- Joined
- Jul 17, 2010
- Runs
- 31,975
- Post of the Week
- 2
England will find it difficult as the spin bowling options are very poor. India will spin them out of the game prettt quickly and probably dominate every test.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
What has Rahul done to deserve a spot,that too no. 3?
Rahul is a top order batsman and can only bat in top 3. Its not always someone has done something to deserve something, cricket is also about experimentation and trying things. There is no better place & time to experiment than in a home series.
Rahul is a terrific test batsman who is in his peak years now. He was our best batsman when Australia toured India back in 2017. But after that India mostly played overseas and he was rightfully dropped due to his struggles there. But he deserves another chance at home as he is an avg 50 test batsman whom we are just wasting in bench.
Though Pujara has done very well in last 2 Australia tour but time has come to look for alternatives. I dont think we need to have both Pujara & Rahane in the side batting at home. In overseas, only 2 out of Pujara, Rahane and Vihari should play.
I mean everyone knows that KL Rahul and Gill will open together in test cricket for long time but we are somehow delaying the inevitability. They tried same with Mayank Agarwal and I told before he will fail. Now there is a new drama going on with Project Rohit which has high potential to fail as badly as project Raina did in test cricket. After that they might try few more make shift openers. Then finally when reality becons, they will give back Rahul his rightful place. But until that happens we simply cant waste him in bench....so best thing is to make him bat at 3.
I am surprised that as an Indian cricket fan you are not able to see this inevitability. Its as clear as a portrait and even my 3rd eye can see - Gill & Rahul test openers (2022 - 2028) with both avg 50+.
Leach: 38-5-119-0
Bess: 26-2-76-0
In less than a couple of weeks, they will be bowling in India to Kohli, Pujara, Rohit, Gill and probably Pant.
: will do all the spinning.England side is:
Mister
Sibbers
Creepy
The New Sobers (c)
The New Botham
His Holiness
Beard
Dr Strangegloves (w)
Bess *
Archer *
Draco
* they have no puerile nicknames yet

Team that should play
Gill
Mayank
Pujara
Kohli
Rahane
Pant
Sundar
Akshar
Ashwin
Bumrah
Siraj
Team that Kohli will play(most likely)
Rohit
Gill
Pujara
Kohli
Rahane
Pant
Saha
Ashwin
Kuldeep
Ishant
Bumrah
Mayank have absolutely done nothing to deserve a spot in playing XI. Rohit is beast at home and will form a great partnership with Gill. We should also finish the Saha chapter for good as we know he is useless with bat and his keeping alone doesn’t merit selection. Pant will improve the more he spend time behind wickets.
Rohit
Gill
Pujara
Kohli
KL/Rahane
Pant
Ashwin
Axar/ H Pandya
Kuldeep
Bumrah
Ishant/Shami(if fit)
This playing XI bats all the way to no 9 and have 5 bowling options. Strongest playing XI we could assemble. If Jadeja was fit then it would’ve made the team unbeatable at home.
Mayank has a better average than Rohit at home.So there's that.Also younger and has better chance to improve overseas.Atleast has had one great series in Aus 2018
Sundar will play at 7 and takes Jaddu's position.
Need Axar to turn the ball away from RHBs
Shami isn't fit and Ishant is poor in India even in his new avatar.Siraj can reverse the ball and is in form.
Rahane is sureshot.KL is fighting for opener's slot and is behind Gill,Mayank,Rohit and Shaw
The team I chose has Ashwin at 9 and 5 bowlers
If Jadeja was there,we would have played Jaddu+Ash+3 pacers
Kohli will play Saha most likely.Pant is undroppable as of now but if he has couple of failures,talks of importance of specialist keepers will start again
Pandya doesn't deserve a place if hes not bowling significant overs.In any case if we need a seam AR,Thakur is there
Mayank’s time will come but for now Rohit is most likely opener alongside Gill. I personally would somehow fit KL into playing XI, should there be a need for a backup keeper but you’re right he won’t make into playing XI as a lower order batsman.
Kohli is already facing huge backlash on social media for ‘Chickening out’ in the middle of the series. Pant is in favour of the month and dropping him will basically mean unleashing wrath of fans and media which I doubt Kohli would want to do.
As much as I hate Kohli’s captaincy, I don’t think even he is that dumb to drop Pant right now after Aus series.
Axar is very similar to Jaddu, keeping things tight and also handy with the bat. I would play either him or Kuldeep alongside Ash. We will need an allrounder in playing XI instead of 3 seamers.
Ash
Allrounder
Axar/Kuldeep
Bumrah
Siraj
We don’t really need 3 pacers at home. Hardik Pandya will add that 3rd seam option( if he can bowl at least 10 overs/day) plus a very good lower order bat. We don’t really need Pandya to bowl more overs as spinners will be bowling bulk of the overs. Jaddu’s absence have somewhat disturb team balance.
