shan
ODI Debutant
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2005
- Runs
- 8,563
no i did not say pak will nuke isreal, more likely that isreal will nuke a muslim country.
Maybe but dont expect Pakistan to strike back if its not Pakistan who is nuked.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: this_feature_currently_requires_accessing_site_using_safari
no i did not say pak will nuke isreal, more likely that isreal will nuke a muslim country.
I have my doubts about reverse engineering Aircraft Engines... it is more metallurgy than reverse-engineerable components. Which is why China struggled for so many decades and kept using Russian engines for a long time, while they could successfully rip-off everything else.
These are nothing but the claims, China still had to buy Russian engines to use it with JF-17 which Pakistan got. Evidence say one thing and claims other, i think now they finally developed their own engine for Jf-17. So they are still decades behind western nations.
Pakistan got 500 USA AMRAAM BVR missiles with F-16 these are way way ahead of anything Iranian got. And must of the already old F-16 are going throug MLU and other advance F-16 are also coming all of them capabale of BVR. Pakistan also is buying Chinese SD-10 BVR missiles to use with JF-17.
Wrong , The Aim-54 Phoenix is the BVR beast of world ... it can strike an aircraft as far as 190 km pulling 17 G's at any altitude even before an hostile Aircraft can even see whats coming its way ... Iran's locally produced Aim-54 is called Sattar .... Only missile that can challenge Aim-54 is the Russian R-37 ( on Mig-31) ....
Iran also has R-73 and R-27 which are the mainstay A2A of Chinese , Russian AF ... Aim-120 is in same class of R-77 and 27 ... Iran also produces Sejjil AIm-23C BVR missile which is basically a SAM installed on F-14 and F-4 Phantom ... being a SAM it has excellent maneuverability and Acceleration .... Funny thing is that it was Israeli experts that gave that idea to iran during contra affairs scandal .... they tried same thing on their F-4s .... There is also fattar IR Homer which is reverse engineered and Improved ( Smoke less ) Aim-9P ... U can search specs and pics ...
out of pakistans 60 + F-16s only 8 r MLU'ed yet ( at Turkish TUSAS facilities ) which means only 38-40 are BVR capable ... also the SD-10 is not operational yet ... now compare that to what i wrote in my previous post .... Rest of the PAF lacks BVR ...
I am not against PAF btw ... I am a fan of MM Alam , Rafighi ... etc
the F-86 Sabre legends .
Actually J-10 isnt anywhere near Rafael, being of same generation is not good enough evidence because its 4.5 gen according to China only. Enough non-biased sources in internet about capablities of both. Even China 5th generation may never come close to F-22.
Well those are opinions ... Chinese experts might ridicule F-22 , Pakistanis will ridicule Indian LCA , Indians can ridicule Pakistan in return , Iranian experts ridicule Israel and Arabs , Russian ridicules US .... whats the point in wasting time on that ....
and btw pakistan has plans to induct 150 Chinese JF-17 ... which is not even in class of J-10 itself so according to ur logic PAF brains r just plain stupids that they r buying Chinese Plane while India is buying Super beasts called Rafaels ? ....
Can u provide those unbiased sources ? i wanna read this stuff
At evidence is there that J-20 and T-50 are still way behind F-22.
How come ? ... i mean what r the technical reasons behind ur claim .
I have my doubts about reverse engineering Aircraft Engines... it is more metallurgy than reverse-engineerable components. Which is why China struggled for so many decades and kept using Russian engines for a long time, while they could successfully rip-off everything else.
.....
Wrong , The Aim-54 Phoenix is the BVR beast of world ... it can strike an aircraft as far as 190 km pulling 17 G's at any altitude even before an hostile Aircraft can even see whats coming its way ... Iran's locally produced Aim-54 is called Sattar .... Only missile that can challenge Aim-54 is the Russian R-37 ( on Mig-31) ....
