What's new

Brendon McCullum appointed as England Head Coach across all formats - The BazBall Saga continues in white-ball format too [Post Updated #141]

Will Jacks is doing pretty well currently. And he bowls canny offies. Buttler is there who can keep. Jacks domestic t20 SR is 160 something
For some guys you're using international Avg and SR and others BBL/PSL/ILt20/100 as exclusion criteria.
Why can't you be uniform?

The thing is all of the names I mentioned have the potential to outscore the ones playing right now.

Because Vince and Billings haven't played T20I's consistently or recently ? Cox has barely played international cricket.

You can use any stats for Jacks and it's not particularly great . SA20 - 28/136 , Hundred - 17/148.

He is not going to be picked for his bowling

Buttler won't be keeping anymore. This was confirmed by McCullum sometime back
 
Will Jacks is doing pretty well currently. And he bowls canny offies. Buttler is there who can keep. Jacks domestic t20 SR is 160 something
For some guys you're using international Avg and SR and others BBL/PSL/ILt20/100 as exclusion criteria.
Why can't you be uniform?

The thing is all of the names I mentioned have the potential to outscore the ones playing right now.
I don't understand the hype around Will Jacks. I think he is a fairly average player. By no means should be making the cut over Duckett and Salt. Even Crawley has more potential than him in white-ball.
 
I don't understand the hype around Will Jacks. I think he is a fairly average player. By no means should be making the cut over Duckett and Salt. Even Crawley has more potential than him in white-ball.
Yes Crawley is good as well.
Jacks is a pretty sweet timer of the ball in the mold of Roy. I don't think there's any hype around Jacks.
 

Injuries affected England's training time - McCullum​


England "backed guys off a little" because of injuries within the squad during their tour of India, says coach Brendon McCullum amid criticism of the team's preparation.

England were thrashed in the third one-day international on Wednesday meaning they ended the tour with seven defeats from eight matches across the ODIs and T20s.

Former captain Kevin Pietersen was among those to question the squad for not training before the second and third matches.

"Guys have come from a lot of cricket and keeping guys fresh is just as important, especially when you have injuries," said McCullum, whose attention now turns to the Champions Trophy next week in Pakistan.

England trained regularly during their 4-1 series defeat in the T20 series and did so before the first ODI.

Captain Jos Buttler referenced the travel between venues and the turnaround between matches when asked about his side's preparation. The three ODIs were played across seven days in three different cities.

Having made his initial comments during the TV commentary, Pietersen repeated his criticism on Thursday, saying "injuries are not stopping batters from batting against new bowlers and learning the art of spin".

"We've done lots of training," McCullum said. "We have had injuries in the camp so we've backed guys off a little bit to make sure we had a fit team.

"We have three training sessions in Pakistan [before the Champions Trophy starts].

"Hopefully in Pakistan we will have a fully fit squad to pick from and we look forward to a fresh challenge. It's been a tough lesson but hopefully it's been great preparation for the tournament."

England's latest fitness concern is over opener Ben Duckett, who injured his left groin in the third ODI. He will have a scan in the coming days before the Champions Trophy opener against Australia on 22 February in Lahore.

"He's had quite a lot of cricket over the last little while," said McCullum. "We will make that call, work out if he's going to be at risk, if he's in or out."

England have already lost all-rounder Jacob Bethell to a hamstring injury - he has been replaced by batter Tom Banton - while wicketkeeper Jamie Smith has not played since the third T20 on 28 January because of a calf injury.

McCullum said Smith will be fit to face Australia and played down concerns over Brydon Carse's toe issue, a cut to Jofra Archer's hand and a hamstring niggle affecting Jamie Overton.

"Jamie [Smith] would have been a risk [on Wednesday] but he will be available for the first game," McCullum said. "With Brydon, hopefully his toe has healed by then and he is available for the first game.

"Jamie Overton feels OK. He felt a little bit of tightness after the last game but he should be fine for the first one. Jofra should be available. That's good news."

 

McCullum does not rule out making outsider captain​


England coach Brendon McCullum has not ruled out appointing separate 50-over and T20 captains or bringing in a player from outside the current squad to do the role.

White-ball captain Jos Buttler resigned on Friday following England's exit from the Champions Trophy.

McCullum has said England will take stock of the situation in the coming weeks and then move to appoint a successor.

"If it's the same person, great, if it's two, that's great too," said McCullum, after England's campaign in Pakistan ended with a sorry seven-wicket defeat by South Africa.

"Give me a couple of weeks to work it out and get this thing back on track."

