What's new

Is Inzamam-ul-Haq right choice as chief selector?

Is Inzamam-ul-Haq right choice as chief selector?


  • Total voters
    77

#GreenRoars

T20I Star
Joined
Feb 8, 2015
Runs
32,520
Today Shahryar Khan made it official that Inzamam-ul-Haq is Pakistan's new chief selector.

Do you guys agree with his selection?
 
Inzamam is a fantastic choice. The man commands respect and has always had an impeccable character. He's taking a large pay cut and giving up a promising gig as the Afghanistan head coach to do this so we know that he's going to take his job quite seriously.
 
After a long time an overwhelming majority of the fans are happy with the selection of a selector (the irony)

It remains to be seen if Inzi can live up to the fans expectations, or hide at number 5 or 6 once again.
 
Inzi isa very good choice but we shouldn't forget that he would be selecting from the same pool of players.. And they pool is wuite shallow.
 
Great choice as he's honest and will have fear of Allah if he under peform
 
At least it's someone who actually knows about cricket and someone who is a fresh name. Inshallah inzi bhai won't let us down, let's give credit to management boys for selecting a fresh and respected name. :inzi :inzi :inzi
 
Inzamam is a fantastic choice. The man commands respect and has always had an impeccable character. He's taking a large pay cut and giving up a promising gig as the Afghanistan head coach to do this so we know that he's going to take his job quite seriously.

As a chief selector personally don't believe he has what it takes - however as Pakistan's Chief selector he is not a bad choice - like you said - he is honest, strong willed, principled and those three qualities alone will allow him to make the right moves to get Pak out of the rut that it is in - I do hope he has the balls to stand up to the corruption (sifaarish, etc) around the PCB inc the players.
 
He is honest and will give his 100%. No doubt about that.
Is he the right choice as a chief selector? Not sure. His services could have been utilized as a batting coach better. Will have to wait and see. As of now, I have a neutral opinion. I guess that's why they have an option 'I don't know' in polls and that's missing here.
 
Not sure if it is the right choice but looking at the options we had; he is definitely a good choice.
 
I answered the question in an other thread. This is my view:

I do not know if Inzi will do well or bad. But it is a waste really as he would have been very handy as the batting specialist of the team.

You could have gotten Rashid Latif, Aamir Sohail people with integrity and more suited to this complicated role.

As NCA's director Mudasser Nazar would have been the best option. But yea the PCB listening to Waqar is a big thing already even though I do not agree with all of Waqar's suggestions/recommendations.
 
I will not support anyone who was forbidden any administrative post in Justice Qayyum's commission.

It will be a disaster again just like 2007 WC and 2009 oath taking scandal.
 
I really like this move from PCB, and finally PCB is listening to something that Waqar suggested. Only problem I have with Inzi is that he is just too religious. We all saw pictures of Afghani players praying on field before match and there were reports that he forced players to pray with him while he was captain of the Pakistani team. I think religion and sport should not be mixed, just like politics and sports. I hope Inzi keep his faith and faith of other players away from his selection process. Again I think Inzi is good choice as long as his selection process is based on merit.
 
This guy has overshadowed yes-man Haroon Rasheed. Even Rasheed picked players like Sohaib Maqsood and Khurram Manzoor.

Inzamam is now one of the worst selectors ever. Destroyed a team that was suppose to go nowhere but upwards after CT 2017. His failure to pick replacements for opening slot.

Most of his career as captain and now chief selector, he has backed and protected the leeches in the team like the senior players, and slipped his club level nephew as well.

After this test series, Inzi will pick Hafeez and Imam for the odi team without any oversight or answering to a PCB higherup.

Watching Pakistan team is an embarrassment. Inzamam literally devastated the team as captain[2004-2007] also when team was collapsing for under 100 runs by 2006/7. Even though the coach at that Bob Woolmer was one of the best in the world and most sincere to the team.

He has somehow got a free pass form PCB. PCB chairman Ehsan Mani is even more responsible for his silence. He needs a session with the parliamentary committee where they are ridiculed and grilled for their decisions.

Inzamam needs to explain about how he is selecting the same players who were collapsing in Jan. 2018 in NZ and still achieving record low colklapses with 57-5 in Jan. 2019 ad then he picks them again alongwith his nephew. The injustice with players like Fawad Alam and Abid Ali is another major issue where Inzamam has still not been grilled.

