What's new

Banks run out of money as Indians hoard cash

R3verse Swing

Local Club Star
Joined
Jan 8, 2018
Runs
2,163
Banks run out of money as Indians hoard cash

India is facing a cash crisis, with ATMs running dry and banks reporting a £7 billion shortfall in currency, threatening a return to the chaos of Narendra Modi’s “demonetisation” initiative.

Banks and cash machines are being closed as supplies of banknotes run out. In the hardest hit areas families are pawning valuables to survive. The State Bank of India said that ATM withdrawals hit their highest levels for almost a decade over the past year as Indians quietly rebuilt cash savings.

India now has more than £200 billion of cash in circulation, back at the levels before demonetisation. The government has increased printing but the sight of long queues outside banks has revived uncomfortable memories of 2016, when Mr Modi scrapped India’s two largest banknotes overnight in a crackdown on tax evasion and corrupt “black money”.

At a stroke 86 per cent of all currency in India was rendered worthless until it could be exchanged for new notes. The move plunged the country into months of turmoil and hit economic growth.

The vast informal economy that runs on cash ground to a halt as a nation of 1.3 billion people queued outside banks to exchange their now worthless savings. Dozens of people died while standing in line and hundreds more deaths were blamed on the crisis.

State elections take place this year and national polls next year. Reviving memories of what is seen as the greatest blunder of his premiership and a defining act of hubris is not how Mr Modi would like to kick off his campaign.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/edition/...f-money-as-indians-hoard-cash-again-rlvlz6fn5
 
Have to hand it to the Congress. Being able to effect a cash crunch through a large part of the country by getting their cronies to withdraw cash is very impressive. However I wonder what noble intentions do they need this cash for before the Karnataka polls?
 
Have to hand it to the Congress. Being able to effect a cash crunch through a large part of the country by getting their cronies to withdraw cash is very impressive. However I wonder what noble intentions do they need this cash for before the Karnataka polls?

Nobody is an angel when it comes to politics. Congress, BJP all do anything either to come to power or stay in power.
 
How did you get that from my statement?

Congress doing everything to create artificial cash crunch right before the polls. It is a dirty trick and I am sure BJP would have done the same if they were in opposition.
 
Congress doing everything to create artificial cash crunch right before the polls. It is a dirty trick and I am sure BJP would have done the same if they were in opposition.

In other news, pigs don't fly
 
Have to hand it to the Congress. Being able to effect a cash crunch through a large part of the country by getting their cronies to withdraw cash is very impressive. However I wonder what noble intentions do they need this cash for before the Karnataka polls?
So, you are trying to say that BJP's garbage demonetisation policy failed due to Congress? I hope you are being sarcastic.
 
What were the failures of demonetisation, and what were the benefits, if any?

Failure of demonitization is written right there in the article.

"India now has more than £200 billion of cash in circulation, back at the levels before demonetisation"


It was a fluff policy, no benefits.
 
Have to hand it to the Congress. Being able to effect a cash crunch through a large part of the country by getting their cronies to withdraw cash is very impressive. However I wonder what noble intentions do they need this cash for before the Karnataka polls?

Wait? You are saying there is a conspiracy here? Any evidence?
 
Failure of demonitization is written right there in the article.

"India now has more than £200 billion of cash in circulation, back at the levels before demonetisation"


It was a fluff policy, no benefits.

I disagree. There were a few benefits. Many shell companies detected who didnt bother to claim their assets. More people under the tex net and most importantly, the lax attitude towards paying taxes. Digital push may take time, but too early to say that it failed. It failed in a few objectives while being in success in others.
 
Modi's demonetisation was a complete abject failure.

Don't take it from me, take it from the Financial Times.

Excerpt:

Less than a year later, a central bank report suggests the policy has not been very effective. It estimates that almost 99 per cent of the high value notes, which at the time of the announcement made up 86 per cent of all the cash in circulation in India, were deposited or exchanged for new notes.

Instead of flushing out the black money, the Modi government may have inadvertently helped wash the funds clean.

The government, in anticipation, set a Rs250,000 limit (about $3,900) on the amount that could be deposited before declaring tax records.

What it failed to foresee though was the elaborate schemes that sprang up to circumvent that limit. Some offered others a fee to deposit money on their behalf, while others allegedly used donations to Hindu temples to launder funds. The bank’s report suggests that the policy has had little success for the disruption it has caused to one of the world’s fastest growing economies.

https://www.ft.com/content/bf7cf078-8e47-11e7-a352-e46f43c5825d
 
Back
Top