Iran also has R-73 and R-27 which are the mainstay A2A of Chinese , Russian AF ... Aim-120 is in same class of R-77 and 27 ... Iran also produces Sejjil AIm-23C BVR missile which is basically a SAM installed on F-14 and F-4 Phantom ... being a SAM it has excellent maneuverability and Acceleration .... Funny thing is that it was Israeli experts that gave that idea to iran during contra affairs scandal .... they tried same thing on their F-4s .... There is also fattar IR Homer which is reverse engineered and Improved ( Smoke less ) Aim-9P ... U can search specs and pics ...
out of pakistans 60 + F-16s only 8 r MLU'ed yet ( at Turkish TUSAS facilities ) which means only 38-40 are BVR capable ... also the SD-10 is not operational yet ... now compare that to what i wrote in my previous post .... Rest of the PAF lacks BVR ...
I am not against PAF btw ... I am a fan of MM Alam , Rafighi ... etc
the F-86 Sabre legends .
AIM-120C-5 AMRAAM which PAF is getting is way ahead of Aim-54 Phoenix, just a little research on google will give you the idea. Aim-54 is old and retired by USA airforce by now.
Well those are opinions ... Chinese experts might ridicule F-22 , Pakistanis will ridicule Indian LCA , Indians can ridicule Pakistan in return , Iranian experts ridicule Israel and Arabs , Russian ridicules US .... whats the point in wasting time on that ....
and btw pakistan has plans to induct 150 Chinese JF-17 ... which is not even in class of J-10 itself so according to ur logic PAF brains r just plain stupids that they r buying Chinese Plane while India is buying Super beasts called Rafaels ? ....
Pakistan is getting 36 J-10, its all over the news. But lets not kid outself Rafael are better. Pakistan simply cant afford Rafael thats why they are not getting them.
.
If you read propely it also said pak has better technology then iran in home made missiles.
PAKISTAN LONGEST RANG MISSILE IS 7,000 WHICH IRAN WILL NEEVR MAKE FOR ANOTHER 2-3 YEARS. FORGET IRAN INDIA HAS DEVELOPED 5,000 MISSILE 2 YEARS LATER WITH 5,000 RANGE IT SHOWS YOU HOW MUCH PAKISTAN ARE AHEAD OF INDIA, IRAN IN TECHNOLOGY.
Pakistan hasnt tested any 7000 km missile, and probably never will even if they have in near future.
Taimur (above 7,000 km range)
pakistans longest missile Intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_missiles_of_Pakistan
Any news source of Pakistan testing this missile? Because i cant find it in wiki.
If you read propely it also said pak has better technology then iran in home made missiles.
PAKISTAN LONGEST RANG MISSILE IS 7,000 WHICH IRAN WILL NEEVR MAKE FOR ANOTHER 2-3 YEARS. FORGET IRAN INDIA HAS DEVELOPED 5,000 MISSILE 2 YEARS LATER WITH 5,000 RANGE IT SHOWS YOU HOW MUCH PAKISTAN ARE AHEAD OF INDIA, IRAN IN TECHNOLOGY.
Read properly
If you read propely it also said pak has better technology then iran in home made missiles.
PAKISTAN LONGEST RANG MISSILE IS 7,000 WHICH IRAN WILL NEEVR MAKE FOR ANOTHER 2-3 YEARS. FORGET IRAN INDIA HAS DEVELOPED 5,000 MISSILE 2 YEARS LATER WITH 5,000 RANGE IT SHOWS YOU HOW MUCH PAKISTAN ARE AHEAD OF INDIA, IRAN IN TECHNOLOGY.
Actually there is nothing to read about, Pak never testes anything close to 7000km missile.
T 50 is supposedly very very close to f 22.search you will get the.comparisions.esp as t 50 will have a special radar on its wings.
j20 though is way behind.so is the j 10 etc.
Not sure if they have tested or not but they have the taimur which is supposedly has a 7000km range. Source http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_missiles_of_Pakistan#section_1
Thats like India saying we have an indegenous aircraft carrier already even though it is only being built in Cochin Shipyard now... If the 7000 K missile had been tested successful then you have it...
