What's new

FIA finds Meesha guilty of ‘vilification’ drive against Ali Zafar [Post#202]

I would smack the bejesus out of him and create a hue and cry there and then so that he could be caught on spot. To begin with i would never meet such a person alone without presence of others.

Counter question to you : what if a woman falsely accuses you of molestation or harrassment? Would you want people to take her word for it?

Numerous studies (across different age groups) have shown "false accusations" are only seen in 2-5% of all reported cases. That's not high at all and should be reason enough to side with the victim until more comes out. Of course, Ali Zafar (or anyone else) deserves an opportunity to clear their name.
 
twitter in action

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">The sick mentality of those commenting on an issue as serious as sexual harassment as casually as they are just shows where the root of this problem exists - in our minds. We will continue to breed harassers for as long as we continue to desensitise this issue.</p>— Mahira Khan (@TheMahiraKhan) <a href="https://twitter.com/TheMahiraKhan/status/987256830597455872?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">April 20, 2018</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr"><a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/MeToo?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#MeToo</a> needs a response <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/ImSorry?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#ImSorry</a> from the offenders. Nothing will change until they acknowledge, take responsibility and make amends. <a href="https://t.co/sphI1c1agT">pic.twitter.com/sphI1c1agT</a></p>— Momina Mustehsan (@MominaMustehsan) <a href="https://twitter.com/MominaMustehsan/status/987351835311771650?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">April 20, 2018</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">It doesn't matter if she was wearing a burqa, a bikini, a skirt or a shawl. <br><br>It doesn't matter if it was her husband, if it was her boyfriend, if it was a stranger. <br><br>If she doesn't want you to touch her, if you still touch her, you are violating a boundary. <br><br>Understand that.</p>— Mahwash Ajaz (@mahwashajaz_) <a href="https://twitter.com/mahwashajaz_/status/986966774037078016?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">April 19, 2018</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
twitter in action



<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr"><a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/MeToo?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#MeToo</a> needs a response <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/ImSorry?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#ImSorry</a> from the offenders. Nothing will change until they acknowledge, take responsibility and make amends. <a href="https://t.co/sphI1c1agT">pic.twitter.com/sphI1c1agT</a></p>— Momina Mustehsan (@MominaMustehsan) <a href="https://twitter.com/MominaMustehsan/status/987351835311771650?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">April 20, 2018</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Things are gonna be really awkward between Danyal Zafar and Momina now.
 
Numerous studies (across different age groups) have shown "false accusations" are only seen in 2-5% of all reported cases. That's not high at all and should be reason enough to side with the victim until more comes out. Of course, Ali Zafar (or anyone else) deserves an opportunity to clear their name.

We can't ignore the few who are falsely accused bro. The question remains, what if you are accused falsely? Would you want people to take the woman's word for it?

In my opinion we cannot rely on word of a person. There is always a big risk that an innocent will be denied justice. This issue needs a creative solution at the base. More awareness to boys and girls from their childhood, more courage to women to take action on the spot. Maybe not meeting men alone can be another way as primitive as it may sound? Or meeting them alone in a place where they have cctv cameras? I mean Nothing comes before safety. It is difficult to achieve. I know it but this is the only way i think.
 
When singer-songwriter and actor Meesha Shafi talks to her two children, a boy and a girl, she always tells them to speak up if at any time someone, anyone, touches them or their private parts or even makes them uncomfortable in any way. It is a rule in her household that the children will never be left alone and will always have a responsible trusted adult, a parent or a family member with them (and which also includes vetted domestic staff, grandparents and so on). It is a subject on which she and her husband (Mehmood Rahman) are completely agreed on.

The kids are never left alone in the car, for instance and with due diligence she tells them: “It’s important to speak up; it is not your fault under any circumstances. It is never, ever your fault. Don’t ever think it is you who needs to hide this.”

So, when caught in the same situation as an adult and a powerful one at that, staying quiet about her own story began to gnaw at her. It has ultimately resulted in Shafi taking to Twitter and sharing her own story with a statement that alleges that popular singer/actor Ali Zafar has, on more than one occasion, subjected her to sexual harassment. Since the statement has gone public, Instep spoke with Shafi at length on, well, what happened. This is her story.

“The first time it happened, I didn’t react and just left,” Meesha recalls in an interview with Instep. “I told my husband but also asked him to not react; I’m a public figure and so is he (Ali Zafar). My thought process was who I am and who he is and what that’s going to lead to. Being ready to talk was far off because it had just happened. I buried it.”

It happened for the second time, Meesha tells Instep, late last year or last quarter of last year. And in both instances, they were not alone. The second time it happened in a jam room.

“I got booked for a concert,” she says. She and Ali Zafar were billed to perform on the same concert. Why did she say yes to the gig in the first place, I ask her, playing devil’s advocate? “It is my bread and butter, it was work coming my way,” she notes.

It eventually resulted in them preparing a song that they could perform together. “I was jamming with my band in Lahore and the organisers insisted that he was trying to get in touch. It started turning into a thing, and I was being seen as difficult or a diva, I got such feelers. I was avoiding him. I was asked to jam, figure out songs, scale and it happened while we were jamming.”

There are images of you and Ali together, I ask her. “I have run into him, our pictures have been taken, at social gatherings etc because it’s easier to to tell yourself to move on in whatever way you can, you try.”

What pushed you to say something and to speak now?

“The first and foremost reason is that I’m ready. I have started talking to people and divulging my experience. I’m finding it hard on my conscious to stay silent any longer than this because I’m seeing such brave girls and women speaking up – not just around the world – but here as well.

I have to say, by the way, I salute these girls,” she adds, referring to the girls who spoke about former Patari CEO Khalid Bajwa. “It’s not easy. They are not public figures and I think it can be harder for me, in a way, but it’s hard for everyone. The more I think about it, the more I realise that if I don’t go public, nothing will change. It was eating away at me.”

“I am telling my children how important it is to speak up, so it was getting difficult for me to stay silent knowing that it was not accidental or subtle.”

As she recalls it, this was not about a hug that went on for too long, a greeting that went on for a little too long or a lingering handshake. “Women who feel that that’s inappropriate and speak-up and feel harassed, that is absolutely their right and not to take away anything from them in any way but it was more than that and that people need to know.”

For Meesha, since going public with her story, a burden has been lifted. “It is liberating, it’s empowering and it’s not the end of the world. I only felt hesitant as long as I hadn’t told anyone. The more people I tell, the more power I feel. I do. That has been my direct experience in the case. I’ve done the thing I feared and I’ve taken the leap of faith. And you know what, it’s okay.”


Ali Zafar denies allegations of sexual harassment

Ali Zafar has denied all allegations made by Meesha Shafi and has decided to take the legal route. His statement in entirely below...

“I am deeply aware and in support of the global #MeToo movement and what it stands for. I am the father of a young girl and a young boy, a husband to a wife and a son to a mother. I am a man that has stood up for myself, my family, my colleagues and friends countless times in the face of slander, defamation and general unkindness. I will do the same today. I have nothing to hide. Silence is absolutely not an option.

I categorically deny any and all claims of harassment lodged against me by Ms Shafi. I intend to take this through the courts of law and to address this professionally and seriously rather than to lodge any allegations here, contesting personal vendettas on social media and in turn disrespecting the movement, my family, the industry and my fans. Ultimately I am a strong believer that the truth, always prevails.”

https://www.thenews.com.pk/magazine...hing-i-feared-and-ive-taken-the-leap-of-faith
 
They seem to be fine 2 years ago at a birthday party

View attachment 80884

If we go by this picture, Meesha is cool with having Ali's hand on her waist but now after two years she has ended up calling him a sexual harraser.

