What's new

India's hidden crisis of sexual violence against boys

The Bald Eagle

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Nov 25, 2023
Runs
21,947
India's hidden crisis of sexual violence against boys

The sexual abuse of male children is a taboo topic that is rarely discussed in India. DW looks at the silent struggle male survivors face.

Boys and young men are often reluctant to admit they were sexually abused [FILE]Image: Anupam Nath/AP Photo/picture alliance
Advertisement

This report contains an account from a survivor of sexual abuse.

In India's southern state of Kerala, a 16-year-old boy said he was sexually assaulted for over two years by 14 men he met through a dating app designed for the LGBTQ+ community.

Police have reportedly opened investigations into 14 men and made at least nine arrests.

Though the case has highlighted sexual violence faced by boys in a country that often comes under international focus for attacks on women, experts and survivors say the topic remains a taboo that is rarely acknowledged or discussed in India.

Shame, Silence, Stigma
DW spoke with one male survivor of sexual abuse, a 24-year-old man who preferred to remain anonymous.

He shared his story of how he was "exploited" as a young boy by his relatives, people he "trusted, looked up to and thought were protectors."

The man said the silence around the abuse he suffered was largely shaped by the overwhelming pressure of societal expectations that men should be strong — and silent.

"Society's idea of masculinity says that, if you speak up, you lose your manhood," he said.

Sociologist Vijaylakshmi Brara told DW that the reluctance to accept men as victims stemmed from traditionally rooted notions of masculinity, in which men are seen as dominant — not as victims.

"The traditional notion of 'manliness' casts men as strong and superior, making it difficult to accept that men can also be vulnerable or subjected to abuse," Brara said.

In mainstream thinking, she said, male victimhood is often dismissed, with patriarchal societies unable or unwilling to accept or even imagine that men and boys could be victims to such crimes.

The rape crisis in rural India is shrouded in silence

Society is deeply ingrained with the belief that only women are victims, leaving male experiences largely invisible," Brara said.

This experience is one shared by the survivor DW spoke with.

"No one imagines a boy could be abused," he said. "When a boy (makes allegations of sexual abuse), he's often laughed at."

A national study by India's Women and Child Development Ministry in 2007 found that more than half of boys had suffered sexual abuse, with just under a quarter experiencing a severe form of sexual abuse.

Though the study's use of a convenience sample rather than a representative one means the statistics should be viewed with caution, it nevertheless illustrates that the issue is widespread.

Male survivors are often overlooked and dismissed

Nandini Bhattacharya, who advocates for men who have survived such violence, told DW that male sexual assault survivors face unique psychological challenges — including deep shame and isolation fueled by a general disbelief in their accounts.

Survivors have to overcome a culture of victim-blaming that is tied to traditional gender norms, in which men are expected to be providers and protectors, while women are seen as weak and fragile, she explains.

"There is an increased feeling of guilt, self-blame and anxiety alongside difficulty expressing emotions and intimacy and often results in silence and reluctance to seek help or report the abuse," Bhattacharya said.

This culture of silence also means that boys are often overlooked in discussions about abuse, feminist writer Yashodhara Ray Chaudhuri said.

"Contrary to common beliefs, boys suffer abuse at rates comparable to girls, with some cases involving female abusers also," she said.

Chaudhuri said many men only revealed such experiences years later in private, highlighting the critical need to confront social taboos and broaden understanding of the abuse beyond prescribed gender frameworks.

"You should protect us not hurt us" is written on a sign at a rally with several people.

 
OP bhai thinks more about India than his home country. This is exactly what @psyoptica was talking about in another thread where @gazza619 was doing drama about women security in India.

This is a Pakistani forum and OP should focus on issues in his country like this -

A child was sexually abused every two hours in Pakistan this year, NGO says

An average of 12 children per day – or one every two hours – were subjected to sexual abuse in Pakistan in 2023, a report by a nongovernmental organisation says


---

:kp
 
OP bhai thinks more about India than his home country. This is exactly what @psyoptica was talking about in another thread where @gazza619 was doing drama about women security in India.

