Pakistan defeated the Saffers comprehensively. They dominated the whole game TBH. It is not a small thing to beat WTC champions.
Agreed, anyone complaining on any matter other then Abdullah Shafique is simply a hater.
Barring Abdullah everyone pulled their socks up and comprehensively played as a team to win.
I think the only genuine weak point is
A) Abdullah Shafique (Obviously)
B) Maybe a bit of Shan's captaincy, he isn't too bad but sometimes sets defensive placements.
I don't really mind Shan's batting tbh, since his return he has tonked 2 centuries and has consistently been batting at an avg of 37. Only one higher is rizwan at an avg of 41.
Even saud and Agha are operating at 35-36.
Granted most of their avg's tanked due to the WI series where pitches were doctored and the Australia series where everyone excluding rizwan flopped.
If you exclude them most of them are batting at 40+ (Agha, Rizwan and Shan) yes Shan are 40+ ironically



.
Abdullah and Babar are both stuck at 18-30 though. Saim was also extremely poor avg 14 I believe.