Bengal villagers lynch two Muslim men who were on van carrying cows

[hafeezrocks]

Villagers beat to death two Muslim men who were on a vehicle transporting cattle in the early hours of Sunday morning, an assault the police said could have been instigated by so-called cow protection vigilantes.

The attack took place at a village in Jalpaiguri district, around 622 kilomteres from Kolkata, shortly after 2:30am on Sunday.

This the second case of cow-related lynching in West Bengal in the last two months after three Muslim youth were beaten to death in June.

Such attacks, ostensibly under the pretext of protecting cows, have increased in recent months with critics pointing the finger at Bharatiya Janata Party. The Prime Minister’s party has been accused of going soft on such attackers, since protection of the cow is seen as a largely Hindu agenda.

“The place of the attack was Dadon, a small village just 15 kilometres from Dhupguri town in Jalpaiguri. On being informed, the police rushed to the spot and found the bodies of the two victims who appear to be in their mid-thirties,” said a district police official. The area where the incident took place is close to the Indio- Bangladesh border at Falakata.

The victims were identified as Hafizul Sheikh, a resident of Dhubri, Assam, and Anwar Hussain, a resident of Patlahawa village in Cooch Behar district of West Bengal.

http://m.hindustantimes.com/india-n...rrying-cows/story-fwLMyqKhRcynIL6jPHJflO.html

Lynchings by Cow protectors seems to have become a regular occurrence in India.

 

[Varun]

Seems to be a daily news story and this nonsense has to stop.

Beef is great and everybody should bite. Maybe that's one way we can soft-conquer the population to stay away from such violence.

 

[Rafa]

Mahan Bharat at it again.

 

[cricketjoshila]

This is surprising.Cow vigilantism in Bengal?This is extremely rare.That place is though already in a state of violence.

 

[90MPH]

Bigger question why doesn't Indian PM speak up ??

Why the silence ?? Is he secretly giving a green light to this cow vigilante groups ?

 

[Cpt. Rishwat]

Bigger question why doesn't Indian PM speak up ??

Why the silence ?? Is he secretly giving a green light to this cow vigilante groups ?

It's not such a big secret, his party was voted to power by a public which backs such nonsense.

 

[ToeCrusher2]

Bigger question why doesn't Indian PM speak up ??

Why the silence ?? Is he secretly giving a green light to this cow vigilante groups ?

Why would the Indian PM waste his time on such petty issues, people die everyday, Indian PM is not going to waste his time on every little crime happening in the country

 

[Rafa]

Bigger question why doesn't Indian PM speak up ??

Why the silence ?? Is he secretly giving a green light to this cow vigilante groups ?

Speaking against it would be like acknowledging the problem which India very desperately wants to sweep under the carpet and maintain the perception of being a Jannat for Minorities.

Meanwhile PM Modi offers much needed support and encouragement to these groups behind closed doors.

 

[hafeezrocks]

Why would the Indian PM waste his time on such petty issues, people die everyday, Indian PM is not going to waste his time on every little crime happening in the country

Hindu - Muslim Violence is a petty issue for you, a little crime? This is not some random murder that took place in one of the Indian Cities but regular killings of Muslims by Hindutva Goons.

Can't believe how easily you can turn it into a trivial issue.

 

[ToeCrusher2]

Hindu - Muslim Violence is a petty issue for you, a little crime? This is not some random murder that took place in one of the Indian Cities but regular killings of Muslims by Hindutva Goons.

Can't believe how easily you can turn it into a trivial issue.

It is you who desperately wants to turn this petty crime into a hindu muslim issue. Did they get killed because they were muslims?
The answer is No. They were killed because they were carrying the cows. This is not a hindu muslim case, this is a simple murder case, I know it is difficult concept for you to grasp as you have been conditioned to view everything from the prism of religion but the Indian PM doesn't have time to comment on every murder that happens in this country

 

[sjahmed23]

Modi is to hindu nationalists what trump is to white nationalists. Modi = Trump of India. Its sad our Indian friends don't see that, but can't blame them, everyone is in it for their own benefits no one really cares about secularism or liberalism. Its only good for propaganda purposes.

 

[cricketjoshila]

Bigger question why doesn't Indian PM speak up ??

