Here is an old report regarding this issue from another cricket related site:
http://clubinfo.pk/articles/1089.php?No=1089
The controversial : Arsal Sheikh
Arsal Sheikh has been a controversy since last year Under 19 World Cup
Pakistan Cup is the new hype created by Pakistan Cricket Board right after Pakistan Super League. The tournament will be based on 50-over format starting from 1st May 2016 in Faisalabad.
While the success of this tournament can be subjected to its outcomes, certain discrepencies are being questioned by Cricket Celebrities regarding a clear case of nepotism revealed lately. An Under-19 player from Islamabad region, named Arsal Sheikh has been selected in the drafting phase. He was picked by Federal Region being led by Misbah ul Haq.
Our whistleblowers have informed us about the fact that Arsal Sheikh is son of Shakeel Sheikh who is president of the Islamabad Regional Cricket Association (IRCA) .
This is not the first time when the young man has been treated in a special way. Arsal Sheikh was noticed for the first time for getting selected in Under 19 World Cup last year despite of having controversial performance. Interestingly, since he was not part of One Day tournament, there is no supporting evidence of his positive performance thus supressing many others having one. He is known to have participated in 3 day tournament though, with a rank of 251 players on Batting Chart; not to mention 251 is way lesser then the total players being selected for the drafting phase. Here's the glimpse of Arsal's career:
Batting
3 Matches
5 Innings
1 NO
18 Total Runs
9 Hightest
4.50 Avg
Bowling
3 Matches
333 Balls
7 Maidens
219 Runs
9 Wickets
24.33 Avg
37.00 Strike Rate
3.95 Econ
Muhammad Arsal Sheikh was selected by Basit Ali & Ali Naqvi who were heading Junior Selection Committee. Many senior cricketers showed their discontent on this nepotism based selection policy and have already recorded their protest on social media.
Abdur Rauf Khan, Test cricketer was furious and updated his status as "I strongly condemn the selection of Shakeel Shaikh's son in under19 World Cup, which is a worst example of nepotism and corruption set by PCB and it's so called selection committee, the boy has no talent nor he has done any thing special in on going under 19 domestic cricket his performance below average even not in 200 players . A sheer negligence from PCB officials which will not only effect the future of young talented players but demoralise them as well,government should take notice deserving player must be included and culprits must be brought into justice."
Umair Masood and Zeeshan Malik are known Under 19 young blood from Rawalpindi & Chakwal respectively with way much better performance than Arsal Sheikh and yet being ignored on the main event. This is one of the biggest reason why Pakistan is no more having quality players.
Speaking of the stats for last years's Under 19 World Cup, it's pretty evident that Arsal Sheikh was nowhere standing as a candidate for Pakistan Cup.
Hasan Mohsin 293 runs, 11 wkts
Zeeshan Malik 225 runs
Umair Masood 150 runs
Shadab Khan 11 wkts
Arsal Sheikh 1 wkt
Few of his supporters (obviously the father and the uncle) are backing Arsal Sheikh with a stance that Islamabad Region has no name other than Arsal right now. Fact or not, this should be considered as a serious dilemma that after Rao Iftikhar , for almost a decade, only Imad Wasim as a pure Islamabad player was able to come up in international lime light. Not to ignore the fact, Islamabad is a separate region having number of grounds and facilities for the players - even more than Rawalpindi - is unable to produce any quality player who can be named for the selection. Should we consider it as an internal politics by Shakeel Sheikh for his son? The dots are here and audience is witty enough to connect them !
Talking about Pakistan Cup, during the drafting it was said that when selection from Under 19 slot came, Skipper Misbah looked uncomfortable and left the hall whereas Coaches was the one who wrote his name and gave it to the PCB authorities.
The social media including the journalists and ex-cricketers are putting their views for the selection of Arsal Sheikh. Until the board doesnt gets rid of people who have made regions their kingdom and are bringing their family on the posts, the merit will be killed and ultimately Pakistan Cricket will suffer in forth coming years.
***Update : Shadab has been included in Pakistan Cup.