Inzamams time is up its time to find a new selector or else I feel I might not watch this team anymore.
 
this guy has overshadowed yes-man haroon rasheed. Even rasheed picked players like sohaib maqsood and khurram manzoor.

Inzamam is now one of the worst selectors ever. Destroyed a team that was suppose to go nowhere but upwards after ct 2017. His failure to pick replacements for opening slot.

Most of his career as captain and now chief selector, he has backed and protected the leeches in the team like the senior players, and slipped his club level nephew as well.

After this test series, inzi will pick hafeez and imam for the odi team without any oversight or answering to a pcb higherup.

Watching pakistan team is an embarrassment. Inzamam literally devastated the team as captain[2004-2007] also when team was collapsing for under 100 runs by 2006/7. Even though the coach at that bob woolmer was one of the best in the world and most sincere to the team.

He has somehow got a free pass form pcb. Pcb chairman ehsan mani is even more responsible for his silence. He needs a session with the parliamentary committee where they are ridiculed and grilled for their decisions.

Inzamam needs to explain about how he is selecting the same players who were collapsing in jan. 2018 in nz and still achieving record low colklapses with 57-5 in jan. 2019 ad then he picks them again alongwith his nephew. The injustice with players like fawad alam and abid ali is another major issue where inzamam has still not been grilled.

Inzamams time is up its time to find a new selector or else i feel i might not watch this team anymore.

potw
 
This guy has overshadowed yes-man Haroon Rasheed. Even Rasheed picked players like Sohaib Maqsood and Khurram Manzoor.

Inzamam is now one of the worst selectors ever. Destroyed a team that was suppose to go nowhere but upwards after CT 2017. His failure to pick replacements for opening slot.

Most of his career as captain and now chief selector, he has backed and protected the leeches in the team like the senior players, and slipped his club level nephew as well.

After this test series, Inzi will pick Hafeez and Imam for the odi team without any oversight or answering to a PCB higherup.

Watching Pakistan team is an embarrassment. Inzamam literally devastated the team as captain[2004-2007] also when team was collapsing for under 100 runs by 2006/7. Even though the coach at that Bob Woolmer was one of the best in the world and most sincere to the team.

He has somehow got a free pass form PCB. PCB chairman Ehsan Mani is even more responsible for his silence. He needs a session with the parliamentary committee where they are ridiculed and grilled for their decisions.

Inzamam needs to explain about how he is selecting the same players who were collapsing in Jan. 2018 in NZ and still achieving record low colklapses with 57-5 in Jan. 2019 ad then he picks them again alongwith his nephew. The injustice with players like Fawad Alam and Abid Ali is another major issue where Inzamam has still not been grilled.

Inzamams time is up its time to find a new selector or else I feel I might not watch this team anymore.

Very well said.

Garbage selector and easily one of the or the worst selector ever.
 
Usually, most teams have 1-2 players that shouldn’t be in the starting xi, Pakistan has 5 players, lol. Those 5 being - Imam, Fakhar, Shafiq, Azhar and Sarfraz.

What we need is players that can bat for 2 days, once we have found such players, only then can we look to bring in attacking batsmen.

You cannot have the likes of Fakhar playing at the top knowing how fragile the middle order is.
 
Usually, most teams have 1-2 players that shouldn’t be in the starting xi, Pakistan has 5 players, lol. Those 5 being - Imam, Fakhar, Shafiq, Azhar and Sarfraz.

What we need is players that can bat for 2 days, once we have found such players, only then can we look to bring in attacking batsmen.

You cannot have the likes of Fakhar playing at the top knowing how fragile the middle order is.

A few months ago people were saying how vital Fakhar is going to be.

And now all of a sudden he shouldn't be in the starting XI?

You fans are so fickle and deserve this embarrassment.
 
He is poor but I am beyond criticizing selectors now. The truth is that we simply don’t have the players.

People can hype as many domestic players as they want, but there is no possible playing XI in the country today that can propel the team to the top of the pile.
 
A few months ago people were saying how vital Fakhar is going to be.

And now all of a sudden he shouldn't be in the starting XI?

You fans are so fickle and deserve this embarrassment.

Fakhar is a hit and miss type of player, is that really what you want at the top, given how poor our batting is?
 
He is poor but I am beyond criticizing selectors now. The truth is that we simply don’t have the players.

People can hype as many domestic players as they want, but there is no possible playing XI in the country today that can propel the team to the top of the pile.

Mate, you sound as if you’ve been watching every domestic game at the grounds.
 