This is a Pakistani forum and OP should focus on issues in his country like this -

A child was sexually abused every two hours in Pakistan this year, NGO says

An average of 12 children per day – or one every two hours – were subjected to sexual abuse in Pakistan in 2023, a report by a nongovernmental organisation says


---

Almost 10 days passed since that asia cup final. Pain should have been subsided by now.

:kp
It's a latest news, and that's why opened it up for discussion. But may be you want to discuss something else here and commenting on it may make you a traitor in your own eyes.
 
OP bhai thinks more about India than his home country. This is exactly what @psyoptica was talking about in another thread where @gazza619 was doing drama about women security in India.

This is a Pakistani forum and OP should focus on issues in his country like this -

A child was sexually abused every two hours in Pakistan this year, NGO says

An average of 12 children per day – or one every two hours – were subjected to sexual abuse in Pakistan in 2023, a report by a nongovernmental organisation says


---

Almost 10 days passed since that asia cup final. Pain should have been subsided by now.

:kp
Their hearts bleed more for India than Pakistan.

Its good that they are highlighting the issues of India in a selfless pursuit. Big hearts :afridi
 
OP bhai thinks more about India than his home country. This is exactly what @psyoptica was talking about in another thread where @gazza619 was doing drama about women security in India.

This is a Pakistani forum and OP should focus on issues in his country like this -

A child was sexually abused every two hours in Pakistan this year, NGO says

An average of 12 children per day – or one every two hours – were subjected to sexual abuse in Pakistan in 2023, a report by a nongovernmental organisation says


---

Almost 10 days passed since that asia cup final. Pain should have been subsided by now.

:kp


Op thread was about boys specifically in India, the article you have posted is about child abuse in general covering both sexes. The stigma over homosexual abuse is problematic so it's not helpful to mix the two issues regardless of whataboutery.
 
Op thread was about boys specifically in India, the article you have posted is about child abuse in general covering both sexes. The stigma over homosexual abuse is problematic so it's not helpful to mix the two issues regardless of whataboutery.

Homosexual abuse is rampant in Pakistan along with child abuse, honor killings etc. There is no mischeif where India is ahead of Pakistan.
 
Homosexual abuse is rampant in Pakistan along with child abuse, honor killings etc. There is no mischeif where India is ahead of Pakistan.

But that's why it has often been brought up in various threads and news articles re Pakistan. I think that was the point of this thread, it is often overlooked in India and if you read the article you would see that.

What good does it do to just brush it under the carpet or start induging in whataboutery?
 
But that's why it has often been brought up in various threads and news articles re Pakistan. I think that was the point of this thread, it is often overlooked in India and if you read the article you would see that.

What good does it do to just brush it under the carpet or start induging in whataboutery?

Also, can you pls highlight me to 'those various threads' where those child abuse and homosexualities in Pakistan were widely discussed?

This is another drama that you do. When highlighted the flaw, come back with standard response 'we already discuss the issues of Pakistan in multiple threads'. A little bit more specific and pointing to the URL will be helpful.
 
But that's why it has often been brought up in various threads and news articles re Pakistan. I think that was the point of this thread, it is often overlooked in India and if you read the article you would see that.

What good does it do to just brush it under the carpet or start induging in whataboutery?

They always do this. Derail the thread with whatabouteries.

This is why India may never experience significant growth like China. Indians don't believe in self-accountability. They think everything is perfect in India.
 
Also, can you pls highlight me to 'those various threads' where those child abuse and homosexualities in Pakistan were widely discussed?

This is another drama that you do. When highlighted the flaw, come back with standard response 'we already discuss the issues of Pakistan in multiple threads'. A little bit more specific and pointing to the URL will be helpful.

So not only you want to deflect from the topic to whataboutery, now you want me to join in and search the threads for you?

Come on man, have some respect for the topic matter. If you don't want to discuss young boys being abused in India, just leave the thread.
 
Also, can you pls highlight me to 'those various threads' where those child abuse and homosexualities in Pakistan were widely discussed?

