What's new

IHC permits Ghotki sisters to stay with their husbands [Update Post #58]

So you did see the video? And yet given the subcontinental setup, you don’t believe things were twisted to favour the powerful accused?

What sub continental set up are you referring to? The one where Muslim preachers actively try to spread Islam to Muslims and non Muslims alike? Is there any surprise that a few converted? Is this an issue because those who converted are young women? Why was this not an issue when youhana did the same thing?
 
I don't. If the father lied about the girls age because he couldn't accept they had chosen to marry out, then he was putting petrol on open flames. I would have had more sympathy for him if he had stuck to the truth.

So two sisters woke up one fine day decided to marry and convert to islam against their parents will ? Seriosuly whats wrong with you all
 
So two sisters woke up one fine day decided to marry and convert to islam against their parents will ? Seriosuly whats wrong with you all

People converting daily to different religion for various reason.

Seriously, what is wrong with y'all, do y'all live with your head under the sand?
 
And they weren't abducted nor forcibly converted. Can't believe people are actually buying that.

The courts of the indian subcontinent are rotten: whether they whitewash this reprehensible atrocity or they acquit fascist CM's for abetting slaughter or minorities.
 
I don't. If the father lied about the girls age because he couldn't accept they had chosen to marry out, then he was putting petrol on open flames. I would have had more sympathy for him if he had stuck to the truth.

Come on cap, please be more empathetic. Its their father who raised them. I know lying is wrong but i can sympathise with him given the nature of relationship between fathers and daughters.
 
So two sisters woke up one fine day decided to marry and convert to islam against their parents will ? Seriosuly whats wrong with you all

Who told you that everything happened so suddenly? Perhaps the relationships went on for a while befote they finally decided to take the step.
 
So two sisters woke up one fine day decided to marry and convert to islam against their parents will ? Seriosuly whats wrong with you all

I don't know where you live, but in the west where girls have more individual freedom, Hindu girls will often marry people of other faiths, and they have no problem converting either. I can give you numerous examples if you wish, in fact even those who were movie stars in India who are household names. Want your memory jogged perhaps?
 
I don't know where you live, but in the west where girls have more individual freedom, Hindu girls will often marry people of other faiths, and they have no problem converting either. I can give you numerous examples if you wish, in fact even those who were movie stars in India who are household names. Want your memory jogged perhaps?

Yea well their men are fighting back against this despicable love jihad. Hiding in backyard sheds, wielding crossbows.
 
People converting daily to different religion for various reason.

Seriously, what is wrong with y'all, do y'all live with your head under the sand?


2 sisters converting and falling in love at the same time is common ?
 
Were they abducted against their will?

For debate, let us assume it was against their will, but on the positive they are no longer marginalized and have advanced socially. Minority rights look good to talk about, but nothing beats the social capital you earn when you part of the majority.
 
Looking at the men they married, I don’t think it’s an affluent of powerful family. They may have married for love or truly to change their faith. Who knows?

But to me this doesn’t look coerced anymore.
 
Safdar Ali and Barkat Ali, both of whom were already married and have children. Safdar and Barkat’s first wives left them as soon as news of the nikkah became public.
 
Why are Hindu teenage girls converted and made wives, why are they not made sisters?

And, why do only young Hindu girls accept Islam, why do older Hindu men &women and young Hindu boys do not accept Islam?
 
Why are Hindu teenage girls converted and made wives, why are they not made sisters?

And, why do only young Hindu girls accept Islam, why do older Hindu men &women and young Hindu boys do not accept Islam?

Because love jihad would not work on older women or young Hindu boys, or at least it is going to be far less common. This is one case not an epidemic, if there is evidence that it is more widespread then perhaps we can look at it more closely.
 
Safdar Ali and Barkat Ali, both of whom were already married and have children. Safdar and Barkat’s first wives left them as soon as news of the nikkah became public.

If this is true, doesn't it make the marriage illegal since for second marriage, you have to have the blessings from the earlier ones?
 
Older minority women are also targeted.There is a network of influential sexual predators operating within the capital
https://www.dawn.com/news/1471340/pakistans-terrified-christians

There was no evidence of a network in that article you cited, the example given was of a lone sex attacker where the victim was Christian.

The writer of the article was correct though, in general third world countries have less protection for minority victims and we must continue to highlight their backward views in order to civilise them.
 
Sindh Assembly adopts resolution against Hindu girls’ abduction

KARACHI: The Sindh Assembly adopted on Tuesday a resolution condemning recurring incidents of Hindu girls’ abduction in the province, reported ARY News.

MPA Nand Kumar Goklani, aligned with the Grand Democratic Alliance (GDA), moved the resolution on the private members’ day, which was unanimously adopted by the legislature with certain amendments.

Goklani, speaking in the assembly, expressed gratitude to Pakistan Peoples Party Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari for raising voice over the issue concerning the abduction of Hindu girls from Ghotki district.

He lamented this is not the country Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah had envisioned as he envisaged a country which guaranteed equal rights for all the minority communities.

PTI lawmaker Khurram Sher Zaman said the minority communities enjoy religious freedom in the country, unlike India where the Muslims are facing atrocities at the hands of Hindu-hardliners.

He said abduction of Hindu girls is a social issue, which needed to be addressed.

Minister for Parliamentary Affairs Mukesh Kumar Chawla said the Muslims and non-Muslims are all Pakistanis.

He said the Sindh government has been making efforts to curb incidents of Hindu girls’ abduction.

MPA Nusrat Sehar Abbasi said there is a need to raise voice over the issue by raising above religious differences.

https://arynews.tv/en/sindh-assembly-adopts-resolution-against-hindu-girls-abduction/
 
Back
Top