He is poor but I am beyond criticizing selectors now. The truth is that we simply don’t have the players.

People can hype as many domestic players as they want, but there is no possible playing XI in the country today that can propel the team to the top of the pile.

So where did Shan Masood come from, France?

The situation is so pathetic thanks to Inzamam we need a team to survive and play 50 overs plus without collapsing. Top of the pile rofl.

This fellow has completely removed Pakistan A performances that faced a similar NZ team with Wagner.
 
Last edited:
He is poor but I am beyond criticizing selectors now. The truth is that we simply don’t have the players.

People can hype as many domestic players as they want, but there is no possible playing XI in the country today that can propel the team to the top of the pile.

Agree but not completely. Lack of players indeed is the biggest issue - but this guy has taken the problem even beyond that. Previous selectors were at least honest for the junior & A team selection. This guy is corrupt/incompetent to the core even for A team. When PAK National team needs a purge to chop down average age (& weight) considerably, this guy has taken official average age of A team over 30. That’s after suggesting that no 30+ player will be selected for A team.
 
So where did Shan Masood come from, France?

The situation is so pathetic thanks to Inzamam we need a team to survive and play 50 overs plus without collapsing. Top of the pile rofl.

This fellow has completely removed Pakistan A performances that faced a similar NZ team with Wagner.

What has Shan Masood achieved and how many teams in the world would he walk into?
 
Agree but not completely. Lack of players indeed is the biggest issue - but this guy has taken the problem even beyond that. Previous selectors were at least honest for the junior & A team selection. This guy is corrupt/incompetent to the core even for A team. When PAK National team needs a purge to chop down average age (& weight) considerably, this guy has taken official average age of A team over 30. That’s after suggesting that no 30+ player will be selected for A team.

He should answer for that, but I don’t think he is to be blamed for the fact that we are routinely getting flogged by quality teams.
 
[MENTION=131701]Mamoon[/MENTION]

Very weak, diversive and hilarious arguments not even a debate. Waste of time to debate who cherrypicks just to suit his worldview.
 
There may not be world beaters waiting but the least we can do is to select very young batsmen with a bit of promise and then groom them in international circuit because our domestic setup continously failing in producing even a single decent batsmen after babar.
 
2ndly batsmen like Saif badar, Saad, Saud and few others may not be world beaters but they are treated harshly in our domestic setup with respect to chances and position.
 
He should answer for that, but I don’t think he is to be blamed for the fact that we are routinely getting flogged by quality teams.

The gap between PAK & top teams are wider beyond selection magic - no doubt. But, even within that limitations, things can be made better - remember this is PAK team after 3 years under one of the best coaches around. Imagine PAK team with WY, Moin or Mohsin in charge instead of Arthur.

Can you tell me for once, we have seen anything positive from him? Starting from PAK tour of England 2016 - he sent half fit Gul & Irfan. WI tour of UAE - he waited for 2 extra days to give MoHa a last chance, then picked Nawaz as 2nd spinner. For ANZ series - 4 pacers into their mid 30s and a spinner in Nawaz!!! For WIN tour - some 35 years old guy picked for middle order. For CT - 3/4 players had to be replaced/introduced otherwise PAK would have been out by 2nd game. For SRL series last year; that ZIM ODI series, 6 pacers for Asia cup without any specialist spinner, MoHa played 5 Tests in UAE - then hiding for SAF.... now this latest one in SAF.

Absolutely rock bottom selection panel upon whom everyone had lots of expectations. And to expose his duplicity, almost every new comer has performed beyond expectations- these players were found out after few months/games which suggests a weakness in domestic system regarding skill development & conditioning of players once they are exposed to international teams. He has picked (read forced to pick) only those players performed or picked in PSL to save his face - Shadab, Asif, Talat, Farhan .... but anyone young not picked by PSL, hardly could break even the A side!!!!

Never thought he was a good choice for such role, but didn’t expect this low either.
 
There are no world beaters waiting in the ranks. We need to accept this and deal with it. The well is dry.

We need world beaters to replace Sarfraz, Imam, Asad, and Azhar? It's not even about the quality of our domestic players. This guy is unfair. Is it seriously hard to replace players who have been averaging in 20s? Sure we don't have Wasim AKrams or Javed Miamdads waiting in our domestic but what we do have waiting in our domestic at least give them a change. He didn't select any backup players for a tour like SA, let that sink in. Sarfraz, Mickey, and Izamam are either incredibly corrupt or incompetent.
 
