What's new

Dean Elgar describes Indian pitches for South Africa’s last tour in 2015 as “a farce”

Abdullah719

T20I Captain
Joined
Apr 16, 2013
Runs
44,825
Dean Elgar describes Indian pitches for South Africa’s last tour in 2015 as “a farce”

'PROBABLY MY BEST'

“Every hundred for your country is special and emotional but I’d like to think it was probably my best for South Africa, especially in such conditions and against the powerhouse of India, the best team in the world,” Elgar said.

“It was very good to contribute today and make a difference to the team and the test match – we always knew it was going to be hard work against quality bowlers on a wearing pitch,” Elgar said after the days play.

“I’m a different cricketer to the one who toured here four years ago,” he said in explaining his success against the spinners. “I’ve played a lot of cricket around the world and concentrating on spin has been a big part of that. It’s good to know I’m still developing and improving as a cricketer.”

“As far as attacking is concerned, it’s about identifying your strengths and hitting the right balls in the right areas, but your defensive game needs to be in good shape first.”

Elgar described the pitches for SA’s last tour in 2015 as “a farce” but heaped praise on fellow centurion de Kock with who he shared a record sixth-wicket stand of 164.

“Quinny was absolutely brilliant – he’s a bit of a genius with the bat, to be honest. I’ve known him a long time as a cricketer and a person and he has so much to contribute to the team.”

Captain Faf du Plessis came to the crease at 63-4 after Temba Bavuma (18) had been trapped lbw by a nip-backer from Ishant Sharma inside the first hour and he added 115 with Elgar during a fighting innings of 55 from 103 balls with eight fours and another slog-swept six.

But an Ashwin offspinner was turned off the full face of the bat into the hands of Pujara at leg gully and South Africa were 178-5.

https://www.supersport.com/cricket/...1004_Elgar_Du_Plessis_dig_in_for_South_Africa

India vs South Africa | Can't Compare Preps With 2015's Wickets Which Were a Farce: Dean Elgar

R. Ashwin might have finished with another five-wicket haul while Ravindra Jadeja became the fastest left-arm bowler to pick 200 wickets in Test matches, but the third day of the first Test between India and South Africa at the ACA-VDCA Stadium belonged to Proteas opener Dean Elgar.

Elgar smashed a brilliant 287-ball 160 on a wicket that not only provided Ashwin and Jadeja with turn, but the odd ball also jumped after hitting the crack.

Elgar was going great guns till he tried to slog sweep Jadeja and Cheteshwar Pujara took a fantastic catch to give the spinner his 200th Test wicket in the post tea session of the third day.

Speaking at the end of the day's play, Elgar said that it is really tough to bat in Indian conditions and he learnt from the experience he had on his last tour with the team.

"It's good to contribute once again. Playing in India is very tough. The last time I was here, I was very inexperienced. In those four years, I have grown a lot as a cricketer. I have played county cricket, which has helped," he pointed.

Asked on what he tried differently this time round, Elgar said: " If you want to use the last series against India in India. Don't think we should use those wickets because that was a farce. You need to defend well against spinners, because then you give yourself the best chance of attacking. County cricket with Surrey has helped a lot. Playing spin is something I have been conscious of, and you will face a lot of spin when coming to India. (Hitting the ball in the air) I think you have to find your strengths. That's a strength of mine, and thankfully it worked out in this game. Implementing those, and obviously on this wicket, which has played well."

Elgar also praised T20I captain Quinton de Kock for putting up a quality show and hitting a century. "I am extremely happy for Quinny. He's a bit of a genius in the way he goes about it. It's not a surprise he's got a 100 here. I think this is the start of a great career for Quinny," he said.

https://www.news18.com/cricketnext/...ts-which-were-a-farce-dean-elgar-2333971.html
 
Last edited:
Why bring up 2015 pitches?

Hypocrisy seems to be way of life for saffers, just like when they went after aussies for ball tampering, now they will talk about pitches, ofcourse both times completely forgetting their own misadventures with tampering be it with pitch or ball.
 
Wonder what he thinks about SA's home pitches in recent times against Asian sides where matches don't last 2.5 days.
 
Saffers have sadly become whiners nowadays.

Except Kiwis I hardly support any neutral team anymore.
 
Maybe something he was just needing to get off his chest as they really couldn't cope with conditions last time around.
 
epic phainta you received from india in that series. don't be salty boy. I actually like you. well not really but you are a good player.

Either way saffers lucky bumrah isn't playing lol.
 
