What's new

Asia Cup likely to take a hit as BCCI plans cricket at home

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
218,133
MUMBAI: The BCCI is all set to once again turn its back on the Asia Cup this year.

The tournament, which was postponed last year because of the pandemic and the global lockdown, is once again in crisis - one that doesn't just put the Asian Cricket Council (ACC) and cricket boards from the sub-continent in distress.

Abandonment of another Asia Cup will result in broadcasters sweating because it puts the highly-rated and financially benefitting 'India versus Pakistan' clash out of gear once again. Outside of an ICC event, in the present environment, an Asia Cup would be the only tournament guaranteeing an India vs Pakistan game(s).

Empathy for the broadcasters will mean the likelihood of BCCI making it up for them elsewhere. South Africa's white-ball series against India which was cancelled in March last year because of the onset of Covid-19; New Zealand's tour of India, which was scheduled in 2019, post the series versus England; the possibility of India hosting Sri Lanka are potential series / matches under consideration to make up for the absence of a tournament like the Asia Cup.

"Further, the Asia Cup - even if it was scheduled - would've probably been played around the same time as the ICC Test Championship final. If India don't make the final, the industry would've preferred the Asia Cup instead. Now, chance of such a thing happening look bleak so it's a kind of catch-22 right now," say those tracking developments.

The global battle surrounding the cricket calendar seems to be one between boards trying to retain their marquee bilateral commitments vis-à-vis ensuring their respective domestic circuits either take root or prosper.

The England & Wales Cricket Board (ECB) for instance would like to pursue with its dream of introducing The Hundred at the earliest and be content in the knowledge that its home season - the English summer - remains protected at all costs. "Australia and South Africa had initiated a battle for the Boxing Day some years ago, which Cricket Australia clearly won. That battle may resume, who knows? India will fight to keep its October-November (Dussera-Diwali) window to play at home and ensure IPL gets a larger window (March added to the April-May). These are matters that'll test the efficacy of the upcoming FTP," say those in the know.

In the meantime, the Asia Cup not happening is likely to upset the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) more than any other country. The 2019 edition of the tournament was PCB's to host, which the Ehsan Mani-led board had decided to first host at a neutral venue (UAE) and later decided to share it with Sri Lanka Cricket (SLC).

"We'll have to wait and see how this one plays out," sources add.

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com...lans-cricket-at-home/articleshow/80321654.cms
 
The Asian Bloc is obsolete.

The Asia Cup of 2018 was an excuse to host 3 Ind-Pak ODI games (Pakistan's performance ensured it ended up as only 2 games).
 
Not suprised if asia cup doesnt take place this year , however i for one do like this tourney so would like to see it happen this year if possible
 
Looks like BCCI does not want PCB to earn a single cent of money off it.

Logistically it is the easiest tournament to hold, as all countries are so close so less expenditure in travel, but a lot of eye balls so more advertisement money.

But BCCI will find another sources.

Time for PCB to either start a new tournament and invite other teams to Pakistan. A Quadrangular tournament may be?
 
Asia Cup has become a useless tournament with one elite team and a bunch of minnows.

Would love to see this tournament scrapped.
 
Asia Cup has become a useless tournament with one elite team and a bunch of minnows.

Would love to see this tournament scrapped.

True, they definitely should get rid of this tournament and instead just organise more meaningful series
 
Pakistan won’t allow Asia-cup to be held in India and vice versa. It’s doomed to fail.

India can as well host Afg, Nepal, SL, BD for a 5-nation tournament with India-B team playing without Kohli, Bumrah, etc. No controversies with lots of fun & money.
 
Pakistan won’t allow Asia-cup to be held in India and vice versa. It’s doomed to fail.

India can as well host Afg, Nepal, SL, BD for a 5-nation tournament with India-B team playing without Kohli, Bumrah, etc. No controversies with lots of fun & money.

PCB is not in a position to allow or disallow anything. If BCCI wants, it can have the Asia Cup in India without Pakistan. PCB cannot do anything about it and the ACC will do as BCCI wants.

The issue is that it will not be a financial success, and BCCI is better off having a bilateral series with a competitive team during that window.
 
This is a useless cup for all intents and purposes. Other than battering Pakistan, there was nothing gained from playing this last time except accumulate injuries and finding out that we are comfortably the strongest Adian side. :facepalm
 
What's even the point of this tournament? All other teams compete to lose against India/India A in the final. :facepalm:

Whatever happened to that top4 team tournament dada was planning on pre-pandemic....
 
