Does Imran Khan and PTI deserve criticism for Karachi's present state?

[Savak]

Have been watching many clips on tv and its pretty telling that plenty of protestors in Defence, Clifton i.e. the posh elite rich educated class areas of Karachi and most were spouting abuse at PTI and Imran Khan for their plight.

Some of the criticism is fair because PTI did win plenty of National Assembly and Provincial Assembly seats in Karachi, the President of the country Arif Alvi won his NA seat in Defence, Faisal Vawda, Ali Zaidi, Aamir Liaqat Hussain, Asad Umar won their seats for Karachi. Imran Khan won their seats from Karachi.

PTI's argument in the last 2 years has been that they are unable to intervene in Karachi's affairs beyond a certain point because the 18th Amendment has given all the powers to the Provincial Government. To be fair to the PTI, every time IK and PTI have talked about taking control of Karachi via making it a federal capital or governors rule, Bilawal has screamed in Press Conferences about a conspiracy against Sindh which i find funny because every time something goes wrong in Khi, his party goes missing and passes the buck to the federal government.

However i do want to ask, do the national assembly and provincial assembly members get any development funds? If yes, how much? Do they have the discretion on how and what kind of projects are to be invested in?

I must admit that i am personally dissapointed that both Arif Alvi, IK have not visited Khi as of yet given the emergency situation on the ground. When the residents of Defence and Clifton feel compelled to undertake a violent mutiny against the Defence Housing Authority and Clifton Cantonment Board officials, you know how dire the situation is.

 

[Colorblind Genius]

Yes, Imran Khan and PTI deserve all the criticism in the world, while portion of awaam and other party supporters like this, should be awared with "Tamgha-e-Imtiyaz.

https://www.facebook.com/100004155338374/posts/1650160448465784/?extid=Bzj1xgPqO3ofPv4X&d=n

 

[MenInG]

ISLAMABAD: Prime Minister Imran Khan on Monday directed the relevant authorities to finalise the much-needed ‘Karachi Transformation Plan’ within a week to address major civic issues confronting the country’s commercial hub.

Presiding over a meeting at Prime Minister House, Mr Khan directed that the plan be finalised in consultation with all the stakeholders.

“The federal government is cognisant of the sufferings of the people of Karachi due to civic issues and will play its role in mitigating them,” the prime minister was quoted as saying in an official press release.

Sindh Governor Imran Ismail, Minister for Planning Asad Umar, Maritime Minister Syed Ali Zaidi (through video link), National Disaster Management Authority chairman Lt Gen Mohammad Afzal and other officials attended the meeting.

Wants all stakeholders taken on board, says govt cognisant of Karachi’s sufferings

Prime Minister Khan said the country’s progress and development was linked to the prosperity of the metropolis.

He was apprised of Karachi’s problems related to clean drinking water, sewerage system, solid waste management and transport, and was updated on the proposals that aimed to resolve the issues on a permanent basis.

A presentation on ‘Karachi Transformation Plan’, prepared by the planning ministry, was also shown during the meeting.

Meanwhile, Information Minister Shibli Faraz, at a press conference on Monday, said the provincial information minister, Nasir Shah, had claimed that Karachi’s problems could be addressed if $10 billion was given to the Sindh government.

“First of all, we do not have the money. And, even if we did, we would not have given it to the Sindh government because the amount would have landed in the bank accounts of the province’s ruling party leaders,” the minister said.

He said PPP leader Qamar Zaman Kaira had claimed in a press conference that “Imran Khan and Pakistan cannot go together”.

“Yes, I agree Imran Khan and Pakistan before Aug 18, 2018, which was rejected by the people. Imran Khan is now representing a new Pakistan in which welfare of the poor is the basic object,” he added.

Mr Faraz said PPP had been ruling Sindh for over 12 years and had swallowed trillions of rupees earmarked for development and uplift projects.

Earlier, in his tweet, the minister said all resources were being utilised to deal with the emergency situation in Karachi without any political discrimination.

He said the federal government and its affiliated agencies were providing all possible assistance to the provincial government.

“Due to rains, the people of the ‘City of Quaid’ are passing through testing times and the entire nation’s sympathies were with them,” he added.

Joint session
During the press conference, Shibli Faraz hinted that the government intended to hold a joint sitting of the Senate and National Assembly to get the legislation related to Financial Action Task Force (FATF) passed.

The opposition in the Senate had earlier opposed the legislation.

“Even if it is a joint session, we have to pass the bills which are a need of Pakistan; otherwise we can be blacklisted,” the minister said.

“We want to tell the people that we are compelled to have such legislations, but there are also some who are trying to protect certain individuals’ corruption by bulldozing the legislation,” he added.

The minister said the opposition wanted a concession similar to the National Reconciliation Ordinance for their “corrupt” leaders by “blackmailing” on FATF-related bills.

Prime Minister Khan also met a delegation of American Business Council.

He reiterated that removal of hurdles in the way of business was the topmost priority of the government.

He directed his advisers on finance and commerce to review the council’s recommendations so that those that were implementable could be adopted.

A cheque amounting to Rs17 million was also presented by the council for the PM’s Corona Relief Fund.

The council has already deposited Rs20 million in the fund Attachments area.

https://www.dawn.com/news/1577321/imran-asks-for-karachi-transformation-plan-in-a-week

 

[Giannis]

Nope. The feds aren't responsible for municipal issues, now that this is a national level disaster it's now Khan's job to respond which is what he is doing but if you're asking why he didn't preemptively prepare for this, the answer is simple - the local infrastructure is the local governments job which is clearly limited by the pronvincial government.

 

[Syed1]

The only criticism the people of Karachi give them is why they haven't fired the Sindh government yet and imposed governer rule. We are enslaved by Sindhi PPP.

 

[Gharib Aadmi]

No. PTI does not control the local government. PTI needs to, and it looks like they will, use federal funds for Karachi. And its best to have zero expectations from PPP, as this way one wont be disappointed.

 

[Savak]

Am trying desperately to convince my dad to postpone his Khi trip this week. Am hearing horror stories about water tanks being filled with Gutter and Sewage water. High risk of diseases

 

[Savak]

Here is Shabhaz Sharif in Karachi. Held a meeting with Zardari and Bilawal Bhutto, Zardari and Bilawal have not once gone in public to express solidarity with the victims in a city in their own province, a province where they have held provincial govt for the last 12 years. The same Zardari whom Shabhaz Sharif threatened to hang once he came to power. The same Shahbaz Sharif who is lecturing the federal government not to play politics at this time and at the same time is blaming the federal government for not providing any funds to the provincial government all this while.

This is just badniyati personified.

 

[Abdullah719]

Here is Shabhaz Sharif in Karachi. Held a meeting with Zardari and Bilawal Bhutto, Zardari and Bilawal have not once gone in public to express solidarity with the victims in a city in their own province, a province where they have held provincial govt for the last 12 years. The same Zardari whom Shabhaz Sharif threatened to hang once he came to power. The same Shahbaz Sharif who is lecturing the federal government not to play politics at this time and at the same time is blaming the federal government for not providing any funds to the provincial government all this while.

This is just badniyati personified.