What's new

Attack on Malala was staged, claims PTI MNA Musarrat Ahmad Zeb

Rafa

Local Club Captain
Joined
Aug 26, 2015
Runs
2,277
1414861-mussaratahmadzebx-1495291489-440-640x480.jpg

PESHAWAR: In a claim that could stir up another controversy for the the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), MNA Musarrat Ahmad Zeb – a member of Swat’s royal family who belongs to the party – has alleged that the 2012 attack on Nobel laureate Malala Yousafzai was ‘staged’ by different groups, including rights activists.

Zeb, however, is adamant that the entire incident was a pre-planned series of events.

The parliamentarian claimed in her tweets that she too had been approached by those groups for the same “drama” but she had refused to be a part of it.

“I was approached for the same drama but refused as I was not interested in seeking asylum in another country,” she told The Express Tribune.

She alleged that those who had conducted Yousafzai’s medical examination after the attack were all allotted plots by the government.

Zeb said she had broken her silence after years as there were other people who she felt proud of rather than Nobel laureate Yousafzai.

“My inner conscience has compelled me to spill the beans,” she added.


https://tribune.com.pk/story/1414861/pti-mna-musarrat-ahmad-zeb-claims-attack-malala-staged/
http://

Ignorant comments from the MNA. As it is there are enough people who believe that the attack on Malala was a conspiracy and such comments add more fuel to the fire.
 
Not trying to be a conspiracy theorist but some of the official details given at the time of attack didn't add up too well .

Malala getting shot, taken outside Pakistan for treatment, miraculously surviving the attack, then becoming an International Celebrity, an icon for Muslim wonder under oppression, even though unintentionally she became a tool for furthering the war in Muslim countries . Her constant criticism of Pakistan.

Can't believe all of this happened without any made up.
 
Not trying to be a conspiracy theorist but some of the official details given at the time of attack didn't add up too well .

Malala getting shot, taken outside Pakistan for treatment, miraculously surviving the attack, then becoming an International Celebrity, an icon for Muslim wonder under oppression, even though unintentionally she became a tool for furthering the war in Muslim countries . Her constant criticism of Pakistan.

Can't believe all of this happened without any made up.
"Not trying to be a conspiracy theorist but I'll write a bucketload of conspiracies without any proof"

Malala went to the White House and on the presidents face said that drone attacks are useless and spread extremism. Never heard any other Muslim leaders do that
 
Not trying to be a conspiracy theorist but some of the official details given at the time of attack didn't add up too well .

Malala getting shot, taken outside Pakistan for treatment, miraculously surviving the attack, then becoming an International Celebrity, an icon for Muslim wonder under oppression, even though unintentionally she became a tool for furthering the war in Muslim countries . Her constant criticism of Pakistan.

Can't believe all of this happened without any made up.

Interesting. Did you know she is the only Pakistani who criticized U.S drone program in front of President Obama at the White House? Did you know she has always spoken against U.S aggression?
 
Deep rooted stupidity into society will takes decades to weed out. Prime example of it here.
 
Just a correction, Musarrat Ahmed Zeb's party membership was revoked back in 2014 by PTI due to her refusal to resign to put pressure on government for investigations against election rigging.

Media was quick to label her PTI MNA, PTI has since clarified they have nothing to do with this statement and also she no longer belongs to PTI.

As for Malala, no doubt she was shot and suffered and her attackers are animals (as we later found in APS and many other attacks). There is also no doubt that she receieved extra ordinary hype and support which 99.9% other victims of terror did not receive. She deserves the life she is living and maximising the opportunity like any of us would have done and it's wrong to say she hasn't spoken against drones or other issues.
 
Last edited:
Just a correction, Musarrat Ahmed Zeb's party membership was revoked back in 2014 by PTI due to her refusal to resign to put pressure on government for investigations against election rigging.

Media was quick to label her PTI MNA, PTI has since clarified they have nothing to do with this statement and also she no longer belongs to PTI.

As for Malala, no doubt she was shot and suffered and her attackers are animals (as we later found in APS and many other attacks). There is also no doubt that she receieved extra ordinary hype and support which 99.9% other victims of terror did not receive. She deserves the life she is living and maximising the opportunity like any of us would have done and it's wrong to say she hasn't spoken against drones or other issues.

