What's new

"Maybe the punishment didn't fit the crime" : Mickey Arthur on 'homeworkgate'

SL_Fan

Senior ODI Player
Joined
Oct 21, 2012
Runs
22,652
Post of the Week
1
Young top order up to Aussie challenge

Link

Pakistan coach backs his inexperienced top-order to handle the challenge set by Australia's quicks.

Pakistan coach Mickey Arthur believes his young top order is well equipped to handle the challenges set to be thrown at them by Australia's pace attack in the upcoming three-Test series beginning in Brisbane on Thursday.

Batting prodigy Babar Azam – who Arthur last week compared to Virat Kohli – and opener Sami Islam are 22 and 21 respectively, and will occupy two of the top three places in company with experienced opener Azhar Ali.

Babar (three Tests) made world headlines in October when he hit three consecutive ODI hundreds against West Indies, while Sami was dependable at the top of the order during Pakistan's drawn series in England, made a Test-best 91 against New Zealand in Hamilton and has six fifties to his name in nine matches to date.

Old heads Younis Khan and Misbah-ul-Haq follow that trio in the order, with 50-Test veteran Asad Shafiq rounding out the top six.

Explosive 'keeper-batsman Sarfraz Ahmed, who scored a rollicking hundred against Australia in Dubai in 2014 and averages 41, looms as a dangerous prospect at No.7.

Arthur moved to qualify his comment regarding Babar but was confident his batsmen could perform well in Australian conditions where, traditionally, they have struggled; only two Pakistanis have made hundreds Down Under in six Tests this century.

"The comment on Babar Azam the other day was taken out of proportion a little bit, but Babar Azam is young … he's going to be a fantastic player," he said.

"He's going to be a very, very good player.

"The guys are all pretty good technicians. I look at our top three and they’re technically very sound.

"Number six, Asad Shafiq, is a very, very good player, technically outstanding.

"So we do have good technicians who if they do get in will score and score fairly quickly.

"I just hope they get stuck in here, have the belief in their ability, because they've got that in abundance, and then we'll see a really good series."

Nathan Lyon was dealt a harsh lesson by Pakistan's batting group in the UAE the last time the two sides met, taking combined figures of 3-422 in two Tests.

The off-spinner believes he'll benefit from the conditions in Brisbane, where he's taken 24 wickets at 23.96 in five Tests.

On the flipside, none of the tourists have played Test cricket at the Gabba, with Pakistan not having visited Brisbane for a five-day clash since 1999.

"They're a world-class batting and bowling line-up so it's going to be a good challenge for us all over the park," Lyon said today.

"They play spin well but hopefully I can generate as bit more bounce than I did in the UAE.

"Hopefully there will be a little bit more pace in the wicket as well so if there are any nicks they carry and will be able to hit the splice of the bats, with a few bat pads and a few caught I hope."

Arthur conceded that his side's returns with the bat in their lone Test warm-up in Cairns had been disappointing, but overall took positive signs from last week's contest in which they comfortably outplayed a young Cricket Australia XI across three days.

"I thought we played quite well actually," he said. "Batting was a little bit of a struggle and there's no secret we need to get some runs and adapting outside our own conditions is difficult – it's like Australia playing in the subcontinent.

"So we're working extremely hard on that. But I was so impressed by the way we bowled; I thought we bowled fantastically well.

"We fielded very, very well, caught well behind the stumps. So we ticked a lot of boxes which was great."

________________________________


Arthur regrets homeworkgate cricket bans

Link

Former Australian coach Mickey Arthur has made a frank admission about the homeworkgate saga that led in part to his sacking, conceding the punishment might have been too harsh.

Arthur, who will coach Pakistan in the three-Test series that starts on Thursday in Brisbane, was axed by Cricket Australia on the eve of the 2013 Ashes.

The South African's dismissal came shortly after handing down suspensions to Shane Watson, Mitchell Johnson, Usman Khawaja and James Pattinson - who were all stood down from a Test in Mohali.

The quartet failed to provide Arthur with written feedback on how the team could improve.