Inzamam had a good start, but is losing it now every time.

BUT it's unfair to blame Inzi only. Mickey and Sarfraz have been poor as well selecting the wrong teams.

Do not forget that Inzi sent Faheem and Shadab, but Neither mickey nor Sarfraz made use of them!
 
Everyone knows PCB will resurrect another dinosaur from the Bronze Age like Wasim Bari or Haroon Rasheed so what Inzamam's sacking will achieve I don't know.

If I was certain sacking Inzamam would lead to his replacement by someone more in tune with domestic like Bazid Khan or Mohammad Wasim then I'd take that outcome, but it ain't happening.

Anyway, I think the team management has to share some blame for these defeats too. Saad Ali was selected in the squad yet Mohammad Hafeez played all five UAE Tests ahead of him !

Going back last year, both Mohammad Asghar and Bilal Asif were selected in the Sri Lanka squad yet Sarfraz/Arthur played three seamers in UAE. Where Inzy definitely messed up is not picking a backup middle-order batsman for this series.
 
Not great to not pick an extra batsman. No signs of a batsman being called up to the squad either.
 
Started off well, giving lots of opportunities to youngsters across formats
But has kind of lost his way now, the idea of merit seems to only apply to certain players and for certain players it doesn’t really matter

Test squads in particular have been a let down, as has been the rotation of players (especially fast bowlers)
 
[MENTION=131701]Mamoon[/MENTION]

Very weak, diversive and hilarious arguments not even a debate. Waste of time to debate who cherrypicks just to suit his worldview.

You can say what you want, but it is about time we acknowledge the fact that the dearth of talent in Pakistan is a major issue. Also, it is not simply a phase that other teams (e.g. Australia today) is going through. It is not simply a nightmare that will be over soon - it is the failure of our system and the gap between us and the other top teams is widening.

Every now and then, we hype some domestic player who turns out to be a dud in international cricket. Latest example is Sahibzada Farhan who was supposed to be the answer to our opening woes, but we saw how poor he was. All these Shakeels, Sauds, Zeeshan Maliks etc. and other new saviours on the block are likely to be out of their depth as well. We are simply incapable of producing world beaters.
 
We need world beaters to replace Sarfraz, Imam, Asad, and Azhar? It's not even about the quality of our domestic players. This guy is unfair. Is it seriously hard to replace players who have been averaging in 20s? Sure we don't have Wasim AKrams or Javed Miamdads waiting in our domestic but what we do have waiting in our domestic at least give them a change. He didn't select any backup players for a tour like SA, let that sink in. Sarfraz, Mickey, and Izamam are either incredibly corrupt or incompetent.

All of this is true, but at the end of the day, does it really matter who plays when pretty much everyone is mediocre? The dearth of talent in Pakistan is an actual crisis and it has reached a point where it becoming pointless to blame selectors and make fantasy XIs. However, I do agree that the lack of quality alternatives should not mean that we have to carry deadweight.

If we are going to lose, why not lose with the next batch of mediocre players. The likes of Azhar, Shafiq and Sarfraz etc. have enjoyed enough failures and defeats now. Perhaps now it is time for the next bunch, i.e. Saud, Saad, Zeeshan Malik etc. etc. to get flogged in international cricket. Someone like Sahibzada Farhan has already had a taste of the massive gulf between Pakistan domestic cricket and international cricket.
 
The gap between PAK & top teams are wider beyond selection magic - no doubt. But, even within that limitations, things can be made better - remember this is PAK team after 3 years under one of the best coaches around. Imagine PAK team with WY, Moin or Mohsin in charge instead of Arthur.

Can you tell me for once, we have seen anything positive from him? Starting from PAK tour of England 2016 - he sent half fit Gul & Irfan. WI tour of UAE - he waited for 2 extra days to give MoHa a last chance, then picked Nawaz as 2nd spinner. For ANZ series - 4 pacers into their mid 30s and a spinner in Nawaz!!! For WIN tour - some 35 years old guy picked for middle order. For CT - 3/4 players had to be replaced/introduced otherwise PAK would have been out by 2nd game. For SRL series last year; that ZIM ODI series, 6 pacers for Asia cup without any specialist spinner, MoHa played 5 Tests in UAE - then hiding for SAF.... now this latest one in SAF.

