What's new

“What is playing without fear?” : Julien Fountain

Saj

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Jun 1, 2001
Runs
96,141
Writing in his exclusive blog for PakPassion.net, the former Pakistan fielding coach Julien Fountain, attempts to put some context and meaning on the often used term "playing without fear" which is used by coaches, players and fans alike.


shehzad_disappointed.jpg


If you followed the latest installment of the cricket World Cup, no doubt you will have heard this phrase uttered by a plethora of individuals. It was a message delivered by captains, coaches, pundits and journalists on a daily basis. But what exactly does it mean to a player, and how exactly do you “Play without fear?”

I lost track of the amount of times I heard “We need to play without fear” during a pre match press conference or “they played without fear” in the post match media interactions. So what does it mean, and why are some teams able to play without fear whilst others conversely seem to play paralyzed with fear?

During my twenty years in professional and international cricket I have heard this phrase both in team meetings prior to games and post match media debriefs more times than I can count. It is one of those cliched sound bites that are the stock and trade of anybody responsible for talking to the media, explaining how their team is either going to play or should have played.

But what does it mean? Well, we can separate the three words and define each one literally using the dictionary definition.

“Play” (a Verb): to occupy oneself in (a sport or diversion); amuse oneself in (a game) (transitive) to contend against (an opponent) in a sport or game - to fulfil or cause to fulfil (a particular role) in a team game (transitive) - to address oneself to (a ball) in a game

“Without” (preposition): not having, not accompanied by, not making use of.

“Fear” (Noun): a feeling of distress, apprehension, or alarm caused by impending danger, pain, - reverence, awe, concern, anxiety,
(Verb) to be afraid to do something, or of somebody

But how does this possibly relate to cricket, and specifically batting, as this is where we often hear it said? It was used in reference to both Pakistan’s batting and bowling on more than one occasion during the World Cup. I believe it was also used in reference to New Zealand’s world cup performances, but in a somewhat different context.

If a batsman swings wildly at a delivery and is bowled or caught out, is that a good thing or a bad thing? Do the captain, coach, fans and media think it's OK or does the player need to be chastised for being reckless and bringing the team’s ultimate performance level down? Nobody is condoning a reckless attitude, but if a player is to truly play without fear, surely we have to know what it is that they are afraid of. Is it the internal feeling that he could have done so much better? Is it the verbal dressing down from the captain or the coach? Is it the public humiliation from the media or the negative interaction with the fans?

Personally I think it is a combination of all of the above. Both Pakistan fans and media are the first to punish a player for being reckless and inconsiderate, playing a rash shot at an inappropriate time, thus causing the ultimate downfall of the team. Surely these are the same people that are telling the players to play without fear. How can a player hear one message and believe it, if the very people sending the message turn on them at the first sign of things not going smoothly?

If you view New Zealand’s World Cup campaign, you can see a team that “Played without fear” in all departments. They were successful, most of the time, and, despite a few hiccups along the way, were lauded by fans and media alike throughout the tournament. Is this more a reflection of how a team's performance is perceived, rather than how it is executed? One team is labelled as irresponsible and of poor quality (because the results were negative) and another is praised and held aloft as champions (because their results were generally positive).

I guess what I am trying to say is, it is easy to make statements after the fact. That massive top edge that for one player carries for six, but the next player it gets caught by an outfielder. Same ball, same shot, different outcome. One player is derided for being reckless; one is complimented for being positive. Go figure!

Personally I believe that a player should try not be weighed down by too many thoughts or too much external pressure. The game situation itself will provide more than enough pressure; let's not create bucket loads of external pressures in addition to that. Yes we want the player to do well, but if the player walks to the wicket dreading what is to be written about them in the following mornings papers, he is already facing an internal battle that most of us would struggle to win. And that’s before a ball has even been bowled at him! Providing he has been properly prepared technically, physically, mentally and tactically; all we can hope for is some sound professional judgement coupled with a bit of good fortune. The rest is down to fate.

In conclusion, I think there is a collective duty of all concerned; player, captain, coach, fans and media, to ensure that the player has the best possible chance of success each and every time they step out to the wicket. Some days it will go well, some days it won’t. Remember Rome wasn’t built in a day!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Pakistani fans are clamoring for a foreign Coach and we had this guy and we lost him! :facepalm:

#Irony!
 
Great article by JF.

I miss Fountain :( ,he was a quality coach, and our fielding improved leaps and bounds under him.
 
The strangest thing about the Julien Fountain debacle by the PCB is that the guy was ready and willing to carry on working with or without Dav Whatmore, yet the PCB let him go.

A very strange decision !
 
"Personally I believe that a player should try not be weighed down by too many thoughts or too much external pressure. The game situation itself will provide more than enough pressure; let's not create bucket loads of external pressures in addition to that. Yes we want the player to do well, but if the player walks to the wicket dreading what is to be written about them in the following mornings papers, he is already facing an internal battle that most of us would struggle to win. And that’s before a ball has even been bowled at him!"

I think more than morning papers, now its a whole different scenario. With majority of players using social media, the 'hate' can be directed towards them and the trolls think they succeeded. The amount of memes that gets generated minutes within a Tamim Iqbal duck, or a drop catch by a fielder -- the players would rather have morning papers dissect their performance than some keyboard warriors making a meme that goes viral.
 
A very nice read.


Our fielding standard went down a lot after julien fountain was let go. Pakistan need to find a ground between tuk tuks :misbah and four every ball :uakmal and thats how normal batsmen play.
 