Why the silence ?? Is he secretly giving a green light to this cow vigilante groups ?

Law and order is a state subject.Bengal has one of Modi's biggest rivals as chief minister.

 

[cricketjoshila]

It's not such a big secret, his party was voted to power by a public which backs such nonsense.

Didnt know Bengal has BjP in power.Atleast know facts before commenting.

 

[cricketjoshila]

Why would the Indian PM waste his time on such petty issues, people die everyday, Indian PM is not going to waste his time on every little crime happening in the country

Every other day you will find pakistanis thanking heavens that partition happened.Yet they will try to tell Indians how India should be run?who should be our PM?How is our PM?What kind of person we have elected?What kind of country we are?

Partition happened so that we dont have to live according to the others views.But seems some people are still stuck.

 

[Black Zero]

India cannot progress with this much division.

 

[Hitman]

Bigger question why doesn't Indian PM speak up ??

Why the silence ?? Is he secretly giving a green light to this cow vigilante groups ?

http://www.hindustantimes.com/india...ble-pm-modi/story-XToseVqb3wNZBJwAeWb0sO.html

 

[Pakpak]

This is surprising.Cow vigilantism in Bengal?This is extremely rare.That place is though already in a state of violence.

Why?

 

[PakLFC]

Some people here think India is a heaven for minorities. Pakistanis don't claim for our country to be a heaven for non Muslim's at all. That is the fundamental difference and why we like proving to Indians how there country is a hell for non Hindu's as well. This is why it hurts them so much.

 

[ToeCrusher2]

Some people here think India is a heaven for minorities. Pakistanis don't claim for our country to be a heaven for non Muslim's at all. That is the fundamental difference and why we like proving to Indians how there country is a hell for non Hindu's as well. This is why it hurts them so much.

I am a non hindu, got a great life here, it is indeed a heaven for minorities

 

[cricketjoshila]

Why?

Its a non bengali speaking area who want a separate state/province.

 

[cricketjoshila]

Some people here think India is a heaven for minorities. Pakistanis don't claim for our country to be a heaven for non Muslim's at all. That is the fundamental difference and why we like proving to Indians how there country is a hell for non Hindu's as well. This is why it hurts them so much.

Basically you have a inferiority complex?Is that what you are saying?Your PM cries every year about India at UN.Doesnt make any difference to anyone in the world.The world has stopped taking any notice what Pakistan has to say about India long time back.And you think you hurt Indians.

 

[Black Zero]

I am a non hindu, got a great life here, it is indeed a heaven for minorities

And minorities can select the temperature of fire in this heaven...
Sad these two muslims had to leave this heaven so soon.

 

[ToeCrusher2]

And minorities can select the temperature of fire in this heaven...
Sad these two muslims had to leave this heaven so soon.

Sad that you chose to identify these to people by their religion instead of their nationality. They weren't killed because they were muslims, try again junior.

 

[Black Zero]

Sad that you chose to identify these to people by their religion instead of their nationality. They weren't killed because they were muslims, try again junior.

So they were attending bbq...my bad.

 

[Chrish]

Issue is stealing of cattle owned by the farmers more than anything

The way I see it, either you eat the meat or you don't. Why would it be okay to slaughter animal A but not B? Hypocrisy I reckon

 

[Shutdown Corner]

It is you who desperately wants to turn this petty crime into a hindu muslim issue. Did they get killed because they were muslims?
The answer is No. They were killed because they were carrying the cows. This is not a hindu muslim case, this is a simple murder case, I know it is difficult concept for you to grasp as you have been conditioned to view everything from the prism of religion but the Indian PM doesn't have time to comment on every murder that happens in this country

But there is nothing wrong with carrying cows in Islam. And there is in Hinduism. Ie its a hindu-muslim issue.

 

[CricketCartoons]

Its a non bengali speaking area who want a separate state/province.

And they deserve it. Why should they be under Bengali rule? #Free Gorkhaland

 

[www787]

Basically you have a inferiority complex?Is that what you are saying?Your PM cries every year about India at UN.Doesnt make any difference to anyone in the world.The world has stopped taking any notice what Pakistan has to say about India long time back.And you think you hurt Indians.

Here is the news for you. Doesn't make any difference in the world when Indian PM cries against Pakistan either.

