Let's ignore their past and have a single standard, because that's what the PCB is doing for Butt.
On merit alone, Asif is far more deserving to play cricket again. A genius and Mastermind of bowling, he's not even allowed to be in the draft.
Butt on the other hand is an accumulator worse than Fawad Alam or Usman Salahduinn.
He has no business playing LOIs. Yet he's selected, in an actual team.
Asif can play for 3-4 more years.
On merit alone, Asif is far more deserving to play cricket again. A genius and Mastermind of bowling, he's not even allowed to be in the draft.
Butt on the other hand is an accumulator worse than Fawad Alam or Usman Salahduinn.
He has no business playing LOIs. Yet he's selected, in an actual team.
Asif can play for 3-4 more years.