England's next white-ball series starts against West Indies on 29 May and the next ICC global event is the T20 World Cup in India and Sri Lanka in February and March 2026.

Batter Harry Brook appears the favourite to replace Buttler, given he was appointed vice-captain in January and led in Buttler's absence last year against Australia.

But appointing him would bring issues because Brook is a regular in the Test side.

He would either have to rest in some white-ball series, an approach England have regularly used, or take on a heavy workload around his Test commitments.

One solution would be splitting the white-ball captaincy but England have not had three captains since Andrew Strauss, Alastair Cook and Stuart Broad held the roles in the early 2010s.

"It could definitely work, I don't see why not," England bowler Chris Woakes told the Test Match Special podcast.

"I feel we are in a stage in the cricket landscape where that can be the way forward.

"The formats are very different. Extremely different. 50-over is not just an extended T20 game. It's not, there's more games within the game which is closer to Test cricket and being able to do things for longer."

Liam Livingstone and Phil Salt have also both captained England in white-ball cricket over the past year. Another option would be to bring in a player who captains in domestic cricket but is not currently part of the side.

England wicketkeeper Sam Billings captained Oval Invincibles to victory in The Hundred last year but has not played for England since November 2022.

James Vince, whose last international was in March 2023, has had success as Hampshire captain while Sam Curran has captained in the Indian Premier League but was dropped by England last year.

Asked if England could bring in such a candidate, McCullum said: "Give us a couple of weeks to work it all out, sort of digest what's happened over the last month and a half, and then we will start to plot and plan our way forward from there."

 
Will be interesting to see how Wngland approaches batting against Bharat
 
How is Brandon Mcculum still holding on to that coaching position? He hasn't won a series against Australia and India.

England is yet to make an appearance in WTC finals.

England does not compete in India or Australia. What is going well for him?

:kp
 
England head coach Brendon McCullum says that the team "trained too much" before the day-night Test at The Gabba in Brisbane, which the visitors lost by 8 wickets in 4 days.
 
England head coach Brendon McCullum says that the team "trained too much" before the day-night Test at The Gabba in Brisbane, which the visitors lost by 8 wickets in 4 days.
A real clanger from McCUllum. He failed to read the room before making this comment.

Reminds me a bit of Peter Moores look at the data ( which Moores claimed he didn't actually say) that led to his sacking.
 
Brendon McCullum himself wasn't a great Test player. He was more of a LOI player.

I was shocked when he was selected as England's Test coach.

When coach himself doesn't understand or respect Test cricket, how can captain and team do the same? :inti

England need to get rid of this Bazball nonsense, sack McCullum, and drop Stokes. They have to select a traditional Test team and a coach who understands Test cricket.
 
I hope the geniuses at the ECB are liking Macca upending everything over the course of a few short years.

Not that they were very successful in the first place, mind.
 
Brendon McCullum shared following thoughts in a latest interview post losing Ashes series on Australian soil:

On Personal Accountability & Mistakes
* “I’m sure there will be plenty of questions asked and rightfully so. We haven’t got everything right and I haven’t got everything right as a coach either.”

* “I put my hand up for that and I accept that and you try and work out ways that you can try identify things which you need to make sure that you polish upon to give yourself more of a chance.”

On Flawed Preparations
* “I have been very strong in the conviction we have had about our preparation and obviously for us it was a matter of trying to replicate what we have done in previous series which have been successful, away from home... But maybe we didn’t quite get that right and I’ll acknowledge that.”

* “Ultimately you are responsible for how you get your side ready and how you prepare them. We are 3-0 down so you would probably say there was room for change there.”

On Tactical Regrets (The "Cottoned On" Comment)
* “You sit there and go, if we had cottoned onto that earlier then we would have been more competitive.” — Referring to the improved line and length bowled by England late in the Adelaide Test.

On Performance Under Pressure
* “(It is) amazing what you can achieve when you just play. Sometimes we put so much pressure on ourselves and... seem to think about things other than playing the game.”

* “The last couple of days we have got back to what we do, which is immersing ourselves and just playing.”

On Australia's Dominance
* “Credit goes to Australia. They have been as precise as a team as I have seen in the last few years. They put us under pressure throughout.”
* “We only had fleeting moments in the last three Test matches where we felt like we were on top.”

On the Player Response
* “I think the boys were excellent today. They showed some great application. They bounced off each other and tried to take the game as deep as they could. We didn’t get there, but I thought it was a fine achievement.”
 