And the funny part is that one of the twitter "claims" was of a fan who said that Ali put his hand on her waist when she was taking a picture with him.

Some of the women have made sexual harrasment a joke.
 
A while back some poster made a thread about how outstanding of a celebrity Ali Zafar has become and how all other celebrities of Pakistan should take their cue from him. The thread was full of bromance over his good looks, great voice and the overall way he carries himself.

I remember making a snide little post on that thread that was rightly taken down because I made a personal remark over his looks. My main beef was that this guy isn’t really as cool as everyone think of him. After the Rockstar song on Coke Studio which seem out of some Bollywood movie set, I was left even more unimpressed. I’m any case, after my post was taken down, I quietly licked my wounds and left the matter alone.

I’m finding it hard not to express the feeling I have inside of me now, simply put, I feel vindicated.

The real questions for me now is how will it impact Ali Zafar’s life. In Hollywood some of the biggest celebrities and power players ended up ruining their careers over the #metoo movement. Will the same happen to him. Will the sponsors abandon him, will the film makers leave him alone and will he ever be invited back to Coke Studio again?

If nothing happens than #metoo will die a depressing and suffocating death. If something does happen than expect more big wigs to be named and shamed as well. Time will tell.
 
Hamza Abassi is a joke as well, saying now how he realises how Islam's pardah is the way to go....so I assume he is resigning from the industry?
 
Hamza Abassi is a joke as well, saying now how he realises how Islam's pardah is the way to go....so I assume he is resigning from the industry?

He resigned from PTI after he had a shirtless photo of him circling the Internet.
 
Hamza Abassi is a joke as well, saying now how he realises how Islam's pardah is the way to go....so I assume he is resigning from the industry?

Yes the hypocrisy of this guy is just amazing. On one hand singing the virtues of fundamentalist Islam like some card carrying Mullah while continuing to enjoy the perks of being a celebrity and star of TV and movies.
 
A while back some poster made a thread about how outstanding of a celebrity Ali Zafar has become and how all other celebrities of Pakistan should take their cue from him. The thread was full of bromance over his good looks, great voice and the overall way he carries himself.

I remember making a snide little post on that thread that was rightly taken down because I made a personal remark over his looks. My main beef was that this guy isn’t really as cool as everyone think of him. After the Rockstar song on Coke Studio which seem out of some Bollywood movie set, I was left even more unimpressed. I’m any case, after my post was taken down, I quietly licked my wounds and left the matter alone.

I’m finding it hard not to express the feeling I have inside of me now, simply put, I feel vindicated.

The real questions for me now is how will it impact Ali Zafar’s life. In Hollywood some of the biggest celebrities and power players ended up ruining their careers over the #metoo movement. Will the same happen to him. Will the sponsors abandon him, will the film makers leave him alone and will he ever be invited back to Coke Studio again?

If nothing happens than #metoo will die a depressing and suffocating death. If something does happen than expect more big wigs to be named and shamed as well. Time will tell.

For many Chris Benoit was their hero who was highly respected but then he ended up doing something which was absolutely out of this world and sickening; quiet frankly people put such individuals on a pedestal and they don't always turn out to be what we imagined when it comes to living a life of perfection and the same can be applied to Ali Zafar if said allegations are true.

However, the poster shouldn't be demonised for admiring Ali Zafar for being successful and charismatic; am sure all the people with insecurities will feel vindicated and delighted to see this man on the ground now though but their issues go beyond being against harassment unfortunately.
 
Yes the hypocrisy of this guy is just amazing. On one hand singing the virtues of fundamentalist Islam like some card carrying Mullah while continuing to enjoy the perks of being a celebrity and star of TV and movies.

Pretty much, the guy is an A grade hypocrite. On one hand advocating for gender segregation on the other hand making movies with women freely and enjoying do so.
 
If we go by this picture, Meesha is cool with having Ali's hand on her waist but now after two years she has ended up calling him a sexual harraser.

And the funny part is that one of the twitter "claims" was of a fan who said that Ali put his hand on her waist when she was taking a picture with him.

Some of the women have made sexual harrasment a joke.

Please just stop. It's pretty obvious after numerous claims by different women that he has done some serious stuff. Stop downplaying this issue and blaming the victim already. Most of these women have nothing to gain from this. Your post makes no sense. What does him having his hand on her waist in a picture have to do with anything? You can't base anything off of one photograph.
 
A while back some poster made a thread about how outstanding of a celebrity Ali Zafar has become and how all other celebrities of Pakistan should take their cue from him. The thread was full of bromance over his good looks, great voice and the overall way he carries himself.

I remember making a snide little post on that thread that was rightly taken down because I made a personal remark over his looks. My main beef was that this guy isn’t really as cool as everyone think of him. After the Rockstar song on Coke Studio which seem out of some Bollywood movie set, I was left even more unimpressed. I’m any case, after my post was taken down, I quietly licked my wounds and left the matter alone.

I’m finding it hard not to express the feeling I have inside of me now, simply put, I feel vindicated.

The real questions for me now is how will it impact Ali Zafar’s life. In Hollywood some of the biggest celebrities and power players ended up ruining their careers over the #metoo movement. Will the same happen to him. Will the sponsors abandon him, will the film makers leave him alone and will he ever be invited back to Coke Studio again?

If nothing happens than #metoo will die a depressing and suffocating death. If something does happen than expect more big wigs to be named and shamed as well. Time will tell.

I made that thread but not because of any kind of bromance. I've never really been a fan of him but I made that thread because he seemed like a decent dude in his interviews and because of the way he carried himself in public. Mostly it was because of his tweets about the mahirah/ranbir thing.

As for the last part of your post, I don't think he will face the same consequences as the sexual harassers in Hollywood and that's unfortunate. You can already see Pakistanis all over social media defending him which is pretty sick. Our public just doesn't take sexual harassment as seriously. However, I think we're seeing a change in attitude for once and tweets from Pakistani celebrities are a good sign.
 
Hamza Abassi is a joke as well, saying now how he realises how Islam's pardah is the way to go....so I assume he is resigning from the industry?

He's a tool. The amount of likeable Pakistani celebrities is just so little
 
Even if he is guilty nothing will happen. It will go some time and people will forget. People sell their country, they are corrupted, people are selling fake goods in bazaars, no one seems to be bothered, this will also die out. You need a big revolutionary change in people’s mindset to get rid of all these evils.
 
My whole take on the situation is as follows :-

Zafar might or might not be guilty but innocent until proven guilty definitely applies here. Such allegations of sexual harrasment can often ruin the careers of such stars and until all this stuff has gone through legal proceedings, we shouldn't be so quick to assign blame. Best to keep an open mind regarding all of this. Wouldn't want someone to lose everything they have over a crime they didn't commit. I'm not saying that he is innocent, but no conclusive evidence to say he is guilty either.
 
I made that thread but not because of any kind of bromance. I've never really been a fan of him but I made that thread because he seemed like a decent dude in his interviews and because of the way he carried himself in public. Mostly it was because of his tweets about the mahirah/ranbir thing.

As for the last part of your post, I don't think he will face the same consequences as the sexual harassers in Hollywood and that's unfortunate. You can already see Pakistanis all over social media defending him which is pretty sick. Our public just doesn't take sexual harassment as seriously. However, I think we're seeing a change in attitude for once and tweets from Pakistani celebrities are a good sign.

