sensible-indian-fan
ODI Star
- Joined
- Aug 1, 2013
- Runs
- 35,587
- Post of the Week
- 3
I would love to see India prevailing in all three formats to be honest.
Thank you.

Just don't see it happening but would be a dream come true.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I would love to see India prevailing in all three formats to be honest.
I would love to see India prevailing in all three formats to be honest.
What about Pakistan in NZ - you think we have a chance or it’s a reality check?
Surprised kuldeep wasn't selected and surprised Bumrah was. Will be a challenge for him to bowl long spells if he does play.
Indian side is settled dilemmas is Ashwin or Jadeja and who is the 3rd seamer. Doubt we'll see a pitch where 2 spinners is an opition. I'll go with Ashwin over Jadeja.
Death of any bowler. Even Amir.
So:
Tests: 2-1 India
ODIs: 4-2 SA
T20I: 2-1 SA
If this happens, we Indians will be over the moon celebrating by lifting Mamoon bhai on our shoulders.
![]()
Backup keeper is needed.
PP sucks though.
So:
Tests: 2-1 India
ODIs: 4-2 SA
T20I: 2-1 SA
If this happens, we Indians will be over the moon celebrating by lifting Mamoon bhai on our shoulders.
![]()
Bumrah doesn't have the qualities an international test bowler should have, as far as I have seen he doesn't even swing the ball a centimeter.
Kumar, Shami, Sharma and Yadav all have bowling averages over 30. However, the same is true of Pakistani and Sri Lankan pacers of today. Not the best era to be an Asian pace bowler.
That was a year back & hasn't played in FC for about a year, that's why dropping Kuldeep wasDon't think bowling long spells is new for Bumrah. He has bowled some marathon spells for Gujarat.
Surprised kuldeep wasn't selected and surprised Bumrah was. Will be a challenge for him to bowl long spells if he does play.
Indian side is settled dilemmas is Ashwin or Jadeja and who is the 3rd seamer. Doubt we'll see a pitch where 2 spinners is an opition. I'll go with Ashwin over Jadeja.
I think most likely XI for first test would be
Vijay
Dhawan
Pujara
Kohli
Rahane
Saha
Pandya
Ashwin
Kumar
Shami
Ishant
I hope Kohli sees the stupidity in playing Dhawan
And Ashwin.
I hope Kohli sees the stupidity in playing Dhawan
And Ashwin.
Ashwin is a much improved bowler and will be pretty effective. If he can't take wickets, he will at least create pressure from one end and won't get an 80+ average phainta
Dhawan on the other hand.
Not much to choose between Ashwin and Jadeja tbh.
What's wrong with his form, scored 5 or 6 fifties vs Aus & 2 or 3 vs SL in SL. Dhawan on the other hand did well against SL in SL but they;re hardly a barometer for anything, he failed twice in two tests here & is playing for his spot right now, hence the low S/R.I'm not sure, Rahul may or may not do well looking at the form he is in.
With Dhawan it is a gamble always but if he gets in he will score pretty quickly.
Yes but we'll see if his non existent batting, in the last one year, gives him an edge or what!Surely his fielding gives him the edge as well as their respective records in the country.
That was a year back & hasn't played in FC for about a year, that's why dropping Kuldeep was![]()
We have enough bowlers in the squad, even pacers, & I doubt we'll overbowl them unless we play on 3 green tracks with 4 pacers in each game. Bumrah should be the backup of a backup, Umesh probably, at best. Kuldeep was a good choice if we needed a spinner on a really flat track, like Joberg on last tour day 5, I don;t see Ashwin bowling teams out on a similar surface in the first innings & there Kuldeep could be crucial, not unlike Dharamshala.How can he play FC when he is a regular LOI starter?
And we are not playing 2 spinners in SA let alone 3. So we need 2 backup pacers for the 4 that will be playing. Don't want England 14 to happen again when our main bowlers were fatigued and we lost 3 tests after going up 1-0 in first two tests.
What will be your playing XI?!
We have enough bowlers in the squad, even pacers, & I doubt we'll overbowl them unless we play on 3 green tracks with 4 pacers in each game. Bumrah should be the backup of a backup, Umesh probably, at best. Kuldeep was a good choice if we needed a spinner on a really flat track, like Joberg on last tour day 5, I don;t see Ashwin bowling teams out on a similar surface in the first innings & there Kuldeep could be crucial, not unlike Dharamshala.
Then we aren;t actually playing the 5 best bowlers are we? OR do you think Pandya will not be an automatic pick? I'd back Ashwin/Jadeja with the bat on a flat track, on the same pitch I'd prefer Kuldeep bowling over both of them. On a green seamer Kohli doesn't seem to have faith in either but I guess we'll play the extra batter.We will play 4 seamers including the all rounder. Kholi is not the "let's draw it dhoni".
Kuldeep is and will be third choice for now and other 2 are all rounders even if Ashwin can't put bat to ball last few matches.