I dont think Kohli or Indian Team management really care about what keyboard-warrior fans say on social media. Remember, Jadeja copped way worse abuse in his initial years from fans and still they kept him in the team. I can see they playing Saha ahead of Pant as his keeping against spinners is not that great and we need to win these tests against England to have a place in the Test championship final. And Saha bats fine in India.Mayank’s time will come but for now Rohit is most likely opener alongside Gill. I personally would somehow fit KL into playing XI, should there be a need for a backup keeper but you’re right he won’t make into playing XI as a lower order batsman.
Kohli is already facing huge backlash on social media for ‘Chickening out’ in the middle of the series. Pant is in favour of the month and dropping him will basically mean unleashing wrath of fans and media which I doubt Kohli would want to do.
As much as I hate Kohli’s captaincy, I don’t think even he is that dumb to drop Pant right now after Aus series.
Axar is very similar to Jaddu, keeping things tight and also handy with the bat. I would play either him or Kuldeep alongside Ash. We will need an allrounder in playing XI instead of 3 seamers.
Ash
Allrounder
Axar/Kuldeep
Bumrah
Siraj
We don’t really need 3 pacers at home. Hardik Pandya will add that 3rd seam option( if he can bowl at least 10 overs/day) plus a very good lower order bat. We don’t really need Pandya to bowl more overs as spinners will be bowling bulk of the overs. Jaddu’s absence have somewhat disturb team balance.
I dont think Kohli or Indian Team management really care about what keyboard-warrior fans say on social media. Remember, Jadeja copped way worse abuse in his initial years from fans and still they kept him in the team. I can see they playing Saha ahead of Pant as his keeping against spinners is not that great and we need to win these tests against England to have a place in the Test championship final. And Saha bats fine in India.
Rohit will also do well here but I'm already looking ahead to Eng tour.Mayank has been bad but atleast he doesn't play outrageous shots and than justify it saying its his role.
I doubt KL has the fitness to keep in Tests.Is getting injured all the time anyway
Pant won't be dropped for now.But I'll be surprised if he has a fair run as a keeper once he has 2-3 bad games.Outside chance that he'll play as a specialist bat here and Saha will keep
Sundar is that allrounder we need.Play both Axar and Sundar to make up for Jaddu.Call me biased but I've been mighty impressed by Sundar's batting and even considering for ODIs,gives another left hand option.
We won't need 3 quicks yes.As of now Pandya doesn't look fit to bowl which is why he was asked to return before Test series.Pandya has to make it as a top 6 bat first.
Official Statement - Zak Crawley
Following the results of last night’s scan, England top-order batsman Zak Crawley has been ruled out of the first two Tests of the India versus England series.
Scan results have confirmed that Crawley has jarred his right wrist, which has sprained the joint and led to local inflammation.
The Kent player sustained the injury during England’s practice in Chennai on Tuesday when he slipped on the marble floor leaving the dressing rooms onto the field of play.
The England medical team will continue to assess his progress over the next few weeks.

New Variant of SG Ball
The England Series at home will be played with the New Variant of SG Ball. The ball will now have a more pronounced seam. The cork used inside the ball will be harder and it will have a darker shade of red.
The ball is expected to bounce more and retain its hardness till the 60th over. The Seam is more pronounced now. The spinners wanted a seam which they can grip and thereby get more revolutions on the ball.
The last ball used to lose hardness, and seam flattened by the 10th over. The New Ball is expected to retain hardness till the 60th over and offer more bounce.
This will also help more seam movement,. The new variety is based on feedback from our Players.
Why the change?
For the past few years, the ball has been criticised by top Indian players like captain Virat Kolhi and off-spinner Ravichandran Ashwin. They have complained about the ball getting scuffed up early and losing hardness within the first 10 overs. Following feedback from the players, SG made changes and gave the handmade ball a machine-like finish. SG has been the official supplier for first-class cricket in India since 1993. Over the years, they have taken players’ feedback and modified the ball.
What has been the specific complaint of the cricketers?
Ashwin was vocal about the change in nature of the SG ball. “When I started playing Test cricket, the SG ball used to be top notch, and you could bowl with it even after the 70th or 80th over. The seam used to be standing up strong and straight. But it is not the same anymore,” Ashwin had told the official broadcaster during the home series against West Indies in 2018. After talking to the players in 2019, SG had been fine-tuning the manufacturing process for 18 months.
What is the change?
The ball will now have, as players like to say, uthi hui (pronounced) seam. The cork used inside the ball will be harder and it will have a darker shade of red. The ball is expected to bounce more and retain its hardness till the 60th over. “An important change is the seam. It is more pronounced now. The spinners especially wanted a seam which they can grip and thereby get more revolutions on the ball,” Paras Anand, the marketing director of SG, said.