I don't think it's comparable. Weinstein and a lot of hollywood celebrities had dozens of victims and much more physical in nature moreover the celebrities who lost their careers were also inappropriate with underage people, Zafar hasn't crossed that line although what he's allegedly done with Meesha and a few other women isn't good at all however every case is different and putting him in the same basket with Cosby and Weinstein and Matt Lauer and Bill O'Reilly isn't fair to him.

Moreover meesha hasn't detailed anything about the incidents unlike in the cases against Kevin Spacey and others where there were very damning detailed accounts.

For all we know this could've been another Aziz Ansari-like incident and he's now been considered innocent by many feminists.
 
Hamza Ali Abbasi is such a hypocrite and a self-righteous person. In his tweet, he mentioned the importance of a ‘gap’ between the opposite sexes to minimize harasssment but he has made and continues to make films in which he is seen hugging and groping women. Top-level hypocrite.
 
[MENTION=139150]aliasad1998[/MENTION] the number of hollywood stars that have faced in consequences pales in comparison to the actual number of predators in the industry. Ben Affleck, Matt Damon, Woody Allen and Charlie Sheen have all kept their careers despite some serious allegations, we're also experiencing a cultural shift in America but a lot of powerful people get away with crimes.
 
Hamza Ali Abbasi is such a hypocrite and a self-righteous person. In his tweet, he mentioned the importance of a ‘gap’ between the opposite sexes to minimize harasssment but he has made and continues to make films in which he is seen hugging and groping women. Top-level hypocrite.

Okay, the messenger sucks but you can agree on the message.
 
[MENTION=139150]aliasad1998[/MENTION] the number of hollywood stars that have faced in consequences pales in comparison to the actual number of predators in the industry. Ben Affleck, Matt Damon, Woody Allen and Charlie Sheen have all kept their careers despite some serious allegations, we're also experiencing a cultural shift in America but a lot of powerful people get away with crimes.

That's because they weren't really seen as crimes until recently. Personally I think we should be careful about judging too harshly while the world is still working out what is acceptable and not in the showbiz industry. Obviously extreme cases like Weinstein are a different category altogether and they deserve no mercy.
 
A while back some poster made a thread about how outstanding of a celebrity Ali Zafar has become and how all other celebrities of Pakistan should take their cue from him. The thread was full of bromance over his good looks, great voice and the overall way he carries himself.

I remember making a snide little post on that thread that was rightly taken down because I made a personal remark over his looks. My main beef was that this guy isn’t really as cool as everyone think of him. After the Rockstar song on Coke Studio which seem out of some Bollywood movie set, I was left even more unimpressed. I’m any case, after my post was taken down, I quietly licked my wounds and left the matter alone.

I’m finding it hard not to express the feeling I have inside of me now, simply put, I feel vindicated.

The real questions for me now is how will it impact Ali Zafar’s life. In Hollywood some of the biggest celebrities and power players ended up ruining their careers over the #metoo movement. Will the same happen to him. Will the sponsors abandon him, will the film makers leave him alone and will he ever be invited back to Coke Studio again?

If nothing happens than #metoo will die a depressing and suffocating death. If something does happen than expect more big wigs to be named and shamed as well. Time will tell.

Vindicated? How?

Vindicated because you don’t like him as a singer?
Because no one (general population) could have known about any of thesw incident unless you seen or experienced it.
 
Vindicated? How?

Vindicated because you don’t like him as a singer?
Because no one (general population) could have known about any of thesw incident unless you seen or experienced it.

True, wrong choice of word. Should have been something like...I never liked the guy, now after knowing all this, glad I wasn't a fan.
 
LAHORE: Pakistan’s entertainment industry has been rocked by allegations against Ali Zafar that he has denied. The scandal has sparked a national conversation about sexual misconduct and promoted others to come forward with few in defense of Meesha Shafi and others in allying with Ali.

Meesha has gone on record saying that the incident took place at Ali’s residence, late last December, when they were jamming for a concert. A number of women have come forward claiming they were present when Ali and Meesha were jamming. They said that the two maintained a very professional relationship while Ali’s nine band members along with his manager, Taha Sadaqat, were also present. Meesha’s manager, Farhan and the event organiser were also amongst the ‘witnesses’.

One of Ali’s band members, Aqsa Ali said, “As a woman and a musician, I have to talk about this issue. Meesha said that her conscious doesn’t allow her to say quiet – so does mine.” She added that she has traveled with the Channo singer and seen girls “throw themselves” at him, but he has always made sure to be friendly and not make anyone uncomfortable.

“At this particular jam session, I was present as a vocalist. So was Farhan and the entire band along with the event organiser. We had a great jam session. As a woman, if I would have felt that there was any sort of misconduct, I would be the first person to take a stand,” explained Aqsa. She also mentioned that everyone jammed for about an hour and Ali and Meesha were not left alone – even for a moment.

Aqsa claimed, “Ali is a genuine person who has always been supportive. Accusing someone is easy but living with the guilt is difficult. I was upset with Meesha’s rude behaviour towards everyone in the band but I feel worse because she is misusing and disrespecting this movement.”

Another band member, Kanza Munir also came forward via Instagram in Ali’s defense. She wrote, “I have been working with Ali for past three years and I stand witness to this particular incident that Meesha has quoted.” Kanza added that there over 10 people present at the jamming session and whatever interaction occurred, was witnessed by everyone who was there. “I have spent hours jamming with Ali on different tours which have been pleasant and professional. It’s important that this movement is not taken for granted or misused for personal reasons, stealing limelight from real cause,” she explained.

Earlier, a Twitter user named Sofi accused Ali Zafar for misconduct during the Shaukat Khanum US tour, stating that the organisers were informed of the incident but they still went ahead with the rest of the shows. However, Naila Khan who was part of the organising committee tweeted, “It is a complete lie because the Washington DC event was the last one in the series. There was no event after that.”

In an interview, Meesha stated that she shared the stage with Ali only because it was about business and she didn’t want reasons like these to affect work. However, Ali and Meesha were hired to perform separately but their duet performance was optional. Currently, Ali is preparing to sue Meesha for her accusations.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/1692469/4-witnesses-reveal-details-meesha-shafi-ali-zafar-spat/

IMG-20180422-WA0013.jpg
 
So two female band members of Ali Zafar have come out in his defense. Good but it should be noted that their own careers depend on his. If he is out of a job so are they. Let’s keep things in perspective. Meesha has no reason to make this accusation, she had enough fame and does not need scandals to elevate her into the spotlight. Plus other women that have one out accusing Ali also seemingly have nothing to gain but more to lose from this. Only God knows who is on the right side but I would give Meesha and others like her the benefit of the doubt.
 
So two female band members of Ali Zafar have come out in his defense. Good but it should be noted that their own careers depend on his. If he is out of a job so are they. Let’s keep things in perspective. Meesha has no reason to make this accusation, she had enough fame and does not need scandals to elevate her into the spotlight. Plus other women that have one out accusing Ali also seemingly have nothing to gain but more to lose from this. Only God knows who is on the right side but I would give Meesha and others like her the benefit of the doubt.

But don't you think it's odd that she says it happened in late December 2017 -- when #MeToo was already a phenomena around the world. Zafar would have to be really stupid to do something like that when all of these scandals are going around.
 
So two female band members of Ali Zafar have come out in his defense. Good but it should be noted that their own careers depend on his. If he is out of a job so are they. Let’s keep things in perspective. Meesha has no reason to make this accusation, she had enough fame and does not need scandals to elevate her into the spotlight. Plus other women that have one out accusing Ali also seemingly have nothing to gain but more to lose from this. Only God knows who is on the right side but I would give Meesha and others like her the benefit of the doubt.

