his Mohaling nature, the amount of winnable matches we have lost in his tenure, the amount of comfortably drawable matches we have lost, the amount of drawn matches we could have won had he shown more spine cannot be reversed.

The Zimb, SA match in the 2015 WC proved what he could have done and achieved had he allowed the team to go for the kill and play without any fear of losing and it was simply forced because our backs were truly against the wall where we just had no option but to go for the attack to survive.

It is interesting how even more terrible his ODI record would have looked like if he did not have the services of a Pre 15 degree Ajmal and Hafeez.

But i have to admit at the same time, Misbah grew on me gradually. I think the PCB did the right thing in requesting him to stay on as captain till the Pakistan tour of Australia where it is absolutely vital that we have a very experienced leader in charge of the team. But you can tell from his body language these days that he knows that this is his final year in international cricket. I seriously hopes he grooms Sarfaraz to take over from him.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Misbah is a decent captain tactically but a wonderful leader. His influence is not just on the field.

He deserves to sign off on a high, but that ship has sailed unfortunately.

A Pakistani captain cannot hope for a good finish if he is retiring after a tour of England or Australia.
 
The fact that even an associate team like Zimbabwe makes same team dance to their tunes once they step outside UAE should be...?

so what are you trying to say, plz explain?

either pakistan is good or bad in test because 1) they dominate in an away ground like UAE or 2) they lost that 1 game to Zimbabwe, and yet they reached no.2 in rankings
 
if it's accusations then you should accept that Misbah was limited in skills? otherwise there is no logical explanations to Misbah's 80 ball 40-50 runs coming to bat in the late order. Look at Mathews. He leads even worse side,bats at same spot but his numbers are always impressive,almost run a ball and always provides a good finish. 230s was the usual scores under Misbah which were really really worse. He failed as a captain in ODIs and failed as a batsman for me. I do not care about his 40s when it were never effective enough to win us a game. We always relied on Umar Akmal,Afridi,Hafeez's heroics for win.

Yet he outperformed the so called talented & 'future ATGs'....majority of the time. Of course it's Misbah's fault they are flops.
 
Last edited:
A good captain but not as good as imran , imran khan probably was one of the best captain the game has ever seen. Also left us with a team which could easily have dominated for a decade but infighting , politics ,ego , jealousy and matchfixing ruined our decade where we could have won 3 world cups.
 
so is it our fault we have been successful in UAE?

THe fact that we get results from a UAE wicket should be appreciated. The fact that we know how to play spin better than everyone should be appreciated. The fact that we know how to take 20 wickets on a UAE wicket should be appreciated. The fact that we are able to chase down High scores in less time should be appreciated.


People talk here as if those wins were walk to the parks, but i have seen all those test games under which Misbah was captain. Every test win we achieved was fought for


Mai keya ganu aur tabalchi keya bazaraha hai - yaar, why always make word by word meaning of my post?
 
Yes I guess it was the ghost of Misbah who led us to a test series win in New Zealamd
On our last tour there

I am aware of that series - won the 1st Test & decided not to win the second, but still it was good performance.

But, still it doesn't change the ZIM tour.
 
Well someone who managed to captain Pakistan for 6 long years obviously must have had some leadership qualities to successfully do so. I would actually compare him to Stephen Flemming. He played the Stephen Flemming role for Pakistan Cricket at a crucial time. At the same time there were no other leadership alternatives, Younis Khan is too volatile and should never ever be given any sort of leadership role ever again. Azhar Ali is just a horrible captain so what are the alternatives? Sarfaraz has just come about now and hopefully the PCB will back him to take over in all formats of the game once Misbah retires.

My only complaint against Misbah is his Mohaling nature, the amount of winnable matches we have lost in his tenure, the amount of comfortably drawable matches we have lost, the amount of drawn matches we could have won had he shown more spine cannot be reversed.

The Zimb, SA match in the 2015 WC proved what he could have done and achieved had he allowed the team to go for the kill and play without any fear of losing and it was simply forced because our backs were truly against the wall where we just had no option but to go for the attack to survive.

It is interesting how even more terrible his ODI record would have looked like if he did not have the services of a Pre 15 degree Ajmal and Hafeez.

But i have to admit at the same time, Misbah grew on me gradually. I think the PCB did the right thing in requesting him to stay on as captain till the Pakistan tour of Australia where it is absolutely vital that we have a very experienced leader in charge of the team. But you can tell from his body language these days that he knows that this is his final year in international cricket. I seriously hopes he grooms Sarfaraz to take over from him.

Agreed, but he was by far the best available in 2010 to lead the side. After that, his team performed & he individually led from the front - averaged almost 55 as Captain & won several Tests. There was no reason to replace him & no denial of his achievement. Question is had anyone - say MoHa or YK been Captain, would PAK achieved the same? My hunch is - Yes; BUT as a Pakistani, would you had been proud of the team? Probably not - why, if I start to list, I'll miss the Tarabih today. Start from Oval gate to Lord's gate - it's absolute disgrace. At least this guy kept a mad house in check.
 
I think comparing the # of wins is a futile exercise.