What's even the point of this tournament? All other teams compete to lose against India/India A in the final. :facepalm:

Whatever happened to that top4 team tournament dada was planning on pre-pandemic....

Is the ODI league even happening? They are struggling to even have a test championship.
 
Asian Bloc must reunite as a Brotherhood for the greater cause of Asians.
 
BCCI should host a tri-series like Australia used to. A long tri-series instead of two bilaterals. Better yet, bring back the quadrangulars.
 
This is a useless cup for all intents and purposes. Other than battering Pakistan, there was nothing gained from playing this last time except accumulate injuries and finding out that we are comfortably the strongest Adian side. :facepalm

Nikhil bhai, we already dont see India-Pakistan matches - we as fans should not toe such jingo lines and should be in support of Asia Cup so we can see each other team's play against each toher.
 
Nikhil bhai, we already dont see India-Pakistan matches - we as fans should not toe such jingo lines and should be in support of Asia Cup so we can see each other team's play against each toher.

I'm all for playing Pakistan but this cup is pointless. The era of multi-nation tournaments is over and India play way too much cricket , across formats in a short period of time.

Last time, after a gruelling tour of England(5 tests, 3 ODI's, 3T20's) we barely had anytime for the Asia Cup and we had to leave out Kohli.
 
It's time to rearrange Asian rivalries and bilaterals should be scheduled accordingly.

India-Bangladesh
Pakistan-Afganistan.

Will be lots of fun then a boring Asia Cup.
 
I'm all for playing Pakistan but this cup is pointless. The era of multi-nation tournaments is over and India play way too much cricket , across formats in a short period of time.

Last time, after a gruelling tour of England(5 tests, 3 ODI's, 3T20's) we barely had anytime for the Asia Cup and we had to leave out Kohli.

Its not that BCCI is intending to give its players a rest during that time. They are trying to accomodate lost series of 2020 rather. Would you prefer to watch bilateral JAMODIs against SA and NZ more than Asia cup?
 
This is a useless cup for all intents and purposes. Other than battering Pakistan, there was nothing gained from playing this last time except accumulate injuries and finding out that we are comfortably the strongest Adian side. :facepalm

We get a chance to improve our head-to-head record. Or else we will be behind at 60-75 in 2030.
 
I enjoyed all previous Asia Cup tournaments, this is sad. Hope other teams go ahead and play this without India.
 
So what if main players will be missing or overworked. We can send a team full of youngsters to Asia Cup, since it is in T20 format will be helpful for our T20 World Cup squad selection.

SK Yadav, Ishan, Krunal, Hardik (captain), Gaikwad, Samson, Chahar bros, Thakur, Saini, Sundar, Tewatia, Tyagi, so many youngsters can do with this experience.
 
Meaningless tournament!!!!Huge different between India and rest of the teams.
Looks like even in future World Cup Cricket will go with top 5 teams playing with each other twice, super 4, semi and final . The later 5 have neither talent nor skill to compete top 5. Modern days cricket revolve around top 5 teams (Eng, Ind, Aus, NZ and S Africa).
 
It's time to rearrange Asian rivalries and bilaterals should be scheduled accordingly.

India-Bangladesh
Pakistan-Afganistan.

Will be lots of fun then a boring Asia Cup.

Under Misbah Waqar soon Afghanistan will start whitewash us.
 
What's even the point of this tournament? All other teams compete to lose against India/India A in the final. :facepalm:

It wasn't a bad idea, it really helped teams like Afghanistan get some international recognition through their performances.

But it's not very watchable, most games are just one-sided and boring.

If they did T20, maybe I'd be interested but the 50 over one was just a waste of time.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
People are saying how multination tournaments were boring, but its absolutely fun to watch Asian Bloc getting mauled in SENA or vice versa.
 
Honestly wouldn't mind seeing a 4, possibly 5 team tournament between Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Afghanistan and an associate team.

Really hope other boards go through with it even if India is not in it.
 
I for once think it would be a good idea to have a T20 Asia Cup just before the T20 WC.
It will give good match practice for all Asian teams participating in the T20 WC.

An idea could be to host it in The UAE as the pandemic situation is more or less under control there, and you also avoid the political troubles.

It does not need to be harder than that, to be honest.
 
We should organize a tournament between ourselves, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, Afghanistan and possibly UAE. Will be a cracker for sure.
 
I would love to see Asia cup happening as its the only tournament (outside ICC events) where we get to see India vs Pakistan game.