It doesn't look like their careers depended on it, they wrote a really long post, as if they wanted to say something.. funny this didn't catch the media's eye, like the allegations that followed from two unknown women after that. It seems some section of our society is hellbent on making the #MeToo movement gain momentum. Well I hope it is relevant for the right reasons and not some scandal that turns out to be a bust.. I'm hoping if it did happen, the right course is taken against Ali, and if it didn't happen, then Meesha be reprimanded
 
My whole take on the situation is as follows :-

Zafar might or might not be guilty but innocent until proven guilty definitely applies here. Such allegations of sexual harrasment can often ruin the careers of such stars and until all this stuff has gone through legal proceedings, we shouldn't be so quick to assign blame. Best to keep an open mind regarding all of this. Wouldn't want someone to lose everything they have over a crime they didn't commit. I'm not saying that he is innocent, but no conclusive evidence to say he is guilty either.

Best part is everyone is saying that 'since it takes a lot of courage for a woman to come out and mention she was harrassed, it means that something must've happened, hence Ali is guilty' - I mean that is ridiculous... Last time I checked, having an intention to face abuse from society is nothing but circumstantial evidence that is not provable in the court of law :))

Some people have really taken the abuse far in terms of defending Meesha... really extreme in their opinions
 
Being a bit too desperate there

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Still waiting for u to respond <a href="https://twitter.com/AliZafarsays?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@AliZafarsays</a>. Do u think u have ever, knowingly or unknowingly, violated a woman in any way or form? <a href="https://t.co/CS2fYHpWN8">https://t.co/CS2fYHpWN8</a></p>— Momina Mustehsan (@MominaMustehsan) <a href="https://twitter.com/MominaMustehsan/status/987633159364923392?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">April 21, 2018</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
It doesn't look like their careers depended on it, they wrote a really long post, as if they wanted to say something.. funny this didn't catch the media's eye, like the allegations that followed from two unknown women after that. It seems some section of our society is hellbent on making the #MeToo movement gain momentum. Well I hope it is relevant for the right reasons and not some scandal that turns out to be a bust.. I'm hoping if it did happen, the right course is taken against Ali, and if it didn't happen, then Meesha be reprimanded

Agreed.Lets hold back accusations unless everything is proved.Someones career should not be destroyed because of accusations.
 
But don't you think it's odd that she says it happened in late December 2017 -- when #MeToo was already a phenomena around the world. Zafar would have to be really stupid to do something like that when all of these scandals are going around.

But #Metoo wasn't a phenomenon in Pakistan, plus most men are not very smart otherwise they would never engage in such behavior and second, men who have been getting away with abuse for some time tend to feel invincible. Like Harvey Weinstein or Kevin Spacey.
 
It doesn't look like their careers depended on it, they wrote a really long post, as if they wanted to say something.. funny this didn't catch the media's eye, like the allegations that followed from two unknown women after that. It seems some section of our society is hellbent on making the #MeToo movement gain momentum. Well I hope it is relevant for the right reasons and not some scandal that turns out to be a bust.. I'm hoping if it did happen, the right course is taken against Ali, and if it didn't happen, then Meesha be reprimanded

Since my last post yesterday, I actually heard with my own ears about an incident that happened at a house party mostly attended by students of a very prestigious business school, involving an underage girl and Ali Zafar, which was narrated to me by the eyewitness. Don't want to go into details but lets just say that the incident reflects poorly on Ali Zafar. There is definitely a pattern here.
 
Since my last post yesterday, I actually heard with my own ears about an incident that happened at a house party mostly attended by students of a very prestigious business school, involving an underage girl and Ali Zafar, which was narrated to me by the eyewitness. Don't want to go into details but lets just say that the incident reflects poorly on Ali Zafar. There is definitely a pattern here.

It could be true... Fame has been used for a long time to get girls, if you see a concert, specially male artists.... artists allow few of their fans backstage, get their contact numbers and what not... Bands do this commonly as well... all of this has changed now with social media
 
Capture.JPG


Actor Sanam Saeed has joined the few celebrities who have lent their support to Meesha Shafi in her sexual harassment allegations against Ali Zafar.

Though the Cake and Zindagi Gulzar Hai star did not name the two singers in her Instagram post, she hailed Meesha for speaking up and explained to those defending Ali that anyone can ‘falter’.

"She did it... she spoke up... she broke the silence. Good on her and every single person who is speaking up,” Sanam started her post.

“For the rest of you passing judgment, take a few minutes to consider that it doesn’t take an evil person, non-family person or an overtly, sleazy, ill-mannered person to cross the line. It can be a good friend, relative, colleague, boss, family person, ‘decent’ person, successful, loved and admired person who falters,” she continued.

The actor stressed, “The tide is changing world over, they need to be shown, #timesup for this behavior to go unchecked.”

Sanam also assured those afraid to speak up of her support.

"For anyone afraid to speak up... we are here to support you. Let’s break the cycle together and support one another. Let inappropriate behaviour not go unchecked."

"No matter when you choose to #SpeakUp, regardless of days, minutes, weeks or years. Feel at ease that you have shared your truth. Their voices must and will be heard," she continued in her statement.


Explaining harassment, the actor wrote, “When a person makes inappropriate flirtatious comment – that is crossing a line. If one takes polite rejection as sign of encouragement and continues, this is not persistence, it is harassment. It doesn’t flatter, it wounds.”

“PS: for anyone who knows they have ever crossed the line, the correct thing to do is own up, apologise and to make sure it never happens again… to anyone!” she concluded.

Last week, Meesha via a statement on Twitter, accused Ali Zafar of physically harassing her on "more than one occasion".

"This happened to me despite the fact I am an empowered, accomplished woman who is known for speaking her mind!" read the statement.

Ali Zafar denied the accusations, threatening legal action against the actress.

"I intend to take this through the courts of law, and to address this professionally and seriously rather than to lodge any accusations here," the singer wrote on Twitter.

Earlier, renowned film actress Resham had defended Ali saying she has known him for 20 years and "he is someone who gives a lot of respect to others… who gives respect to women."

"Ali cannot do such a thing [harass a woman]," she said while speaking on Geo News' programme Capital Talk.

"Ali knows the difference between friendship and harassment. He cannot do such a thing," she had further said.

Actress Maya Ali had also posted on Instagram saying she respects Ali and "we shouldn’t judge anyone’s character" until the truth comes out.

"I’m not here to say who is wrong and who is right or who did what and who didn’t... Let’s say, I haven’t known him for long, but I have been working with him since once year, we shot our film in Lahore and then we were all together in Poland to shoot the rest of the film and I never ever got any kind of that vibe from him," Maya had said.

https://www.geo.tv/latest/193003-ti...nchecked-says-sanam-saeed-on-meesha-ali-issue
 
Actress and singer Meesha Shafi asked Ali Zafar to tender apology and withdraw his legal notice of defamation against her.

She sent a four-page legal notice through human rights activist Hina Jillani and her lawyers.

The notice states that Meesha Shafi is living a happy life with her husband and two children. Furthermore, it states that the accusations leveled towards Zafar are true.

The actress, in the notice, has accused the singer of manipulating the facts.

She has asked against her and has asked the actor to take back his legal notice and she has the right to take the matter to the court. he has asked the actor to apologize for his behavior.

Singer, model and actor Meesha Shafi that pop singer and actor Ali Zafar sexually harassed her.