There really was no need to bring up the past, especially after playing such a quality knock.
 
I kinda agree with Dean Elgar, i thot pitches in that series were exceptionally bad, thanks to Shastri and Kohli. Winning test matches on those pitches may embellish your record, but i doubt there can ever be any sense of accomplishment for those victories. Btw it was the same series where SA batted for 150 overs in one inning to score around 140 runs.
 
Don't think Elgar said anything wrong. He was asked a question about what he will do differently compared to the 2015 series, and he was perfectly correct in stating there's no comparison as those pitches weren't fit for test cricket. Elgar should know as he got career-best figures bowling absolute pies in one of those tests.
 
There was only one bad pitch. What happened to Saffers at Kotla and Chinnaswamy on good wickets? They were getting destroyed. Excuses nothing more.
 
How about that pitch in South Africa where every ball was an injury waiting to happen?

In spite of that, we ended up winning.
 
If you get pounded in every match by opposition, the only way to decrease your frustration is by whining.

I am proud that our new test team under ravi shastri never rants about pitches we get in foreign conditions.
The 3rd test in Sa was on a deadly pitch where saffers were trying to escape but our team defeated them.
 
How about that pitch in South Africa where every ball was an injury waiting to happen?

In spite of that, we ended up winning.

Or the pitch against Pakistan when the pitch was cracking on that offstump line by day 2 :) . It's another matter that Pakistani bowlers were not exploiting it properly . :srini
 
There is nothing wrong in what Elgar said.
He was asked question pertaining to 2015 and he answered honestly.
He is also 100% correct. The pitches at Mohali and Nagpur were definitely not fit for Test cricket. Lottery cricket it was
 
Elgar was asked about 2015. Did not bring it up himself. Don't know why everyone is unnecessarily berating him.

Elgar is the best opener in the world. He himself played a brilliant knock in the 4th innings in wanderers on that deadly pitch.
 
Don't think Elgar said anything wrong. He was asked a question about what he will do differently compared to the 2015 series, and he was perfectly correct in stating there's no comparison as those pitches weren't fit for test cricket. Elgar should know as he got career-best figures bowling absolute pies in one of those tests.

s.africa do the same. they prepare pitches to suit their team. india did nothing wrong. it's only not twst material when you get smashed rofl. saffers are whiners. they deserved to get smashed and that's exactly what happened.
 
Dean Elger - It's a challenge to go to.small places (India) where the hotels are not so good

Little bit of success seems to have got into this man's head.

He must be reminded that even Modi, India had some of the most renowned luxury hotels in the world.

If your broke cricket board cannot book good hotels for you it's not fault of India which is on its path to become a true super power of the world.
 
lol at this elgar clown. India has far more luxiorus hotels than south africa. You just need money to pay for it which you guys clearly don't have. Good luck.
 
Little bit of success seems to have got into this man's head.

He must be reminded that even Modi, India had some of the most renowned luxury hotels in the world.

If your broke cricket board cannot book good hotels for you it's not fault of India which is on its path to become a true super power of the world.
You can't live without bringing politics into everything, can you?
 
lol at this elgar clown. India has far more luxiorus hotels than south africa. You just need money to pay for it which you guys clearly don't have. Good luck.


Little bit of success seems to have got into this man's head.

He must be reminded that even Modi, India had some of the most renowned luxury hotels in the world.

If your broke cricket board cannot book good hotels for you it's not fault of India which is on its path to become a true super power of the world.

He's clearly talking about small places as in Ranchi compared to places like Mumbai, Delhi, Kolkata etc.

The host board are responsible for the booking of hotels for the touring team.
 
Last edited:
There must be atleast one or two hotels even in small cities. Idea of hosting these matches in small town is to bring crowd to the matches. Both teams stay at similar hotels. Not sure why it is a problem for him. Check Virat Kohli's house located in Mumbai. Most of these Indian players live in expensive houses.
 
There must be atleast one or two hotels even in small cities. Idea of hosting these matches in small town is to bring crowd to the matches. Both teams stay at similar hotels. Not sure why it is a problem for him. Check Virat Kohli's house located in Mumbai. Most of these Indian players live in expensive houses.

Both teams were meant to be staying at the same hotel (as they quite often do) but there was an issue with the booking so South Africa got shifted last minute to another hotel further away from the stadium that from the looks of things is usually about half the price the one they were mean to stay at/India are staying at is.
 
Little bit of success seems to have got into this man's head.