No one spoke like her.
She spoke when swat valley was under fazallluh
She spoke even after several life threats.
She spoke when IK wanted Taliban's office in Pakistan

and lastly she did speak against drones when she met Obama.

She is the best of Pakistan and naturally worst of Pakistan are jealous or making various excuses.
Wasn't PTI minister (farman) stopped the book launch and when confronted by IK, he started making excuses about venue etc.

KP has a lot of animosity about Malala, which is natural considering the level of support for taliban there.
 
No one spoke like her.
She spoke when swat valley was under fazallluh
She spoke even after several life threats.
She spoke when IK wanted Taliban's office in Pakistan

and lastly she did speak against drones when she met Obama.

She is the best of Pakistan and naturally worst of Pakistan are jealous or making various excuses.
Wasn't PTI minister (farman) stopped the book launch and when confronted by IK, he started making excuses about venue etc.

KP has a lot of animosity about Malala, which is natural considering the level of support for taliban there.

What are the names of the other two girls who were hurt in the same incident?
 
They also go to school in England btw

That's nice, these girls nearly gave their life for Pakistan but Pakistan can't even educate them but it's up to the UK taxpayer to do so.

I just wondered why they aren't as known as Malala.

Btw I dont think the attack was staged at all. I wish her will but just have issues with her being used as propaganda.
 
Lol at spilling the beans, she said that as if she did some secret investigative work with "Shabbir tu dekhay ga" and leaked it to expose a huge criminal gang. Malala has done a lot of good compared to this bitter woman. She should be ashmed of herself.
 
What are the names of the other two girls who were hurt in the same incident?

How is it relevant?
Why are you diverting the subject? seems like another closet terrorist's apologist??

Kainat Riaz and Shazia Ramzan are the names of her friends however Malala was the TARGET and she was Target as she was speaking against taliban on her blog.

Her friends are given due recognition in various documentaries.
 
How is it relevant?
Why are you diverting the subject? seems like another closet terrorist's apologist??

Kainat Riaz and Shazia Ramzan are the names of her friends however Malala was the TARGET and she was Target as she was speaking against taliban on her blog.

Her friends are given due recognition in various documentaries.

I would stop 'seeming' if I were you, only embarrasing yourself.

I just wondered if anyone knew the names of the other two. Sure she was the target but you seem to think she is the next Messiah too. She is being used as propaganda, no child has any influence in the world.
 
It probably was. Malala seems like a suspicious character as a whole.
 
I would stop 'seeming' if I were you, only embarrasing yourself.

I just wondered if anyone knew the names of the other two. Sure she was the target but you seem to think she is the next Messiah too. She is being used as propaganda, no child has any influence in the world.

why are you trying your best to divert the topic?
do not you have any shame?
 
why are you trying your best to divert the topic?
do not you have any shame?

The two girls were shot alongside her, it's no diversion. You should have some shame like the elites who are using this girl as a propaganda tool.
 
No one spoke like her.
She spoke when swat valley was under fazallluh
She spoke even after several life threats.
She spoke when IK wanted Taliban's office in Pakistan

and lastly she did speak against drones when she met Obama.

She is the best of Pakistan and naturally worst of Pakistan are jealous or making various excuses.
Wasn't PTI minister (farman) stopped the book launch and when confronted by IK, he started making excuses about venue etc.

KP has a lot of animosity about Malala, which is natural considering the level of support for taliban there.

Don't think you read my post, this is what i said as well that some people spread the propaganda that she is western agent or something and doesn't speak against drones or injustice against Muslims, she spoke on many issues including drones.
 
It's no surprise some of the answers here from particular posters align with the miserable woman claiming conspiracy in the article. As long as you have these apologists, Pakistan will never be free of terrorism.
 
Don't think you read my post, this is what i said as well that some people spread the propaganda that she is western agent or something and doesn't speak against drones or injustice against Muslims, she spoke on many issues including drones.

Yes, you are right in this aspect.
I was mainly responding to underlined comment.
 
The two girls were shot alongside her, it's no diversion. You should have some shame like the elites who are using this girl as a propaganda tool.

Thread is about "Attack on Malala was staged, claims PTI MNA Musarrat Ahmad Zeb"
 
I really want to know What does Malala want ?? No seriously I would really like to know what does the girl want with regards to Pakistan in general or specifically.