AIM-120C-5 AMRAAM which PAF is getting is way ahead of Aim-54 Phoenix, just a little research on google will give you the idea. Aim-54 is old and retired by USA airforce by now.
and how is it ahead exactly ? I mean with all due respect u r just running away from the discussion that u urself initiated ....
Aim54 is retired from USAF because only one aircraft in the world fires it and that is F-14 ... USAF was no longer interested in keeping the High maintenance costs Tomcat thats why it has been retired otherwise armed with Aim-54 , Tomcat can take out any ... and by that I mean any aircraft in this world ( other than Stealths ) .... Its APG71 radar range is exceptionally long that it can search , track aircrafts even before they know what is happening to them ....
F-14 with Aim54 and Mig31 with R-37 are absolute nightmares for any aircraft in sky ...
and that btw is not the only BVR option of IRIAF ... There is R-73 , R-27 which r both mainstays of Russia and China AF ... then there is A2A Aim 23 C Sejjil , Infra Red Homer Fatter , Aim-7E for F-4 ... On 200 + BVR fighters ... of which majority are fourth generation and recently upgraded Mig-29s .... compared to only 38-40 of PAF ....
Pakistan is getting 36 J-10, its all over the news. But lets not kid outself Rafael are better. Pakistan simply cant afford Rafael thats why they are not getting them.
Look friend .... I see that u r claiming this for some time that J-10 which PAF wants to buy is crap in front of rafael ... I will ask u one more time that do u have any Technical info or proof to back this up ? ... What is in rafael that makes it Superior to J-10 ? .... I dont mean any quick google search links ...
Do be honest I don't care much for weapons of any kind . All they do is create fear and unnessecary rivalry . If I had it my way no country would have missiles or nukes .
Do be honest I don't care much for weapons of any kind . All they do is create fear and unnessecary rivalry . If I had it my way no country would have missiles or nukes .
.....
I am not against deterrence as it is self defense...
Yeah but there will be a day when it goes too far that day we will lose it all .
I dunno the technicial know how of the J-10's but in all honesty do you believe a Chinese made product which probably costs less that half of Rafalles would be as good or if not better ? I mean how long have China been manufacturing fighter jets again ?
They r still behind US but they will catch up in next 10-15 years maximum ... !
PAK-FA will be a great 5th generation bird but I highly doubt it would be anywhere close to the F22...........
The comparisions say they aremvery close.Pak.Fa will have d band radars.on its wings which will be able.to.detect the f 22 from a longer distance then the f22 radar can detect the Pak fa.where.as Pak.Fa will be much.more manueverable than f 22 there by able.to.escape the f 22.so though f 22 will ne more.stealthy all in all it will be close.also russia is talking about using plasma stealth on pak.fa
Sure this will workThere are signs China will try to pressure the US and Russia not to sell missile guidance systems to India
Sure this will work
In Missile tech only China is close to the US, but navy especially aircraft carriers etc, fighter jets like F22 I believe US is ahead of rest of the world by 50 years....
Problem with modern warfare is that nobody has seen it happening in reality .... No two comparable countries have fought a war in modern time where we would have seen what happens when Cruise missiles r fired from both sides or when 2 comparable navies come head to head .... only war that was fought between comparable forces was the Iran vs Arab war of 1980s and even that is a 2-3 decades old case now .... We dont know if All those F-15s and Mig-29s , Rafaels , J10s will be destroyed on ground when a 1 ton warhead will hit the air base ? ... or would the Aircraft carriers survive the barrage of anti ship missiles fired at them ? Because we havnt seen such a balanced fight yet ... all the recent wars were one sided as opposition was too weak to challenge the bigger enemy in conventional warfare ...
When u start building a military ... u base it on ur enemies ... China doesnt have the Navy like US ... US navy is built around the idea of dominating the globe ... anywhere ... Chinese force is more defensive then offensive ... They can inflict severe damage to enemies near their waters but cant dictate the distant seas like US does .... but thats just today ... they r putting in massive R & D and $ in their military projects ... I wish i could tell u in details but this aint a military forum and i dont want to derail the thread ...