Does a pronounced seam change the ball’s behaviour?
It certainly does. West Indian legend Michael Holding is of the view that this changed ball will help both pacers and spinners. “Firstly, the higher seam gives the bowler a better grip with his fingers. And especially for the spinner, the better grip gives him ability to impart more spin on the ball. For both the quickie and spinner, when the ball with the pronounced seam hits the pitch, it will deviate more because the higher the seam, the more friction created by the ball on the surface. If you think about the ball hitting the pitch with no friction created, there would be no deviation. Like bowling on glass where you get no friction and the ball just skids off straight,” he says.
Is this change sudden?
Former India pacer Irfan Pathan noticed the evolution of the SG ball when India played South Africa at home in 2019. “I felt the seam was a little more prominent and the ball was much harder when I was doing commentary for the India vs South Africa series. I remember in the Pune game, the way the fast bowlers were bowling, it seemed like they were not bowling with an SG ball, but with a Kookaburra ball. The ball has become of better quality and lasts longer. I think because the seam is a lot more upright, you will see the fast bowlers getting a lot of help as well,” Pathan said.
https://indianexpress.com/article/e...rker-red-sanspareils-greenlands-ball-7174199/
From what I understood from this article, the new variant of SG ball is more like a Duke's ball, if that's the case England will really enjoy it & they will end up wining at least 1 match.
We should definitely play Sundar ahead of Axar. I don't follow domestics much but unless I am missing something I am not sure why many Indian posters would like to see Axar in the XI.
Bro, Axar is better spinner than Sundar and he is perfect bowler for tests on square turning pitches.
From what I have seen of Axar I can't agree, I am sorry. We have now reached a position in test cricket where we have the luxury to see the bigger picture and act upon it instead of solely focusing on short-term gains. I would much rather invest on a 21 year old spinner of immense future potential and much higher ceiling than a 27 year old who hasn't played single test match till date. Hell, I don't think we will even produce square turners for this series.
lets see how Axar will perform on given chances.
We should definitely play Sundar ahead of Axar. I don't follow domestics much but unless I am missing something I am not sure why many Indian posters would like to see Axar in the XI.
From what I have seen of Axar I can't agree, I am sorry. We have now reached a position in test cricket where we have the luxury to see the bigger picture and act upon it instead of solely focusing on short-term gains. I would much rather invest on a 21 year old spinner of immense future potential and much higher ceiling than a 27 year old who hasn't played single test match till date. Hell, I don't think we will even produce square turners for this series.
I don’t think we will have 3 spinners in playing XI. I was reading on cricinfo that pitch curator have suggested that there will be some bounce on a pitch and will have turn on day 4/5. It won’t be typical ‘Indian’ pitch which could mean we will definitely need 3 seamers. Unfortunately, our seamers are classic tailenders and will struggle to buy a run. To fix that problem, we sure will need to bat deep or else one bad session could really undo all the hard work.
Ash
Axar/W Sundar / K Yadav
Bumrah
Ishant
Siraj
If K Yadav is selected then we will have 4/5 tailenders who can’t bat. Even Ash have regressed a lot lately in his batting and may not be same Ash of 2016 with the bat.
I just hope Jaddu is fit for last two test matches, as it will be played in his hometown and he wouldn’t want to miss playing in new stadium.
His inclusion will boost both batting and bowling strength.
Jaddu is out for whole series
If we play 3 seamers,Thakur has to be one of them
As per Kohli’s interview, Ash and Kuldeep are sure starters, which would mean 3 seamers. We will have very long tail I’m afraid.
Ash
K Yadav
Bumrah
Ishant
Siraj
That’s a very long tail. I’m glad that Pant is going to play or else our batting would have been further depleted. I just hope Kohli and Co fire all cylinders and not leave it for the tail to rescue.
Why three seamers? He has said the pitch is expected to be traditional flat Cheapauk wicket with assistance to spinners later. If he goes with Ash and Kul, I am sure he will pick one of Axar or Sundar at no.7.
That's great news.New Variant of SG Ball
The England Series at home will be played with the New Variant of SG Ball. The ball will now have a more pronounced seam. The cork used inside the ball will be harder and it will have a darker shade of red.
The ball is expected to bounce more and retain its hardness till the 60th over. The Seam is more pronounced now. The spinners wanted a seam which they can grip and thereby get more revolutions on the ball.
The last ball used to lose hardness, and seam flattened by the 10th over. The New Ball is expected to retain hardness till the 60th over and offer more bounce.
This will also help more seam movement,. The new variety is based on feedback from our Players.
Why the change?