Well spotted. Probably showing my age by forgetting that Twitter, Blogs, Internet News Sites, are where people read everything first now, not news papers. Come to think of it I cannot remember the last time I actually bought a news paper!
 
If batsman is aggressive and it works (Dhawan in CT 2013), its called fearless batting.
If a batsman is aggressive and it flops (Dhawan sometime before WC 2015), its called being a hack.

If a captain makes an unorthodox move and it works, its called street smartness.
If a captain makes an unorthodox move and it flops, its called cluelessness.

If a batsman steps out of crease and smashes a bowler to break the shackles, its called innovative batting.
If a batsman steps out of crease and gets out while trying to break the shackles, its called irresponsible batting.

If a batsman is aggressive, he is a match winner (even if he performs once in 10/20 games).
If a batsman is not aggressive, he is a coward (even if he performs in every other game).

If a team tries out different combinations for different conditions and wins, its called inspired selections.
If a team tries out different combinations for different conditions and loses, its called inconsistent selections.

And so it goes on....
 
Julian is a great fielding coach.. the best fielding coach Bangladesh has had.
Fully agree with the point he made although the article feels a little stretched (well written none the less). Was not aware of this particular talent of his.
 
The play without fear is a nice slogan as JF puts it - a marketing man's dream as long as the player succeeds as was the case with Afridi at some point. But a few failures and the same play without fear becomes a joke.

To some on this forum, players like Afridi or Umar Akmal represent the very essence of the concept.
To some on this forum, players like Misbah are the exact opposite of above.

Who really succeeds in their style of play is something we can judge by stats.

The answer is not that simple!
 
First of...i dont rate this guy very highly. in my opinion not a good fielding coach.. but i guess what he is saying i do agree to a certain extend. But i think playing without first comes down to playing with a positive intent withoug being reckless!

It's the players who at the end of the day (when they perform) get all the acknowlegdment, adoration, respect, fame and money. There is a flipside to it, they just have to deal with it or find something else to do.
 
First of...i dont rate this guy very highly. in my opinion not a good fielding coach.. but i guess what he is saying i do agree to a certain extend. But i think playing without first comes down to playing with a positive intent withoug being reckless!

It's the players who at the end of the day (when they perform) get all the acknowlegdment, adoration, respect, fame and money. There is a flipside to it, they just have to deal with it or find something else to do.


Care to expand upon that . . .
 
Care to expand upon that . . .

Probably thinks you're the current coach Julian.

Being completely blunt and sincere when I say you did a marvellous job at trying to achieve the impossible.

There was a marked improvement particularly in the ground fielding and overall intensity.

I'll join the crowd and politely ask you to get off the internet and get yourself back to pakistan!
 
PHP:
Care to expand upon that . . .

Sure...

let me start of by saying this is all my personal opinion. I've never met you. But I am a huge baseball fan, and have played baseball my entire life, and i do understand why someone would want to include aspects from baseball in cricket! Having said that, let me tell you why i think you're not a good coach.

During your stint as fielding coach for Pakistan i didn't see any improvement in fielding. Guys that are known for their nimbleness, agility and speed did field ok, but they were fielding ok before you came. Overall team performance wasn't improved (in my opinion). Neither the 'weaker' fielders nor the 'good' fielders got any better.

I'll be blunt. I think you had a very negative effect on the pak team and I don't consider you to be a team man. I think the only team you represent is team Julien. In my opinion, the (fielding) coach should be in the background. And not try to hogg the attention for himself. After every catch you were seen gesturing with your thumbs up and giving approving nodds... As if to say, 'that's my hard work that's paying off.' Maybe you were just engouraging the lot. Honestly i don't know. Initially i was inclined to give you the benefit of the doubt.

That changed when i read your tweet after a horrible fielding display where you said 'You can lead a horse to water, but you cannot force it to drink.' I was shocked, if you did that to me after a match, and you were my fielding coach. I wouldn't stand for it. I would question the motives of a guy who was airing our teams dirty laundry to the world. It was like, you were trying to vindicate yourself by putting the blame on the players.

Even if it was true. Even if you felt that the guys weren't giving their 100%...Is putting that on twitter really the right move? Isn't it your job to get them motivated? If i go to work tomorrow and don't do a proper job. I can't get away with saying. 'Hey you know what...I can't force the horse to drink, if it doesn't want to'...My name plate will be removed from my office door within 5 minutes lol.

But like I said...This is all my personal opinion. I've never met you, nor do I have any idea of your training methods. My coaching experience consists of coaching baseball to kids of age 12. So I have no idea about the pressure etc you have to deal with. But you asked for me to elaberate, so i did!
 
Is this what fearless batting is supposed to be? (Bangladesh openers vs Pakistan)
 
Seems like quite a difference between the Pakistan Test side and the one day side.

Difficult to understand why the huge difference in levels of performance.
 
With all talk about 'fear' by Mickey Arthur, maybe time to re-read JF's views
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-partner="tweetdeck"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Former Pakistan fielding coach Julien Fountain "I would love the opportunity to work with the Pakistan squad for the upcoming tour of England" <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/ENGvPAK?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#ENGvPAK</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/Cricket?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#Cricket</a></p>— Saj Sadiq (@Saj_PakPassion) <a href="https://twitter.com/Saj_PakPassion/status/1270772223004020737?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">June 10, 2020</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
Back
Top