 

[www787]

Every other day you will find pakistanis thanking heavens that partition happened.Yet they will try to tell Indians how India should be run?who should be our PM?How is our PM?What kind of person we have elected?What kind of country we are?

Partition happened so that we dont have to live according to the others views.But seems some people are still stuck.

Please Learn the difference between discussing the atrocities against minorities by radical extremists in India vs telling what India should do.

Again! It is a forum, where discussion is taking place, not amending laws or making new laws. None of us have that power, and apparently everyone but you understand that.

Again, discussing on a forum NOT telling how to perceive things and live your life.

DISCUSSION of what's happening in our neighbor NOT telling Indians how they should run the country.

It is Forum, a Pakistani based forum, hence PakPassion, where people discuss wide range of topics in the world, India is one of them, none of the member here trying to change the law of India, Just discussing the daily occurrence in India.

So, again, discussing, define as "a conversation or a debate about certain topic", it isn't as same as telling India who should India elect as a PM. Because discussion doesn't equal Vote.

I hope it is clear by now, people in the world will continue to discuss whether you like it or not and will continue to criticize India for the good or bad it is doing within India on many world's forum, one of them happen to be Pakpassion, it is again only "Discussion", random people on the internet discussing, who have no power to to change or amend India's law.

Discussion, conversation, and criticism. NOT telling how to run India.

 

[big_gamer007]

Said it many times before this madness needs to be stopped it's only a matter of time when someone is brainwashed into believing enough is enough and revenge is taken against civilians like me and other Indians here.. Seeing Mamata Banerjee is anti Modi I would have thought she would make sure this behaviour does not happen in bengal.. Let's see what she does now

 

[cricketjoshila]

Here is the news for you. Doesn't make any difference in the world when Indian PM cries against Pakistan either.

How many pakistani organisations are under sanctions?How many so called your freedom fighters are now sanctioned terrorists?

 

[cricketjoshila]

Please Learn the difference between discussing the atrocities against minorities by radical extremists in India vs telling what India should do.

Again! It is a forum, where discussion is taking place, not amending laws or making new laws. None of us have that power, and apparently everyone but you understand that.

Again, discussing on a forum NOT telling how to perceive things and live your life.

DISCUSSION of what's happening in our neighbor NOT telling Indians how they should run the country.

It is Forum, a Pakistani based forum, hence PakPassion, where people discuss wide range of topics in the world, India is one of them, none of the member here trying to change the law of India, Just discussing the daily occurrence in India.

So, again, discussing, define as "a conversation or a debate about certain topic", it isn't as same as telling India who should India elect as a PM. Because discussion doesn't equal Vote.

I hope it is clear by now, people in the world will continue to discuss whether you like it or not and will continue to criticize India for the good or bad it is doing within India on many world's forum, one of them happen to be Pakpassion, it is again only "Discussion", random people on the internet discussing, who have no power to to change or amend India's law.

Discussion, conversation, and criticism. NOT telling how to run India.

I am all for discussions.Thats why i am on PP.PP timepass section was one of the best places for this discussions where actually debate took place without throwing mud or going personal.

The actual meaning of discussion is lost,the real intention is what another poster posted in this thread.


Bhai Pakistan is an islamic republic.Minorities are treated very poorly there.Indians dont ask you,why your PM isnt making statement etc etc etc.Your country your problem.My country my problem.




Problem is when people start calling xyz as murderer etc etc.

Next will be India isnt secular or democratic.Dont think Indians pass a judgement regarding how much islamic Pakistan really is or how muc of it is republic.

Then they will start calling hindu extremists or terrorists,but will cry hoarse if terrorists of ISIS or Al Qaida are linked to Islam.

Threads on India are normally for bashing India and the same group of posters will open them.

I can go on and on and on.

 

[cricketjoshila]

Said it many times before this madness needs to be stopped it's only a matter of time when someone is brainwashed into believing enough is enough and revenge is taken against civilians like me and other Indians here.. Seeing Mamata Banerjee is anti Modi I would have thought she would make sure this behaviour does not happen in bengal.. Let's see what she does now

I am shocked that this Mad cow disease is in Bengal.We have incidents where villagers have clashed with cow smugglers or cow thieves but not vigilantism.

This bovine anarchy has to stop.

