People have rightly pointed out his premeditated shots and his potential weakness around the short ball. However, one thing that's apparent to me is his personality, that's currently holding him back a bit.
It's very clear that Alhamdulillah he's incredibly talented. But because of this, batting almost comes too easy to him and hence he either:
a) loses concentration and gets out to nothing balls. Case in point is the LBW and the caught behind against Ngarava, when he played across the line, when an on drive would have sufficed.
b) beats himself up if he doesn't put a bad ball away. Case in point was the dismissal in the third T20i where, the ball before he got out, he really really was annoyed with himself for not getting a shot away. Next ball, he carried his annoyance into his shot, and promptly nicked off.
My point is, the best sportsman stay in the moment they need to and switch off in between play. A Pakistani example of this was Mo Yousuf in his record breaking test year. I remember, when Pakistan toured England (in 07 I believe), the english commentators remarked on how Yousuf was able to switch off between balls, and then concentrated on the ball he was currently facing.
Younis, a vastly inferior technical batsmen was good at that too. If he can train Haider's mind to be more present in the moment, InshAllah you may see lesser of these innocuous dismissals.
Just my two cents!
On the contrary, I think he is pretty darn good at playing the short ball. He pretty effectively delivers that classic trademark of a Pakistani tulla shot towards the cow corner between deep mid-on and deep midwicket.
This actually seems like his strongest shot which is again, a good and effective hammer in T20. Effective in ODI's, and IMO, an agricultural unorthodox slog in Test cricket.
The problem I've noted is that when he premeditates this cow corner slog to a ball which is on the good length or not short enough, he gets trapped and struggles to find room.
But on the other hand,
The pace, style and culture in Test cricket has already changed quite a bit. That "classic stroke play" seems like a diminishing art just like the charm of pace bowling is choked due to the hell bent rules in favor of the batsman. Thanks to T20.
The mindset and approach of the batsmen has evolved. Tests are now usually decided in 3 to 4 days. I mean, when was the last time you saw a Test opener carrying his bat? When was the last time we saw batsman running 4 runs? (Thanks to ever decreasing boundary lines)
So this sorta of subtle Tulla batting style perhaps IS the future of cricket?
In which case, he isn't a bad find when you look at the absolute pathetic standard of our domestic cricket.
My major concern for him perhaps not whether he gets the right advice or not (which is definitely very important) but an even more important aspect is the yearning fans who are desperately awaiting another Javed, or Inzi or MoYo or YK churned out by our domestic cricket. And when these fans see a small glimpse of talent in a new batsman, they all jump on the hype bandwagon and put the player over the moon just when he gets his feet wet in the international arena.
This in turn, makes the player feel like he is ultimate hero and he has done it all.
There is nothing more to be achieved, and hence, he puts the learning process on the backburner and focuses more on making sure that his collars are raised during the field.
I think Umer Akmal would be a classical example of this.
He was hyped so much that he totally lost it all.
Let's hope Haider Ali remains wise and conscious of handling the fame. Those fans will perhaps won't ever learn how to strike a fair balance between the sticks and carrots.