Does she want to educate girls ?? does she want to lead Pakistan in future ?? does she want to join politics ?? Nobody actually knows what the girl wants, which leads to a lot of speculation and hyperbole.

The picture would be much more clearer if Malala came out and said what her plans were for the next 20 years with regards to her life and whether or not she is would be involved in Pakistani politics or not.....

Would make life much more easier for everyone involved.
 
If you were part of a conspiracy, would you agree to let someone shoot you in the head to further it?
 
I really want to know What does Malala want ?? No seriously I would really like to know what does the girl want with regards to Pakistan in general or specifically.

Does she want to educate girls ?? does she want to lead Pakistan in future ?? does she want to join politics ?? Nobody actually knows what the girl wants, which leads to a lot of speculation and hyperbole.

The picture would be much more clearer if Malala came out and said what her plans were for the next 20 years with regards to her life and whether or not she is would be involved in Pakistani politics or not.....

Would make life much more easier for everyone involved.

Agreed. I struggle if someone asks me my plans for the next year, but as a Nobel Laureate she should at least explain her plans for next 20 years. Because then those who doubt her will start believing because she says so.
 
Neurosurgeon reveals details of Malala operation after Taliban attack

Five years have passed since the young Malala Yousafzai was shot at by the Taliban, but some people continue to dish out rumours and express doubts about whether the attack ever took place. Social media was again abuzz when a Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf MNA Mussarat Ahmed Zeb claimed in a series of tweets that the attack on the Nobel peace prizewinner was staged and that the medics and the doctor who did the CT scan who examined her were awarded plots by the government.

In a first, the neurosurgeon who was the first doctor to operate on Malala appeared in Geo News show Aaj Shahzeb Khanzada to put to rest all such claims.

Dr Mumtaz Ali, a doctor at the Lady Reading Hospital in Swat, narrated how he got a call at around 1:30PM about an injury and started preparations to receive the patient. But Malala was instead shifted to the Combined Military Hospitals (CMH), he said. Ali was called in the afternoon from the clinic to perform a checkup of Malala.

“She was unconscious [when I saw her]. She had a severe head injury,” he said.

The doctor then found a mark on her head made by a bullet which had entered her left temporal of the brain, which is responsible for speech functions. The bullet had passed through the neck to the shoulder.

“She looked pale and the CT scan showed the left part of the brain was severely injured,” Ali said.

Ali said that he instructed his colleagues to not perform any other medical procedure and only administer medicines to Malala, and decided to perform a check-up after two hours. At around 1:30PM, he got a call from his colleague who informed him that Malala’s condition is deteriorating.

“They said she is going to die.” Ali rushed to the hospital and gauged the situation. The doctors performed a tracheostomy and then an “extensive surgery” on the brain and removed the bullet.

The surgery ended at 4AM.

Ali said that he, a senior neurosurgeon and a brigadier at the CMH performed a check-up of Malala and decided that no further treatment, apart from “rehabilitation” was required. Malala was kept in CMH for two days and then was sent abroad for treatment.

Mussarat rubbished the claims that the attack did not happen, saying there is a marked difference in the way Malala now speaks due to an injured facial nerve on the left side of the face.

He added that the procedure itself was not difficult, but the timeliness of the decision was.

“In case of a delay of 2-3 hours or perhaps minutes, Malala might not have been around. And that would have laid to rest all these rumours as well.”

https://www.geo.tv/latest/143066-ex...ails-of-malala-operation-after-taliban-attack
 
typical pathetic antics from apologists who cant stand to see their countries inadequacies exposed. The Taliban targeted her because she was daring to challenge them.

Just because her case has been highlighted by the western media doesnt mean it isnt valuable or that it isnt true. Yes they have their own agenda in their ongoing war with the Taliban but the Talibans barbaric actions and attitudes towards female education are well known.
 
shes burying her head in the sand about the violence and intimidation so many Pakistani women and girls face simply for wanting an education at the hands of terrorists or their own family members.
 
Malala must be the only living creature in the world to survive a point-blank rifle head shot, that too without having a single mark on her head.
 
[MENTION=135]Waseem[/MENTION]
PTI cancelled her membership as she refused to join the boycott but i am wondering why PTI did not start the process to de-seat her. do you have a clue?
 
Back
Top