The actor, while rejecting the allegations against him, had served a legal notice to the actress and demanded Rs 100 crores in defamation.

https://www.samaa.tv/culture/2018/05/***-for-tat-meesha-shafi-sends-legal-notice-to-ali-zafar/
 
this is no childs play. both are adults. mesha should fight the case in the court and provide the proof instead asking ali to take back his notice.
you are throwing accusation without proof and when someone asking you for proof , you are basically saying just shut up and apologize. WTH is this ?
the matter should be settle in court now.
 
this is no childs play. both are adults. mesha should fight the case in the court and provide the proof instead asking ali to take back his notice.
you are throwing accusation without proof and when someone asking you for proof , you are basically saying just shut up and apologize. WTH is this ?
the matter should be settle in court now.

Its a difficult case for mesha as its hard to provide proof for sexual harassment unless its in a written form. I am not supporting either as only God knows the truth. However, it is rather stupid of Mesha to request Ali Zafar to take back the notice. I don't think he will do that. She is now stuck.
 
(Dunya News) – Zafar-Meesha spat on Saturday took a new turn as actor Ali Zafar on Saturday filed defamation suit worth Rs1 billion against singer Meesha Shafi over hurling harassment allegations.

Read also: Meesha Shafi accuses Ali Zafar of sexual harassment

As per details, Zafar’s legal counsel Tariq Rahim lodged petition in Lahore’s session court terming Meesha’s accusations as reckless and baseless.

Rahim—in his petition—went on to say that Meesha’s accusations were aimed at gaining cheap publicity whereas apprising court that latter did not seek apology despite legal notice.

Meesha, in Twitter post, had hurled serious harassment allegation at co-star Ali Zafar.

http://dunyanews.tv/en/Entertainmen...ar-files-Rs1-bn-defamation-suit-against-Meesh
 
If we go by this picture, Meesha is cool with having Ali's hand on her waist but now after two years she has ended up calling him a sexual harraser.
.

There's so much wrong in this statement.....
 
If Zafar wins this he maga suit I think he will end this one for and all, no one would dare contest him in the future.
 
I will go and enjoy Teefa in trouble and support Ali Zafar with my money. I am all for feminism but people like Meesha Shafi are harmful to it.
 
Meesha Shafi asked to submit reply by July 5 in defamation case filed by Ali Zafar

A sessions court in Lahore on Monday asked musician and actor Meesha Shafi to submit her reply by July 5 in the Rs1 billion defamation case filed against her by fellow artist Ali Zafar.

In a statement on Twitter on April 19, Shafi had accused Ali of sexually harassing her on more than one occasion. She wrote: "I have been subjected, on more than one occasion, to sexual harassment of a physical nature at the hands of a colleague from my industry: Ali Zafar [...] It has been an extremely traumatic experience for me and my family [...] I feel betrayed by his behaviour and attitude and I know that I'm not alone."

Shortly after, Zafar had denied the allegations in a statement and sent a legal notice to Shafi, demanding that Shafi deletes the tweet accusing him of harassment and issues an apology on Twitter.

During today's hearing, presided over by Additional Sessions Judge Shehzad Ahmed, Zafar's counsel argued that his client was "subjected to baseless allegations of harassment for publicity", which has impacted his image across the globe.

Advocate Rana Intizar Hussain asked the court that Shafi be asked to pay Rs1 billion in damages to his client.

The court, while directing Shafi to file her response by July 5, restrained her from "making any derogatory remarks" against Zafar "in any manner on print or electronic or social media".

https://www.dawn.com/news/1416014/m...-july-5-in-defamation-case-filed-by-ali-zafar
 
I really hope that justice prevails but how are they going to prove that in court and what sort of evidence will the court demand??
 
A sessions court in Lahore has given musician and actor Meesha Shafi until August 13 to submit her reply in the defamation case filed against her by fellow artist Ali Zafar.

Additional Sessions Judge Shehzad Ahmed on Thursday ordered that the notice seeking Shafi's reply should be reissued as it has not been received. It should also be posted outside Shafi's residence, the court directed.

In a statement on Twitter on April 19, Shafi wrote: "I have been subjected, on more than one occasion, to sexual harassment of a physical nature at the hands of a colleague from my industry: Ali Zafar [...] It has been an extremely traumatic experience for me and my family [...] I feel betrayed by his behaviour and attitude and I know that I'm not alone."

Shortly after, Zafar had denied the allegations in a statement and sent a legal notice to Shafi, demanding that Shafi delete the tweet accusing him of harassment and issue an apology on Twitter.

Zafar then filed a defamation case against Shafi for damages worth Rs1 billion. The court, in its last hearing, had asked Shafi to submit a reply.

https://www.dawn.com/news/1418123/c...til-aug-13-to-submit-reply-in-defamation-case
 
Ali Zafar addresses Meesha Shafi's sexual harassment claims in BBC interview

Ali Zafar has gone public for the first time since his fellow singer Meesha Shafi accused him of sexual harassment.

In an interview with BBC Asian Network, the Channo singer spoke with Haroon Rahid about the allegations levied against him

"People will find out in time. With time everything comes out and the truth unveils itself. I, since day one, said that I will not fight this over social media as I will take the professional course and I have sought professional remedies and the due course of law shall give justice in time."

When asked if he could've intentionally or unintentionally harmed or affected Meesha, his reply was a firm "No. Never could that have happened because if it did she was a very close family friend, she used to come to our house, she was my wife's friend.

He continued, "We had a concert together, and the jam that she's talking about, that has a video and there were 10 witnesses and two witnesses out of that jam were women. They came out in the open and said that 'we were there how could she event think and say this?'

That is why I was more hurt, because I've been working towards women's empowerment."

Ali Zafar tried to divert the conversation, but Haroon brought him back on track and asked him what Meesha has to gain if her allegations are proven untrue.

Although he refused to comment on it, he didn't seem worried by the fact that the some are planning on boycotting Teefa In Trouble. "I don't worry because when you know things and when you are on the right side and know the truth you don't worry because falsehood by its nature is bound to perish," he responded.

In April, Meesha accused Ali of sexually harassing her on more than one occasion. She wrote, “I have been subjected, on more than one occasion, to sexual harassment of a physical nature at the hands of a colleague from my industry: Ali Zafar [...] It has been an extremely traumatic experience for me and my family [...] I feel betrayed by his behaviour and attitude and I know that I'm not alone.”

Ali denied the allegations in a statement on the same day, "I categorically deny any and all claims of harassment lodged against me by Ms Shafi." Later, he sent Meesha a legal notice in which he demanded that Meesha delete the tweet that contained her allegations against him and issued an apology on Twitter, failing which he will file a Rs100 crore defamation suit against her.

Zafar has filed a defamation case worth Rs1 billion against Shafi in a sessions court in Lahore last month. Meesha too has taken legal action against him by filing a sexual harassment case which is still pending before the relevant authorities.

https://images.dawn.com/news/118047...fis-sexual-harassment-claims-in-bbc-interview
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Today <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/TeefainTrouble?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#TeefainTrouble</a> marks history as it shatters all previous records by any Pakistani Film on its opening days with a grand total of 2.25 crores in Pakistan alone and that too a non-Eid holiday and against all odds and hurdles put in our way. Be-Shak, Vo ber Haq hai! <a href="https://t.co/ZLTCaHAel5">pic.twitter.com/ZLTCaHAel5</a></p>— Ali Zafar (@AliZafarsays) <a href="https://twitter.com/AliZafarsays/status/1020652507431952384?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">July 21, 2018</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Today <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/TeefainTrouble?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#TeefainTrouble</a> marks history as it shatters all previous records by any Pakistani Film on its opening days with a grand total of 2.25 crores in Pakistan alone and that too a non-Eid holiday and against all odds and hurdles put in our way. Be-Shak, Vo ber Haq hai! <a href="https://t.co/ZLTCaHAel5">pic.twitter.com/ZLTCaHAel5</a></p>— Ali Zafar (@AliZafarsays) <a href="https://twitter.com/AliZafarsays/status/1020652507431952384?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">July 21, 2018</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Sanju made more on its first day in Pakistan
 
Teefa in trouble looks like a pile of garbage. Another awful Pakistani movie
 
Shafi is refusing to receive the court papers? So much so that they now have been told by judge to pin it outside her gate!!
 