Have Clarified butter & Sugar in your mouthI'm going to go out on a limb here and say that India will win the Test series. For the first time, I see a good fast bowling unit that has the capability to knock the opposition out. The key will be Shami. If he's fully fit and bowling at 140+, India have a great chance. South Africa on the other hand should go for green pitches to nullify India's batting.
Then we aren;t actually playing the 5 best bowlers are we? OR do you think Pandya will not be an automatic pick? I'd back Ashwin/Jadeja with the bat on a flat track, on the same pitch I'd prefer Kuldeep bowling over both of them. On a green seamer Kohli doesn't seem to have faith in either but I guess we'll play the extra batter.
And we;ve seen Ashwin/Jadeja fail in SA/Aus/Eng/NZ although we were facing better, in form, opponents then.We should be playing 11 best possible players. Kuldeep is young and is yet to play outside. Don't go assuming that he will outwit SA batter just cause he is a wrist spinner. Just check his record on green pitches in Ranji. He iha blown hot and cold as it expected.
If some pitch is exceptionally green then we can go with 6 batters and 3+1 bowlers. But I doubt they will take the risk of evening out the the advantage they have over our pacers.
If we have to depend upon spinners to make inroads in SA then we might as well surrender now.
And we;ve seen Ashwin/Jadeja fail in SA/Aus/Eng/NZ although we were facing better, in form, opponents then.
The best track record in SA was of a team who's key linchpin was a wrist spinner, heck Aus beat SA with Bevan bowling them to a victory in 97/98 IIRC. Pacers don;t have to win you games, if they can keep it tight the spinner will get his wickets, the best spinners on SA/Aus tracks have always been wrist spinners.
KL
Vijay
Pujara
Kohli
Rahane
Pandaya
Saha
Ashwin
Shami
Yadav
Ishant/Bhuvi
Rahane is in pathetic form. He does not merit a spot. But he is VC. So he plays.
Expecting a green pitch. So below should be ideal.
Rahul
Vijay
Pujara
Kohli
Rahane
Pandya
Ashwin
Saha
BK
Shami
Ishant/Yadav
Battingwise there is nothing after Kohli. :-(
Looking forward to this series as India on paper have the batting strength to compete in S.A conditions. The question is will the bowlers be able to thrive in such conditions away from the comforts of home. I can S.A just squeezing a series win here.
Rahane is in pathetic form. He does not merit a spot. But he is VC. So he plays.
Expecting a green pitch. So below should be ideal.
Rahul
Vijay
Pujara
Kohli
Rahane
Pandya
Ashwin
Saha
BK
Shami
Ishant/Yadav
Then you have not seen.
What about James Anderson?
1) Elgar
2) Markam
3) Amla
4) ABD
5) Faf (c)
6) de Kock (wk)
7) Phelukwayo
8) Philander
9) Rabada
10) Steyn
11) Maharaj
VS
1) Vijay
2) Rahul
3) Pujara
4) Kohli (c)
5) Rahane
6) Saha (wk)
7) Pandya
8) Jadeja/Ashwin
9) Kumar
10) Shami
11) Ishant
Looks pretty even, on current form. Should be a great contest.
In what world it looks even?
Ishant- Shami- Kumar looks even to Steyn- Philander- Rabada to you?
Amla-Abdv-faf-de qock vs Pujara-Kohli-Rahane-Saha is even?
Lesser teams can win so India can win but it will be a really big upset...
Steyn and Philander are Coming back from injuries but even on one leg they are better than Ishant and Bhuv...
Just one spinner will play for both team, Maharaj vs Jadeja/Ashwin. I din’t See them having any impact one the results as they will go wicketless all 3 being pretty mediocre.
It's going to be a massacre where the Indian team won't know what hit them. It's very difficult to beat South Africa in South Africa and playing Sa pacers is another impossible task...
I prefer Raina over the likes of Jadhav and Pandey.
Raina is a proven match winner and can hit big shots. He is also a gun fielder and can bowl better than Jadhav.
He is only 31 and can easily play for another 3-4 yrs. If he is not picked now, it shows that he is not in the good books of Kohli.
Sa 3-0
odi 6-0
t20 2=0
Me too. UVI, Raina and Dhoni should all be picked. They're proven quality and can play in the next World Cup.
India will never have a better chance; this is an ageing Saffer team plagued by injuries and loss of form. Rabada also looks to have lost a bit of form and sharpness and the others are getting on a bit.
Contrary Steyn and Philander have been in better condition than ever in past two years according to report. AB is coming back and they have found an excellent opener in Makran. This SA side should be much stronger than what England faced.
India will never have a better chance; this is an ageing Saffer team plagued by injuries and loss of form. Rabada also looks to have lost a bit of form and sharpness and the others are getting on a bit.
Bumrah doesn't have the qualities an international test bowler should have, as far as I have seen he doesn't even swing the ball a centimeter.
Indian ODI team is only about top 3 batsman. If they fail , then the match is as good as gone. Pretty average team.