"I would do a couple of things differently, without a doubt I would," Arthur told Fox Sports on Tuesday.

"The constant thing that always plagues and plagues me is around homeworkgate. Would I have handled that differently? I guess I might have.

"Probably not suspend four guys ... maybe the punishment didn't fit the crime."

However, Arthur reiterated his explanation that a "significant stand" had to be made.

"Discipline was not where it should be," he said.

"We wanted to try and create an environment of excellence."

Arthur shared a laugh with his successor Darren Lehmann, captain Steve Smith and vice-captain David Warner on Tuesday at the Gabba.

He also hoped to catch up with Michael Clarke, noting his relationship was "soured" by legal proceedings Arthur launched against Cricket Australia.

Leaked documents at the time detailed allegations Clarke had called Shane Watson a "cancer".

"I reached out to Michael because I felt an obligation to Michael," Arthur recalled.

"Pup and I had a really good relationship. Our relationship was really solid. Obviously, around the time when I went through the legal issue, there was that stuff that came out which soured our relationship.

"But we've spoken through that."

Khawaja insisted on Tuesday he moved on from the saga a long time ago, while Josh Hazlewood noted the team had "a different culture now and ... things have improved a lot" since Lehmann's appointment.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Shafiq is mentally fragile and moving him around has destabilized him. The biggest excuse people made for him in ODIs is that he flopped because he never got a long run at 3.

Yet in tests once he finally got a chance at 3, a hundred, few fifties and a pair later he got crapped back to #6, think that was a hasty move, and while Babar has done ok for someone new at 3, think this is yet another case of us pushing a newbie into the deep end, and usually they sink after swimming for a bit. Hopefully that is not the case, but that's what history tells us...
 
Mickey Arthur seems to be conversing with quite a lot of media outlets these days.

Hopefully we can back up all the talk with some solid performances.
 
Can he freakin focus on the Pakistan cricket team

Ever since we have landed down under he has been blabbering about his time as Australia coach.

Move the heck on! We lost a series against NZ for the first time in 30+ years and even then his interest was on his Aussie return :facepalm:
 
Can he freakin focus on the Pakistan cricket team

Ever since we have landed down under he has been blabbering about his time as Australia coach.

Move the heck on! We lost a series against NZ for the first time in 30+ years and even then his interest was on his Aussie return :facepalm:

To be fair, there are two articles in OP out of which one is completely about the Pakistan team.

When he talks to media, there are naturally a lot of questions about the past which is why is keeps popping up.
 
To be fair, there are two articles in OP out of which one is completely about the Pakistan team.

When he talks to media, there are naturally a lot of questions about the past which is why is keeps popping up.

Looks like Mickey is piggy backing on this tour to pull a PR Stunt. I seriously cannot remember a touring coach (forget subcontinental team) talking so much to media.

On topic, the headline gives me an impression that his sacking was the punishment and homework-gate was the crime.

Good luck to him though, and hope he is ready for the real press conferences which would come during and after the games. Skill level seems to be same if not Pakistan slightly ahead, however Aus would probably score on fitness. Those big grounds would need Pakistan to run 3's and apart from Sarfaraz and to some extent Misbah, I don't see this team running too much.
 
Clearly it's what all the press wants to talk about. Not entirely his fault.
Besides it keeps the press focus off the team: kinda like Graeme Smith on his first tour
 
Can he freakin focus on the Pakistan cricket team

Ever since we have landed down under he has been blabbering about his time as Australia coach.

Move the heck on! We lost a series against NZ for the first time in 30+ years and even then his interest was on his Aussie return :facepalm:
He is at press conferences with the Australian press in Australia.

Of course the questions they ask are about what went wrong when he coached Australia!
 
He is at press conferences with the Australian press in Australia.

Of course the questions they ask are about what went wrong when he coached Australia!

To be fair, there are two articles in OP out of which one is completely about the Pakistan team.

When he talks to media, there are naturally a lot of questions about the past which is why is keeps popping up.

Common sense prevails.
 
Back
Top