What's new

England v West Indies | Group B | WC'11 | Chennai | 17/3/11

Status
Not open for further replies.
West Indies | 6/211 | 38 Overs | Need 33 runs to win from 72 balls

7 off the over!
 
Good call by the third umpire. I'd rather give the benefit of the doubt to the batsman than trust Trott, he just looks shady :P
Jokes aside, you cannot take a fielder's word when his side is under pressure and on the verge of being knocked out in a global tournament.
 
Trusting players has gone out of the game. We all remember Ponting's bump ball claim against India. :afridi
 
im not watching the match live....can someone fill me in of what just happened between nasser and sanjay manjraekar please

Nasser was complaining that you need to trust the player's word here. And Manjrekar replies saying, Nasser..that was in the old days. In 2011 we don't do that anymore. Enough has happened on the field in the past that we HAVE to go to the third umpire.
 
trott friggin cheater

Harsh!!! as it was not conclusive from the replay if he touched it or not. but the benefit of the doubt has to go to the batsman.

He did not react badly when it was given as a six, just got on with it.

Can you imagine Pontings reaction, grandad would have thrown his toys out of the pram.
 
Nasser was complaining that you need to trust the player's word here. And Manjrekar replies saying, Nasser..that was in the old days. In 2011 we don't do that anymore. Enough has happened on the field in the past that we HAVE to go to the third umpire.

thanks for that bro
 
West Indies | 6/216 | 39 Overs | Need 28 runs to win from 66 balls

5 off the over!
 
Harsh!!! as it was not conclusive from the replay if he touched it or not. but the benefit of the doubt has to go to the batsman.

He did not react badly when it was given as a six, just got on with it.

Can you imagine Pontings reaction, grandad would have thrown his toys out of the pram.

Trott should not have put the finger up as if he was 100% sure it was out, he was clearly touching the rope, should've said he was unsure.
 
Trott is a major cheat :127:

wth?!? I honestly think he thought it was out. like Manjeraker said it was in the heat of the moment and sometimes you're not quit sure so obviously he was going to say Out. heck anyone would've done that.

Edit: and yea he did apologise afterwards.
 
Last edited:
West Indies | 6/217 | 40 Overs | Need 27 runs to win from 60 balls

1 off the over!
 
Tredwell on. Swann's last over being saved?
yep.

The biggest thing that's cost England is poor squad selection. Prior should never have been included. Tredwell, Yardy, Wright, all rubbish in both bowling and batting, took up valuable spots in the squad. They should have had a back up batsman (so they wouldn't have to play Tredwell and Wright in the same team) to replace a failing batsman.
 
Can people just confirm that an England loss here = Bangladesh qualifies??

Thats what I get from my calculations.
 
LOL, The replays showed Trott's shirt hitting the boundary, check it out again. The shadow should give you a hint.
 
Can people just confirm that an England loss here = Bangladesh qualifies??

Thats what I get from my calculations.

Yes, England has only five points, Bangla already has 6. If they had hammered WI they could have even ousted India on run-rate, but with such a close game, India has also virtually qualified even if England win.
 
yep.

The biggest thing that's cost England is poor squad selection. Prior should never have been included. Tredwell, Yardy, Wright, all rubbish in both bowling and batting, took up valuable spots in the squad. They should have had a back up batsman (so they wouldn't have to play Tredwell and Wright in the same team) to replace a failing batsman.

Kiesvester was a good keeper and batsman ....


He deserved another go..
 
windies looking a major threat in this WC??
England haven't played particularly well today. West Indies have been pretty average as well, except for Russell.

They're looking pretty strong. But I'd still bet on Pakistan if we had to face them. Don't think they'll beat India either.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top