Absolutely rock bottom selection panel upon whom everyone had lots of expectations. And to expose his duplicity, almost every new comer has performed beyond expectations- these players were found out after few months/games which suggests a weakness in domestic system regarding skill development & conditioning of players once they are exposed to international teams. He has picked (read forced to pick) only those players performed or picked in PSL to save his face - Shadab, Asif, Talat, Farhan .... but anyone young not picked by PSL, hardly could break even the A side!!!!

Never thought he was a good choice for such role, but didn’t expect this low either.

As selector, Inzamam is doing exactly what he did as captain. Keep his friends happy and pick and choose his favourites. He was a wonderful player, but he is a toxic individual who has done a lot of damage to Pakistan cricket without a bat in his hand, and I am not even going to his role in the ICL and the oath-gate.

He has made some very poor selections, but when I look at the talent pool in the country, I increasingly feel that those decisions have had marginal impact on the outcome. As a result, I find it tiresome to come up with fantasy XIs and blaming Inzamam for not selecting this and that player when the net effect is hardly going to be any different.

Nonetheless, it is time for fresh faces now. Not only in terms of players but also in terms of management. Inzamam, Sarfraz, Shafiq, Azhar and Flower are 5 individuals who need to be purged with immediate effect.
 
Younis Khan also opening up against Inzamam.

If Sarfaraz is removed, then the selectors must also be held accountable for providing him with choice of players.
 
Well done to the chief selector for screwing meritocracy for good, he has finally made the coach Mickey Arthur retreat. What a team he has selected For Australian tour.

This would not be possible if a poor and ignorant administrator like Ehsan Mani was not at the helm, another blemish for the PTI govt.

Its a first that before a World Cup, captain who suppose to lead the side has been removed from the team calling it 'rest'.

Selections are hilarious, loose cannon and disciplinary liability Umar Akmal, failure Rizwan and darling nephew Imam ul Haq.

There is no one to explain how Rizwan and Imam are getting too many chances whereas Hussain Talat or Asif Ali is dropped after one tour. Token selections Abid Ali and Saad Ali who I can bet will not get a chance in one match.

Inzamam as chief selector will be remembered for the way he destroyed Pakistan batting thru his nepotism. He did the same as captain in 2005-07. There is really no logic Inzamam is doing it openly now as many can see. Soon he will select his son in the team. A very dangerous road ahead, Pakistan all set to regress back to 2016 team.
 
Well done to the chief selector for screwing meritocracy for good, he has finally made the coach Mickey Arthur retreat. What a team he has selected For Australian tour.

This would not be possible if a poor and ignorant administrator like Ehsan Mani was not at the helm, another blemish for the PTI govt.

Its a first that before a World Cup, captain who suppose to lead the side has been removed from the team calling it 'rest'.

Selections are hilarious, loose cannon and disciplinary liability Umar Akmal, failure Rizwan and darling nephew Imam ul Haq.

There is no one to explain how Rizwan and Imam are getting too many chances whereas Hussain Talat or Asif Ali is dropped after one tour. Token selections Abid Ali and Saad Ali who I can bet will not get a chance in one match.

Inzamam as chief selector will be remembered for the way he destroyed Pakistan batting thru his nepotism. He did the same as captain in 2005-07. There is really no logic Inzamam is doing it openly now as many can see. Soon he will select his son in the team. A very dangerous road ahead, Pakistan all set to regress back to 2016 team.

Oh boy, where do I start?

First of all, this is not an Australian "tour", the series is taking place in the UAE, last time I checked.

Secondly, his nephew averages around 60 in ODI cricket. Please do explain how Imam does not deserve to be one of the first names on the team-sheet based on merit. The only ones killing merit are "fans" like you who cannot accept that Imam has outperformed all of your domestic darlings and despite his family name, is all set to achieve a lot on his own merits. This hate against Imam is getting old and makes you look truly ignorant so I suggest you stop.

The loose cannon you're upset over has had a very good PSL and did well in other domestic tournaments recently as well, he deserved a recall and if he can translate his domestic performances to the national team, it will be a big boon for the team because there is no other player in Pakistan that can do what Umar Akmal has the capability of doing.

Additionally, Mohammad Rizwan has been one of the top domestic performers for some time now. It is silly to question his inclusion, especially when he has batted well at the international level in the past, as well. Sarfaraz deserved a rest and Inzamam clearly stated that he will be the captain for the World Cup and his place is virtually guaranteed, no matter what Rizwan does during this series.
 
Oh boy, where do I start?

First of all, this is not an Australian "tour", the series is taking place in the UAE, last time I checked.

