What's new

Demonetisation success: Explained in numbers

Hitman

Senior T20I Player
Joined
Feb 25, 2013
Runs
17,345
In the backdrop of the RBI's report stating that 99 per cent of the demonetised cash had come back into the banking system, the government today released data to substantiate its claim that note ban has achieved all its objectives.


INDIA'S HIGHEST EVER DETECTION OF BLACK MONEY

* Scrutiny of suspected 18 lakh accounts done

* Cash deposits worth Rs 2.89 lakh crore under investigation

* Advance data analytics tools identified 5.56 lakhs new suspect cases

* 4,73,003 suspicious transactions detected

* Undisclosed income worth Rs. 29,213 crore detected and admitted.

* Black money worth Rs 16,000 crore did not return post demonetisation
* 21 per cent reduction in currency in circulation


UNPRECEDENTED INCREASE IN TAX COMPLIANCE

* 56 lakh new tax payers added

* Number of returns filed increase 24.7 per cent compared to 9.9 per cent in previous year

* Advance tax collections of personal income tax grow at 41.79 per cent over same period of last year

* Personal income tax under self-assessment tax grow at 34.25 per cent over same period last year.


CLEANSING INDIA'S FINANCIAL SYSTEM

* Transactions of more than three lakh suspected shell companies under the radar

* 2.1 lakh shell companies de-registered

* Around 450 companies delisted and 800 untraceable companies to be further delisted

* More than 400 benami transactions identified and market value of properties attached more that Rs 800 crore


SLEW OF BENEFITS TO THE COUNTRY

* Deposits in the banking system increased around Rs 3 lakh crore

* Additional liquidity helped reduce interest rates by 100 basis points

* Digital payments increase by 56 per cent from 71.27 crore transactions in October 2016 to 111.45 crore transaction in May, 2017

* More than one crore workers added to EPF and ESIC system post-demonetisation

* Bank accounts opened for about 50 lakh workers to get their wages credited directly in their accounts


Link: http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...explained-in-numbers/articleshow/60310546.cms
 
The biggest gain of it all from my POV, many have started using debit and Credit Cards.

May parents who were totally against using Debit card before use it pretty much every where now. Actually they like it now. Saves them the hassle of going to the bank and drawing the money once every month. Also no chance of thieves and robbers stealing money.
If the card is stolen, call the bank and immediately cancel the card and get a new card.

Still a long long long way to go before majority start using e-transactions. All the transactions are monitored by the banks.
 
Last edited:
My takeaway is that , one really has to look long term in seeing the value of this move rather than the now. I for one believe that it took a lot of guts to go ahead with this decision to demonetize and would love to hear the backstory on the real people involved in getting Modi to take this step, and how much planning in getting there. Assuming the idea came from the office dealing with treasury and finance. But in a country like India where im thinking 75 to 80% are dwelling in cash transactions, and to change all that in one swoop with this move takes a lot of heart and courage, not to mention the criticisms from all angles. Long term i would like to believe that this would make people more accountable and realize the advantage in using cards, can't avoid tax evasion, there's a digital trail with money coming in and out, more money in banks means banks can afford to give loans at lower interest and overall more money flowing towards the economy...
 
My takeaway is that , one really has to look long term in seeing the value of this move rather than the now. I for one believe that it took a lot of guts to go ahead with this decision to demonetize and would love to hear the backstory on the real people involved in getting Modi to take this step, and how much planning in getting there. Assuming the idea came from the office dealing with treasury and finance. But in a country like India where im thinking 75 to 80% are dwelling in cash transactions, and to change all that in one swoop with this move takes a lot of heart and courage, not to mention the criticisms from all angles. Long term i would like to believe that this would make people more accountable and realize the advantage in using cards, can't avoid tax evasion, there's a digital trail with money coming in and out, more money in banks means banks can afford to give loans at lower interest and overall more money flowing towards the economy...

