What's new

Ian Botham under fire for lifeless Ashes Commentary

Savak

World Star
Joined
Feb 16, 2006
Runs
50,120
Post of the Week
3
Cricket commentary mystery: When will Ian Botham come to life?

Lord Ian Botham was appointed the UK's trade envoy to Australia last month.

Perhaps in his new role he could export his personality Down Under and start to show it on Channel 7's coverage of the Ashes.

Because at the moment, Beefy is displaying about as much panache and punch as the insipid England cricketers he's forced to critique.

Botham was one of the game's most exciting players, a thrill-a-minute maverick who took spectators for a wild ride with bat and ball.

Off the field he was tabloid gold, his tales of partying well into the night almost as famous as his deeds between 11 and 6.

It was a given Botham would join the gallery of ex-players behind the microphone and he was a natural, entertaining Sky Sports audiences for 25 years before his stint was abruptly ended at the end of the last Ashes series in England.

His ex-teammate and good pal David Gower went at the same time, while much-loved colleagues Michael Holding and David 'Bumble' Lloyd also parted company with Sky recently.

It's though their passing – in a professional sense - changed something in Botham, at the least on the strength of this tour.

Ian Botham's enthusiasm levels at an all-time low
Ever since he arrived in Australia, he doesn’t seem to have his usual level of enthusiasm - and it’s not just on the back of England's horrid form.

Australian viewers get the impression he's coming off his short run, or maybe we're just accustomed to our own witless types screaming incessantly into the mics.

Lloyd spoke of the commentary box feeling "a little emptier" without Botham, Holding and Gower. Perhaps Beefy is feeling the same way.

He looks like a 66-year-old forced to go out with blokes 20-30 years his junior, drinking craft beer infused with strawberries, after suddenly finding himself on the singles circuit.

During the Boxing Day Test the cameras panned into the commentary box as Ricky Ponting and James Brayshaw enthralled us with a riveting story about how they'd choose bats at the Kookaburra factory back in the day.

Botham didn’t even pretend to be interested (it would have been a stretch, admittedly), looking straight ahead at the action and no doubt thinking he'd rather be tucking into one of his Ian Botham cab sauvignons over a long lunch or teeing off at nearby Royal Melbourne.

Even a carpark catch-up with Ian Chappell had more appeal at that stage.

A mate texted me soon after: "I hope Beefy isn’t being paid by the word. He's said about seven."

Small talk's not really his thing. As he told audiences at the start of the Ashes: "I have a very, very low boredom threshold."

That much is obvious.

Link: https://au.sports.yahoo.com/ashes-2...id=facebook_facebook_k0cpmc7b04w&guccounter=1
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ditched by sky alongwith the old crew he has had heart surgery, spinal surgery and two hip replacements spent 2 years bedridden on crutches, and most of all he lost a team mate , a sky colleague a good friend and was with him in his last few days Bob Willis.

So he needs to be cut some slack.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have been saying this for a while now, the standard of cricket commentary around the world is declining rapidly.

Barring a couple of good commentators (Nasser Hussain and Mike Atherton), the cupboard is pretty bare.

Too many commentators stating the obvious and getting gigs as part of the jobs for the boys/girls network.
 
Michael Vaughan’s commentary is even worse. It’s like he’s reading a bedtime story and is trying to make the viewers fall asleep.

Ian Bishop
Nasser Hussain
Micheal Atherton
Nick Knight
Rambo
Ian Smith

The only commentators I can listen to.
 
Ditched by sky alongwith the old crew he has had heart surgery, spinal surgery and two hip replacements spent 2 years bedridden on crutches, and most of all he lost a team mate , a sky colleague a good friend and was with him in his last few days Bob Willis.

So he needs to be cut some slack.

It’s so easy to feel sorry for Botham, poor chap :(
 
Sky were loyal to Botham for 20 plus years. Eventually the older guard makes way for the younger lot. That's how it works every where
 
I say better be quiet than make those lame jokes Aussie commentators make. I'm not too fond of their banter. AB is excellent, though.
 