My God ... lol F-22 is a modern advanced plane but not something from Mars ... it has been going on since arms race terminology started ... I build something and then u respond by making something similar ... US made F-4 Phantom in 1958 ... it was like a spaceship at that time because half of world was flying props of WWII ... USSR took time but responded by Making Mig-23 and then Mig-25 ... US made F-14 ... Su-27 came in return ... F-15 came out , Mig-31 and Su-30 were there ..... F-16 came , Mig 29 came out .... French made Rafael , EU made EF2000 , China made J-10 , Swedes came with Jas 39 .... for how long u think u can keep a country from developing something ? a gap of only 10-12 years at max .... Researchers and Scientists do not care much abt which nationality they belong to or how their country is seen in the world ... they think ...they figure it out ... they succeed ... mostly ! .... did someone ever imagined that a Unmanned Stealth Airplane of US would be hacked and landed ? or would a Stealth Vessel be hit by a Cruise missile ? ... My dad has served for 39 years ... he says that quality and quantity ( Q n Q ) of military equipment is only one of the 10 other factors that decide the fate of a conflict ...
OFF TOPIC since we are talking about everything now, what do you think of the Russian/ Indian 5th generation stealth jet T-50/ PAK FA ?
Off course its an excellent project .. I guess u r referring to Hal FGFA project .... like MKI is the customized ToT of Su-30MK ... i guess it will fly around 2018 ( i see it getting late for atleast 6-8 years more , happens with everyone ) ... we dont know the what avionics will it have , what will be its Armaments ... the current Russian T50's proposed avionics set is highest that Russians can offer at this moment .
The fact is India’s Nuclear arsenal serves to protect and preserve Hinduism against the mighty Pakistan. Religious motive – nothing else.
....
India equals Hinduism. Not just because secular India is a myth, but because India is the homeland and birth land for Hindus and Hinduism respectively.
A nation surrounded by Islam and Buddhism, it doesn’t come as a surprise why India wants to develop a weapon of peace protecting and preserving Hinduism. Remember, it was India who colluded with Israel and USA so to prevent Pakistan – The Islamic State - from acquiring the Bomb. India Failed.
Though must say, a woman at the forefront of AGNI V - a weapon of peace. No better irony. India is a peaceful nation with peaceful ambitions – cough cough.
Remember, it was India who colluded with Israel and USA so to prevent Pakistan – The Islamic State - from acquiring the Bomb. India Failed.
I agree the Chinese are improving at a rapid rate and they have the $$$ however I think it is going to take a lot more than 10-15 years for them to catch up with the US if at all in all defense sectors except missile tech, Missile tech wise I think they may be very close.... Regardless of whether their navy is for defending or dominating it doesnt take away the fact that US is still worlds apart from the chinese, its quite similar to an Indian saying if China attacks us we can inflict severe damage to them, sure but at end of the day India wont be around but China will survive...China has never operated an aircraft carrier before & it would take them years just to learn how to run it, taking off and landing an aircraft in the middle of the ocean with a ship moving up and down is no easy task..... One concerning thing from an Indian prespective is that; China has now given the full throttle for home grown products, sure you see India buying this and that but not much is known about what the Chinese are doing.....
its quite similar to an Indian saying if China attacks us we can inflict severe damage to them, sure but at end of the day India wont be around but China will survive........
Regarding ur second point of inflicting max damage before going down ... let me give u an example ... consider that u r a very Strong grown man and ur enemy is not very strong but thuggish teen who carries knives and stuff ... and is very aggressive minded whose whole ideology revolves around causing pain to u .... offcourse u can finish him off because u r stronger but before going down he would give u fractures , ugly scars , that u would remember all ur life ... ..
what if an aircraft carrier or a Destroyer is sunk in the middle of an ocean ? what if the crazy expensive military aircraft countries buy would be destroyed on ground when hostile missiles hit the base ? .... ..