Also, I enjoy the rivalry (in social media) with our Bangladeshi brothers...so thats an interesting game as well.

From a neutral perspective, Pak vs Afg and Pak vs BD games are interesting too as all three teams have fans who dont like each other.

Actually, apart from Srilanka, all other teams have fans that dont like each other and that itself make the tournament interesting. Even Srilankan fans got charged up during Nidahas trophy :cobra :yk

So Asia cup is anyday better than random ODIs against some Lockie Ferguson or Van Der Dussens at home.

I would love to see Asia cup but hopefully they change the venue as Srilanka is an awful place to play cricket. Move it to Dubai or in Dhaka rather.
 
Last edited:
So what if main players will be missing or overworked. We can send a team full of youngsters to Asia Cup, since it is in T20 format will be helpful for our T20 World Cup squad selection.

SK Yadav, Ishan, Krunal, Hardik (captain), Gaikwad, Samson, Chahar bros, Thakur, Saini, Sundar, Tewatia, Tyagi, so many youngsters can do with this experience.

Completely agree with this. If this is a T20 tournament , there is no reason why we should play our T20 team . Even if this conflicts with WTC final we can still get a squad with KL, Agarwal, Hardik, Sundar, Samson, Sky, Acar to get them ready. On case Agarwal plays the WTC match we should include the next IPL, SMA performers in line. I don't see a reason why BCCI should avoid the tournament except that they may not agree to visit Pakistan due to political reasons. And I am sure Pakistan won't travel to India either with the souring relationship.

Even if India does not participate, Pakistan should still host the tournament. It will be very competitive with Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Pakistan.
 
This is poor form from the BCCI. I am a huge fan of the Asia Cup. It is a tournament with good context unlike jamodis.
 
Last edited:
Always found the Asia Cup games to be entertaining and thrilling, it'd be sad to see it scrapped.
 
Asia Cup getting cancelled will be injustice to the "6th team". No one here is talking about them.

These associates are at the same level where Afghanistan or Ireland were a few years back. They win sub regional and then the final qualifying rounds to earn themselves a chance against the elite sides.
 
Pakistan should set up an annual ODI/T20 tournament with SL, Afg, BD & UAE with round robin hosting rights. This will bring excitement even if India is not there. Even I may like to watch it.
 
A t20 cup in asia would definetly been have a lot more competitive.
 
Honestly wouldn't mind seeing a 4, possibly 5 team tournament between Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Afghanistan and an associate team.

Really hope other boards go through with it even if India is not in it.

That's exactly what I was thinking. Yes India is big and everything but there are 4 other cricket playing countries in Asia and they can in theory have a tournament among themselves.
 
Asians have each other’s backs, especially abroad. We should promote good cricket between each other.
 
Just when Asia Cup was given some meaning, they are making it useless again. I hope it is not cancelled rather postponed.

Yes, cricket has suffered due to covid and boards will look to maximize profit to make up on lost revenues. But Asia Cup was supposed to be a pre-cursor to world tournaments. Would like for it to happen sometime before WT20.
 
Test series that relates to World Test Championship, or a series realting to the qualification to a ICC tournament (ODI and T20 World Cup)
Test Series as a "tournament" is completely fraud. Tell me what tournament lasts for freaking 3 years?

For the World Cup, we already know that top 8 teams will be playing in it at the very least.
 
India should no longer be considered an Asia team they should be classified separately as India alone.
 
India should no longer be considered an Asia team they should be classified separately as India alone.
That’s will not be decided by you or anyone. BCCI and Indian government will decide with whom we play and when.
Same as England and Newzealand decided to not play with mughabes Zimbabwe in 2003 forfeiting there points.
 
That’s will not be decided by you or anyone. BCCI and Indian government will decide with whom we play and when.
Same as England and Newzealand decided to not play with mughabes Zimbabwe in 2003 forfeiting there points.

Wrong comparison. England don't claim to be part of any greater union and neither do NZ. They are only representing themselves on the cricket stage, and I already suggested India could do the same. They cannot claim to be representing Asia when they refuse to take part in the premier Asian events or play against the best Asian teams.
 
Wrong comparison. England don't claim to be part of any greater union and neither do NZ. They are only representing themselves on the cricket stage, and I already suggested India could do the same. They cannot claim to be representing Asia when they refuse to take part in the premier Asian events or play against the best Asian teams.

When did India said they are representing Asia?
It’s and independent country and they are representing India/Bharat/Hindustan.

And they will play other Asian teams like Srl and Bangladesh as well.
There is more to Asia then what you think.
 