For the past few years, the ball has been criticised by top Indian players like captain Virat Kolhi and off-spinner Ravichandran Ashwin. They have complained about the ball getting scuffed up early and losing hardness within the first 10 overs. Following feedback from the players, SG made changes and gave the handmade ball a machine-like finish. SG has been the official supplier for first-class cricket in India since 1993. Over the years, they have taken players’ feedback and modified the ball.
What has been the specific complaint of the cricketers?
Ashwin was vocal about the change in nature of the SG ball. “When I started playing Test cricket, the SG ball used to be top notch, and you could bowl with it even after the 70th or 80th over. The seam used to be standing up strong and straight. But it is not the same anymore,” Ashwin had told the official broadcaster during the home series against West Indies in 2018. After talking to the players in 2019, SG had been fine-tuning the manufacturing process for 18 months.
What is the change?
The ball will now have, as players like to say, uthi hui (pronounced) seam. The cork used inside the ball will be harder and it will have a darker shade of red. The ball is expected to bounce more and retain its hardness till the 60th over. “An important change is the seam. It is more pronounced now. The spinners especially wanted a seam which they can grip and thereby get more revolutions on the ball,” Paras Anand, the marketing director of SG, said.
Does a pronounced seam change the ball’s behaviour?
It certainly does. West Indian legend Michael Holding is of the view that this changed ball will help both pacers and spinners. “Firstly, the higher seam gives the bowler a better grip with his fingers. And especially for the spinner, the better grip gives him ability to impart more spin on the ball. For both the quickie and spinner, when the ball with the pronounced seam hits the pitch, it will deviate more because the higher the seam, the more friction created by the ball on the surface. If you think about the ball hitting the pitch with no friction created, there would be no deviation. Like bowling on glass where you get no friction and the ball just skids off straight,” he says.
Is this change sudden?
Former India pacer Irfan Pathan noticed the evolution of the SG ball when India played South Africa at home in 2019. “I felt the seam was a little more prominent and the ball was much harder when I was doing commentary for the India vs South Africa series. I remember in the Pune game, the way the fast bowlers were bowling, it seemed like they were not bowling with an SG ball, but with a Kookaburra ball. The ball has become of better quality and lasts longer. I think because the seam is a lot more upright, you will see the fast bowlers getting a lot of help as well,” Pathan said.
https://indianexpress.com/article/e...rker-red-sanspareils-greenlands-ball-7174199/
We should definitely play Sundar ahead of Axar. I don't follow domestics much but unless I am missing something I am not sure why many Indian posters would like to see Axar in the XI.
How about 'loch bess' for bess..England side is:
Mister
Sibbers
Creepy
The New Sobers (c)
The New Botham
His Holiness
Beard
Dr Strangegloves (w)
Bess *
Archer *
Draco
* they have no puerile nicknames yet
This is a big blow.
I guess Lawrence and Pope will both play now.

Archer injured and misses the 2nd Test.
I wonder if England will pick Anderson and Broad to play together again at last!
The other option is to rest Anderson so he stays fresh for the 3rd Test (pink ball / day-night), and to go with Broad & Woakes for the 2nd rubber.
Yes, Broad 100% will be playing.
However, don’t you think it’s a bit harsh Bess has been dropped? in he scored handy runs and bowled well in the first innings, am a fan of Mo but I don’t know if dropping Bess was the right thing to do, a bit of a ruthless move tbh
Archer injured and misses the 2nd Test.
I wonder if England will pick Anderson and Broad to play together again at last!
The other option is to rest Anderson so he stays fresh for the 3rd Test (pink ball / day-night), and to go with Broad & Woakes for the 2nd rubber.
Archer will be huge loss
India will win this
No archer no anderson and no bess

Moeen Ali better get a 5fer now and score at least a 50.
He will be heavily criticized if he flops.
India will win this
No archer no anderson and no bess
Anderson not playing?![]()
When was Anderson in T20??
There seem to be a few doubts around the stamina, endurance and overall fitness of Bess. In his 2nd innings Chennai spell he bowled far too many full tosses and short balls, which pretty much all went for boundaries. Whereas Leach has had a similar workload this season and yet he was landing it much more consistently towards the end of that game. Bess might be brought back towards the end of the series, or he might be sent home to work on his fitness.
The step up from bowling in English county matches within mild cloudy conditions, to bowling overseas for England in Test cricket under baking hot sun in 35 degree temperatures, remains a massive leap in standards.
what you on about

I think he means Eng can still win without Anderson just like their T20 side has been winning without the likes of Anderson for a long time. Whether this is a good comparison, is quite questionable.
I think they can as well since Kohli is back for India.![]()
With Archer and Anderson not playing, Broad and Woakes are pretty adequate replacements.
I thought they may have gone with wood since archer is injuired and is a like for like replacement