What's new

Is Doug Walters the most underrated Aussie batsman ?

Nikhil_cric

T20I Star
Joined
Dec 4, 2011
Runs
32,243
5357 runs @48.26 is a very good record but perhaps he was overshadowed by Greg Chappell . I have heard EAS Prasanna say that Walters was one of the best players of spin of that era but I haven't heard much about him when the pantheon of Aussie greats is discussed.

[MENTION=7774]Robert[/MENTION] [MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION] [MENTION=129939]wrongun[/MENTION]
 
I think Neil Harvey is the most underrated Aussie batsman. He is not recognised in the same league as Greg, AB, Ponting and Waugh.
 
I think Neil Harvey is the most underrated Aussie batsman. He is not recognised in the same league as Greg, AB, Ponting and Waugh.
50s and 60s were relatively easier eras for batting and there weren't many great bowlers out there apart from Trueman and The Aussie twins.
Maybe that's the reason for Harvey being underrated, actually it's not just harvey most of the 50s and 60s cricketers aren't really remembered much apart from Trueman and Miller.

Same can be said for Edrich, Dexter, Barrington, I didn't even knew a player named Ian Redpath existed until some time ago and he has pretty solid stats.
 
5357 runs @48.26 is a very good record but perhaps he was overshadowed by Greg Chappell . I have heard EAS Prasanna say that Walters was one of the best players of spin of that era but I haven't heard much about him when the pantheon of Aussie greats is discussed.

[MENTION=7774]Robert[/MENTION] [MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION] [MENTION=129939]wrongun[/MENTION]

He might be under-rated internationally but he's a much loved, cult figure to older generations of cricket fans- perhaps a bit forgotten by youngsters.

He's my dads favourite batsman- because of his runs but also his commitment to an attacking, entertaining style. Doug once scored 100 runs in a single test match session (normal length) at the WACA- hooking Bob Willis for six off the final ball of the session to bring it up! He was that kind of player- he knew everyone wanted that sixer & he took on a great bowler & hooked the bouncer, took the risk rather than play it safe.

He smoked like a chimney, drank like a fish but treated everyone so well, never put a foot wrong off the field or on it.

Was a real character though, behaved the same whether he got 100 or a duck- never really trained. Rod Marsh used to get a shock if Walters ever turned up for nets- even then he famously didn't go in the nets, just chucked a ball up to himself 3 times, missed it completely the first two times (by now all players were watching him in shock), middled the third & then declared he was seeing them much better now and wandered away again.

He once borrowed a bicycle from the crowd to get from end to end after Chappell made him field at 3rd man from both ends (punishment for sleeping in)!

I'd have to check but I think perhaps his results away in England weren't as stellar as his other venues, so that may be the only thing really holding him back from legend status.

So a well loved fellow- the kind who made a whole career as an after dinner speaker & beer company spokesman after cricket. But unlikely to push past the likes of Border & S Waugh for the middle order spots in an ATG Oz team.
 
He might be under-rated internationally but he's a much loved, cult figure to older generations of cricket fans- perhaps a bit forgotten by youngsters.

He's my dads favourite batsman- because of his runs but also his commitment to an attacking, entertaining style. Doug once scored 100 runs in a single test match session (normal length) at the WACA- hooking Bob Willis for six off the final ball of the session to bring it up! He was that kind of player- he knew everyone wanted that sixer & he took on a great bowler & hooked the bouncer, took the risk rather than play it safe.

He smoked like a chimney, drank like a fish but treated everyone so well, never put a foot wrong off the field or on it.

Was a real character though, behaved the same whether he got 100 or a duck- never really trained. Rod Marsh used to get a shock if Walters ever turned up for nets- even then he famously didn't go in the nets, just chucked a ball up to himself 3 times, missed it completely the first two times (by now all players were watching him in shock), middled the third & then declared he was seeing them much better now and wandered away again.

He once borrowed a bicycle from the crowd to get from end to end after Chappell made him field at 3rd man from both ends (punishment for sleeping in)!

I'd have to check but I think perhaps his results away in England weren't as stellar as his other venues, so that may be the only thing really holding him back from legend status.

So a well loved fellow- the kind who made a whole career as an after dinner speaker & beer company spokesman after cricket. But unlikely to push past the likes of Border & S Waugh for the middle order spots in an ATG Oz team.

Wow. Thanks for the detailed explanation. Exactly what I was looking for . I didn't know about the six off the last ball.
 
For England and Australian cricketers Ashes (especially away Ashes) is key factor for determining legacy.

Doug Walters averaged 25.xx after 18 matches in England.

Similarly Dennis Amiss was a player with high quality record (50 matches 46 avg 11x100 including 70+ avg against Windies).

But against Aus he averaged just 15.xx in 11 tests

Both Amiss and Walters are not remembered as generational greats
 
Back
Top