Including UA and Rauf in ODI is a gamble worth taking, we are not like ENG/IND who are already top team and not need to take extra risk. We are #7 rank team for heaven sake, taking this gamble make sense...
They both are X factor players who can win the match on their own. Playing too many bits and pieces allrounders is not worth it, team is already filled with lot of mediocre players.
Umar Akmal
He can replace Asif Ali easily. He will be ideal for last 15 overs or even after 30+ overs on flat decks(which we are suppose to get in WC, considering how good is ENG on those decks). If he gets in to rhythm in ENG, Pakistan can get huge benefit from it... Other batters (Malik, Sarfraz, Immad, Shadab) does not have ability to charge the way he can regardless of bowling quality or pitch conditions...You can see that in PSL as well...
Harris Rauf
He can play instead of Faheem/Immad. As a bowler he is far better than these guys. If we play Amir, Afridi, Hasan, Rauf, Shadab as our 5 bowlers, we can cut down 40-50 runs, chase can be lot more manageable. Rauf 6/8 overs in last 20/25 overs can be vital in, not only controlling run rate but taking wickets. He is not easy to lineup and his Yorker is already best in the country...
Point is: Pakistan cannot have X factor batsman (there is no Sharjeel, nothing impressive in PSL or domestic) in 3 months nor an allrounder. But in Rauf we can further strengthen our bowling...That can help us win matches against top teams, like we did in 90s by playing 4/5 wicket taking bowlers in playing 11...Even in 2015 WC, when we started playing Shoial, Irfan, Wahab and Rahat (4 seamers), things started to happen, we closed down on SA and put AUS in serious trouble (that too without Irfan, if he was playing things could have been different)...
They both are X factor players who can win the match on their own. Playing too many bits and pieces allrounders is not worth it, team is already filled with lot of mediocre players.
Umar Akmal
He can replace Asif Ali easily. He will be ideal for last 15 overs or even after 30+ overs on flat decks(which we are suppose to get in WC, considering how good is ENG on those decks). If he gets in to rhythm in ENG, Pakistan can get huge benefit from it... Other batters (Malik, Sarfraz, Immad, Shadab) does not have ability to charge the way he can regardless of bowling quality or pitch conditions...You can see that in PSL as well...
Harris Rauf
He can play instead of Faheem/Immad. As a bowler he is far better than these guys. If we play Amir, Afridi, Hasan, Rauf, Shadab as our 5 bowlers, we can cut down 40-50 runs, chase can be lot more manageable. Rauf 6/8 overs in last 20/25 overs can be vital in, not only controlling run rate but taking wickets. He is not easy to lineup and his Yorker is already best in the country...
Point is: Pakistan cannot have X factor batsman (there is no Sharjeel, nothing impressive in PSL or domestic) in 3 months nor an allrounder. But in Rauf we can further strengthen our bowling...That can help us win matches against top teams, like we did in 90s by playing 4/5 wicket taking bowlers in playing 11...Even in 2015 WC, when we started playing Shoial, Irfan, Wahab and Rahat (4 seamers), things started to happen, we closed down on SA and put AUS in serious trouble (that too without Irfan, if he was playing things could have been different)...