 

[PakLFC]

Basically you have a inferiority complex?Is that what you are saying?Your PM cries every year about India at UN.Doesnt make any difference to anyone in the world.The world has stopped taking any notice what Pakistan has to say about India long time back.And you think you hurt Indians.

No I am honest in admitting what Pak is where as you Indians think India is a land of milk and honey Actually it is your PM who is always crying about Pak terrorism and so are your media!! CPEC and so called POK are things you are obsessed with. As if the world cares what India thinks of Pakistan or Modi for that matter.

 

[cricketjoshila]

No I am honest in admitting what Pak is where as you Indians think India is a land of milk and honey Actually it is your PM who is always crying about Pak terrorism and so are your media!! CPEC and so called POK are things you are obsessed with. As if the world cares what India thinks of Pakistan or Modi for that matter.

Bhai i am least bothered about making an opinion about Pakistan.Not my country not my problem.

I see that so many Pakistani organisations are sanctioned as terrorists.So the world actually cares what India is saying.

CPEC?LoL Indian annual defence budget is close to 50bn.CPEC lol.

India may be whatever world country but we are doing far better than Pakistan.Pakistan cant even hold international cricket matches for 8 years,Remember That.

 

[PakLFC]

Bhai i am least bothered about making an opinion about Pakistan.Not my country not my problem.

I see that so many Pakistani organisations are sanctioned as terrorists.So the world actually cares what India is saying.

CPEC?LoL Indian annual defence budget is close to 50bn.CPEC lol.

India may be whatever world country but we are doing far better than Pakistan.Pakistan cant even hold international cricket matches for 8 years,Remember That.

Equally, I could not care who calls Pakistan what fully realising that Pak has many enemies who want to make it another Iraq, Syria and Afghanistan. Then why do you keep posting an opinion on Pakistan if it does not interest you? Admit it, you are obsessed with us. Pak not being able to hold matches is due to one neighbours terrorism, we know who that is. That is the same one who always cries like a baby when any damage is done to it by others. Keep in mind your size when talking of economy who who in your country benefits from it, only the wealthy. You are not better then us at all and never were. Look how minorities and ladies are treated in your country for starters. Listen, keeping your size in mind your economy should be better then ours however a spoonful of honey can not be tasted in a massive bowl. It is only a few billionaires that benefit from your economy whilst most live in abject poverty.

 

[cricketjoshila]

Equally, I could not care who calls Pakistan what fully realising that Pak has many enemies who want to make it another Iraq, Syria and Afghanistan. Then why do you keep posting an opinion on Pakistan if it does not interest you? Admit it, you are obsessed with us. Pak not being able to hold matches is due to one neighbours terrorism, we know who that is. That is the same one who always cries like a baby when any damage is done to it by others. Keep in mind your size when talking of economy who who in your country benefits from it, only the wealthy. You are not better then us at all and never were. Look how minorities and ladies are treated in your country for starters. Listen, keeping your size in mind your economy should be better then ours however a spoonful of honey can not be tasted in a massive bowl. It is only a few billionaires that benefit from your economy whilst most live in abject poverty.

Pakistan is not able to hold matches because of a neighbour?Ok.what else?The point is you cnnot hold the matches.

I do not care if you think we are better or not than Pakistan.Its not our point of reference and never should be. Look at minorities and woman in your own country and then point fingers at India.Your new population of close to 220mn has brought down every demographic indicator a few notches.Take care of that.India doesnt need your advice.Use it in your own country,will serve it well.

 

[PakLFC]

Pakistan is not able to hold matches because of a neighbour?Ok.what else?The point is you cnnot hold the matches.

I do not care if you think we are better or not than Pakistan.Its not our point of reference and never should be. Look at minorities and woman in your own country and then point fingers at India.Your new population of close to 220mn has brought down every demographic indicator a few notches.Take care of that.India doesnt need your advice.Use it in your own country,will serve it well.

There is more to life that playing Cricket neither do I consider it a priority. Of course you care which is why you have a thousand posts on every Pak related thread! Our minorities are not stopped from eating from whatever they want! We do not blind our minorities with bullets like you do or lynch them. Why do you keep replying to my posts if you do not care what I think|? We don't need your concern or advice either pal and never will do.