Stokes wants McCullum to remain England coach​


Captain Ben Stokes says he cannot imagine "someone else" replacing head coach Brendon McCullum, despite England's Ashes series defeat in Australia.

Stokes and McCullum united in 2022 and this tour was billed as a defining moment for their leadership, only for England to surrender the series with defeats in each of the opening three Tests.

England won the fourth Test in Melbourne, their first win in this country for almost 15 years, and will finish the series in Sydney from Sunday (23:30 GMT, Saturday).

Stokes and McCullum have contracts until 2027 and both have stated they want to remain in their jobs after this tour.

While Stokes remains England's best leader and will probably get the opportunity to continue into the home summer, the positions of McCullum and director of cricket Rob Key could come under scrutiny.

"There is no doubt in my mind that me and Brendon are the right people to carry on doing this for the near future," said Stokes.

Asked if he and New Zealander McCullum come as a partnership, Stokes replied: "I can't see there being someone else who could take this team from where we are now to even bigger heights."

This latest defeat extends England's awful run in Ashes series in Australia - their victory in 2010-11 is their only success in the country since 1986.

Losses down under are often the signal for sweeping changes to the England management - Stokes and McCullum were bought in following a 4-0 defeat four years ago.

"We have not won here since 2010-11 and since that series things have happened because we think people need to change things, but it has not really worked has it?" said Stokes.

"There's a lot of people who sit above me. Ashes tours in the past haven't gone well. But if you do what we did four years ago, we'll just end up back in the same situation."

McCullum is due to lead England to the T20 World Cup in India and Sri Lanka next month, and a decision on his future is unlikely to be taken until after that tournament.

And all-rounder Stokes said he would "hope" to be consulted on any potential changes to the England hierarchy.

"It is a situation nobody knows whether it is going to happen or not but we're both pretty keen on carrying on doing what we are doing," said Stokes.

England won 10 of their first 11 Tests under Stokes and McCullum, but their results have been mixed since that opening burst of success.

In their past 34 Tests, England have won 16 and lost 16, with two draws. They have not managed a victory in a marquee five-Test series against Australia or India.

At the beginning of 2025, McCullum also assumed control of England's white-ball teams. Since then, England have won only four of their 10 Tests, including an expected comfortable victory Zimbabwe at Trent Bridge in May.

In explaining the reasons for England's poor performance in the Ashes, Key pointed to the white-ball series in New Zealand prior to this tour as a hindrance to preparation in Australia. The former England and Kent batter said he was not willing to "write off" the matches against the Black Caps.

But Stokes does not believe McCullum's dual role is having a detrimental effect on the Test team.

"He has got two jobs to do now," said Stokes. "It has not influenced the relationship we have with this Test team whatsoever."

England have named a 12-man squad for the final Test, with spinner Shoaib Bashir and seamer Matthew Potts included.

The tourists will make at least one change to the XI that played in Melbourne after pace bowler Gus Atkinson was ruled out because of a hamstring injury.

Bashir has not played since July after suffering a broken finger in the third Test against India at Lord's, then being overlooked for the first four Ashes Tests.

Durham's Potts has waited more than a year since his last cap, against New Zealand in Hamilton in December 2024.

"He's been in and about," said Stokes of Potts. "He obviously had a great start to his Test career with the ball and he finds himself in a slightly different position now within the team and in the squad.

"There's an opportunity there for someone to come in this week after the disappointing news with what happened to Gus last week."

Australia could make two changes to their team. Todd Murphy could come in as a specialist spinner, possibly at the expense of seamer Jhye Richardson.

In training on Friday, Beau Webster practised in the gully position usually occupied by Cameron Green, suggesting Australia could switch their all-rounders.

 
McCullum defends Brook, Ashes squad and leadership style

England head coach Brendon McCullum has defended Harry Brook, the off-field behaviour of his Ashes squad and his own leadership style, describing some of the criticism they have received in the last few months as a "pile on".

Speaking after England's 3-0 T20 series victory over Sri Lanka, McCullum argued the England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) had handled the fallout from their challenging winter tours "pretty well".

England white-ball captain Brook has come under significant scrutiny after it was revealed he was punched by a nightclub bouncer on England's tour of New Zealand that preceded the Ashes.

It was subsequently revealed he had lied about being alone for the encounter and was accompanied by several team-mates - a stance McCullum defended, saying the 25-year-old was trying to "look after his mates".

The story followed England's Ashes squad being criticised for a mid-series break in Noosa where several players were reported to be drinking excessively.