Secondly, his nephew averages around 60 in ODI cricket. Please do explain how Imam does not deserve to be one of the first names on the team-sheet based on merit. The only ones killing merit are "fans" like you who cannot accept that Imam has outperformed all of your domestic darlings and despite his family name, is all set to achieve a lot on his own merits. This hate against Imam is getting old and makes you look truly ignorant so I suggest you stop.

The loose cannon you're upset over has had a very good PSL and did well in other domestic tournaments recently as well, he deserved a recall and if he can translate his domestic performances to the national team, it will be a big boon for the team because there is no other player in Pakistan that can do what Umar Akmal has the capability of doing.

Additionally, Mohammad Rizwan has been one of the top domestic performers for some time now. It is silly to question his inclusion, especially when he has batted well at the international level in the past, as well. Sarfaraz deserved a rest and Inzamam clearly stated that he will be the captain for the World Cup and his place is virtually guaranteed, no matter what Rizwan does during this series.

Inzi's PR agent on pakpassion trying to defend Inzamam, rofl no surprises. Playing with words and trying to manipulate.

Coming with the best excuses and diversions.

Why Umar Akmal's performance in PSL, why not consider series performances from One Day Cup, National T20, Quaid e Azam trophy, etc. for last 3 years.

Has he gone through the fitness test which Inzamam made excuse for, when selecting other players rofl?

Hahahah yeah Imam averages alot playing inferior teams put that hear also and the no. of matches he has played. More than his family name he is an eyesore for Pakistani fan to watch he'll help more people leave watching cricket. There were 11 players averaging more than Imam, his average is around 33 in domestics and 27 in tests. He is definitely the best choice and those above him should retire and leave for another country where their talent will be recognized.

Please personally thank Inzi for batting prospects who would've shined for Pakistan from 2005 - 2007 and 2016 -2019, due to him were lost to corruption and nepotism. Players like Asim Kamal, Ashfaq Ahmed, Fawad Alam, and so many other domestic batsmen who would've transformed this team.

Inzamam has done so much for the batting talent for our country, crushing them so valiantly. Like the recent T20 we won't find a new batsman thinking to make his career in Pakistan, 38 year olds Imam will be playing 42 year old Umar Akmals. There won't be any competition left for them.
 
Inzi's PR agent on pakpassion trying to defend Inzamam, rofl no surprises. Playing with words and trying to manipulate.

Coming with the best excuses and diversions.

Why Umar Akmal's performance in PSL, why not consider series performances from One Day Cup, National T20, Quaid e Azam trophy, etc. for last 3 years.

Has he gone through the fitness test which Inzamam made excuse for, when selecting other players rofl?

Hahahah yeah Imam averages alot playing inferior teams put that hear also and the no. of matches he has played. More than his family name he is an eyesore for Pakistani fan to watch he'll help more people leave watching cricket. There were 11 players averaging more than Imam, his average is around 33 in domestics and 27 in tests. He is definitely the best choice and those above him should retire and leave for another country where their talent will be recognized.

Please personally thank Inzi for batting prospects who would've shined for Pakistan from 2005 - 2007 and 2016 -2019, due to him were lost to corruption and nepotism. Players like Asim Kamal, Ashfaq Ahmed, Fawad Alam, and so many other domestic batsmen who would've transformed this team.

Inzamam has done so much for the batting talent for our country, crushing them so valiantly. Like the recent T20 we won't find a new batsman thinking to make his career in Pakistan, 38 year olds Imam will be playing 42 year old Umar Akmals. There won't be any competition left for them.

Please learn how to have an intelligent discussion without resorting to name-calling. It will make you sound like an adult.

With the World Cup coming up in a couple of months, we need players who are in form NOW, not players who were in form three years ago. That is why Umar Akmal's performances from three years ago do not matter, just like *insert domestic nobody*'s performances from two to three years ago do not matter either.

The fitness camp and the associated tests take place after the squad has been named. You cannot put the thousands of domestic players through the test and I'm sure you can think of at least a couple of reasons why.

Imam was very prolific against South Africa in South Africa. I would have to politely disagree with your assessment that South Africa are a weak team. Also, I assume that once Imam proves himself (again) in the upcoming series, against another team that cannot be considered weak, you will stop your whining against his inclusion in the national side?

You seem to have a hard time understanding that the PCT can only accomodate 11 players at a time. Alam, Kamal and every other player who failed at the highest level and was then dropped, only have themselves to blame. If you do not shine immediately, do not expect the selectors to give you many more chances in a country of 200 million, cricket-mad people.