Arun Jaitley: It pays to be honest, I-T department will go after evaders

This above statement kind off sums it off to me .
It may not pay to be honest yet , but they have taken steps to ensure evading taxes and getting away cant be easy , most people will start believing its simply not worth the effort . Once the tax base goes up another 20-30% they will have the buffer to relax the tax brackets . Which again means , more money in our pockets and more spending to take GDP growth rates a notch higher .
 
So in a country of 1.2 billion, you added 5.6 million tax payers!!.... unbelievable.

A huge chunk of them are day laborers, Vegetable vendors, Dhobis, rickshaw pullers.... They are never going to pay taxes. Majority of India earn less than $2/day. Cannot tax them on that.
 
A huge chunk of them are day laborers, Vegetable vendors, Dhobis, rickshaw pullers.... They are never going to pay taxes. Majority of India earn less than $2/day. Cannot tax them on that.

That and the biggest reason is Agriculture is not taxed which makes up more than 50% of our work force . The working population in India is only around 400m anyway .
 
That and the biggest reason is Agriculture is not taxed which makes up more than 50% of our work force . The working population in India is only around 400m anyway .

Ideally everyone should be taxed. But political do not have the courage to touch agricultural sector and other low income group. They are everyone's vote bank. Cannot anger them.
 
Well we had only ~45 million tax payers till last year .
we are talking about , ~3.5 Lac crore added in tax revenues

Don't you have a middle class in the 100s of million people? Middle class by definition should be paying tax, But still only 50 million tax payers, something doesn't add up.
 
Don't you have a middle class in the 100s of million people? Middle class by definition should be paying tax, But still only 50 million tax payers, something doesn't add up.

middle class includes kids and housewifes and old parents etc

or do you think everyone in middle class will pay tax :))
 
Don't you have a middle class in the 100s of million people? Middle class by definition should be paying tax, But still only 50 million tax payers, something doesn't add up.

Anyone doing agriculture pays no tax.Thats almost 30 to 40% of the work force.These people belong to every strata,from mercedes riding ones to extremely poor ones.
 
Anyone doing agriculture pays no tax.Thats almost 30 to 40% of the work force.These people belong to every strata,from mercedes riding ones to extremely poor ones.

You can be millionaire farmer and yet pay no tax. That's not right. Why is agriculture such a sacred cow ... pardon the pun.
 
You can be millionaire farmer and yet pay no tax. That's not right. Why is agriculture such a sacred cow ... pardon the pun.

No idea. The image of "garib kisan" have been there forever.They also get subsidies.
 
So in a country of 1.2 billion, you added 5.6 million tax payers!!.... unbelievable.

Not even 5.6 millions. This figure includes the existing tax payers who have moved to e-filing.


"The data maintained by the Income Tax Department shows that during April 1, 2017 to August 5, 2017, 2.79 crore e- returns of individual taxpayers were received as against 2.23 crore e-returns received during April 1, 2016 to August 5, 2016. Thus, the additional ITRs received in 2017 works out to be 56 lakh," CBDT said in a statement.

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...ency-in-numbers-cbdt/articleshow/60123042.cms
 
Hilarious to see Bhakts so desperate running around like chickens without heads.
 
Anyone doing agriculture pays no tax.Thats almost 30 to 40% of the work force.These people belong to every strata,from mercedes riding ones to extremely poor ones.

I thought it was just a Pakistani thing

because the landowners in Punjab and Sindh (who are rich beyond anything) who basically run the country also engage in agriculture
 
its same in Pakistan

Really? A blanket exemption is just madness.

Oh well the sacred cow needs to be tackled but considering how all the Waderas are also the law makers, do not see that forthcoming anytime soon.
 
Really? A blanket exemption is just madness.

Oh well the sacred cow needs to be tackled but considering how all the Waderas are also the law makers, do not see that forthcoming anytime soon.



Yes it's not changing

Both pml-n and PPP depend on landowners of Punjab and Sindh so it would be stupid for them to break their own power base.