This is another drama that you do. When highlighted the flaw, come back with standard response 'we already discuss the issues of Pakistan in multiple threads'. A little bit more specific and pointing to the URL will be helpful.
Guys no more off topic stuff, if someone can't search threads then they should see tutorial on using search option.
 
OP bhai thinks more about India than his home country. This is exactly what @psyoptica was talking about in another thread where @gazza619 was doing drama about women security in India.

This is a Pakistani forum and OP should focus on issues in his country like this -

A child was sexually abused every two hours in Pakistan this year, NGO says

An average of 12 children per day – or one every two hours – were subjected to sexual abuse in Pakistan in 2023, a report by a nongovernmental organisation says


---

:kp
I condemn every child abuse in Pakistan. I will not sit here and classify it as a minuscule event as you did when we were discussing rape issue in India.

For you lot the Asia cup trophy stolen is the main issue.
 
India is the most dangerous country in the world for girls. But now it seems like even little boys are not safe in the rape capital of the world.
 
Rape and sexual violencec seem to be major problems in India.

Minorities, women, and children are not safe in chaiwala Modi's India.
Other than spewing venom, what do you contribute to a discussion?

Even a pea-sized brain can put a better argument than you to be honest. You claim to be a pious muslim, yet all you have is hatred filled for Hindus and India. You put blanker statements without any data backing and yet revel in your delusional world.
 
Other than spewing venom, what do you contribute to a discussion?

Even a pea-sized brain can put a better argument than you to be honest. You claim to be a pious muslim, yet all you have is hatred filled for Hindus and India. You put blanker statements without any data backing and yet revel in your delusional world.
Have not seen your contribution yet... What do you think about this issue???
 
OP bhai thinks more about India than his home country. This is exactly what @psyoptica was talking about in another thread where @gazza619 was doing drama about women security in India.

This is a Pakistani forum and OP should focus on issues in his country like this -

A child was sexually abused every two hours in Pakistan this year, NGO says

An average of 12 children per day – or one every two hours – were subjected to sexual abuse in Pakistan in 2023, a report by a nongovernmental organisation says


---

:kp
So your saying its absolutely fine for boys to be sexually abused in india because something similar happens in pakistan? You have a sick twisted mind for defending sexual abuse in India.
 
Have not seen your contribution yet... What do you think about this issue???
Does any sane person support any kind of violence on Children?

You need to ask people to condemn on this these days? What are we becoming?

While I hear news on violence on children in India very rarely, I didn't see or hear any evidence of those growing cases in India. If you can provide any stats, I would welcome it.

Child abuse laws in India are very strict in India and at-least I believe in Indian judiciary to deliver justice to these cases. I also welcome any active efforts from government and awareness programs from NGOs to eradicate all the cases. If you want can list out some of this initiatives.

But blanket claims on women and children are not safer in India is far from reality when it reflects any other sub-continent region. Infact, on UN metrics, India is doing better than Pakistan for example. I agree that we have a lot of work to do but definitely, will retort to those blanket statements.
 
You have a sick twisted mind for defending sexual abuse in India.
Where in the world did he defend sexual violence??

Any sane person would likely condemn violence on Children. On Pakpassion, we see threads on India regarding its issues on daily basis but no one is interested on Pakistan’s own issues. Its a glaring hypocrisy one can see.
 
Where in the world did he defend sexual violence??

Any sane person would likely condemn violence on Children. On Pakpassion, we see threads on India regarding its issues on daily basis but no one is interested on Pakistan’s own issues. Its a glaring hypocrisy one can see.
Its your own choice to come on pakpassion nobody is forcing you, if the content of this site isn't for you better not come here.

Your free to open thread on Pakistani issues if your so concerned about about Pakistani issues
 
Does any sane person support any kind of violence on Children?

You need to ask people to condemn on this these days? What are we becoming?

While I hear news on violence on children in India very rarely, I didn't see or hear any evidence of those growing cases in India. If you can provide any stats, I would welcome it.

Child abuse laws in India are very strict in India and at-least I believe in Indian judiciary to deliver justice to these cases. I also welcome any active efforts from government and awareness programs from NGOs to eradicate all the cases. If you want can list out some of this initiatives.