I don't think I've seen anyone as pathetic as Pakistan fans on PakPassion. I'm not going to mention a certain user for the sake of this post being deleted, but I genuinley question what weak upbringing some of you have.

Saying "Asia Cup is meaningless" yet defending generic long winded series that other teams play is the defention of pathetic **** behaviour.

No doubt BCCI have more clout and call the shots. That doesn't mean we should encourage Pakistan to give in to BCCI's whims and aims.

BCCI has shown it will undermine Pakistan, and you have some Pakistani fans here bending over for them.

Asia Cup is still unique to Asian teams, if BCCI don't want to be involved then screw the. Sure, it may not have the money Indian's population brings but so what? Pakistan, SL and Bangladesh xan take initiative for it's own benefit.
 
Sad and dissapointing especially because of the way Kardar and co helped setup the acc and tried to counter teh colonials from aus and eng. All the progress made over the last 40 years , that have helped teams like India become a strong side is because the asian nations banded together and flexed their muscle.

The simple fact is cricket will die if it is not allowed to spread wider and the top 8 nations are not strong. you cant keep playing cricket between three countries while treating the rest like dalits.

I hope the other boards get together and organise a big T20 tournament. We need more tournaments rather than bakwaaas bilateral series. Playing for trophies is more fun.

But every golden age comes to an end and one day india's will end too..
 
I don't think I've seen anyone as pathetic as Pakistan fans on PakPassion. I'm not going to mention a certain user for the sake of this post being deleted, but I genuinley question what weak upbringing some of you have.

Saying "Asia Cup is meaningless" yet defending generic long winded series that other teams play is the defention of pathetic **** behaviour.

No doubt BCCI have more clout and call the shots. That doesn't mean we should encourage Pakistan to give in to BCCI's whims and aims.

BCCI has shown it will undermine Pakistan, and you have some Pakistani fans here bending over for them.

Asia Cup is still unique to Asian teams, if BCCI don't want to be involved then screw the. Sure, it may not have the money Indian's population brings but so what? Pakistan, SL and Bangladesh xan take initiative for it's own benefit.

Some of the worst pakistani internet users i have encountered have been on this forum. I have never seen so much hate for their own country couched under words like "realism" and "being honest".
 
Sad and dissapointing especially because of the way Kardar and co helped setup the acc and tried to counter teh colonials from aus and eng. All the progress made over the last 40 years , that have helped teams like India become a strong side is because the asian nations banded together and flexed their muscle.

The simple fact is cricket will die if it is not allowed to spread wider and the top 8 nations are not strong. you cant keep playing cricket between three countries while treating the rest like dalits.

I hope the other boards get together and organise a big T20 tournament. We need more tournaments rather than bakwaaas bilateral series. Playing for trophies is more fun.

But every golden age comes to an end and one day india's will end too..

We need to also remember how PCB tried to backstab BCCI, scuttle IPL, move WC out of India and colluded with other countries to rob BCCI of hundreds of millions from its own homes market every year; while leaching on the Indian market at the same time. Unfortunately BCCI won’t forget easily. We can debate on it but this is the perception BCCI has.

India (& Pak) can individually promote Asian cricket by inviting countries for bilateral events incl FC/tests, inviting their top players in IPL/PSL and some other local tournaments even Ranji, giving access to the top Indian training academies and coaches, incl training with India U-19, U-23 and national teams. There’s some effort already there but it can be made more extensive.

Just organising a one-week ODI or T20 tournament where they get bashed up is not the ideal way to help minnows.

India and Pak can also separately organise ODI tournaments for other Asian nations, without attending each others event. Asian countries will gain even more by having two, instead of one, tournaments and cricket gains overall.
 
Last edited:
We need to also remember how PCB tried to backstab BCCI, scuttle IPL, move WC out of India and colluded with other countries to rob BCCI of hundreds of millions from its own homes market every year; while leaching on the Indian market at the same time. Unfortunately BCCI won’t forget easily. We can debate on it but this is the perception BCCI has.

India (& Pak) can individually promote Asian cricket by inviting countries for bilateral events incl FC/tests, inviting their top players in IPL/PSL and some other local tournaments even Ranji, giving access to the top Indian training academies and coaches, incl training with India U-19, U-23 and national teams. There’s some effort already there but it can be made more extensive.

Just organising a one-week ODI or T20 tournament where they get bashed up is not the ideal way to help minnows.