Dunno why the martial law dictators didn't break this hold. Atleast they didn't have any interest linked to this
 
Yes it's not changing

Both pml-n and PPP depend on landowners of Punjab and Sindh so it would be stupid for them to break their own power base.

Dunno why the martial law dictators didn't break this hold. Atleast they didn't have any interest linked to this
Because the military as an institution and military personnel own a lot of agricultural land and have several other businesses involved in agriculture (AWT, FFC/FFBL etc.). You should read Ayesha Siddiqa's "Military Inc" for an in depth look into the underlying structure of our military's economy. Some excerpts that should at least partially answer your question:

"This is because after 1947 the most significant amount of land reclaimed for agriculture (through building reservoirs and canals) was in Sindh. The military was given 10 per cent of the approximately 9 million acres of land reclaimed through the construction of the Kotri, Guddu and Ghulam Mohammad dams in Sindh."

"According to Hassan-Askari Rizvi's study approximately 300,000 acres were given to military officers in Sindh during Ayub's rule."

"The army's direct involvement in agriculture and its possession of rural land did not become evident until the eruption of a conflict in Okara in Central Punjab in 2001, between landless peasants and the armed services. The Okara farms are part of a military farms group, Okara and Renala, which comprises 16,627 acres of land, consisting of two dairy farms, seven military (oat and hay) farms, and 22 villages."
Note: Nurpur, of butter and cheese fame, is one of the products of Okara. There were similar protests to the ones in 2001 about 2 or 3 years ago.

"The most conspicuous case of exploitation of land, however, relates to the transfer of agricultural properties to military personnel. The military, as mentioned above, has acquired about 6.9 million acres of land for further redistribution to individual officers and soldiers."

"The army has often forced the provincial governments to grant land for agriculture and other purposes. In most cases, the acquisition is justified in the name of national security or the reason is not given at all. For instance, the service demanded 20,000 acres in 2000 along the superhighway in Karachi, an upcoming area for industrial development. The army also asked for 12,000 acres of agricultural land for transfer to militart personnel affected by the establishment of the capital in Islamabad during the 1960s. This particular attitude generates resentment, especially in smaller provinces that see the military as an invading force rather than a national army."
 
Like I said earlier stop looking at it from the now or the prior but the long term success then it's worth in the sense the future is a lot brighter. Sure there were hardships and from what I hear some people dies over this but if India needs to keep moving forward that I think this risk was worth it in the end... Every other country should take notice and maybe try to do something similar irrespective of the chaos that will ensue..
 
India's economic growth slumps as big reforms bite

India's economy is having a difficult year.
The South Asian nation's gross domestic product grew 5.7% in the quarter ended June, the government said Thursday. That's a big drop from the quarter before and much slower than the 7.1% growth it recorded in the same period last year. It's also the weakest rate of growth in three years.
The slowdown has ended India's claim to be the world's fastest-growing major economy and is being blamed on big reforms introduced by Prime Minister Narendra Modi: last year's sudden ban on 86% of the country's cash, and the recent introduction of a national goods and services tax (GST).
"There has been a hit to growth on the back of various disruptive changes," said Anubhuti Sahay, head of South Asia research for Standard Chartered. "Initially it was [the cash ban], now the GST impact has just hit and it's likely to persist for a couple of quarters at least."
Related: India's red-hot economy is losing steam
The goods and services tax marks a significant overhaul of India's tax system, replacing a complex web of local tariffs and uniting the country's 29 states into a single market for the first time.
It is widely expected to boost growth in the long run, but economists predict months of disruption as business gets used to the new system and more people are drawn into the tax net.
The self-inflicted cash crisis, meanwhile, had already helped slow growth to 6.1% in the quarter ended March, down from 7% in the previous quarter.
It was sparked by Modi's decision to take all 500 rupee and 1000 rupee notes -- the two largest denominations at the time -- out of circulation in November. Their removal led to widespread chaos as millions lined up to deposit their money and activity in parts of the economy came to a virtual standstill.
Related: What happened when India trashed its cash
The government says it wanted to crack down on tax evaders by rendering piles of hidden cash suddenly useless, and also to flush out fake currency from the economy.
But 99% of the banned notes have found their way back into the system, the central bank revealed this week, leading some to suggest that Indians had found ways to launder their so-called "black money."
India's finance ministry admitted that a "significant portion" of the deposited cash could represent illegal wealth. It said it had identified around 1.8 million accounts that "did not appear to be in line with their tax profile," and it continues to investigate the deposits.
Experts say that the government needs to show results fast if it wants to paint the cash ban as a success.
"99% of the cash has come back into the system, so extinguishing black money really hasn't worked," Pronab Sen, the India head for the International Growth Centre and the country's former chief statistician, told CNNMoney.
"The negative effects of demonetization are going to last at least another year, if not longer."