In a wide-ranging interview, McCullum, who will lead England in the T20 World Cup which begins in India and Sri Lanka this week, also said:

He didn't think the ECB needs "to release findings every time something arises" around player disciplinaries

The criticism of his players "can go too far" and he finds continual discussion of disciplinary proceedings "quite annoying"

Brook is an "outstanding" leader on the field and "wears his intelligence lightly"

He didn't think his players "went overboard" on a mid-Ashes series holiday in Noosa where they were pictured drinking, calling the Queensland resort "a place where people go and retire"

In terms of his own future, he'd "like to finish what we started" and hopes to be in charge beyond the T20 World Cup

England beat Sri Lanka by 12 runs on Tuesday, and carry momentum from an undefeated T20 tour that was preceded by a 2-1 ODI series win.

Afterwards, however, New Zealander McCullum, 44, was keen to rally round his captain and players.

He spoke repeatedly of the need to protect cricketers from the unique pressures of a year-round fixture list and believes disciplinary procedures should be kept private - saying Brook was "keen to put his hand up when the information came that it was going to land in the media".

"It seems like we keep going on and on and on about it," he said. "I think these guys, they know that they've made a mistake and they've put their hand up.

"Harry was trying to look after his mates and in the end, people say what they want but our job is to look after him.

"Our job is to make sure we support these guys and I think sometimes the criticism can go too far.

"When we're made aware of things that haven't gone right, we discipline them, we have a stern word and deal with things internally.

"I don't think we need to release those findings every time something arises. We feel like we deal with them and we've dealt with the processes of the last little while pretty well."

Asked whether the ECB could have been more transparent about Brook's altercation, McCullum reiterated: "I don't think there was any need to release the details until it was found in the media.

"And to be honest, I find it quite annoying that we keep going on and on about it because these are young men who are under immense pressure that have put their hands up, been disciplined for it and piling onto them is not helpful for anyone."

The Daily Telegraph have reported that Brook, Jacob Bethell and Josh Tongue could be subject to an investigation from the cricket regulator with regard to the incident in Wellington, which occurred the night before a one-day international which England lost.

The incident, which happened in November, did not come to light in the media until January, and followed a mid-Ashes break in Noosa which also drew criticism for some excessive drinking by players.

"Cricket is 12 months a year, you have to be able to enjoy yourselves. I don't think the boys went overboard at all," McCullum said of the Noosa trip.

"A lot of the pile-on for it was completely out of line. Noosa is where people go and retire, there's a reason why we chose Noosa.

"It's being made [out] as this big stag do place, it couldn't be further from that. If we wanted a stag do and we wanted a tear up, we'd have gone to the Gold Coast."

McCullum's leadership style has drawn criticism from outsiders, with some feeling the players are given too much freedom on and off the pitch.

However, McCullum bristled at such sentiments and believes his message has been misinterpreted by those outside the dressing room.

"I think you guys [journalists] have got to work me out a little bit better to be honest," he said.

"If you go back to the day I walked into the job, the first thing I said to these boys is don't do anything that lands you on the front page of the paper and nothing good happens after midnight, but we're going to have a good time.

"[I said] we're going to grow, we're going to enjoy ourselves, cricket is a tough game, it has its challenges mentally, which we've seen with many people that have played cricket in the past, but we're going to try and play a style of cricket that allows us to succeed.

"I'm not against making sure these boys are controlled in a manner. It's [about] looking after them to ensure they don't make mistakes. The curfew is a different interpretation of the words I mentioned three and a half years ago."

McCullum said he thought there was a "misconception" that he ran a "loose ship" and wanted everyone out drinking, and that he didn't care about cricket.

"It couldn't be further from the truth," he said.

"I'm fiercely determined, I'm fiercely competitive and I want the best for these guys, and I want the best for English cricket."

England start their World Cup campaign against Nepal on Sunday, 8 February (09:30 GMT).

Brook will lead the team in India and Sri Lanka and McCullum says he is impressed by the Yorkshireman's captaincy so far.

"I think Harry Brook is an outstanding leader on the field," he added. "His tactical acumen is as good as I've seen in a short period of time from a young man.

"He has work to do off the field without a doubt, as do some of the other young lads we have in our side - and that's what happens when you come in at 20 and you're growing up on a world stage with spotlight, fame, fortune and the pressure that comes with it.

"He's a strong leader, he's a young man but he's got a very good head on his shoulders. People will say he's not that clever, I couldn't disagree with that more, he wears his intelligence lightly and he's a very strong leader.

"He's a player they play for in that dressing room and our job is to keep looking after him because he is young and he's got his best days in front of him."

BBC
 
Back
Top