A question to every Muslim poster regarding Kashmir and Palestine

[Hitman]

This is in no way a disrespectful thread. I repeat, no disrespect intended. But I want to know from Muslim posters from Pakistan, Bangladesh and elsewhere on PP regarding something. I'll keep it simple.

You have to pick one among them, just one -

1. Referendum in Indian Kashmir.

2. Liberation of Palestine.

What would be your pick and why?​

 

[sweep_shot]

Both should be free.

In terms of importance, Palestine ranks higher I guess because Jerusalem contains Al-Aqsa mosque.

 

[Hitman]

Both should be free.

In terms of importance, Palestine ranks higher I guess because Jerusalem contains Al-Aqsa mosque.

You have to pick one among them, just one -
​

 

[sweep_shot]

You have to pick one among them, just one -
​

Palestine obviously. 2 reasons:

1) Palestinians are in worse situations. It is a bigger emergency.

2) Al-Aqsa mosque (third holiest site in Islam).

There is a reason why you see global protests for Palestine but you don't see such protests for other groups (even though other groups are important too).

 

[Bhaijaan]

What’s the point of this thread?

 

[DeadlyVenom]

Why restrict the choice to one lol are you the headmaster of people's choices?

 

[RexRex]

What’s the point of this thread?

i'd like to know as well.

 

[Hitman]

What’s the point of this thread?

To know whether Kashmir holds dearer to the heart of Muslim posters or Palestine.

 

[Hitman]

No offence, but what Pakistan has gone through because of Kashmir including wars, it would be absured for them to pick Palestine.

 

[Devadwal]

Both wishes are never going to happen.

 

[RexRex]

This non-muslim would like to see a referendum in Balochistan.

 

[Hitman]

Both wishes are never going to happen.

Any sensible person would know that. But the question is what would they choose given a choice.

 

[sweep_shot]

Both wishes are never going to happen.

Never say never.

 

[Devadwal]

Any sensible person would know that. But the question is what would they choose given a choice.

You know the answer . But does it matter? Absolutely not

 

[Hitman]

You know the answer . But does it matter? Absolutely not

I don't. They cry equally for both the causes.

 

[sweep_shot]

Why are Indians so obsessed with Muslims?

They act like Muslims owe them explanations.

 

[Hitman]

Why are Indians so obsessed with Muslims?

They act like Muslims owe them explanations.

Why are Muslims so concerned about Hindus in India? Almost every other thread on the Time Pass section is on India and Hindutva.

 

[Suleiman]

Palestine. Ordained by God. Jerusalem aka Al Quds is the 3rd holiest site in Islam.

Any Muslim who says otherwise has no knowledge on their own faith.

Ofc we want Kashmir free, but if we are talking about the importance between those 2, it’s a no brainer as a Muslim.

 

[RexRex]

Palestine. Ordained by God. Jerusalem aka Al Quds is the 3rd holiest site in Islam.

It's only the 3rd holiest in Islam. For Jews and Christians, it is THE holiest land. So, who is the land more important to ?

 

[Local.Dada]

Here is a reference sheet @Hitman from my understanding.

Hamas- Freedom fighters
RSS/ BJP- terrorists
Kashmiri Mujahideen- Freedom fighters
BLA - terrorists
TTP- bad terrorists misguided and split from the good terrorists (real Taliban)
Taliban- good humans turned bad terrorists
Osama - Shaheed
ISIS- after super verbal gymnastics on their motto usually consensus is they are terrorists

 

[Farhan The Man]

Palestine. Ordained by God.

Not true.

Prove it with "godly" text.

Else you are innovating. god.

 

[Suleiman]

It's only the 3rd holiest in Islam. For Jews and Christians, it is THE holiest land. So, who is the land more important to ?

Islam, because it’s the truth.

 

[Suleiman]

Not true.

Prove it with "godly" text.

Else you are innovating. god.

Done many, many times over the course of 1400 years. If you really care, look it up. Not here to spoon feed you.

 

[rickroll]

My answer based on reality - Declare current LOC as the international border, and Pakistan declare Azad Kashmir as part of Pakistan. This helps divert some of the military spend towards economic growth. Anything outside of this solution is pure fantasy by either side at this point.

Palestine - Happy to provide moral support but not happy if it involves diverting any of Pakistan's resources for the cause.

 

[Farhan The Man]

Done many, many times over the course of 1400 years. If you really care, look it up. Not here to spoon feed you.

So no ordainment by god then.

Your personal narrative is not a "godly" prescription.

Surely you misspoke in jest.

 

[Suleiman]

So no ordainment by god then.

Your personal narrative is not a "godly" prescription.

Surely you misspoke in jest.

Here’s the thing. I have seen your posts on Islam in this forum. And from what I can tell you just want to argue with your misinformed opinions on things you can easily look up in the Quran and Hadith (if you’re Muslim yourself)

And if you’re not Muslim, the Quran and the rulings and miracles within it as well as the teachings of the Prophet PBUH in the Hadith and the explanation and actual practice of the above by his companions are a click away in this day and age.

If you really care about gaining knowledge, put a little effort in if your intention is genuine, and you will find your answers. You can visit a local mosque if you’d like as well. It’s not my responsibility to do that for you.

If you’re here to just argue about your opinion, I really don’t care. I am fully at peace with Islam as my religion, submitting to Allah, and following the teachings of Prophet Muhammad PBUH. Ramadan isn’t the time for me to get into arguments

 

[topspin]

Here’s the thing. I have seen your posts on Islam in this forum. And from what I can tell you just want to argue with your misinformed opinions on things you can easily look up in the Quran and Hadith (if you’re Muslim yourself)

And if you’re not Muslim, the Quran and the rulings and miracles within it as well as the teachings of the Prophet PBUH in the Hadith and the explanation and actual practice of the above by his companions are a click away in this day and age.

If you really care about gaining knowledge, put a little effort in if your intention is genuine, and you will find your answers. You can visit a local mosque if you’d like as well. It’s not my responsibility to do that for you.

If you’re here to just argue about your opinion, I really don’t care. I am fully at peace with Islam as my religion, submitting to Allah, and following the teachings of Prophet Muhammad PBUH. Ramadan isn’t the time for me to get into arguments

As mentioned in another thread, it's best to ignore this guy. He was banned under his previous account(s) and he's now coming after Islam because he's got a problem with the mods.

 

[Farhan The Man]

Ramadan isn’t the time for me to get into arguments

That's a cop out.

You were found to inaccurately speak on behalf of your "god".

I have sufficient madrassah time under my belt to identify antagonistic utterings from a society who are at "peace". Supposedly.