http://money.cnn.com/2017/08/31/news/economy/india-economic-growth-slumps-cash-tax-reform/index.html
 
Because the military as an institution and military personnel own a lot of agricultural land and have several other businesses involved in agriculture (AWT, FFC/FFBL etc.). You should read Ayesha Siddiqa's "Military Inc" for an in depth look into the underlying structure of our military's economy. Some excerpts that should at least partially answer your question:






Note: Nurpur, of butter and cheese fame, is one of the products of Okara. There were similar protests to the ones in 2001 about 2 or 3 years ago.

Thanks

really eye opening info. Id always suspected sth of this sort but never really had the info/proof
 
Thanks

really eye opening info. Id always suspected sth of this sort but never really had the info/proof

The book is available for free in the public domain and given your educational and professional background, it's one you would enjoy. Contains a treasure trove of extremely meticulously sourced and referenced information on the subject.
 
The book is available for free in the public domain and given your educational and professional background, it's one you would enjoy. Contains a treasure trove of extremely meticulously sourced and referenced information on the subject.

Thanks. Obv Ive heard about it but never got to actually reading it

But will def give it a read
 
I thought it was just a Pakistani thing

because the landowners in Punjab and Sindh (who are rich beyond anything) who basically run the country also engage in agriculture

There is no feudal system.
 
You can be millionaire farmer and yet pay no tax. That's not right. Why is agriculture such a sacred cow ... pardon the pun.

No idea. The image of "garib kisan" have been there forever.They also get subsidies.


Because people are greedy even if you are a millionaire and you are not expected to pay tax you would love it and won't pay..

The agriculture community in India is huge any government who tries to mess with them and impose taxes on them would be out of office before you can blink an eye.. No leader or political party is strong enough to impose taxes on them only if we get a honest military dictator then he "might" impose taxes.. But since that will never happen Kisaan's will continue to get a free ride..
 
Ideally everyone should be taxed. But political do not have the courage to touch agricultural sector and other low income group. They are everyone's vote bank. Cannot anger them.

I do agree but practically speaking we are not yet ready for it . I know a small section of farmers are millionaires , but a large majority are still not doing well . The first step should be to ensure Farmers get their due and I think there are quite a few measures already taken especially against hoarding .

Also its a sensitive topic , with Farmers committing suicides every years any such move will be very unpopular . So unlikely anyone will even think of taxing Agriculture for next 10 years minimum
 
The real question is - Was demonetization worth it? Tough time for Bhakts

if thats the real question and even if the answer is "No" , the Govt has nothing to be ashamed off . They took a bold decision to clean the Indian system , thats commendable .
 
NO sure whats that supposed to mean . e-filing is also tax filing !!

OP says 56 lakhs new taxpayers added which is misleading. 56 lakh people have moved to e-filing which will include taxpayers who were filing tax returns through conventional methods till last year. Thus, the total taxpayers added this year would be less than 56 lakhs.
 
if thats the real question and even if the answer is "No" , the Govt has nothing to be ashamed off . They took a bold decision to clean the Indian system , thats commendable .

Deaths of more than 100 people and government has nothing to be ashamed off? It was Modi who forced demonetization on the country without taking adequate measures. He should have resigned.
 
Back
Top