Understanding the Meesha Shafi-Ali Zafar squabble

KARACHI : In what was termed as “dismissal on technical basis” in regards to Punjab governor’s latest order, Meesha Shafi’s counsel forwarded the matter to Lahore High Court (LHC) via writ petition filed on August 1.

The recent unfolding came after the Punjab governor dismissed Shafi’s complaint against the Teefa in Trouble actor, under the Protection against Harassment of Women at Workplace Act 2010.

Following the petition, a hearing held the next day premised on its contents. “The honourable judge issued notices to the ombudsman, governor and Ali Zafar to reply to the petition,” Shafi’s lawyer Ahmed Pansota told The Express Tribune.

Next steps by Shafi

Speaking on the matter, Pansota explained the grounds that formed the basis of the petition.

Therein, Shafi’s legal team clarified their stance that she and Zafar were to perform in Islamabad under a contract with JS Events. Pansota specified that section 2L of the act defines organisation, which includes any physical work space one is obliged to go to for work. The alleged harassment took place at Ali’s studio during practice sessions, which deems the incident as “workplace harassment”.

Punjab governor dismisses Meesha Shafi’s sexual harassment appeal against Ali Zafar

Furthermore, the writ petition, as per the act section 2F of the act, identified the definition of an employee, which includes a regular or contractual employee. By virtue of contract, the aforementioned relationship between Shafi and the JS Bank therefore existed.

On the occasion, Shafi’s counsel also raised, “The emphasis of the act isn’t employer-employee relationship but to guarantee a safe working environment free from sexual harassment.” In light furtherance, Pansota remarked that a judgment by the honourable high court reported as 2013 MLD 225 states that even educational institutions fall under the act because it’s happening at workplace.

Responding to the order of the governor, another ground of the petition defined sexual harassment as per the law as an “unwelcome sexual advance”. According to the contract, no ‘employer-employee’ rights were agreed. However, Pansota countered that this is not sustainable in the eyes of law for matters such as sexual harassment. “Employer-employee rights may disqualify someone from pension and gratuity but it sure doesn’t enable blanket for acts like harassment,” he furthered.

Lastly, Barrister Pansota asserted that laws contain ‘preamble of statute’, which in laymen terms is defined as legislative intent. “The intent behind this legislation is to allow women to enter the workplace, whereby sexual harassment doesn’t hinder their growth in order for them to contribute to the national gross domestic product (GDP),” he elaborated.

Zafar’s version

A member of Zafar’s legal team, Ambreen Qureshi, pointed out that the opposition demanded the court to immediately suspend the governor’s order. However, the judge only issued notice but succumb to the demands. Instead he said, “We will hear both parties out in the next hearing”.

Pertaining to the case, Qureshi remarked that Shafi is trying to fall under the ambit of the law which is not possible. “She was not an employee and the law covers harassment at workplace”. According to her, the Aaya Laariye singer signed the contract “at her free will”. When asked what free will means, she elaborated that Shafi laid out the terms and conditions of the contract herself about who she wants to work with etc. “This isn’t same as employment, as opposed to a full-time job at some company.”

Ali Zafar breaks silence on Meesha Shafi’s sexual harassment allegations

Next hearing on October 4

Shafi’s counsel maintained that laws have both literal and purpose-driven interpretations. “As far as purpose was concerned, the governor should have sent the case back to the ombudsman and should have allowed the matter to be heard.”

High Court Advocate Aleena Alavi commented that the gap lies between the interpretation of what constitutes as workplace as per the discretion of the governor and ombudsman. “Even if I am at home for work, it counts as workplace,” she added.

Alavi said that another avenue is to lodge a complaint under Section 509 of Pakistan Penal Code which is “insulting the modesty of woman or sexually harassing them”, which is a criminal procedure.

For harassment through electronic means, Alavi continued, that a complaint can be filed under Protection of Electronic Crimes Act 2016.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/1773079/4-understanding-meesha-shafi-ali-zafar-squabble/
 
Meesha Shafi throws major shade at Sadaf Kanwal for her remarks on #MeToo

With the gradual uprising of #MeToo in Pakistan, many have come forward with their own ordeals of sexual harassment.

Sadaf Kanwal’s recent remarks on the matter has sparked social media outrage. Many called out the supermodel for her insensitivity on the subject and how problematic her stance really is.

“You know aap ke sath #MeToo jab ho, tab bol do. Baad mein aap ko yaad araha hai #MeToo, So I think jab ho bol do. (You know, when you have a #MeToo incident, say it then. Why are you remembering it later? I think when it happens you should say it.)” Sadaf was speaking about the campaign in a local talk show.
She further added, “Agar mere saath #MeToo kabhi hua tou mai bolungi na. aur mai social media pe nahi bolungi mai aap sab ko bataungi (If I ever have a #MeToo incident, I would say it. And I won’t just say it on social media. I’d tell all of you.)”

Meesha Shafi, too, had a thing or two to say about it. Taking to Twitter, the Coke Studio singer threw some major shade at the 25-year-old and wrote, “Strong eyebrows.. do not make a strong backbone. Pfffft.”

A user then went on to comment how difficult it must have been for Meesha to talk about own episode of alleged harassment.

“After this whole Sadaf Kanwal incident, I realise how difficult it must have been for Meesha Shafi to take a stand for herself and point a harasser in the same media community which harvests people like Sadaf,” wrote Javeria.

Other than the Aya Lariye singer, Twitterati slammed Sadaf’s comments as well.

“I’m disappointed how Sadaf Kanwal made light of #MeToo movement, how I was her fan, how her privilege blinds her to ordeals of sexual abuse victims who find courage to fight the evil, how all this education and exposure doesn’t bring empathy, how this is how she uses her impact,” tweeted Maryam.

Another user, Kiran, wrote, “Sadaf Kanwal says there’s no point of speaking against harassment once it has in the past. Well Sadaf, as you said that you’re lucky enough to have never faced harassment, I don’t think you can understand what it feels like in that very moment. It’s easier said than done.”

“Sadaf Kanwal is a prime example as to how mediocrity and toxicity receive appreciation in Pakistani Fashion industry,” wrote, Ayesha Kamal penned. “The woman doesn’t even know a damn thing regarding significance of #MeToo and spews crap as to how meray sath #MeToo kabhe nahi huwa. How Disgusting it is!”

“Bored out of my mind, I ended up watching Sadaf Kanwal’s full interview and my God, this girl speaks absolute trash. How has she survived in this industry for this long? I’m so disappointed,” tweeted another user.

While many criticised Sadaf, PR mogul Fahad Hussain came out to support the model. Taking to Instagram, Fahad posted several pictures of Sadaf and wrote – which seemed like major shade on Meesha, “Strong eyebrows, even stronger backbone!”

“Sadaf Kanwal, you are a fighter and a real person. Do not let these negative comments bring you down, they never did in the past, nor shall they do so in the future. More power to you girl,” he said.