Also, sometimes you are just not destined for things. During 2005-2007, three batting spots were more or less locked with Younis, Yousuf and Inzamam himself, making up the greatest Pakistani middle-order of all time. The #6 spot was usually used to unearth the next Imran, with the likes of Razzaq and Afridi being tried out there. However, a few batsmen did get a chance as well but none of them stuck, including Misbah ul Haq and Faisal Iqbal. The only open spots were #1 and #2, and Pakistan tried a bunch of openers during that time. In case you forgot, not only was Inzamam's time as captain free of any infighting, we were also considered one of the strongest teams in the world and ranked in the top three in both formats of the world.

I suggest you follow a different sport if you find things so dark and gloomy in Pakistan cricket right now. As long as Inzamam keeps unearthing good, young players with loads of potential and keeps delivering trophies, like the 2017 CT, he's not going anywhere out of his own free will. Likewise, as long as Imam keeps performing with the bat, he's going nowhere either. I'm sure you can find something else to entertain you for the next decade.
 
Please learn how to have an intelligent discussion without resorting to name-calling. It will make you sound like an adult.

With the World Cup coming up in a couple of months, we need players who are in form NOW, not players who were in form three years ago. That is why Umar Akmal's performances from three years ago do not matter, just like *insert domestic nobody*'s performances from two to three years ago do not matter either.

The fitness camp and the associated tests take place after the squad has been named. You cannot put the thousands of domestic players through the test and I'm sure you can think of at least a couple of reasons why.

Imam was very prolific against South Africa in South Africa. I would have to politely disagree with your assessment that South Africa are a weak team. Also, I assume that once Imam proves himself (again) in the upcoming series, against another team that cannot be considered weak, you will stop your whining against his inclusion in the national side?

You seem to have a hard time understanding that the PCT can only accomodate 11 players at a time. Alam, Kamal and every other player who failed at the highest level and was then dropped, only have themselves to blame. If you do not shine immediately, do not expect the selectors to give you many more chances in a country of 200 million, cricket-mad people.

Also, sometimes you are just not destined for things. During 2005-2007, three batting spots were more or less locked with Younis, Yousuf and Inzamam himself, making up the greatest Pakistani middle-order of all time. The #6 spot was usually used to unearth the next Imran, with the likes of Razzaq and Afridi being tried out there. However, a few batsmen did get a chance as well but none of them stuck, including Misbah ul Haq and Faisal Iqbal. The only open spots were #1 and #2, and Pakistan tried a bunch of openers during that time. In case you forgot, not only was Inzamam's time as captain free of any infighting, we were also considered one of the strongest teams in the world and ranked in the top three in both formats of the world.

I suggest you follow a different sport if you find things so dark and gloomy in Pakistan cricket right now. As long as Inzamam keeps unearthing good, young players with loads of potential and keeps delivering trophies, like the 2017 CT, he's not going anywhere out of his own free will. Likewise, as long as Imam keeps performing with the bat, he's going nowhere either. I'm sure you can find something else to entertain you for the next decade.

No point arguing with people who think Imran Khan should personally intervene and sack Ehsan Mani because he hasn't fired Inzamam for poor selections yet.

I mean it's not like Imran has a war or anything on his hands.
 
Please learn how to have an intelligent discussion without resorting to name-calling. It will make you sound like an adult.

With the World Cup coming up in a couple of months, we need players who are in form NOW, not players who were in form three years ago. That is why Umar Akmal's performances from three years ago do not matter, just like *insert domestic nobody*'s performances from two to three years ago do not matter either.

The fitness camp and the associated tests take place after the squad has been named. You cannot put the thousands of domestic players through the test and I'm sure you can think of at least a couple of reasons why.

Imam was very prolific against South Africa in South Africa. I would have to politely disagree with your assessment that South Africa are a weak team. Also, I assume that once Imam proves himself (again) in the upcoming series, against another team that cannot be considered weak, you will stop your whining against his inclusion in the national side?

You seem to have a hard time understanding that the PCT can only accomodate 11 players at a time. Alam, Kamal and every other player who failed at the highest level and was then dropped, only have themselves to blame. If you do not shine immediately, do not expect the selectors to give you many more chances in a country of 200 million, cricket-mad people.