He must be reminded that even Modi, India had some of the most renowned luxury hotels in the world.

If your broke cricket board cannot book good hotels for you it's not fault of India which is on its path to become a true super power of the world.

South Africa batsman Dean Elgar has drawn some anger from fans on social media for comments made on “testing conditions” in India.

Speaking after the South Africa practice session in Ranchi on Thursday, Elgar had said, “You get to know yourself a lot as a person when you come to the smaller places where the hotels are maybe not as good, and you get challenged on the food you eat potentially.”

“It’s always a good learning curve coming to India. They’re very streetwise and clever with touring teams,” he had said.

Elgar’s comments did not go down well with fans. Some called him a “sore loser”. Some recalled the fact that there had been a water crisis in Johannesburg when the Indian team had toured the last time – because of which Indian players had been told to not use the shower for more than two minutes.

https://indianexpress.com/article/s...criticizing-indian-ranchi-hotel-food-6076640/
 
He's clearly talking about small places as in Ranchi compared to places like Mumbai, Delhi, Kolkata etc.

The host board are responsible for the booking of hotels for the touring team.

Have never been to Ranchi, which is strictly tier-2, but can imagine the hotels not being nice enough. However, Elgar is coming across as a sore loser, especially with the comment that "Indians are street smart with touring teams" indirectly blaming the Indian team/board of conspiring against SA and having them being given poor lodging so that it impacts their game. If that's not the dictionary definition of being a sore loser then I don't know what is. Especially when his team has not put up a fight in a single session and wasted the spectator's money on a sub standard show.
 
Elgar is such a sook, will sook over pitches, conditions and now even over hotel!
 
lol at this elgar clown. India has far more luxiorus hotels than south africa. You just need money to pay for it which you guys clearly don't have. Good luck.

Why do Indians take every small comment as a personal insult lol.

From donkey-gate (Nasser Hussain) to manual sight screens (Hayden) to Sharapova not knowing Sachin, it seems Indians look for opportunities to be offended.
 
Last edited:
Why do Indians take every small comment as a personal insult lol.

From donkey-gate (Nasser Hussain) to manual sight screens (Hayden) to Sharapova not knowing Sachin, it seems Indians look for opportunities to be offended.

We take pride in being sensitive and emotional.
 
Elgar is such a sook, will sook over pitches, conditions and now even over hotel!

Crybaby. Remember when we were in SA the team members were asked to use shower for less than 2 minutes per day. Sick and tired of these SENA prima donnas whining and crying every time they step foot in Asia.
 
Last edited:
what a whiny twit. This midget will try and complain and make excuses unless his team is winning rofl. Get over it. You are nothing special. You just came yo against a GOAT home team. Now get lost as there is another phainta incoming.
 
this clown will now proclaim that the food was poisoned.

had too much curry as meat wasn't available for protein. I couldn't find protein shakes in the neighbourhood.
we dint win the toss rofl. Like that would make a difference in india anyway.
Pitches are a farce even though even though these were good batting pitches rofl with enough assistance for the seam attack. Just cause you can't bat doesn't mean the pitches are a farce. The pitch you served india last time they toured? That was beyond pathetic.

Grow up man. India lost the toss in s.africs too where toss actually matters. No one whined ?
 
Why do Indians take every small comment as a personal insult lol.

From donkey-gate (Nasser Hussain) to manual sight screens (Hayden) to Sharapova not knowing Sachin, it seems Indians look for opportunities to be offended.

Okay not everybody gets upset over everything. On issues like Sharapova not knowing sachin , i defended Sharapova. There is one particular south state (sreesanth's state) where people are ultra nationalistic just on social media. Rest of them don't bother about every little thing. Besides with such high number of internet users, there must be one or two voices against every thing.
 
What about second test in Pune?? Why proteas failed on green patches
Bavuma said Pune pitch is similar to home pitch.

Elgar trying to something to cover the series loss
 
They did that to nullify Abdv/ Amla factor. But SA got their revenge in return by preparing wickets that they themselves were scared to bat on in 4th inning.
 
Crybaby. Remember when we were in SA the team members were asked to use shower for less than 2 minutes per day. Sick and tired of these SENA prima donnas whining and crying every time they step foot in Asia.
True.

Try telling these prima donnas to limit their showers to just 2 min and see what hue and cry they raise. Elgar though has managed to sook about his own pitches, now beat that!
 
Golden duck at Centurion.

Failing at home too now. The great Indian curse takes one more victim.
 
Back
Top