India and Pak can also separately organise ODI tournaments for other Asian nations, without attending each others event. Asian countries will gain even more by having two, instead of one, tournaments and cricket gains overall.

Don't really see what any of this has to do with a collective Asia Cup. You are basically just rehashing gripes between two countries which India is still harping on 15 years later. What we are talking about here is the Asia cup which is supposed to be a competition for all the nations in the region which includes Sri Lanka, BD and Afghanistan. It's not all about India and Pakistan despite some people's blinkered and frankly patronising view of it.
 
Sad and dissapointing especially because of the way Kardar and co helped setup the acc and tried to counter teh colonials from aus and eng. All the progress made over the last 40 years , that have helped teams like India become a strong side is because the asian nations banded together and flexed their muscle.

The simple fact is cricket will die if it is not allowed to spread wider and the top 8 nations are not strong. you cant keep playing cricket between three countries while treating the rest like dalits.

I hope the other boards get together and organise a big T20 tournament. We need more tournaments rather than bakwaaas bilateral series. Playing for trophies is more fun.

But every golden age comes to an end and one day india's will end too..

ACC had no role in India's rise. India's rise coincided with Dalmiya and later administrators monetizing Indian cricket and using that money to nurture Indian cricket. The money comes from India and not ACC.

Pakistan is free to play as many cups they want, why is India obligated to play in one?

PCB never had the money to counter Eng or Australia. Both the times Asian boards outbid Australia and England to win the WC bid in 1987 and 1996, the sponsors, Reliance and ITC wills came from India.

PCB's role was to support the bids as a asian bid, in return of which they got hosting rights.

Its funny you mention Kardar, when actually it was Air Marshal Nur Khan who supported the formation of ACC along with Gamini Dissanayake. The idea came from Bcci, which why the Bcci man was the first president.
 
Last edited:
I don't think I've seen anyone as pathetic as Pakistan fans on PakPassion. I'm not going to mention a certain user for the sake of this post being deleted, but I genuinley question what weak upbringing some of you have.

Saying "Asia Cup is meaningless" yet defending generic long winded series that other teams play is the defention of pathetic **** behaviour.

No doubt BCCI have more clout and call the shots. That doesn't mean we should encourage Pakistan to give in to BCCI's whims and aims.

BCCI has shown it will undermine Pakistan, and you have some Pakistani fans here bending over for them.

Asia Cup is still unique to Asian teams, if BCCI don't want to be involved then screw the. Sure, it may not have the money Indian's population brings but so what? Pakistan, SL and Bangladesh xan take initiative for it's own benefit.

Absolutely. Other teams should go ahead and play.
 
Don't really see what any of this has to do with a collective Asia Cup. You are basically just rehashing gripes between two countries which India is still harping on 15 years later. What we are talking about here is the Asia cup which is supposed to be a competition for all the nations in the region which includes Sri Lanka, BD and Afghanistan. It's not all about India and Pakistan despite some people's blinkered and frankly patronising view of it.

If it’s not all about India and Pakistan, both can help other Asian teams on their own or through ICC tournaments as I mentioned. Asia Cup does not serve any purpose - does not help emerging teams nor is exciting for the biggest fan base in the region that’s is India , except as a cunning tool to exploit the huge Indian Market. At least this is what the Indian govt and BCCI think.

As I said it’s unfortunate and many fans will like India to forget ‘15 years old’ issues without ‘rehashing’ but this is the reality.
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-partner="tweetdeck"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">A press release on matters discussed will be issued separately.(2/2)<a href="https://twitter.com/JayShah?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@JayShah</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/BCCI?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@BCCI</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/TheRealPCB?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@TheRealPCB</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/OfficialSLC?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@OfficialSLC</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/BCBtigers?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@BCBtigers</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/ACBofficials?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@ACBofficials</a> <a href="https://t.co/gRxDIE72rD">pic.twitter.com/gRxDIE72rD</a></p>— AsianCricketCouncil (@ACCMedia1) <a href="https://twitter.com/ACCMedia1/status/1448920186380238848?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">October 15, 2021</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>


<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-partner="tweetdeck"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">The Executive Board of the Asian Cricket Council (ACC) met in Dubai, U.A.E.<br>Mr. Jay Shah, President, Asian Cricket Council chaired the meeting. Owing to COVID-19 related risks and restrictions, it had been two long years since an in-person meeting of the Board was convened. (1/2)</p>— AsianCricketCouncil (@ACCMedia1) <a href="https://twitter.com/ACCMedia1/status/1448920177693937672?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">October 15, 2021</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
Back
Top