Also, sometimes you are just not destined for things. During 2005-2007, three batting spots were more or less locked with Younis, Yousuf and Inzamam himself, making up the greatest Pakistani middle-order of all time. The #6 spot was usually used to unearth the next Imran, with the likes of Razzaq and Afridi being tried out there. However, a few batsmen did get a chance as well but none of them stuck, including Misbah ul Haq and Faisal Iqbal. The only open spots were #1 and #2, and Pakistan tried a bunch of openers during that time. In case you forgot, not only was Inzamam's time as captain free of any infighting, we were also considered one of the strongest teams in the world and ranked in the top three in both formats of the world.

I suggest you follow a different sport if you find things so dark and gloomy in Pakistan cricket right now. As long as Inzamam keeps unearthing good, young players with loads of potential and keeps delivering trophies, like the 2017 CT, he's not going anywhere out of his own free will. Likewise, as long as Imam keeps performing with the bat, he's going nowhere either. I'm sure you can find something else to entertain you for the next decade.

If I was not civil I doubt you would be responding to my post.

Your first excuse for Umar Akmal 'NOW' in-form rofl, after he does well in a one off T20 tournament encashing mostly left arm offspinners.
Saad ALi in QAU 2018 season made 957 runs, Sahibzada FArhan scored most in the same year in domestic 50 format starting with the one day cup, Gauhar Ali keeper showing grit in the NAtional T20 Cup. The top scorers Sohaib MAqsood and many more ignored by Inzamam for like 3 years now.

Inzamam has ignored dozens of players on now form.

Please check the average of Fawad Alam or Asim Kamal when they were removed from the team. ITs more than what Imam's was when Inzi uncle inducted him in National team using his cs seat.

You talk about solid middle order you ignored another valuable player alongside Misbah, Younis, who was banned for a year for revolting against captain Younis Khan breaching codeof conduct.

The Younis Khan revolt episode was also planned in Inzamam's house.

NAme's Shoaib Malik who replaced in-form Fawad Alam with a 42 Average.

During Inzi's captaincy era there was an opener who has a record lowest average of 18.6 alongside Yousuf, Younis by the name of Hafeez who was kept with the team even after multiple failures and ASim Kamal was discarded after one bad tour.

Same things are hapenning to others not in Inzi camp like Hussain Talat dropped whereas Rizwan retained.
 
Constantly selecting Yasir is poor from Inzi. He can virtually pick any spinner in Pakistan and they would do a better job. Gohar, Asghar, Raza Hasan- you name it.
 
Inzamam best utilisation would be as a Batting coach or batting mentor .

Tactical jobs are not for him , nor administrations.
 
I will not support anyone who was forbidden any administrative post in Justice Qayyum's commission.

It will be a disaster again just like 2007 WC and 2009 oath taking scandal.

He lacked integrity then, he lacked integrity now. Selecting his bhanja only proved it.

Lets hope this World cup is not a disaster for us.
 
This guy is too dishonest and pretend to be a righteous. Should never be anywhere near any PCB position. His selection is too suspicious.Even he is exposed he is too shameless to admit it and rectify his mistakes. He wanted full authority in selection so that he can chose his favorites.
 
Really hope he is criminally charged and prosecuted for destroying careers of many Pakistani batting talents as captain [2004-2007] and chief selector [2016-]. For his favorite few Akmals,Azam, Hafeez, Malik, Yousuf he decimated so many careers who would've done wonders if nurtured and given confidence.

People only see his open nepotism in favoring his crap nephew Imam which in itself is a gross violation but once one assesses and investigates the ploys he used to favor some and discard domestic talents they'll understand he has done worse than that and has gotten away with it.

He has been occupying selector post for 3 and a half years and there is no batting talent he introduced who can help Pakistan in ODI format. He has been pre-occupied with barteriing with team management to keep his nephew in the team. PCB is more to blame for keeping him.
 
He needs to go after the world cup, he can choose if he wants to retire gracefully or be shown the door by PCB.
 
Selected a better squad for CT but after that his inner dishonesty got the better of him and he started picking garbage likes Imam,Shan, Bilal Asif,Nawaz, Yasir (for ODIs),Amir,Hussain Talat,Rahat, etc...

Never selected some of the best players we have got in the country Kashif,Fawad,Sadaf,Saud,Khalid Usman, Zafar Gohar,Usman Salah uddin...surely one of the worst and corrupt selectors we have ever had
 
@ Khwaja 78,
Inzi's power is more than we think. He knows how to manipulate system plus he has powerful people behind him. Even if we don't make in semi he most likely will be retained. He is a upgrade version of Basit Ali.
 
Back
Top