Sadaf, on the other hand, has kept mum about the controversy as of now.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/1807847/4-meesha-shafi-throws-major-shade-sadaf-kanwal-remarks-metoo/
 
“You know aap ke sath #MeToo jab ho, tab bol do. Baad mein aap ko yaad araha hai #MeToo, So I think jab ho bol do. (You know, when you have a #MeToo incident, say it then. Why are you remembering it later? I think when it happens you should say it.)” Sadaf was speaking about the campaign in a local talk show.
She further added, “Agar mere saath #MeToo kabhi hua tou mai bolungi na. aur mai social media pe nahi bolungi mai aap sab ko bataungi (If I ever have a #MeToo incident, I would say it. And I won’t just say it on social media. I’d tell all of you.)”

-Sadaf Kanwal

This sums up everything. Unless you are physically threatened by aggressor you shouldn't shut up; which is a very rare case in this day and age.

Problem is: many women have shut up to gain fame and are only talking years later. Mind you, I ain't defending the aggressors here, just stating an observation.

Even if you are a man, you have to deal with unwarranted advances and "accidental touches"; in my personal case I laugh at them and sometimes even pity at the desperation :P

My opinion is same: If Ali did harass her then he should be thrown in jail so that he may not harass others in future and otoh if Shafi is lying she should be punished. That's the true spirit of #MeToo.
 
LAHORE: Singer-cum-actor Ali Zafar on Saturday filed a petition against Meesha Shafi over submitting an allegedly fake affidavit in the civil court.

The petition stated there is a contradiction in the date mentioned on the affidavit and the account of the events shared in it.

"The events that Meesha promised and claimed took place afterwards," the petition further said.

Meanwhile, Shafi's counsel has requested adjournment and did not question the witnesses presented by Zafar in the civil court.

The court has reserved its verdict over the adjournment.


Ali Zafar files Rs1bn defamation suit against Meesha Shafi

Last year, Ali had submitted a defamation suit to a district court against peer Meesha, who had accused him of sexual harassment.

In April 2018, Meesha had taken to Twitter to publicly accuse Ali of physically harassing her on "more than one occasion". "This happened to me despite the fact I am an empowered, accomplished woman who is known for speaking her mind!" her statement had read.

Ali, on the other hand, had "categorically" denied the allegations and threatened to take legal action against the actress. "I intend to take this through the courts of law, and to address this professionally and seriously rather than to lodge any accusations here," the singer had said on Twitter.

https://www.geo.tv/latest/230533-al...st-meesha-shafi-for-submitting-fake-affidavit
 
LHC extends deadline for Ali Zafar-Meesha Shafi case conclusion for another 90 days

The Lahore High Court (LHC) on Tuesday set aside an earlier directive from a Lahore district court that had mandated a conclusion to the Ali Zafar-Meesha Shafi defamation case on April 15, instead giving the petitioners and respondents another three months to argue their respective cases.

According to the counsel for Meesha, the court also stated that Meesha's legal team cam seek a further extension if need be. "Our stance — i.e. difficulty involved in concluding the trial, involving examination of more than forty witnesses till 15.04.2019 — stands vindicated today," he said in a statement.

Meanwhile, Ali Zafar's lawyer, Ambreen Qureshi, described it as "a great day for us [...] as now the honourable high court has given orders to decide the case in 90 days which Meesha and her team have been trying to delay since last one year by seeking adjournment after adjournment and filing various applications."

The LHC's Justice Masood Jahangir, taking up a petition filed by singer, model and actress Meesha Shafi, had reviewed a lower court's earlier order to decide the case by April 15.

Shafi in her petition had argued that the order to decide the case in two weeks was in contradiction with ground realities and sought more time to produce witnesses in her favour in the case against Zafar, who she alleges sexually harassed her and others on multiple occasions.

Following the allegations last year, Zafar had filed a Rs1 billion defamation suit against Shafi.

https://www.dawn.com/news/1474941/l...sha-shafi-case-conclusion-for-90-another-days
 
LAHORE: A sessions court here on Wednesday fined singer Meesha Shafi Rs10,000.

The court which is hearing Ali Zafar’s defamation case against Meesha Shafi imposed the fine over the non-appearance of the latter’s lawyer in court.

The hearing of the case has been adjourned till April 17.

Ambreen Qureshi, the lawyer for Ali Zafar said Shafi’s failure to appear in court was a blatant attempt to delay the case.

On Tuesday, Justice Masood Jahangir of the Lahore High Court (LHC) suspended the order of District Judge directing the trial court judge to concluded Ali Zafar’s defamation case against Meesha Shafi by April 15.

The time limit was increased by three months and Justice Jahangir observed that the legal team of Meesha Shafi was at liberty to see a further extension.

Zafar had filed the defamation suit last year against Shafi, who had accused him of sexual harassment.

The suit, claiming damages of Rs1 billion, was filed under the Defamation Ordinance 2002. In the notice, the singer claimed Shafi damaged his reputation through false allegations of sexual harassment.

In his plea for early disposal of the case, Zafar pleaded that Shafi and her lawyers should not be granted any more adjournments which waste the court’s precious time. He further requested the court to decide the case within the next 30 days as it had already been almost a year since the inception of the case.

In April 2018, Shafi had taken to Twitter to publicly accuse Zafar of physically harassing her on "more than one occasion". "This happened to me despite the fact I am an empowered, accomplished woman who is known for speaking her mind!" her statement had read.

Zafar, on the other hand, "categorically" denied the allegations and threatened to take legal action against the actress. "I intend to take this through the courts of law, and to address this professionally and seriously rather than to lodge any accusations here," the singer had said on Twitter.

https://www.geo.tv/latest/233756-lahore-sessions-court-fines-meesha-shafi-rs10000
 
Meesha Shafi petitions SC to overturn LHC ruling in case against Ali Zafar

Musician and actor Meesha Shafi on Friday petitioned the Supreme Court to overturn the Lahore High Court's (LHC) rejection of her petition to have the statements of Ali Zafar's witnesses recorded and their cross-examination conducted in separate hearings.

Shafi, who is fighting a defamation case filed by Zafar over allegations of sexual harassment, had earlier approached a trial court and later the high court, noting that failure to conduct the witnesses' testimonies and their cross-examination in separate hearings "would be amounting to extending undue favour to the plaintiff".

She had also stated that "cross examining witnesses on the basis of their statements only and without knowing them would be impossible."

Both the courts had turned down Shafi's petitions, with the LHC adding that the request was "devoid of any merit" as the defendant was cognizant of the witnesses' names and has had reasonable time to prepare for cross-examination.

Shafi, through her attorney, challenged the high court's ruling in the apex court today, stating that "the valuable right" of cross-examination must be "real, fair and reasonable" to the defendant.

Take a look: LHC extends deadline for Ali Zafar-Meesha Shafi case conclusion for another 90 days
Sexual harassment allegations

In April, last year, Shafi on Twitter alleged that fellow musician and actor Zafar had sexually harassed her on multiple occasions.

"I have been subjected, on more than one occasion, to sexual harassment of a physical nature at the hands of a colleague from my industry: Ali Zafar. These incidences did not happen when I was young, or just entering the industry.

"This happened to me despite the fact that I am an empowered, accomplished woman who is known for speaking her mind! This happened to me as a mother of two children," she had claimed.

Hours after Shafi's tweets, Zafar released a statement categorically denying "any and all claims of harassment lodged against me by Shafi".

He then filed a defamation case against Shafi for damages worth Rs1 billion in June 2018.

Shafi in a response to the petition in Oct 2018 stated that Zafar had harassed her on more than two occasions. "Ali Zafar harassed [me] at a private studio and family functions," she said.

