Greenstorm
T20I Debutant
- Joined
- Mar 18, 2016
- Runs
- 6,409
The person with an identity crisis is you, and other "Muslim" liberals. You are not sure if you want to Identify with Islam, and since you live in a Muslim majority country, the idea of being a secular or cultural or liberal Muslim is alien too you. So you think that others must be confused. And therefore anyone who is religious is deemed "Arab". And liberals will mention Sufis even though they have very little knowledge of what they actually preached, and they will mention civilizations like the Indus even though they have zero knowledge about them and would not be able to mention one King of that civilization or what they actually contributed to modern day Pakistan, and the worst thing is you hold Muslims to different standards than every other group.
Your second problem is that you like right wing Indians have deemed Muslims who came and settled in the subcontinent from Central Asia, Afghanistan, and to a lesser degree Iran and Arabia, as perpetual foreigners. This is why you made the absurd statement that Muslims of Subcontinent have no achievements. So the architecture, the poetry, the cuisine, the literature, art, etc that all the various Muslim empires produced is foreign. You cant accept the idea that Muslims who settled in the subcontinent assimilated the other local Muslims into there culture, and together they created a new civilization, which had elements from both Islamic culture, Persian culture, as well as local subcontinent culture.
This would be the equivalent of people in England saying that because Anglo-Saxons invaded, Westminster Abbey and Palace of Westminster is not part of there heritage. Or because the Normans invaded the Tower of London and Canterbury Cathedral is not part of there heritage. Or because the Romans invaded Hardians Wall and Bath is not part of there heritage. And that they want to go back to the culture that existed before the Romans arrived. And they want to rename England, which is a name from the Anglo Saxons, and get rid of the English language and go back to the language before they all came.
But people in England like all sane people, don't view invaders and settlers as perpetual foreigners. They accept that there culture has many influences.
Last point one is forcing anyone to watch Etrgul. You are free to make your own show about the Indus Valley Civilization. However you are not entitled to stop others from watching what they want because you don't like it.
Nailed it. Pakistanis are watching Ertugrul because of its depiction of Islamic values not Arab or Ottoman values. It is a simple concept which some of our insecure/confused folk fail to understand. They are easily swayed by ethno/nationalist trappings whereas Islam emancipates mankind.