But blanket claims on women and children are not safer in India is far from reality when it reflects any other sub-continent region. Infact, on UN metrics, India is doing better than Pakistan for example. I agree that we have a lot of work to do but definitely, will retort to those blanket statements.

FYI. Now I am waiting for your reponse
Other than spewing venom, what do you contribute to a discussion?

Even a pea-sized brain can put a better argument than you to be honest. You claim to be a pious muslim, yet all you have is hatred filled for Hindus and India. You put blanker statements without any data backing and yet revel in your delusional world.


"The National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) revealed that crimes against children increased by 4.5% in 2019 as compared to 2018.[20] In its report, NCRB stated that as many as 148,185 crimes against children were reported in 2019 in the country.[20] In this, 31.2% cases of crimes against children were registered under the POCSO Act, 2012.[20] Maharashtra is the state where the maximum number of 8,503 cases under the POSCO Act, 2012 were registered in the country during 2017–2019. In nearly 50% of these cases, minors were lured online into meeting people, who then subjected them to sexual abuse or entered into sexual relationships with the promise of marriage.

 
Its your own choice to come on pakpassion nobody is forcing you, if the content of this site isn't for you better not come here.

Your free to open thread on Pakistani issues if your so concerned about about Pakistani issues
I am not as much concerned on Pakistani issues and hence I don't open too many threads on Pakistan.

I can also point out the hypocrisy when its visible. I appreciate Pakpassion moderators for keeping the discussions healthy in most of the cases but trolls have gone up in the past year which makes it uninteresting.

But you skipped the point. Where did he defend violence on kids in that post?? You just want to do the point scoring by putting down India but care zilch about actual issues
 
FYI. Now I am waiting for your reponse



"The National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) revealed that crimes against children increased by 4.5% in 2019 as compared to 2018.[20] In its report, NCRB stated that as many as 148,185 crimes against children were reported in 2019 in the country.[20] In this, 31.2% cases of crimes against children were registered under the POCSO Act, 2012.[20] Maharashtra is the state where the maximum number of 8,503 cases under the POSCO Act, 2012 were registered in the country during 2017–2019. In nearly 50% of these cases, minors were lured online into meeting people, who then subjected them to sexual abuse or entered into sexual relationships with the promise of marriage.

Response??

The OP said that there is a ‘hidden crisis’ of child rape cases in India. Please tell me, if the per-capita rate of the cases is high or alarming??

No one defends child abuse. But the thread claims that there is a crisis brewing. The same link has data on percapita cases in its notes. India has 1.4B population for gods sake and putting in raw numbers doesnt prove anything.
 
Response??

The OP said that there is a ‘hidden crisis’ of child rape cases in India. Please tell me, if the per-capita rate of the cases is high or alarming??

No one defends child abuse. But the thread claims that there is a crisis brewing. The same link has data on percapita cases in its notes. India has 1.4B population for gods sake and putting in raw numbers doesnt prove anything.
Did you read the report that I mentioned you in???
 
"Contrary to common beliefs, boys suffer abuse at rates comparable to girls, with some cases involving female abusers also," she said.
------
Things are pretty bad, while urban areas there are talks on this, esp with movies having these difficult conversations but more can be done.

Highway, Page3 , Taish did have these issues as subplots but audience usually rejects such important topics. If I'm not wrong there was an episode of this on Satyamev Jayate.

I do think Urban India is ready to have this conversation, it will be hard for rural/conservative one to have this talk, schools can help but sex education itself is frowned upon so i doubt there will be awareness on this.
 
Response??

The OP said that there is a ‘hidden crisis’ of child rape cases in India. Please tell me, if the per-capita rate of the cases is high or alarming??

No one defends child abuse. But the thread claims that there is a crisis brewing. The same link has data on percapita cases in its notes. India has 1.4B population for gods sake and putting in raw numbers doesnt prove anything.
The "hidden crisis" or infact the whole OP is a DW news story that is a German outlet, so do they work on my payroll? Because I am getting a feeling as if I twisted and concocted the whole horrible crisis in India. I think it's better to address the issue then shooting the messenger.
 
Back
Top