Your Top 10 Test all-rounders of all-time

Ted123

Tape Ball Regular
Joined
Sep 26, 2017
Runs
552
The definition of all rounder is someone who has the ability to simultaneously deliver performances with both bat and ball.

Very few in the game have got the ability to win matches and series with their secondary discipline but those are widely regarded as among the best ever. Here is my list for the top 10 test all rounders of all-time.

1. Garfield Sobers - Regarded as absolute genius of the game, one of the greatest batsman of all-time and a game changer with bowl also, can bowl pace and spin both and a great captain. Undoubtedly, a GOAT of the game.

2. Imran Khan - One of the best ever fast bowlers who revolutionized reverse swing and was a technically proficient batsman with a match winning knock in World Cup Final 1992 in winning cause as well. With an average of 22 with bowl and 37 with bat, he has a strong case to be regarded as GOAT all rounder. Alongwith that, one of the all time great captains of the game.

3. Jacques Kallis - The greatest South African cricketer of all-time and also their greatest test batsman who mastered runs-scoring in all conditions, be it pace or spin. His numbers with bat or bowl speaks for himself but alongwith that, he was also the player of tournament in the only ICC tournament that South Africa have won.

4. Ian Botham - Arguably the best ever genuine all rounder for a substantial period(1978-1983). Match winner with both bat and bowl and probably good enough to get into most sides on either of the two suits.

5. Keith Miller - Much like Sobers, a genius in true sense with amazing ability with both bat and bowl. Another player who would get into most sides with both bat and bowl.

Apart from these 5, some of the other names who have a genuinely strong case are:-

Kapil Dev
Tony Greig
Chris Cairns
Ben Stokes
Shakib/ Jadeja
 
In white ball cricket

1. Andrew Flintoff
2. Abdul Razzaq
3. Shakib Al Hassan
4. Shahid Afridi
5. Ben Stokes
6. Brett Lee (awesome number 8)
7. Shaun Pollock
9. Jacque Kallis
10. Angelo Mathews
 
In white ball cricket

1. Andrew Flintoff
2. Abdul Razzaq
3. Shakib Al Hassan
4. Shahid Afridi
5. Ben Stokes
6. Brett Lee (awesome number 8)
7. Shaun Pollock
9. Jacque Kallis
10. Angelo Mathews

Honourable mentions:

-Wasim Akram
-Sanath Jaysuriya
-Shane Watson
 
In white ball cricket

1. Andrew Flintoff
2. Abdul Razzaq
3. Shakib Al Hassan
4. Shahid Afridi
5. Ben Stokes
6. Brett Lee (awesome number 8)
7. Shaun Pollock
9. Jacque Kallis
10. Angelo Mathews

You are in the wrong thread. He said test all rounders
 
Tests
1 Imran
2 Miller
3 Botham
4 Kapil
5 Kallis
6 Sobers
7 Jadeja
8 Shakib
9 Pollock / Cairns
10 Vettori

Stokes is a poor bowler to consider a pure all-rounder while Hadlee was below average with bat.

ODIs
1 Shakib
2 Klusener
3 Kapil
4 Flintoff
5 Pollock
6 Imran
7 Watson
8 Razzaq
9 Kallis
10 Bravo
 
My Test all rounders

1. Flintoff
2. Daylight
3. Shane Warne
4. Shahid Afridi
5. Jacque Kallis
6. Kumar Sangakara
7. Shaun Pollock
8. Daniel Vettori
9. Patrick Cummins
10. Benjamin Stokes

Legendary players who I never saw play but I will claim to have knowledge about

1. Ian Botham
2. Imran Khan
3. Kapil Dev
 
And here is the most awaited list of test all rounders :-

1. Garfield Sobers
2. Imran Khan
3. Jacques Kallis
4. Ian Botham
5. Kapil Dev
6. Richard Hadlee
7. Ravichandran Ashwin
8. Ravindra Jadeja
9. Rishabh Pant
10. Chris Cairns
 
Player Mat Runs Bat Av 100 Wkts Bowl Av 5W Avg Diff Wks Per Mat 100 per match
GS Sobers (WI) 93 8032 57.78 26 235 34.03 6 23.74 2.53 0.2796
JH Kallis (ICC/SA) 166 13289 55.37 45 292 32.65 5 22.71 1.76 0.2711
Imran Khan (PAK) 88 3807 37.69 6 362 22.81 23 14.88 4.11 0.0682
KR Miller (AUS) 55 2958 36.97 7 170 22.97 7 13.99 3.09 0.1273
RA Jadeja (IND) 65 2706 35.6 3 268 24.28 12 11.31 4.12 0.0462
SM Pollock (SA) 108 3781 32.31 2 421 23.11 16 9.19 3.90 0.0185
TL Goddard (SA) 41 2516 34.46 1 123 26.22 5 8.23 3.00 0.0244
AW Greig (ENG) 58 3599 40.43 8 141 32.2 6 8.23 2.43 0.1379
Shakib Al Hasan (BAN) 66 4454 39.07 5 233 31.06 19 8 3.53 0.0758
MA Noble (AUS) 42 1997 30.25 1 121 25 9 5.25 2.88 0.0238
IT Botham (ENG) 102 5200 33.54 14 383 28.4 27 5.14 3.75 0.1373
Sir RJ Hadlee (NZ) 86 3124 27.16 2 431 22.29 36 4.86 5.01 0.0233
CL Cairns (NZ) 62 3320 33.53 5 218 29.4 13 4.13 3.52 0.0806
BA Stokes (ENG) 94 5756 35.75 12 196 32.1 4 3.64 2.09 0.1277
W Rhodes (ENG) 58 2325 30.19 2 127 26.96 6 3.22 2.19 0.0345
R Ashwin (IND) 92 3129 26.97 5 474 23.93 32 3.04 5.15 0.0543
N Kapil Dev (IND) 131 5248 31.05 8 434 29.64 23 1.4 3.31 0.0611
JO Holder (WI) 62 2744 29.5 3 155 28.8 8 0.7 2.50 0.0484
TE Bailey (ENG) 61 2290 29.74 1 132 29.21 5 0.52 2.16 0.0164
MW Tate (ENG) 39 1198 25.48 1 155 26.16 7 -0.67 3.97 0.0256
IK Pathan (IND) 29 1105 31.57 1 100 32.26 7 -0.68 3.45 0.0345
MH Mankad (IND) 44 2109 31.47 5 162 32.32 8 -0.84 3.68 0.1136
A Flintoff (ENG/ICC) 79 3845 31.77 5 226 32.78 3 -1.01 2.86 0.0633
CR Woakes (ENG) 45 1675 27.91 1 130 30.73 4 -2.82 2.89 0.0222
DL Vettori (ICC/NZ) 113 4531 30 6 362 34.36 20 -4.36 3.20 0.0531

My List
=====

1. Sobers (best batting AR)
2. Imran (best bowling AR)
3. Kallis (2nd best batting AR)
4. Miller (2nd best bowling AR)
5. Bothom (best peak AR)

Rest is pretty subjective , ill go with
6. Kapil
7. Grieg
8. Hadlee
9. Jadeja
10. Stokes
 
There is no GOAT AR or bowler in cricket. Bradman is the only GOAT in cricket.

Imran, Botham, Kapil are all the same stature players. Arguments could be made for all of them being better than others in certain aspects.

Imran’s bowling average is remarkable
Ian Botham at his peak was phenomenal AR
Kapil had a different gear in him as a batter and reserved his best for the West Indies.

Sobers is more Pollockish or Ashwinish as an all rounder. This will hurt some but it’s true.
 
Back
Top