Imran sat out quite a few of the 'padding up stats' series' because he just didnt want to minnow bash. For eg. he didnt play against NZ (esp once Hadlee retired ) and generally avoided SL too because he deemed it as a waste of time playing at an inferior level. Javed Miandad captained in his absence mostly and the fact that he has same number of wins as Imran (most being when he was standing in for Imran), means that if IK really wanted he would have def more than the 14 wins. All his wins are against Eng, Aus, WI, Aus and SL (farewell series). He sat out on wins over NZ home and away, Eng at home in 87 and SL in 1985.

So the number of wins comparison will never be a fair metric in this case.

However one must not discount Misbah too. To say that anyone would have won these series' in UAE is not true because our prior captains exactly failed to do that and def with this much domination. Misbah has a well laid out plan which he ensures is followed to the hilt and that deserves credit.

UAE is a fortress for Pakistan due to their style of play and players.

Dhoni (the much ridiculed test captain) has only lost 1 series at home (that too when 4 out of 7 batsmen were over the hill and his strike bowler went missing).

21 tests won. 3 tests lost. 6 drawn.

Absolute brutal dominance. Those are ATG stats.

Now is he a great test captain?

Kohli replaced him and won 2 series right away.

90s....India were rubbish but unbeatable at home.

Its not because of captaincy but because of the right team. The venue UAE fits Pakistan more perfectly than venue Pakistan. If you take a look at a lot of Asian captains with home records, you will see awesome stats.
 
Last edited:
Imran Khan

Mushtaq Muhammad

A.H. Kardar

Misbah-ul-Haq

In that order. Until Misbah beats Australia in Australia, England in England, South Africa in South Africa and India in India.

That's unfair given the fact that no Asian captain in history (and probably any captain) has such a record.
 
However one must not discount Misbah too. To say that anyone would have won these series' in UAE is not true because our prior captains exactly failed to do that and def with this much domination. Misbah has a well laid out plan which he ensures is followed to the hilt and that deserves credit.

Would Imran be regarded in the same vein if he had not won tests overseas?
 
Its mind boggling how people conveniently ignore the series win in NZ lol.

And if winning in home was so easy why didnt our previous captains do that with such regularity?

Yeah I missed the NZ series, but also missed the Zimbabwe 1-1 series :odoyo

For the point about how I said it doesn't take much to win on UAE tracks with a good spin attack, I guess I put it too bluntly. What I meant to say is that you're not really tested much on UAE tracks to think outside the box as a subcon captain to outsmart the opposition. Winning in home at Pakistan is different to winning at home in the UAE. Pakistan is a place where you have to outbat the opposition into submission with wonderful flat tracks to cash in on as a batsman (trend throughouts the 00's). If we were still allowed to play in Pakistan then I highly doubt Misbah's stellar record in the UAE would've been as stellar in Pak. Our batting in tests bar Sarfraz and Hafeez is ultra defensive and in Pakistan you need an Aussie like line-up or the new English line-up with guys like Warner, Stokes, Bairstow to cash-in and put the other team under a mountain of runs at 3+ RPO. Ofc this isn't the case anymore as with the lack of intl cricket the grounds have been laid to rot and have become a joke.

In UAE as you saw in the 1st test vs England, the pitch had a ton of runs and were ran incredibly close when we got bowled out 2nd innings and we got lucky England's chase to 99 got cut short. Admittedly, Yasir's omission cost us as well.

Tactically he isn't a simpleton like my original post may have sent out this vibe. He's decent in that regard, but more than that he has been one of the best captains in bringing the team together and making it play as a unit, I'll give that to him.

Having said that, he hasn't exactly done something extraordinary to be considered the best EVER by Pakistan, but can definitely make a case for 2nd or 3rd best.
 
Last edited:
True words, which were never spoken before.

Some people here don't know what was IK, and how he built a team on his own. People are over-rating Misbah because may be the think that he lifted a team who was under controversies, spot fixing scandal e.t.c e.t.c.

Imran Khan had to lead a team that was severely troubled by in-fighting and had in it some players who even refused to speak to each other. In in 1983, he quit cricket for two years due to some injury. And with his exit team once agai crumbled, internal revolts woken up. Khan returned as skipper in 1986.

Imran arrived as a captain with an aggressive plan to turn Pakistan into an attacking side. And then he lifted his team upto no.1 Team in ICC ranking, not only ranking, his team was praised by the whole world.

Pakistan team conditions when Khan took the charge was more worst than the time when Misbah took the charge.

I am not taking away Misbah's achievements, but he is no way near Imran Khan.

And you are asking about 2010 and captaincy options, Misbah was not even in the squad when he was asked to lead. Misbah had made his Test debut in 2002 but was soon dropped. He was recalled to the side five years later in 2007.

In 2010, he was again dropped and was most likely to have remained in obscurity but thanks to spot fixing.

Cricket board requested him to lead the side for the 2011 series against South Africa. It was a one-series-deal, a series played in the UAE.

Board wasn't able to trust those players who were in the squad, as there were some reports of internal fights, so Board went for Misbah.

correction plz he was asked to lead in 2010 series not 2011
 
More wins then IMran, and in less numbers of games i think

keep crying, but Misbah is the best and he has crossed Miandad and Imran both, dig in the stats

Going by your logic Misbah is also a better batsman than Saeed Anwar, Zaheer Abbas and Salim Malik because he averages higher?

Look how stupid you sound now...
 
Major,

More wins in less matches doesn't automatically mean the better captain.

Cricket isn't played on excel.
 
Back
Top