Botham was always a lifeless commentator. Why are people noticing now? More importantly how is he still getting commentary gigs when even Sky dropped him?
 
I say better be quiet than make those lame jokes Aussie commentators make. I'm not too fond of their banter. AB is excellent, though.

Aussie commentators are worse because their entire commentary box is usually filled with Australians. It tends to become an echo chamber of the same kind of banter/rubbish commentary.

Gilly and Hussey are good. AB also comes across as fairly lifeless at this point. Whereas the rest led by Warne are simply unbearable.
 
Even listening to David Gower's calling of the remarkable English implosion made it feel like a library.

I understand these English commentators are sad watching their country's side getting pummeled by their oldest rivals, but the job of a commentator is to transfer the emotions and drama of the action on the field and the atmosphere in the stadium to the viewer at home.

These guys do the complete opposite.
 
I have always found Botham to be an extremely boring commentator. No matter what happens in the middle, his tone of voice never changes. It’s the same monotone boring voice.

Maybe Aussie viewers are only now hearing him. As is often the case with Ashes series, each of the host nations usually runs their own commentary and so Botham’s monotone on Sky Sports has probably not been heard a great deal in Australia.
 
Too many former players are becoming commentators, and too many of them are commentating at the same time. It should be one or two genuine people who can properly analyze the game from an unbiased perspective, and maybe one former player who can add a player perspective to the discussion
 
I have been saying this for a while now, the standard of cricket commentary around the world is declining rapidly.

Barring a couple of good commentators (Nasser Hussain and Mike Atherton), the cupboard is pretty bare.

Too many commentators stating the obvious and getting gigs as part of the jobs for the boys/girls network.
Ricky Ponting is pretty good, provides great analysis.
 
Doesn't matter for Channel 7, they wanted Botham for the reputation and recognition with Australian audiences and not for cutting edge analysis. That doesn't matter that much as they have the best commentator in the world in their team. Ricky Ponting has been simply superb during this Ashes series, he's surpassed Hussain and Atherton for me.
 
Michael Vaughan’s commentary is even worse. It’s like he’s reading a bedtime story and is trying to make the viewers fall asleep.

Ian Bishop
Nasser Hussain
Micheal Atherton
Nick Knight
Rambo
Ian Smith

The only commentators I can listen to.

How is Michael Vaughan even allowed to commentate after the recent racism controversy? I thought all the networks had removed him from the Ashes coverage.
 
Ditched by sky alongwith the old crew he has had heart surgery, spinal surgery and two hip replacements spent 2 years bedridden on crutches, and most of all he lost a team mate , a sky colleague a good friend and was with him in his last few days Bob Willis.

So he needs to be cut some slack.

I didn't know that.

I think he should protect his health, retire to his estate and fish for trout.
 
How is Michael Vaughan even allowed to commentate after the recent racism controversy? I thought all the networks had removed him from the Ashes coverage.

Australia welcomed him with open arms so he contracted to fox currently, one surprise tho in the UK BT were going to cover over his commentary stint to avoid backlash after he was named in rafiq scandal, however vaughan is also commentating on BBL and sky sports seem to have no issue with using the feed with him on it.
 
Could be that he's losing interest in Cricket. He has a wine business in Australia that could be more appealing to him.
 
I thought that “Lord” Beefy was a political envoy now or something.
 
If you are upset with likes of Botham, then spare a thought for us Indian cricket viewers. We have to put up with worst commentators ever who are more cheerleaders of Indian team than commentators and in the name of providing expert insights say things that are as plain as the nose on your face. Whatever little Indian cricket i watch, i do it with tv on mute.
 
Trade envoy. Probably a big Tory donor.

Conservative peer in the House of Lords now!

Not sure what value he will add doing that.

Probably just there for the daily allowance and free food.
 
Back
Top