She stated that she had been "compelled" to take action against Zafar because of the harassment incidents, adding that Zafar had harassed several female artists other than herself.

"I will also provide evidence [of the allegations] when the court asks for it," Shafi had said.

https://www.dawn.com/news/1475655/m...overturn-lhc-ruling-in-case-against-ali-zafar
 
KARACHI/LAHORE: Women's rights lawyer Nighat Dad on Saturday night explained that singer Meesha Shafi "has not been called by the court as of yet" but "will go once court will direct her to" appear.

Dad was speaking on Geo News programme Naya Pakistan in response to singer Ali Zafar's comments outside a sessions court in Lahore earlier in the day when he claimed that he was being targeted through an organised plan for personal gains.

Dad, who is part of the legal team representing Shafi in the defamation case filed by Zafar in response to allegations of sexual harassment made by Shafi, refuted the assertions he made and said the propaganda was, in fact, against the survivor.

The campaign, she added, was under the hashtag "#FaceTheCourtMeeshaShafi".

When TV show host Shahzad Iqbal asked the lawyer about why she follows what he claimed were suspicious accounts, Dad said: "I follow any account that supports Meesha Shafi and her cause. I retweet tweets posted in favour of Meesha Shafi and her cause."

However, "if Ali Zafar believes that an account is fake, he can go ahead and lodge a complaint," she added.

Further, on her Twitter account, she explained that the "other party to the case uses mainstream media and online spaces to spread misleading narrative around the case and viciously calls [Shafi] liar" whereas it was ironical that the survivor "has a gag order against her under defamation suit" and, thus, "can’t talk on mainstream media & social media about the case".

Dad also questioned on Twitter whether "all other accounts came forward with harassment allegations [were] fake too".

"Meesha has not been called by the court as of yet, she will go once court will direct her too. Why lawyers are there? To represent her client. Our case on sexual harassment has never been heard on merits. Dismissed on technical grounds, order is challenged in the LHC," she added.

Earlier in the day, Zafar had reached the sessions court in Lahore that heard the defamation suit against Shafi, despite not having being summoned by the court. He had said: "I wasn’t called to court today yet here I am.

"I am truthful and those who are honest appear without being called," he had said. "There was a social media campaign against me and I have taken this up with the FIA [Federal Investigation Agency]."

Zafar had further noted, "Meesha's lawyer has been following and retweeting fake accounts. This was done according to a proper plan. I was targeted for personal gains. Was this done because [Meesha Shafi] is going to Canada and her immigration is happening? I don’t know if she wanted international recognition there and become a Malala.”

The singer had added that he filed a contempt case against Shafi a year ago. Her "case was dismissed as was her appeal," he stated. "My case is that of compensation; it has been a year and our witnesses have appeared eight times."

Meesha Shafi alleges Ali Zafar sexually harassed her on multiple occasions

"The case should be decided fast so my truth and their lie can be revealed," Zafar had said.

During today's hearing presided by Additional Sessions Judge Shakeel Ahmed, the court had recorded witness Baqar Abbas' testimony and summoned other witnesses at the next hearing. The hearing of the case was adjourned till May 4.

'Happened to me'
The singer-cum-actor had filed the defamation suit last year against Shafi, who had accused him of sexual harassment.

The suit, claiming damages of Rs1 billion, was filed under the Defamation Ordinance 2002. In the notice, the singer claimed Shafi damaged his reputation through false allegations of sexual harassment.

After Meesha Shafi, more women accuse Ali Zafar of harassment

In April 2018, Shafi had taken to Twitter to publicly accuse Zafar of physically harassing her on "more than one occasion".

"This happened to me despite the fact I am an empowered, accomplished woman who is known for speaking her mind!" her statement had read.

Zafar, on the other hand, "categorically" denied the allegations and threatened to take legal action against the actress.

"I intend to take this through the courts of law, and to address this professionally and seriously rather than to lodge any accusations here," the singer had said on Twitter.

https://www.geo.tv/latest/235538-az
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Here’s the copy of Meesha’s case dismissal exonerating me in the eyes of the law. Now I will prove in the eyes of people, with evidence, how she lied! I will also expose the most heinous social media campaign against me that you may ever seen. <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/FaceTheCourtMeeshaShafi?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#FaceTheCourtMeeshaShafi</a> <a href="https://t.co/3gEqFpQJhh">https://t.co/3gEqFpQJhh</a></p>— Ali Zafar (@AliZafarsays) <a href="https://twitter.com/AliZafarsays/status/1122374752121835520?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">April 28, 2019</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
LAHORE: Singer-cum-actor Ali Zafar on Tuesday vowed to fully respond to singer Meesha Shafi's fresh allegations against him.

The actor, in his statement, said he would respond to every verbal or written allegation through facts and evidence, adding, " will issue a decisive thing today".

His legal team said the actor was aware of Meesha's submission of a sexual harassment complaint against him with the ombudsperson.

The complaint was turned down by the ombudsperson, and subsequently by the Punjab governor, the legal team said in the statement.

The statement read that Meesha approached the Lahore High Court seeking suspension of ombudsperson's decision, saying the matter is sub judice and the court had neither nullified the ombudsperson's decision, nor of the governor's.

Zafar's legal team stated that the orders of the ombudsperson and provincial governor are in place regarding rejection of Meesha's complaint.

Meesha Shafi responds to Ali Zafar’s allegations

The lawyers said their client said the right thing that the complaint against him had been turned down.

"Ali Zafar sent a legal notice to Meesha Shafi for levelling false allegations," his legal team said, adding that the actor filed a lawsuit against his accuser on June 23, 2018.

The team further said the court issued notice to Meesha on July 5, 2018, adding, "The court issued orders barring Meesha from speaking against Ali Zafar on print, electronic and social media".

It said the singer didn't receive the notice despite its airing on media and submitted power of attorney through her legal team on August 13, 2018.

Zafar's lawyers noted that the court sought reply from Meesha several times, whereas her legal team did not cross-examined witnesses presented by the defence.

The court fined Meesha Rs10,000 for not cross-examining the witnesses, Zafar's legal team said, questioning, "If these are not delaying tactics then what else will it be called?"

Zafar's lawyers said this statement was a response to "false statements" given by Meesha's legal team, noting that their client reserved the right to take legal action over such statements.

https://www.geo.tv/latest/235802-ali-zafar-vows-to-fully-respond-to-meesha-shafis-fresh-allegations
 
Pathetic excuse by AZ to defend himself.

‘I have worked with beautiful Bollywood actresses and I did not harass them. Why would I harass such a woman(Meesha)?’
 
I don't blame AZ for doing his utmost to clear his name on all forums. Just like women are sexually harrasssed and made uncomfortable there are some women who use the woman card to throw mud on guys and the stain, stigma stays forever. If meesha shafi made allegations in public then she has to see it through and prove her case or withdraw the accusations if she can't prove them. She can't walk away midway
 
Pathetic excuse by AZ to defend himself.

‘I have worked with beautiful Bollywood actresses and I did not harass them. Why would I harass such a woman(Meesha)?’

If true this tells you everything you need to know about the mindset. Out depraved, backwards, sexist society will never stop victim blaming and harassing her though
 
I don't blame AZ for doing his utmost to clear his name on all forums. Just like women are sexually harrasssed and made uncomfortable there are some women who use the woman card to throw mud on guys and the stain, stigma stays forever. If meesha shafi made allegations in public then she has to see it through and prove her case or withdraw the accusations if she can't prove them. She can't walk away midway

And where has she said she is walking away midway,may i ask?
 
Back
Top