What's new

How great was Alvin Kallicharran as a batsmen?

Harsh Thakor

First Class Star
Joined
Oct 1, 2012
Runs
3,519
Post of the Week
2
Technically Alvin Kalicharan was arguably the most correct of all left-handed batsmen.No attacking left-hander tackled spin bowling better than Kalicharan.Nor did any batsmen treat great pace with as much contempt ever in the in the world cup as Kali did against Australia in 1975.For sheer virtuosity and domination it was close to the best cricketing innings ever.At one stage he averaged above 50 in his test career before 1976 and looked stet to become the best batsmen of his generation.He was also very prolific representing Warwickshire.

Sadly politics let him down doing complete injustice to his talent.His form declined from 1976 being greatly overshadowed by Greenidge,Viv Richards and Lloyd.He made a comeback in India in 1978-79 and partially in Australia but again declined before joining the rebel tour of South Africa in 1982 which effectively ended his official career.

To me at his peak from 1973-75 he was in the Barry Richards class.I can never forget his classical 158 against the English team led by Tony Greig in 1974.He also scored a classy century facing Lillee and Thomson in 1975-76 down under .In Mumbai in 1978-79 he looked set to registering a double century before being wrongly adjudged lbw.

At his best Kali simply looked Bradmanesque or a Rohan Kanhai the other way around.Arguably no left -hander was as consummate at his best as Kalicharan.Resembled an a surgeon ,poet and boxer rolled into one blending grace,power and technical skill into a complete package.Rarely seen a batsmen treat such a good ball with such disdain or ease as Kalicharan.On his day as technically correct as Boycott as graceful as Majid Khan and as destructive as Viv Richards.Potentially he was better than Clive Lloyd or Gordon Greenidge and almost on par with Viv Richards.A very close contender for the test xi of the 1970's and would have made it in the era of 1970-75.

To me close to the most under-achieved of left handed cricketers ,let alone batsmen.
 
From the video clips I’ve seen, Kallicharan looks like a very stylish and elegant stroke player - one of those players I wish to have seen at his peak.

Also a shame that future generations will get to see video recordings of today’s mediocre West Indies and Pakistani batsmen (like Hafeez) in full HD and even Ultra HD (4K) with multiple camera angles, and yet the likes of Kanhai, Kallicharan, Sobers, Majid Khan, Zaheer Abbas, you only get grainy poor quality video recordings most of which are viewed from behind the wicket keeper...
 
From the video clips I’ve seen, Kallicharan looks like a very stylish and elegant stroke player - one of those players I wish to have seen at his peak.

Also a shame that future generations will get to see video recordings of today’s mediocre West Indies and Pakistani batsmen (like Hafeez) in full HD and even Ultra HD (4K) with multiple camera angles, and yet the likes of Kanhai, Kallicharan, Sobers, Majid Khan, Zaheer Abbas, you only get grainy poor quality video recordings most of which are viewed from behind the wicket keeper...

Agreed. But at least it has preserved the romance of that era. Bowlers were demons from hell who bowled 30 overs in a day at 105 mph. Batters had perfect technique and temperament.

Downside of the technology is that it has killed the romance from game. Now we hyper analyse everything based on facts an evidence. In past it was based on eye test and feelings.
 
From the video clips I’ve seen, Kallicharan looks like a very stylish and elegant stroke player - one of those players I wish to have seen at his peak.

Also a shame that future generations will get to see video recordings of today’s mediocre West Indies and Pakistani batsmen (like Hafeez) in full HD and even Ultra HD (4K) with multiple camera angles, and yet the likes of Kanhai, Kallicharan, Sobers, Majid Khan, Zaheer Abbas, you only get grainy poor quality video recordings most of which are viewed from behind the wicket keeper...

How would you rate Kalicharan compared to Majid Khan?On par or better?Or also Vishwanath or Zaheer Abbas?
 
My dad rates him and rohan kanhai very highly.. For him these two were artistic for their time..
 
Last edited:
To my mind, Kalicharan was like left handed Vishwanath or Vishwanath was right handed Kalicharan.

Incidentally, one Hindi movie maker Subhash Ghai made one movie called "Kalicharan"(1976). The title was clearly inspired by the name of the cricketer. This movie was a hit. Later, the filmmaker made another movie called "Vishwanath"(1978) and this title was clearly inspired from the name of the cricketer. This movie turned oyt to be a super hit.
 
[MENTION=79064]MMHS[/MENTION] [MENTION=7774]Robert[/MENTION] @ Junaids please come here
 
He was good from what I have seen. Played in an era when the West Indies were full of great batsmen so probably did not receive the recognition he deserved. A brilliant batsmen for Warwickshire as well.
 
[MENTION=134300]Tusker[/MENTION] coming to destroy this thread in 3,2,1...
 
Back
Top